Forge of Destiny(Xianxia Quest)

Tbh I'd be down for a Bureaucracy training, that'd be more interesting than War. Or maybe politics. Ling Qi knows nothing about the world and the Elder's teachings might be as enlightening as the ones we got regarding Spirit Beasts.
I wouldn't mind a 'I'm a babby cultivator with no political training, Elder pls halp' lesson. I'd much prefer that over ZB+, because Ling Qi has an excuse for her political ineptitude.
 
I thought that was the point of the 'holding' parts of the flute and FVM? That they could be unplayed for a round and then resumed without repaying activation.
You are correct, @Codex is incorrect here. holding means we can keep coming back to playing after.
In case anybody's wondering about what Alectai is saying in regards to Jiao and swords, here is an excerpt:


Jiao's formation in Zhou's test has also been emphasized by Yrsillar on Discord to be the "Blade Memory Formation".

So he's supposed to be skilled at the use of blades.
There is also this:
There did remain some advantages to physicality, Jiao mused. "Yes, I suppose so," he replied, the majority of his attention still spread through the newly formed basin, exterminating the plague mutated spirits and fauna. It was a little irritating that the barbarian child had been slain by an arrow, death imprints pulled from a bow were less clear than those of a blade.
 
[X] Plan War
- [X] Elder Jiao's Training
-- [X] Larceny
--- [X] SCS
-- [X] War
--- [X] ZB+ (get from Archive)
-[X] Train with Zeqing
-[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
-[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
-- [X] Do it on your own
--- [X] Free: But let Meizhen know that you're doing it and where
-[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
-- [X] Arm Meridian
-- [X] Free: Give her AC
-- [X] Minor: You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
- [X] Have a chat with Han Jian, it has been some time since you trained together, see what is occupying him
- [X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?

Will fill out pills tonight.
 
Last edited:
Do we know what we'd expect a formation at our level to be capable of? Because we generally have a good sense of what a good art and mediocre art at Red and Yellow can accomplish.

Suppose we get a formation that darkens the area. How dark can it make the area? How large a radius? Can we put it up in combat time, or does it need to be a trap set beforehand. Can we just write the formation on a stone and throw it down, or do we we need to write it into the ground? How easy is it to dispel? Do we need any special materials to make it?

One reason I'm hesitant to support going too deep into formations is that I don't really have an idea of what the payoff is.

Also, I think ZB+ is going to be a waste of time.
 
What's the tally right now?

Do we know what we'd expect a formation at our level to be capable of? Because we generally have a good sense of what a good art and mediocre art at Red and Yellow can accomplish.

Suppose we get a formation that darkens the area. How dark can it make the area? How large a radius? Can we put it up in combat time, or does it need to be a trap set beforehand. Can we just write the formation on a stone and throw it down, or do we we need to write it into the ground? How easy is it to dispel? Do we need any special materials to make it?

One reason I'm hesitant to support going too deep into formations is that I don't really have an idea of what the payoff is.

Also, I think ZB+ is going to be a waste of time.

Xuan Shi was capable of paralyzing a peer for a month with Formations.
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Vanguard_D on Oct 9, 2017 at 6:38 PM, finished with 32128 posts and 38 votes.

