Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
Mathilde isn't, actually. There are grandmasters in the Empire who've spent the lion's share their self-improvement actions studying the blade, compared to Mathilde who's spent most of that time learning magic. Mathilde's ability to claim mastery level swordswomanship largely comes from learning how to best utilize her one-of-a-kind magic sword's advantages. And even then, a grandmaster wielding a Runefang would still wipe the floor with her in a sword-only fight.

In fairness, if they have a Runefang, then we should probably get to keep Branalhune, at which point it becomes a question of if they can completely avoid parrying or taking even what would ordinarily be a glancing hit, while Mathilde has no such restrictions.

It probably wouldn't make it an easy fight, even so, but "You win if you get any hit on me, I need to get something properly incapacitating on you, and also I lose if I parry" seems like the sort of thing you might see a swordmaster impose on themselves to make a fight against a less-skilled opponent relatively even.
 
I don't see why people aren't voting for both. We are nearly the best humans alive at swording. Why not go full force into this? I absolutely think it's worth the time.
I'm pretty sure we aren't even close to the best human alive at Swording. We can get away with a hell of a lot due to Branalhune, but in pure technical skill I would expect a bunch of people to be ahead of us, such as the heads of knightly orders.

And that's fine. Mathilde is a Wizard, gunner, sword-using sneaky girl. She probably shouldn't have as much pure skill as a Knightly order grandmaster. She doesn't have to. She just has to cheat harder.
 
Not sure what exactly would happen if a cuts-through-anything Runefang parried a Cannonball-blade, or vice versa. But it seems to me likely it would not be good for at least one of the weapons.
From who made the runefangs i do think the fang survives it better. The wielder still has to deal with the transfer of the force so how he's doing is another matter. But Alaric was very good at making bs weapons when he set his mind to it.
 
"My Emperour! Urgent News! The entire Grey Collage has been murdered down to the last man! This is truly dire news. We need to find the culprit at once!"
"Have you checked the library?"
"...The library sire?"
"Yes, dead shadow wizard's have a mysterious tendency to show up there after dying"

The virgin Tomb Kings versus the chad nerd Shadow Wizards.
 
I suspect that regardless of which sword wins that exchange, the more pressing problem for whoever's on the other side is that the Runefang winds up going through you when a cannonball hits it because you put it between you and said cannonball, yes. Whether that's because it explodes or because it's ripped out of your hands is somewhat academic.
 
I know it probably won't happen, but I can't help but imagine Eike wearing a full imitation of Mathilde's usual outfit during her journeying and thus spreading Mathilde's legend further as people mistake her for Mathilde.
 
I know it probably won't happen, but I can't help but imagine Eike wearing a full imitation of Mathilde's usual outfit during her journeying and thus spreading Mathilde's legend further as people mistake her for Mathilde.
I feel you have to earn the hat by having a handsome older witchhunter fall in battle next to you and then entrust you with their legacy. Otherwise it's like witchhunter chic. And Eike is too young for handsome older witchhunters.
 
All right, so we know one of the ??? is Greatswords.

With the remaining two... unless she also studied a different weapon, could just be two different kinds of Strategy or Tactics? Probably nothing completed, but a 1/3 or 2/3?
So I just realized that we actually have one more piece of evidence in the puzzle that is Eike's charsheet:
There's three +1 boni there. One is Pistols, one is Greatswords, so that leaves just one +1 unaccounted for. So it can't be that both of the remaining skills are uncompleted, unless Eike also has a general trait that improves martial*. One has to be complete and provide Eike with a +1 martial bonus. I think it can't be a weapon skill, because Greatswords just got completed and that would imply that she has another weapon that she's been training with more than the one she's receiving private lessons for, and in that case why wouldn't she use that weapon instead? And it can't be Strategy and Tactics, those skills don't give a generic Martial bonus. I think the only plausible skill left is Riding, though I don't know if that would give +1 Martial.

*maybe Book Protagonist, +1 to all stats - ah but actually that can't be right, learning just has a +2
 
Eike shows up dressed as Mathilde, first reaction is just
"Have you grown, you look taller Mathilde!"
 
So I just realized that we actually have one more piece of evidence in the puzzle that is Eike's charsheet:

There's three +1 boni there. One is Pistols, one is Greatswords, so that leaves just one +1 unaccounted for. So it can't be that both of the remaining skills are uncompleted, unless Eike also has a general trait that improves martial*. One has to be complete and provide Eike with a +1 martial bonus. I think it can't be a weapon skill, because Greatswords just got completed and that would imply that she has another weapon that she's been training with more than the one she's receiving private lessons for, and in that case why wouldn't she use that weapon instead? And it can't be Strategy and Tactics, those skills don't give a generic Martial bonus. I think the only plausible skill left is Riding, though I don't know if that would give +1 Martial.

*maybe Book Protagonist, +1 to all stats - ah but actually that can't be right, learning just has a +2
Fitness does give +1 to Martial right? It is probably that.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top