Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Honesly, I'd rather not discuss a character based largely on his canon warhammer representation. This is Boneyhammer, the empress was a Lahmian agent, Algard faked his death and became the Grey Patriarch, Van Horstmann has a large chance of being incredibly loyal. Canon is but a suggestion.

I also used to be very much against Starke before we met him, but this version seems a bit more reasonable than his canon self. Of couse, grey wizards are extremely good at seeming., but still.
 
Last edited:
I want to make use of all the everyone.
Question about this specifically, because you're not the first to voice something similar. Why do you either a.) Think someone is more qualified to make decisions on this expedition or b.) Think someone has a unique relevant skill to this situation?

Mathilde is a lady magister, even if someone had the wind sight to notice the magic flow or the mentality to notice the cognitohazard (and they probably don't, it could effect dwarfs without them noticing and Mathilde only noticed because of what she is) nobody is more qualified to make decisions on magic than the lady magister.
 
I think the only person that might have a unique capability to add here might be Deathfang, and Stand your ground calls him here.
 
The possibility space of likely responses is not nearly confined to 'triggering their Ritual early'.

As others have also pointed out the ritual might not be the immediate threat. Conflating the Big Bad Magic with the response they (any active observers) may trigger to someone discovering the Big Bad Magic isn't helpful to your factual analysis. Making decisions based on 'they won't trigger a 200-year-ritual early just because Protagonist' doesn't seem to be a sound premise.

Any active observers- assuming they exist- had advance warning something significant was probably coming up the pass when the weather was cleared.
Mathilde has given no clear indication that
Bearing in mind the Rangers may also need to pass the bluff.
They only beed to pass the bluff if they can first see through Mathilde's bluff.
Act normally won't accomplish much in this scenario. If it's a triggered effect we've already activated, we'd probably be caught in between, neither able to disrupt it, and possibly not far enough away to be safe.
The Warhammer Fantasy universe has many mind affecting spells. Mind reading not so much. Even with excellent Windsight Mathilde's inherent Ulgu makes it hard for anyone to discern if she is confused about anything.
You're not insane and despite voting for standing our ground I do worry that we are jumping the gun. Despite that, I feel that going back to the convoy would be giving up ground when we desperately need every inch and any advantage we gain might very well give our unseen opponents more time to prepare. I don't feel like the possible advantage is worth ceding the initiative. I guess I also am willing to bet on the expedition being better able to react to 'suddenly chaos' than whatever is lurking in the mountain can react to sudden discovery. His argument about stacking the deck was strong, but Mathilde already had every ace up her sleeve.
What if the Chaos ambush in question isn't here at all, because this ritual that we know nothing about happens to not be about blasting or swarming passing expeditions? What if instead the ambush is somewhere just ahead on the High Pass with the goal of preventing anyone from turning off their free influx of magic? In that case standing our ground here and calling for backup massively weakens the expedition caravan while running away in a rush informs the locals that, not only do we fear an imminent ambush, we also seem to know far too much to be allowed to escape alive.
Part of Mathilde's soul is made of Ulgu instead of whatever it is souls are usually made of, so it's impossible to cut her off entirely without tearing out those parts.
If Mathilde were to go to a realm that doesn't have a device that splits magic into eight parts, one of which is Ulgu, would her soul still continue to be a piece and source of Ulgu on its own? Or is it more of a conduit/attractor?
I know that Mathilde has no way of knowing the exact answer to this IC, but it doesn't seem like something to become relevant anytime soon if this doesn't become a planswalker/isekai/crossover quest, so I thought I could try asking anyway.
The next duel for Supreme Patriarch is in the second half of this year.
I forgot. Is the position of College Matriarch also up for being won through dueling?
Algard faked his death
Wait, what? I missed that part. Is Algard a canon character too?
 
I forgot. Is the position of College Matriarch also up for being won through dueling?

Wait, what? I missed that part. Is Algard a canon character too?
1) Each College is free to employ whatever method they want for it, but usually it is a vote by LMs or all Magisters of the College in question. It wouldn't surprise me if it is a duel for Brights. Not very likely for Greys, though.
2) He doesn't have a huge presence, but he has some lines attributed to him here and there and his Towers of Screaming Death are canonical.
warhammerfantasy.fandom.com

Algard

The legends of Algard, the renowned Grey Wizard, are rife with half truths and fictitious tales, not surprising perhaps, for a practitioner of the Lore of Shadow. However, one enduring myth turned out to be true--Algard had achieved his collection of eldritch tomes into a fastness so well...
 
