Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
[X] Regrowth - Ghyran, instantly restores someone to full health from any state up to and including 'recently dead'. -9 College Favours
[X] As a chronicler, here to record events.

Thought I voted chronicler.
 
tally
Adhoc vote count started by Seventeen on Mar 26, 2018 at 8:15 AM, finished with 13164 posts and 102 votes.
 
[X] Regrowth - Ghyran, instantly restores someone to full health from any state up to and including 'recently dead'. -9 College Favours
[X] Nothing further was commissioned.

[X] As a representative of the Grey Order, here to lend a hand where it can be of most use.
[X] As a representative of the Colleges of Magic, here to provide magical aid.
[X] As a chronicler, here to record events.
[X] As a researcher, here to investigate any strange and interesting phenomena that can be found.
 
I'm kind of surprised Empire is so low down on the list, it seemed like a pretty popular sentiment that we wanted to go to Eight Peaks because to pay back the help we previously received from the dwarfs.

Also chronicler seemed to come out of nowhere. I thought Mathilde hated having to write reports and I don't think anyone expressed the sentiment of wanting to write things down about what goes on at Eight Peaks.
 
I've come up with a possible weapon we can use during the coming battles. The concept is using Mathilde's Matrix to place Pall of Darkness into an animal which is placed in a cage. The cage can then be thrown into a group of enemies to put then into a field of bewildering impenetrable darkness. I can see it being very effectively used to counter charges, quite possibly even causing a charge to completely fail and only cause casualties on the enemy side.

Of course there are a number of potential problems.

1. It might not even work, Pall of Darkness is a new spell for Mathilde and I don't think she's ever used it for a matrix. The result might cause the target animal to explode and successfully release the spell or to release the spell and not explode (good results), or it might result in complete failure such as the darkness remaining only inside the animal and thus being pointless (who cares if an animals insides are dark).

2. The dwarfs tend not to think much of human magic so I very much doubt the dwarfs would want to be given an animal that explodes into a cloud of impenetrable darkness that Mathilde cooked up over an hour or so.

Admittedly the dwarf's acceptance of human magic makes giving this to the dwarfs worse that pointless (it would probably antagonize them) but there are almost certainly at least some human auxiliaries around and they might be far more accepting, especially if this Darkness grenade works as well as I expect it might to counter charges. Considering that any humans here are going to be relatively soft and desirable targets compared to the dwarf forces we might pick up some decent customers and popularity if this concept works out well.

Regardless it only takes about an hour to test so it's something we should give a shot at some point to see if it has potential.

3. It might not be as effective against those who already spend their lives in almost complete darkness like goblins and Skaven who have other senses like ears and smell to guide them. Still be handy in a fight but they would not be completly lost like those who primairly depend on sight to move and fight.

I'm kind of surprised Empire is so low down on the list, it seemed like a pretty popular sentiment that we wanted to go to Eight Peaks because to pay back the help we previously received from the dwarfs.

I personally think it's a lie since the Empire did not send us and we are not commissioned as their representative, plus it would feel like an insult the Empire honours their help by sending only one person, and a wizard at that.
 
We could grab some of the enemy place a spell matrix into them and then Mindhole them, then wait until a battle and trigger the spells so that we can surprise them with a bunch of spells from the inside of their formation.
 
[X] As a wanderer, not entirely sure what you seek.
[X] As a representative of the Grey Order, here to lend a hand where it can be of most use.

[X] Boon of Hysh - Hysh, instantly heals all wounds, poisons and disease. -5 College Favours.
[X] 2 Dispel Scrolls

The regrowth recharge method has been noted as being 'dramatic' if something that can be done in a reasonably short time period. To me that implies a certain level of difficulty or danger, wheras the boon of hysh is almos as good and almost certainly easier to recharge.

The dispel scrolls are incredibly valuable because being able to slap down a high powered spell that no one on your side could counter in time can make or break battles or entire campaigns. Whilst they can cast again high tier magic has a fairly high miscast chance and gives the rest of the army or our mortars a round or so to target them without large portions of the army dying in the process.

I don't like the chronicler vote. I feel that making this a job for Mathilde, especially with the exacting details the dwarfs may desire, will suck the fun and inspiration out of her words just like writing the matrix paper did. Having her make a chronicle at the end would make more sense to me.
 
Given how much dwarves use guns, I don't think they'd enjoy random blind spots anyway.
Pall of Darkness is mostly valuable when retreating from an oncoming force, since it throws them into chaos when you start shooting bullets, bombs and fire while they cross darkness. Situational. Noting of course that any laden animals with darkness spells in them are prone to be squished in the chaos of battle, so stocking large numbers isn't a bright idea when they might go off in your own formations.