  • [X] Plan everything and sharing
    -[X] Resources: 3 RS, 1 YS, 1 qi expansion pill (inventory), Black ichor, Gushing spring pill (2), Flowing Rivers Pill (6), White Hart Elixir (6), 1st level Wood pill (2), 2nd Level wood Pill (6), 1 Steady Growth Pill (8), 1 Sturdy Oak Pill (18), 1 Qi Sea Pill (25) = 1 YS, 76 RS. (Change 1Y to 10R).
    -[X] Major Actions
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Train with Elder Jiao (LOCKED)
    --[X] Larceny
    ---[X] SCS
    --[X] Throwing knives
    ---[x] ZB+ (Take from archive)
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    --[X] Do it on your own.
    ---[X] But tell Meizhen where we're going, so if we don't back she knows where to drop the hammer
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    --[x] TRF
    --[X] Share AC with Su Ling
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    ---[X] Share the contents with Li Suyin
    -[X] Minor Actions
    --[x] Xuan Shi seems to be busy setting something up at the council meeting pavilion, perhaps you could help him out?
    --[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    [X] Plan Please let us have everything oh benevolent QM?
    -[X] Resources: 3 RS, 1 YS, 1 qi expansion pill (2), basic wind/water/wood pills (6), 2nd level wind/wood pills (12), 1 Black Ichor Elixir, 1 sturdy oak pill (18), 1 steady growth pill (8), 1 Qi Sea Pill (25). Total = 1 YS, 74 RS
    -[X] Major Actions
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Train with Elder Jiao (LOCKED)
    --[X] Larceny
    ---[X] SCS
    --[X] War
    ---[x] ZB+ (grab from archive)
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    --[X] Do it on your own.
    ---[X] But tell Meizhen where we're going, so if we don't back she knows where to drop the hammer
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    --[x] TRF
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    -[x]Minor Actions
    --[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    --[x] Xuan Shi seems to be busy setting something up at the council meeting pavilion, perhaps you could help him out?
    [X]Plan A snek in hand is worth two in the bush
    -[X] Resources: 3 RS, 1 YS, 1 qi expansion pill (inventory), basic water/wood pills (4), 2nd level water/wood pills (12), 1 Black Ichor Elixir, 1 sturdy oak pill (8), 1 steady growth pill (18), 1 Qi Sea Pill (25). Total = 1 YS, 70 RS
    -[X] Major Actions
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Train with Elder Jiao (LOCKED)
    --[X] Formations
    ---[X] Try to figure out the locking formations on the last bag
    --[X] Larceny
    ---[X] Sable Crescent Step
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    --[X] Thousand Ring Fortress
    --[X] Offer AC to Su Ling, Li Suyin, and Meizhen, if they want to make use of it.
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    --[X] Ask Meizhen to back you up
    -[X] Minor Actions
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    --[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    [X]Plan Plumb the Darkness
    -[X] Resources: 3 RS, 1 YS, all Darkness, Wood, Water, and Fire pills available, Soul Concentrating Elixir.
    -[X] Major Actions
    --[X] Train with Elder jiao (LOCKED)
    ---[X] Formations
    ----[X] Try to figure out the locking formations on the last bag
    ---[X] Larceny
    ----[X] Sable Crescent Step
    --[X] Train with Zeqing
    --[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    ---[X] Thousand Ring Fortress
    --[X] Train with Meizhen
    ---[X] Argent Current
    ----[X] Share it with her.
    --[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    ---[X] Ask Meizhen to back you up
    -[X] Minor Actions
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    --[x] Xuan Shi seems to be busy setting something up at the council meeting pavilion, perhaps you could help him out?
    [X] Plan Mountain's 11
    -[X] Resources: 3 red stones, 1 yellow stone, 1 qi expansion pill, 1 White Hart Elixir (6), 1 Soaring Sky Elixir (6), 1 Black Ichor Elixir, 1 sturdy oak pill (18), 1 steady growth pill (8), 1 Qi Sea Pill (25), 1 Skyblood elixir, 1 clear wind pill, 1 Bright sky pill (2). (1 yellow stone, 68 red stones)
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Train with Elder Jiao (LOCKED)
    --[X] SCS
    ---[X] Larceny
    --[X] ZB+
    ---[X] War
    ---[X] Spend the 20 sect points required to get it
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    --[X] Ask Meizhen to back you up
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    --[X] Falling Star Art
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    ---[X] Give Argent Current to Su Ling and Li Suyin
    -[X] Have a chat with Han Jian, it has been some time since you trained together, see what is occupying him
    -[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    [X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    [X] Plan Please let us have everything oh benevolent QM?
    -[X] Resources: 3 RS, 1 YS, 1 qi expansion pill (inventory), basic wind/water/wood pills (6), 2nd level wind/wood pills (12), 1 Black Ichor Elixir, 1 sturdy oak pill (18), 1 steady growth pill (8), 1 Qi Sea Pill (25). Total = 1 YS, 72 RS
    -[X] Major Actions
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Train with Elder Jiao (LOCKED)
    --[X] Larceny
    ---[X] SCS
    --[X] War
    ---[x] ZB+ (grab from archive)
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    --[X] Do it on your own.
    ---[X] But tell Meizhen where we're going, so if we don't back she knows where to drop the hammer
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    --[x] TRF
    --[x] You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    -[x]Minor Actions
    --[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
    --[x] Xuan Shi seems to be busy setting something up at the council meeting pavilion, perhaps you could help him out?
    [X] Plan War
    - [X] Elder Jiao's Training
    ---[X] Larceny
    --- [X] SCS
    ---[X] War
    --- [X] ZB+ (get from Archive)
    -[X] Train with Zeqing
    -[X] Spend time taking care of and raising Zhengui
    -[X] Infiltrate Yan Renshu's hideout
    -- [X] Do it on your own
    --- [X] Free: But let Meizhen know that you're doing it and where
    -[X] Train at the vent with Su Ling
    -- [X] Arm Meridian
    -- [X] Free: Give her AC
    -- [X] Minor: You haven't had much time for Li Suyin lately, and you have a mysterious tome, maybe the two of you could work on deciphering it?
    - [X] Have a chat with Han Jian, it has been some time since you trained together, see what is occupying him
    --[X] Meizhen is going out shopping for something at the market, though she hasn't mentioned what. Tag along?
 
What's the tally right now?



Xuan Shi was capable of paralyzing a peer for a month with Formations.
Yeah, but how long did it take for him to get to that level? Did he have to prepare it beforehand? Did it cost him any Qi?

I mean it's a decent data point, but it still doesn't give us a heuristic for what we can expect after studying for say a month.
 
My opinion is that if we find an art, we want the maximum amount of weeks remaining to change plans for it if we like it. Same for a number of other items, like exceptional medicine.
Opening the Shaman's bag is fine and something I want to do, but we have too many other important minors to do so. I'm still hesitating to change my vote for Thor's Twin plan because I prefer the Han Jian minor to Xuan Shi's, but both of those are really important.

Also, getting ZB+ early means being able to tell early how much we want to train it, just like for a hypothetical art in the shaman's bag.
Didn't the Elder just say we wouldn't have been able to keep them if they were that dangerous?

And didn't we just open the first set of bags without the Elder's oversight?
We did get a +3 to the rolls thanks to the Lesson, but @yrsillar has confirmed the successes are piling on each others, so we don't actually need the +3 dice at all. It's like the Tokens, we aren't going to destroy them, we just might take longer to open them.
 
Mmmh, OK, going to switch for a few hours, to see how it will go. Mainly because I really like Han Jian's action. Not a huge fan of meridians instead of TRF though. That plan is also VERY similar to @Thor's Twin, but I think I prefer meridian to FSA, mostly because beginning FSA now still feels iffier to me than waiting a couple weeks for it.

[X] Plan War

Will probably switch back when waking up if sharing is caring needs votes against a non-ZB plan.
 
Back
Top