Forge of Destiny(Xianxia Quest)

How tough is a five success Resolve test, by the by? I don't remember everything that's included in such a roll, but my impression is that five successes is pretty hard at the moment?
 
[X] Night Blooming Lotus Blade
[X] Tailor's Regret
[X] Sharp Note/Yue Shi(to be decided if selected)

Going with these for now.
 
How tough is a five success Resolve test, by the by? I don't remember everything that's included in such a roll, but my impression is that five successes is pretty hard at the moment?
My impression is a 5 success Resolve test means getting 5 just through your stat or arts that increase resolve itself. For Ling Qi, that is Resolve 5 + TRF 3 + AM 2= 10 dice. So in average we would get 4 and thus fail such a test more often than not.

So such a test is pretty hard at our cultivation level even though we have 2 arts enhancing resolve, which I would think is not that common. Obviously the more cultivation we have the easier such a test will be, but it seems the sword will grow with us for a while yet.
 
How tough is a five success Resolve test, by the by? I don't remember everything that's included in such a roll, but my impression is that five successes is pretty hard at the moment?
Today? It's slightly harder than 50/50. For high Green, or even Cyan? Easy-peasy. It's an ability that gets less valuable as we level up, hence my desire for a scaling bonus.
 
My impression is a 5 success Resolve test means getting 5 just through your stat or arts that increase resolve itself. For Ling Qi, that is Resolve 5 + TRF 3 + AM 2= 10 dice. So in average we would get 4 and thus fail such a test more often than not.

So such a test is pretty hard at our cultivation level even though we have 2 arts enhancing resolve, which I would think is not that common. Obviously the more cultivation we have the easier such a test will be, but it seems the sword will grow with us for a while yet.
There's a pretty good chance it's not entirely common, since we have to be very worried about dispels due to our specific build, but there are a few characters we know of who will be pretty high up on it. And any professional and experienced green cultivator will by common sense, if they are not an idiot, boost their resolve so they are not vulnerable to effects which require a resolve test.
 
Today? It's slightly harder than 50/50. For high Green, or even Cyan? Easy-peasy. It's an ability that gets less valuable as we level up, hence my desire for a scaling bonus.
As per our conversation with Meizhen, we have explicit reason to expect that the weapon will scale with our cultivation. It's made of powerful enough materials by an experienced enough crafter that Ling Qi simply cannot tap into its full potential.
 
As per our conversation with Meizhen, we have explicit reason to expect that the weapon will scale with our cultivation. It's made of powerful enough materials by an experienced enough crafter that Ling Qi simply cannot tap into its full potential.
She said the material would give us extra abilities when we hit Cyan. There was nothing at all about any other abilities improving.
Also, explicit mechanical scaling is irrelevant because we won't have the mechanics after this year.
Mechanical scaling becomes narrative scaling, but it's still scaling.
 
What I don't like about the Singing Mist Blade is that it's too loud to take someone out stealthily.
Though I suppose you could argue that that's not an option anyway for anyone we need our Domain Weapon for.
 
What I don't like about the Singing Mist Blade is that it's too loud to take someone out stealthily.
Though I suppose you could argue that that's not an option anyway for anyone we need our Domain Weapon for.
Well we'd need to add a stealth art or two to really enable stealth takedowns for people we use our Domain Weapon on, but it's within reach. More to the point is that that just isn't at all what the Singing Mist Blade is for - it's for team fights or 1v10 sort of scenarios where the fight is going to be loud and visible anyway due to AoE stuff. Right now, we punch way under our potential if we have to be quiet since we don't have extra Arts to slot in to our build to replace FVM and FSS. We might as well keep that rolling with a Domain Weapon whose potential matches up with those Arts and the next step of Arts after them. Then later after we develop another fighting style option more fully we can get another Domain Weapon to support it.
 
Ok they all look good in some form or another. Ill just wait to see what popsas the winner since i might just vote for all anyway
 
[X] Singing Mist Blade

I'm narrowing my support down to just the music option, since I've always been a fan of fluting people to death. Also, having Qi drain on hit instead of on damage is pretty nasty, it'll put all but the dodgiest enemies on the clock against us
 
You are thinking of the Singing Mist Blade as if it is a health-takedown weapon as opposed to a qi-takedown weapon.

