Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
I could have sworn there was a conversation years ago trying to figure out how invisibility works specifically, and how it works on both physical bodies and magical energy, and the explanation was 'it makes things invisible by making them invisible via magic'. Because magic.

Any of the honourable archivists able to help?
 
I could have sworn there was a conversation years ago trying to figure out how invisibility works specifically, and how it works on both physical bodies and magical energy, and the explanation was 'it makes things invisible by making them invisible via magic'. Because magic.

Any of the honourable archivists able to help?

Beep boop I'm a quote fetching bot:

The mechanism that Shroud of Invisibility uses to make people invisible is magic. It's not perfect transparency, or bending the light, or some form of telepathy where you influence people's brains to not notice you. The mechanism it uses to achieve invisibility is magic. That's why it also makes you invisible to Magesight, because it's not dependent on preventing people from sensing the light that bounces off you and therefore other forms of sight that don't use this mechanism still work. It is making you invisible with magic.

It's like if someone asks how a Bright Wizard makes a fireball, they're barking up the wrong tree if they start thinking that they must be creating heat and fuel and oxygen. They create fire by magic. Yes, fire normally needs heat and fuel and oxygen. Magical fire doesn't, because it works by magic.
 
Summoning in the Fate series feels too risk free for my tastes. But that is just my personal opinion.
"If I die, you'll follow shortly after because the contract is all that keeps you alive" is a pretty efficient leash. IIRC, there is also supposed to be a "ready to obey, even if grudgingly" criteria on summoning, but that's an IIRC and nasu is bad with these things at the best of times.

Even with that in play, tho, getting punked by your own servant is a thing that... actually happens pretty regularly? In every war, there are a bunch of masters who are killed by their servants, directly or indirectly.
 
You can make the same argument for all Heroic Spirits. Wich is kind of why i don't like Fate very much, it feels weird seeing powerful historical and mythological figures (many of them famous for their ego and pride) obey modern day humans without a second trought.

Realistically, most Servants would just murder their Master at the first chance they get and proceed to do whatever they want.

Summoning in the Fate series feels too risk free for my tastes. But that is just my personal opinion.
There's really 3 things keeping them in line. The 3 command spells that let them give an absolute order, which *can* include ordering them to suicide. So... there's that. Then there's the fact that the servants are, for the most part, utterly dependent on their summoner for mana to sustain their existence. And, finally and perhaps most importantly, they mostly *also* want the wish from the grail. It's part of how the spell chooses who to summon. So they'll go along with things because they need the mage alive so they can win. Saber tends to be pretty loyal and obedient to her summoner, but uh, almost every other servant is pretty independent. Like, they'll protect their master because that person is their obvious weakpoint, but very few of them actually are submissive or obedient.

So, to make this less of a derail, what do we think Mathilde's wish would be? She seems to have mostly accepted Van Hal's death at this point, so I doubt she'd wish him back. (She could have just gone the omegahugger route if she wanted that :V) So... Killing a chaos god? Knowledge of some sort? I dunno, how strong a wish *could* the grail grant?
 
So, to make this less of a derail, what do we think Mathilde's wish would be? She seems to have mostly accepted Van Hal's death at this point, so I doubt she'd wish him back. (She could have just gone the omegahugger route if she wanted that :V) So... Killing a chaos god? Knowledge of some sort? I dunno, how strong a wish *could* the grail grant?

Since there are four Chaos Gods and I am assuming a wish can only kill one from how that is formulated (I do not know much about Fate so this is just a guess on my part) I think her wish would be to close the warp gates. Yes it would put an end to Wind magic but that is a small price to pay for cutting off the Dark Gods from reality for good... especially since she would not have to pay it (*cough*AV*cough*)
 
You know on the subject of future spells, while people are very interested in a Cloudkill spell why don't we consider a mass Sleep spell instead?

Basic idea is a fog that inflicts a juiced up version of the Sleep spell to those within it, maybe using a apparition to act as the targeting method to avoid friendly fire. It would work in a similar way to our Rite of Way spell, since it would effectively be using the fog as a medium to cast the petty magic spell Sleep (although preferably a bit stronger or multiple times if the target resists) on a bunch of people all at once.