The light spell probably wouldn't be bad.
I'm kind of surprised Empire is so low down on the list, it seemed like a pretty popular sentiment that we wanted to go to Eight Peaks because to pay back the help we previously received from the dwarfs.
As a Magister of the Grey Order(a title equivalent to a a noble rank), we are in fact qualified to claim honestly that we are here on behalf of the Grey College without stretching overmuch. The grounds grow more tenuous when claiming for the Colleges as a whole. When claiming for the Empire...its mostly bullshit and the dwarfs know it,, considering they've been to the Elector's Meet and know the decisionmakers' opinion on things.
Also chronicler seemed to come out of nowhere. I thought Mathilde hated having to write reports and I don't think anyone expressed the sentiment of wanting to write things down about what goes on at Eight Peaks.
She quite enjoyed writing Asarnil's memoirs, and the players in general expressed approval of the idea of writing memoirs in general.

She mostly has a problem with dry research papers, and its well...only the one paper...which to be fair she's trying to explain the construction of a particular shape using sight alone to someone who only has the sense of touch. The Perfect paper would have been Mathilde explaining that such that it made sense.
 
Pall of Darkness is mostly valuable when retreating from an oncoming force, since it throws them into chaos when you start shooting bullets, bombs and fire while they cross darkness. Situational. Noting of course that any laden animals with darkness spells in them are prone to be squished in the chaos of battle, so stocking large numbers isn't a bright idea when they might go off in your own formations.

The light spell probably wouldn't be bad.
Honestly, the best battlefield use of Pall is probably against a gunline. Drop it in front of the enemy and you give your troops time to close in.
 
Honestly, the best battlefield use of Pall is probably against a gunline. Drop it in front of the enemy and you give your troops time to close in.
Short range of the spell may make it rather hard.


Speaking about Matrix and released spells - silly as it is, a wandering mouse equipped with Dread Aspect and released against an opposing army makes for an amusing mental picture.
 
Why not grab individual enemies place the pall of darkness matrix into them then Mindhole them, once we do that we can simply trigger the spell whenever we need it?
 
Last edited:
[X] Regrowth - Ghyran, instantly restores someone to full health from any state up to and including 'recently dead'. -9 College Favours
[X] As a representative of the Empire, honouring the ancient alliance between Man and Dwarf.
[X] As a representative of the Grey Order, here to lend a hand where it can be of most use.

Because like fuck we gonna have someone we like or care about die on our watch this time.
 
You know, I had a thought. The best possible use the Dwarves could make of us in battle would be to build a Siege Tower with a bonfire on the top of it. Then build a mirrored shield behind the bonfire, with us in front of it. That way we could be an Icon of Fear whose shadow burns away enemies flesh.
 
You know, I had a thought. The best possible use the Dwarves could make of us in battle would be to build a Siege Tower with a bonfire on the top of it. Then build a mirrored shield behind the bonfire, with us in front of it. That way we could be an Icon of Fear whose shadow burns away enemies flesh.
I'm pretty sure it's not the best use of our talent.
 
The best use the dwarves can make of us is not our direct combat potential, the thing Grey wizards are good at is being sneaky. What we should be doing is scouting the enemy, finding their troop concentrations, sabotaging their equipment and artillery, poisoning their supplies, damaging their moral through grisely examples and showing them they aren't safe anywhere and potentially assassinating their leaders. If we do it right we should be able to both find the best place and time for a battle and tip the balance before it even begins.
 
You know, I had a thought. The best possible use the Dwarves could make of us in battle would be to build a Siege Tower with a bonfire on the top of it. Then build a mirrored shield behind the bonfire, with us in front of it. That way we could be an Icon of Fear whose shadow burns away enemies flesh.
Mathilde doesn't know battle magic, and trying to directly alter the battlefield like she does seems like it won't end well. The best use for someone of her talents is to locate a dwarf ranger willing to bring her stealth skills up to par, and train under him long enough they'll grudgingly permit her to participate in the shadow wars, which is her best chance at changing the outcome of battles.
How would one do artillery in tunnels? What's the average tunnel war like anyway?
For the size of things in Karak Eight Peaks we're talking about a major Dwarf hold so they start at massive, and end somewhere at "took triple digit generations to complete".
 
Last edited:
What do you mean bring our skills up to par the advantage from our spells in terms of any shadow war is so huge it blows almost any Dwarf ranger out of the water. Sure we can always improve but we're certainly useful now.
 
To be fair, Dwarf Rangers are good, but they're probably the worst at fieldcraft out of all of the races.

They're good enough that they can get their job done and occasionally get one over their opposite numbers, but aren't typically noted for being exceptional on the big scheme of things.
 
What do you mean bring our skills up to par the advantage from our spells in terms of any shadow war is so huge it blows almost any Dwarf ranger out of the water. Sure we can always improve but we're certainly useful now.
To be fair, Dwarf Rangers are good, but they're probably the worst at fieldcraft out of all of the races.

They're good enough that they can get their job done and occasionally get one over their opposite numbers, but aren't typically noted for being exceptional on the big scheme of things.
Dwarves do all have excellent night vision, able to see well up to about 25-30 metres in just starlight. So, they can probably get by underground with ambient phosphorescence or the dimmest of lanterns. As far as I'm aware, Mathilde can't, and I'm not sure if her Ulgu-windsense compensates(?)
 
Last edited:
[X] Boon of Hysh - Hysh, instantly heals all wounds, poisons and disease. -5 College Favours.
[X] 4 Dispel scrolls (-2 collage favours)
 
Voting is open
Back
Top