Last edited:
The Warhammer Fantasy universe has many mind affecting spells. Mind reading not so much. Even with excellent Windsight Mathilde's inherent Ulgu makes it hard for anyone to discern if she is confused about anything.

Creatures with good Windsight can read your thoughts straight off your soul, no active magic required.
 
On the Reiner Starke subject its important to notice that his zealot character is a canon thing of the future. While we don't ignore canon we can't ignore the butterflies, Reiner is currently a faithful, we know that but it doesn't necessarily means a zealot. He can become one but so much things have changed we can't count on his beliefs that The cult of Sigmar unites the Empire. Thats his zealot thing, not the prayer itself. For all we know the Ulric-Elf thing, possible glory from Knight units such as the Taal one, the Ranaldite Empress stuff... canon religion balance has being thrown of a long time ago.

Edit: but even so, if he does become Patriarch we have to take the boss religion in consideration if we want a nice relationship. Thats not even a zealot thing, just a common sense one. Disdain is different from neutrality.
 
Last edited:
They can read your feelings. That can be a very large difference.

Mathilde can read people's feelings. Other creatures with Witchsight can read surface thoughts or memories. Yet other creatures can see echoes of people's past actions or reverberations of their potential future ones.

Different people have very different versions of Witchsight.
 
Truthfully I am proud of Turkish in how dwarwish it is, -with being almost understandable in almost 3 thousand years old writings.

Real talk, that even my own contemporaries often don't understand the bastard southern twang is the true reason I refuse to abandon my accent despite not using it normally. This attitude is acceptable.
 
If Mathilde were to go to a realm that doesn't have a device that splits magic into eight parts, one of which is Ulgu, would her soul still continue to be a piece and source of Ulgu on its own? Or is it more of a conduit/attractor?

Mathilde's soul is not a source of Ulgu, it is partially made of it.

The question is unanswerable, because it would depend entirely on the nature of souls in the new realm.

I forgot. Is the position of College Matriarch also up for being won through dueling?

Not in the Grey College.
 
I'm not trying to argue that the Rune of Superior Skill should work on the mountain here, but I was re-reading the Early quest the last few days, and "Mountains are not foes" amused me right about the time I hit the section of the purge dealing with the "Blasphemy of Blood". I had forgotten that we've seen a mountain killed before, for doing "evil magic stuff".

Gustav had greater luck with his adventure; what was once the tallest peak in the western Wold is now very much not so, and he's quite pleased to add 'killing a mountain' to his list of deeds.
....
The problem of what to do with the spring was puzzling for a while, and then he'd apparently decided that thinking was for other people and decided to hit it until it went away,
....
You're slightly annoyed that 'hit it until it stops doing evil magic stuff' has proven effective even against inanimate objects.
 
I mean, look at the size of the military expedition. Six steam wagons, 13 wizards, several thousand people and a dragon.

Err. I believe the headcount is, and somebody correct me if I'm wrong:

150 Rangers
50 Engineers
50 Slayers
---
13 Wizards
1 Ice Witch
---
1 Dragonlord (real dragon included!)
100 Knights of Taal's Fury
100 Winter Wolves

Which adds up to less than 500.
 
I didn't notice whatever people seem to think implies the "mountain" knows it's been discovered. Rather, it's been there for centuries. It may notice that something is going on from the large-scale wheather manipulation, but I don't see anything that's about to unleash a demon horde on us right this second. As such, I don't think immediate actions is warranted. More "Immediate consolidation of forces".

[X] Act normal
[X] Run like hell
 
Last edited:
[X] Act normal

With the clarification that Mathilde thinks inviting all the other wizards to shank any incoming spell in the ribs will have better odds then just doing it alone, plus the earlier foreshadowing in the update about not tipping off your mark, I'm switching to this.
 
[X] Act normal

With the clarification that Mathilde thinks inviting all the other wizards to shank any incoming spell in the ribs will have better odds then just doing it alone, plus the earlier foreshadowing in the update about not tipping off your mark, I'm switching to this.
Yeah, OK, fair enough.

[X] Act normal
[X] Stone is an excellent insulator of magic.
 
Back
Top