Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting will open in 19 hours, 38 minutes
You'd think so. You'd fucking think so. But it's vital infrastructure, which is why the government will immediately start cutting the funding and manpower. And then some new project manager wants to change everything to show how in charge he is and mucks things up until he gets fired, and then he gets his momma and they come back to demand the position back. And by the end, nobody cares about the thing keeping everyone alive, because it's been working just fine so far. And the only one who actually understands and maintains the system is you. If you think not being able to leaving is going to make the boss more likely to hire support for you, then you live in a better world.

Please, you are Caledor Dragontamer, master of the Vortex, wielder of power greater than gods. You don't have a boss. Or manpower beyond the mages who got stuck in the Vortex with you. And no one can really reach you to either add or detract from your manpower. Maybe you feel vaguely sorry for the poor sods frozen in time with the care packages just beyond the walls. But still, you do have dozens of archmages sitting in the vortex with you and they don't have much better to do. Honestly having something new to do is probably a godsend for relieving boredom.
 
We do also have dwarf and Skaven books on Warpstone, the latter up to exotic. What, if anything, do they say on the matter?

I'd imagine that if the halflife of warp stone is anywhere over a hundred thousand years, then they don't have enough data to draw conclusions yet.

I think the idea is that evaporation is proportional to surface area, like with physical material, and grinding it up massively increases surface area. You then rub it on the waystone so that when the phase transition is triggered (potentially by the rubbing), it gets absorbed right away.

On the other hand, grinding up uranium really won't change the amount of radiation it emits, I think. And uranium won't just evaporate into radiation, it sticks around even though it emits.

Mental models may not match reality here.

I imagine theyd prefer having dwarfs protecting these specifically, but at the same time I imagine if the dwarf numbers aren't there, they're looking over at the Udumgi while stroking their beards contemplative.

"Hey Gretel, do you have an apprentice we can put in charge of another bunch of territory yet? How about Wolfheart, what's he up to these days?"
 
Sylvania is, appropriately enough, already dead. There's just a lot of work left to do with axe and flame before it gets the message.
I just noticed a rather amusing irony.

The Reikland Emperor thinks that now the time is right to invade Sylvania and put an end to the vampire menace once and for all. The other Emperors think this would make him too popular, so they team up and threaten to go to war on him if he does. Politics ruins everything.

An attempt by the feuding Emperors to unite against him is stymied when two of them simultaneously assassinate each other while battling on the same side against the undead hordes.

"Okay, but why in the world would..." she falls silent, then sighs. "Because I'm an unmarried and apparently childless woman with an inoffensive pet cause. The ambitious think they might be able to marry me into their dynasty, the unambitious think that the power of the Emperor stamping down on Sylvania is preferable to the usual political or religious pet causes of nobility, and everyone thinks that if they put me on the throne, they or their heir will get another chance to properly exercise that power before too long, whereas anyone else as Emperor would have the inheritance locked down for their preferred heir. I'm a perfect compromise candidate if none of the others can get a clear lead."
It is kind of funny that after the absloute clusterfunk that is the empire turning against itself whenever they are finally pushing back Sylvania, so as to not get someone popular enough from crushing the vampire menace to end the age of three emperors. It end up that going the exact opposite with someone who had already crushed them and well on the way to subdue Sylvania getting chosen as a political compromise candidate.

History does like to Rhymes after all.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, grinding up uranium really won't change the amount of radiation it emits, I think. And uranium won't just evaporate into radiation, it sticks around even though it emits.

Mental models may not match reality here.
Sure, but we do know that warpstone does in fact evaporate into gas. We can conjecture it does this at a low level all the time, to explain why it produces Dhar. And if that's the hypothesis, then guessing the surface area makes a difference is a plausible idea.

Testing it would be quite simple, though also dangerous and illegal.
 