The resulting spell would have a lot of utility in both battlefield and non-combat scenarios, since it would allow a skilled enough Grey Wizard to knock out an entire complex of people if they wanted to and on the battlefield....well I don't think I need to explain how entire formations of enemy troops just falling asleep on the spot would be easy pickings for even the weakest of chaff.

Plus the effect would be within our staff's range, meaning we would be able to use it as casually as Rite of Way.

I can see 2 variations we could develop:
  • One and done mass sleep: A single cast spell that inflicts sleep on a lot of people at once. Would likely be easier to make but would only put them to sleep for a limited time. Still a bunch of people falling asleep for upwards of half a minute (or longer if we juice up the sleep side of things) would still be useful in a lot of situations.
  • Lingering Sleep Fog: Similar to the above but taking the form of a lingering fog that will hit the targets with another dose of sleep if they start to wake up. Plus it would cause others who enter the fog to also be affected. Would likely need an Apparition to handle the IFF of the spell to prevent friendlies being put to sleep.
Now this isn't without it's flaws, the biggest of which is simply those targets that aren't affected by Sleep. Mainly things like Undead and Daemons, since I doubt even the weakest of them do anything resembling sleep....well I'd imagine Vampires sleep but still you get the idea. Still I think that is a decent tradeoff for the utility of using it in other situations.

Additionally it accomplishes much of what a theoretical Cloudkill spell would do in terms of getting rid of enemy chaff. It just sacrifices lethality for utility.

Thoughts?
 
So, to make this less of a derail, what do we think Mathilde's wish would be? She seems to have mostly accepted Van Hal's death at this point, so I doubt she'd wish him back. (She could have just gone the omegahugger route if she wanted that :V) So... Killing a chaos god? Knowledge of some sort? I dunno, how strong a wish *could* the grail grant?
I honestly think Mathilde would be way too paranoid about the Grail to make a wish. She might think it's a Nurgle thing for example, what with the prominence of the number 7, or Khorne because of the bloodbath required beforehand.
 
In this hypothetical, Mathilde would be long-dead but her spirit is summoned in a cross-world Grail War, right?

Is the Wish something that could take place in her own time, or is it limited to 'now'?

If the latter, I think it depends on what shape the world is in in that hypothetical future.
 
Saber tends to be pretty loyal and obedient to her summoner, but uh, almost every other servant is pretty independent.
It is also worth noting that even Saber betrays and kills her Master in one of the Bad Ends (that you basically have to try to get)
So, to make this less of a derail, what do we think Mathilde's wish would be?
*breathes in*
She seems to have mostly accepted Van Hal's death at this point, so I doubt she'd wish him back. (She could have just gone the omegahugger route if she wanted that :V)
*exhales*
Spoilsport.

I honestly think Mathilde would be way too paranoid about the Grail to make a wish. She might think it's a Nurgle thing for example, what with the prominence of the number 7, or Khorne because of the bloodbath required beforehand.
Assuming a 'regular' Grail War, Mathilde would probably accurately deduce that the Holy Grail is full of bad mojo.
 
Mathilde's motivation (and by extension, the thread's) has always been some variation of "a better tomorrow".

The repeating cycle of the Grail War runs contrary to that aim—there are quite a few characters who have suffered generational trauma due to the Grail War (IIRC, it's been I while since I've done anything Fate related), so it's easy for me to imagine that Mathilde's wish would revolve around breaking that cycle somehow, rather than something more personal.

That, or we'd just pass the Wish on to Ranald and let him YOLO it.
 
In this hypothetical, Mathilde would be long-dead but her spirit is summoned in a cross-world Grail War, right?

Is the Wish something that could take place in her own time, or is it limited to 'now'?