The point of this blade is to enable our ability to disable our opponents and drain them of qi. It doesn't need to ever deal a single point of Health damage to do that.

To start, we get +5 to our ability to music our enemies to death with FVM and FSS. On top of that, this domain weapon's -debuff stacks are applied on HIT, not on DAMAGE, so it doesn't matter if our enemy has an excessive amount of armor or perfect defense; they still get affected.

Finally, once we've got three debuffs stacked, this starts draining 6qi/turn unless the opponent passes a (hard) Resolve check. This puts the enemy on a timer even if they try to conserve Qi.
IMO the Sharp Note synergies with our build more, by severely curtailing an enemies ability to recover their Qi.
 
She said the material would give us extra abilities when we hit Cyan. There was nothing at all about any other abilities improving.
"After some studying, yeah," Ling Qi grimaced, reading the auras of objects in such detail was hard. "It's a fourth grade material, right?"

"Only just," Meizhen replied. "Yet it is still above the resources one would expect of a new baronial clan. It is likely you will not be able to fully access the power of a weapon crafted with it, as you are."

"Like with your own sword," Ling Qi mused, she knew her friend was still teasing out abilities, but her sword came from the scale of a seventh ranked spirit beast, so that was to be expected.
I guess interpreting it as someone only gain the abilities when someone jumps to the requisite realm is a bit valid, but it doesn't really map right to the line about "teasing out abilities" because Meizhen should not get anything until she hits Prism by your thought. And she did not say anything about additional abilities, just not fully access the power which is too broad to specify any particular thing.
Adhoc vote count started by BungieONI on Apr 15, 2018 at 7:16 PM, finished with 185 posts and 88 votes.
 
Last edited:
Also, in addition to both of those abilities being passive rather than on hit, but with the counter Sharp Note can give us up to two attacks per round, one of which can drain even more Qi.
 
Last edited:
I guess interpreting it as someone only gain the abilities when someone jumps to the requisite realm is a bit valid, but it doesn't really map right to the line about "teasing out abilities" because Meizhen should not get anything until she hits Prism by your thought. And she did not say anything about additional abilities, just not fully access the power which is too broad to specify any particular thing.
It should be noted that the scale from a Prism beast need not (I would even say should not) be a Prism-level material.

I expect that for a material to be at level X, it needs to be valuable or even precious to people at that level. I don't expect an individual scale to qualify. Such a thing is of increadible value to someone at Green, but I doubt it is going to be particularly valuable to someone at Prism or even Violet.
 
Last edited:
Re: scaling, the dress has scaled. It didn't tell us at first that it would, we just knew that it was a really rad dress. But for Ling Qi it got stronger at Green, and again after being jailbroken/Life-fibred. While obviously the Umbral Shard won't have DRM like the dress, I do imagine that it will scale by nature of being made professionally with a fourth-grade material for a third-grade cultivator. What we don't know (and can't know) is the granularity of that scaling. Maybe by the time Ling Qi hits Green 4 it's given another new ability, or its numbers have just increased every breakthrough/bottleneck within Green, or maybe she has to hit Cyan before getting anything. But I think all of the options will scale.
 
Last edited:
[X] Night's Edge
Let's go stabby, and commission a potent stealth talisman with our 3rd grade moon core. After all, what is more stealthy than a new moon?
 
How hard is the resolve test on the singing mist? From the way people talk about dice numbers I assumed it would not be that tough for the people that matter to pass.

Edit: I read one page further and find my answer.
 
Last edited:
How hard is the resolve test on the singing mist? From the way people talk about dice numbers I assumed it would not be that tough for the people that matter to pass.
Pretty hard, Arkeus has the numbers a few pages back, and in our combat spec sheet I think. This is because its stats plus arts, though Resilience may come in at some point. I don't recall, and that may be for resisting dispels.
Adhoc vote count started by BungieONI on Apr 15, 2018 at 8:44 PM, finished with 196 posts and 93 votes.
 
How hard is the resolve test on the singing mist? From the way people talk about dice numbers I assumed it would not be that tough for the people that matter to pass.
Well, Ling Qi herself throws 10 dice on a resolve test(which makes it about a coinflip or so to win), but she has 2 techs boosting it, which probably isn't usual even for high tier combatants(at least at our level).
 
Back
Top