However, the riverine component of the hybrid waystones gets wasted if it's not put in a river, obviously, and it is explicitly noted to be "Very difficult, moderate cost" compared to Caledor leylines' "Trivial, simple cost".
Ah, I hadn't realised that the Leyline component was so cheap to include. Okay, it's not worth making a rivers-only version. A cheap Leyline-only version and an expensive Leyline-only version should be good enough, unless the thread unexpectedly decides to look into Material transmission.

(Which wouldn't be the worst thing in the world, mind you - even if we never make a Waystone with it, the chance to learn how these various extremely knowledgeable magic-users manage that could be extremely useful for enchanting someday.)
 
Sure, but we do know that warpstone does in fact evaporate into gas. We can conjecture it does this at a low level all the time, to explain why it produces Dhar. And if that's the hypothesis, then guessing the surface area makes a difference is a plausible idea.

Testing it would be quite simple, though also dangerous and illegal.
We don't know that Warpstone evaporates. That's the leading theory but there's no actual proof.
 
Question then: Is Morrslieb solid Warpstone, or is it something else, covered in it? ... we could speak with our dragon friends about it.
Edit: Frankly would make my year if it was a Old One space station.
If it's an old ones orbital platform, that could help explain why and how it keeps coming back every time it gets shoved away.
 
But man actually do wanna see what diety Tindomiel thinks is totally Hekarti in a human friendly hat.
Me too, but we didn't pick the "dedicate the Waystones to a human diety" option, we picked the "dedicate the Waystones to Hekarti but be subtle about it" option, so we're not going to find out the identity of Hekarti's supposed human guise from House Tindomiel's Waystones.
You're right, Sarumar is actually Eltharin.
Article:
Sarumar - Temptation, fulfillment, discipline, the Watcher in the Dark.

...They sent the guy named The Watcher in the Dark, Discipline, and Temptation to Watch over his colleague in a Dark land, mantain Discipline and ensure he doesn't fall into Temptation.
 
"Forty of these," you say, tapping on the schematics, "equidistant around the shore." You tap a map of the region around the Black Water. "According to the range of estimates of how much exposed warpstone there is underwater, the ambient level of magic in the water will reach an equilibrium at somewhere between a quarter to a twentieth of the current levels within a year of completion."

The King of Barak Varr and the King of Zhufbar look from the maps to Thorek, who nods once.

That is the end of the meeting.

One of my favourite parts is, for someone who doesn't know about Mathilde's relationship with Dwarves, this look the two Kings give Thorek would probably be interpreted as, "Does this mad Umgi mage really think we're buying any of this shit?"

While of course it's actually closer to, "Is this one of those fabled Mathilde-brand miracles we're being offered right now?"

Thorek: Nods once.
 
Last edited:
We don't know that Warpstone evaporates. That's the leading theory but there's no actual proof.
Do you have a quote on that? I thought that was exactly the point under contention.
We know it does evaporate from the ratling gun paper, because explosive transition into dhar, which for a short time acts as an tangible gas, which is how the bullets are fired. Someone quoted that a few pages back.

What we don't know is whether it does this without an external trigger like in the ratling gun. It's plausible and explains why warpstone emits Dhar, but it's not a given.
 
Last edited:
We know it does evaporate from the ratling gun paper, because explosive transition into dhar, which for a short time acts as an tangible gas, which is how the bullets are fired. Someone quoted that a few pages back.

What we don't know is whether it does this without an external trigger like in the ratling gun. It's plausible and explains why warpstone emits Dhar, but it's not a given.
I wouldn't describe that as evaporation though. That's a detonation.
 
So are we going to need to do the other deployment actions in kislev and the empire or will the governments handle that without us?

If you trust those governments to handle it without you, you can leave it entirely in their hands. If you think there's something that should be prioritized, it's best to do it yourself.

Article:
Sarumar - Temptation, fulfillment, discipline, the Watcher in the Dark.

...They sent the guy named The Watcher in the Dark, Discipline, and Temptation to Watch over his colleague in a Dark land, mantain Discipline and ensure he doesn't fall into Temptation.

