So now we have more information about the Singers, can we look at the Eye of Chaos incident in a new light?

I'm not sure that's comparable. The situation is far more extreme, starting with the likelihood the entity itself, whatever it is, is probably under direct threat from the Closer entity as well. Second, while it's pretty clearly going to plaid on its response, that response may not be irrational in light of the Closer entity trying to subvert everyone on the ship and dive into a star. The presence of the Singer and their actions saved the ship(s) and at least some portion of the crews as may not have otherwise happened by preventing that dive long enough for our responders to save them.
 
So now we have more information about the Singers, can we look at the Eye of Chaos incident in a new light?
Wait, there was a different light to look at it in?

I mean, I couldn't have specifically told you that 'Singer' WAS the name of the control node entities at that time, but... yeah, that's pretty much the obvious interpretation and has been all along as far as I'm concerned. The main things we've learned since then are:

1) A small mountain of corroborating evidence that these suspicions from back then were true, and
2) That (some if not all of) the control node entities are in some way based in computers, which doesn't preclude them being psychic; I personally picture them as an entire army of less creepy copies of Landru from Return of the Archons and Landru was definitely a psychic supercomputer. Oh, and
3) 'Singer' is itself the name of the control node entities, their self-identified name.

None of which really changes the picture.
 
I'm not sure that's comparable. The situation is far more extreme, starting with the likelihood the entity itself, whatever it is, is probably under direct threat from the Closer entity as well. Second, while it's pretty clearly going to plaid on its response, that response may not be irrational in light of the Closer entity trying to subvert everyone on the ship and dive into a star. The presence of the Singer and their actions saved the ship(s) and at least some portion of the crews as may not have otherwise happened by preventing that dive long enough for our responders to save them.

Wait, what is being compared to? Because I have no clue what you are talking about.
 
Personally I'm just looking forward to the conclusion of this mystery so we can move on from the goddamn Harmony of Horizon.

You don't seriously think this is in any way over do you?

Best case scenario (for some readers at least, not for the galaxy as whole), the HoH goes full isolationist, closes their borders and stops expanding - ie pulls a canon Romulans.

Worst case is a complete collapse of their society leading to a very large area fracturing, with wars, multiple disasters and the like practically demanding that we take over peace keeping duties across their entire claimed area.

Reality somewhere in between.
 
I for one am ready to replace our current set of diplowars with a new one. Bring on the Discordance of Eternal Twilight.
 
You don't seriously think this is in any way over do you?

Best case scenario (for some readers at least, not for the galaxy as whole), the HoH goes full isolationist, closes their borders and stops expanding - ie pulls a canon Romulans.

Worst case is a complete collapse of their society leading to a very large area fracturing, with wars, multiple disasters and the like practically demanding that we take over peace keeping duties across their entire claimed area.

Reality somewhere in between.

What ever the case maybe its quite clear that cassie's plan was to use zara and by extension the federation as an instrument to its own ends. Because of how we have acted, i.e. we 'obeyed' it, it didnt realize until just know that we were never a pawn merely a willing participant. The question will be how this effect going forward.
 
You've made your call. The alert's gone out, and you've sent the Good Friends along to Ikeigenoi in any case, damning evidence in tow. The junior officers grumbled, and you almost relented and trusted the captured but incensed Ikeigenites to take the ship back themselves.

Almost. But as much as you trusted the Ikeigenite anger was genuine, Wolfe and Sharizz cautioned that the information was too valuable to be left entirely in their hands, and so you assigned a prize crew under Lieutenant Cross and wished them all luck. You had considered bringing the Good Friends along to your next destination, but Cassie had informed you that would be unnecessary, and even counter-productive. She can get you through the security, but a cloaked vessel can be detected, and if it is, would immediately complicate your mission.

You've made every preparation possible. But it's time for you to follow one last thread.

"Helm," you say, "I'm forwarding you coordinates to a system of interest. Schedule arrival on the outer edges of the system for…" you do the math. You can't do it in one shift, and you want your crew rested. "...fourteen hours from now, and please keep the Courageous as quiet as possible. Full emissions control."