If the latter, I think it depends on what shape the world is in in that hypothetical future.
I'll be honest, I'm mostly unaware of the greater overarching metastory of Fate, but I'm pretty sure Saber's whole motivation is basically to use a wish to do something back when she was alive, yeah.
Since there are four Chaos Gods and I am assuming a wish can only kill one from how that is formulated (I do not know much about Fate so this is just a guess on my part) I think her wish would be to close the warp gates. Yes it would put an end to Wind magic but that is a small price to pay for cutting off the Dark Gods from reality for good... especially since she would not have to pay it (*cough*AV*cough*)
Closing the gates is a good one, yeah. And yeah, it's funny that she'd still retain some ability to generate Winds despite it. Hm. The Slann would probably still be able to use magic via the web in some form since it existed before the Gates. Godly magic would *probably* still work? Though since gods didn't seem to exist before the gates maybe the gates closing would make it harder for gods both chaotic and of order to affect the world. There'd probably be a pretty significant delay before the Vortex managed to drain all the magic out of the world. Though maybe Caledor would just let it go and let the existing magic be consumed via spellcasting over the next few years. I bet there'd be a lot of chaos cults trying to open warp gates on behalf of the gods to try and make a new breach. It would certainly lead to some excitement.
 
Assuming a 'regular' Grail War, Mathilde would probably accurately deduce that the Holy Grail is full of bad mojo.
"Regular" Grail Wars exist? I thought they were just a myth! :V

Mathilde's motivation (and by extension, the thread's) has always been some variation of "a better tomorrow".

The repeating cycle of the Grail War runs contrary to that aim—there are quite a few characters who have suffered generational trauma due to the Grail War (IIRC, it's been I while since I've done anything Fate related), so it's easy for me to imagine that Mathilde's wish would revolve around breaking that cycle somehow, rather than something more personal.

That, or we'd just pass the Wish on to Ranald and let him YOLO it.
Breaking the cycle wouldn't necessarily require a wish, but it would make it easier. Could just get it dismantled like the F/SN Grail was in some timelines, though I guess someone other than Mathilde would have to do that part given the premise.

Passing the wish onto Ranald is kind of intriguing, but I think He'd be more likely to just straight up jack the whole thing and put it to use somewhere else, like with the Coin that was part of the stolen stuff from Mork and Gork. Hmmm... I guess we now know where the Lady got her magic cup from...
 
Passing the wish onto Ranald is kind of intriguing, but I think He'd be more likely to just straight up jack the whole thing and put it to use somewhere else, like with the Coin that was part of the stolen stuff from Mork and Gork. Hmmm... I guess we now know where the Lady got her magic cup from...
Ranald gives Shallya her Cup, creating a stable time loop that results in his own ascension to godhood :V
 
Ruler Mathilde:

Noble Phantasms: The Book Clan Goes to War, Let's You and Him Fight

Skill: UsurpationRightful Assumption of Authority

Reality Marble: Karak Vlag
 
Can't stop won't stop, Peerless Production, etc etc.
No "Liber Mortis [Sealed Due to Distaste], Requires the use of a Command Seal" ala Tamamo's Witchcraft?
Just have Rider Mathilde Weber be the one that went all in on the thread's ideas and desires for apparition stuff and studied the notes on Nagash's Ring and has bound things like Liminal Realms and has Wolf and Weber's Asp. This would be the Lawful Evil Weber.
Scariest class would be Caster Alter.:sad:
 
If I understand Fate classes right, she's got access to four more classes. Saber because she's got a sword, Archer because she's got a gun, and Rider because she's got a shadowsteed and a gyrocarriage. She never went berserk so no Berserker, and she's never used a spear so no Lancer.
 
She never went berserk so no Berserker,
Well...
'Oo do you fink you are?! you... think? No. You're shouting it, tears streaming down your face. Sure, we 'ave a good scrap when there's nuthin' betta ta do, but dat doesn't mean we ain't bruvvas! You're not sure if the words are directed at the Orc before you or at the God his prayers are addressed to. He knows you are here, has done even before you began shouting, but the course he has set upon is one that he dares not interrupt, hoping against hope that he can somehow complete his work before the consequences of his heresy reach him. Something about the energies in the room have changed... no, you realize. The energies are the same. You have changed, and the energies that once burned unpleasantly against your senses flood into you, your muscles bulging as power is stolen away from the Idol Of Only Gork. You lift your sword and bring it down upon the heretical Prophet, and again, and you scream at the top of your lungs as you bludgeon the slumped corpse of the dead Prophet, rage and sorrow flooding through you.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top