That's Eltharin for you. Every word has so many meanings that you can't do anything without it seeming to be foreshadowed by destiny.
 
I wouldn't describe that as evaporation though. That's a detonation.
It's a detonation produced by evaporation. Or, well, technically it's sublimation, since it's solid to gas, and evaporation means liquid to gas. But it goes from something dense to something that really doesn't want to be dense (gas) and so it pushes all the surrounding stuff away. Gunpowder works the same way. Solid thing becomes a cramped gas and is mad about it.
 
Ah, I hadn't realised that the Leyline component was so cheap to include. Okay, it's not worth making a rivers-only version. A cheap Leyline-only version and an expensive Leyline-only version should be good enough, unless the thread unexpectedly decides to look into Material transmission.

(Which wouldn't be the worst thing in the world, mind you - even if we never make a Waystone with it, the chance to learn how these various extremely knowledgeable magic-users manage that could be extremely useful for enchanting someday.)
I'm not arguing that a riverine-only model would be bad (riverine-only leylines do have the advantage of making the Foundation component easier/cheaper, which could pair up nicely with the cheaper versions of the other components), I'm only arguing that hybrid riverine/Caledor leylines are in fact the most costly/difficult of the leyline options and thus it'd be a bit of a waste to use the hybrid model in places where there are no rivers.
 
Last edited:
Ah, I hadn't realised that the Leyline component was so cheap to include. Okay, it's not worth making a rivers-only version. A cheap Leyline-only version and an expensive Leyline-only version should be good enough, unless the thread unexpectedly decides to look into Material transmission.

(Which wouldn't be the worst thing in the world, mind you - even if we never make a Waystone with it, the chance to learn how these various extremely knowledgeable magic-users manage that could be extremely useful for enchanting someday.)

It might be worth it to make a stripped down riverine-only waystone if we go for the mobile waystones on boats idea. If we don't do that it's probably not worth it.
 
Understated thing is "blackwater that's waaaay less blackwater-y AND dotted by a ton of Dwarven fortifications" is that's gonna open up a ton of livable territory that dwarves aren't going to be terribly interested in filling the economic niche of. I predict that there are going to be fishing villages popping up before the fortifications are even halfway done.
 
I'm not arguing that a riverine-only model would be bad (riverine-only leylines do have the advantage of making the Foundation component easier/cheaper, which could pair up nicely with the cheaper versions of the other components), I'm only arguing that hybrid riverine/Caledor leylines are in fact the most costly/difficult of the leyline options and thus it'd be a bit of a waste to use the hybrid model in places where there are no rivers.
Yes, that was my position as well.

It might be worth it to make a stripped down riverine-only waystone if we go for the mobile waystones on boats idea. If we don't do that it's probably not worth it.
Even then, for removing "Simple/Trivial" implementation costs it wouldn't be worth it.
 
Understated thing is "blackwater that's waaaay less blackwater-y AND dotted by a ton of Dwarven fortifications" is that's gonna open up a ton of livable territory that dwarves aren't going to be terribly interested in filling the economic niche of. I predict that there are going to be fishing villages popping up before the fortifications are even halfway done.
Well probably not quite then. Until all the weird beasties die of dhar starvation or what have you. There is shit up there thats really ,really scary, and far more likely to venture out of the deep than the stuff thats in middle of the ocean.
 
Reminder that on the timescale of the Way Stone Network, rivers shift all the time. A given waystone may switch between being in a river and not being in a river multiple times over the course of even just a single millenia.
 
Understated thing is "blackwater that's waaaay less blackwater-y AND dotted by a ton of Dwarven fortifications" is that's gonna open up a ton of livable territory that dwarves aren't going to be terribly interested in filling the economic niche of. I predict that there are going to be fishing villages popping up before the fortifications are even halfway done.
Given the Black Water's population of Dhar-affected water-life, that might have to wait a few decades before it's deemed safe enough even for Umgi... though certainly, humans have settled in worse locations over the years.
 
Voting will open in 19 hours, 38 minutes
Back
Top