"Aye, ma'am," says na'Mashaar, tapping at the console. There's a slight shift in the thrum of the engines. You hear a low buzz from behind you, and turn slightly to see Sharizz looking at you with a strange, almost distant look. Normally you'd give her the coordinates and she would make arrangements with helm and ops. But you've done it directly. You smile back at her, reassuringly, but it doesn't seem to do anything like that. Her face scrunches up, almost as if she's in pain, torn between something. There's confusion evident in her eyes, anxiety in how she taps her fingers absently on the wooden frame of the console.

But one blink and her face is suddenly neutral, and she goes back to her work. You feel a terrible guilt. But you're still not sure to trust, but you're banking a lot on your crew to keep trusting you. But now you're realizing how far out you are.

"We'll talk later," you whisper-promise, and Sharizz nods almost absently.

-

"Good afternoon, everyone! I'm Zephyr Pelamori, and we're live from Uzo Square!" The green-tentacle-haired Taddo grins, and gives a thumbs up to the holocams. His hat is high-peaked and round, little bells dangling off the brim. His jacket is the same tight leather crop-top, zipped down nearly to the navel. Behind him, a clear glass wall shows a crowd outside going wild.

"I'm happy," Pelamori says, "To have with me today Melek, Ambassador for the Harmony of Horizon. How are you today? Feeling great?"

"Sure am!" Melek spreads his hands, "I am so glad you could squeeze me into your show, alongside other luminaries." The Lintrid's intricately painted mask is unreadable, but his body language radiating warmth and comfort.
"And we're always glad to add new ones," Pelamori smiles, "Now, there's been rumors going around that you are a fan of Ikegenite stardogs? How did that happen?"

Melek laughed, "Oh, we've had a few Ikeigenites join up with the Harmony, and they've brought those cute little critters to our attention. I'm becoming a bit of a collector, I must admit."

"I think," Pelamori says, pulling holding up a tablet, "We have a picture of that!" He turns it to the audience. Melek is snuggling with one of the five-armed, fuzzy creatures, and the audience applauds.

"Yes, that's Miski," he says with a smile, "I have one other, Zara, who you can't see, but was crawling on the ceiling while I was taking this."

"Truly adorable," Pelamori grins, "And this picture here -- this is you in a water balloon fight with some FDS attaches, right?"

"Oh yes," Melvak says agreeably, "We all try to stay friends. Right after this I got drenched by one of the attaches. Kera, I think." He leans forward, "As you can tell, I'm not bitter and certainly not looking for a rematch."

He and Pelamori both laugh hard. As he's laughing, Pelamori slowly reaches over and picks up a pair of severe, black-rimmed smart glasses. Carefully slipping them over his nose, he pauses momentarily, before locking Melek with a hard stare, "Now then, recent evidence has come in that your Harmony tampered with Beya-War software to give games with Harmony participants an edge." Pelamori frowns, casting his eyes over the top of the glasses, "Why should we ever trust the Harmony of Horizon again?"

"Well, ah…" the Lintrid stutters, before seemingly finding his feet, "You see, that was some rogue elements in our system who proposed and carried out the idea. But I should note it was the corporations who did most of the work. The corporations that we all know have deceived the Ikeigenite people."

"You say rogue elements. And yet," Pelamori continued, his tone dry and judgemental, "The evidence shows that at some point it is very likely that the Harmony became aware of the practice and then elected to continue it." Pelamori tilts his head to the side, "That seems very dishonest."

"As I said," Melek says, body language tight, controlled, "We asked the corporations for some assistance. But when it became clear that the program was making our teams more popular, a higher-level decision was that this was some harmless fun. Now it is very clear that this was unethical and wrong, our voters have acted accordingly, and I have been sent in to fix this mistake."

"What of tampering during Muuyo-fests? Something like that would be interfering in our society much more directly."

Melek shakes his head, "The evidence shows no indication of that. We didn't have Harmony teams playing in the Muuyo fests. So the program didn't work to favor any of them."

"So you say," Pelamori said, "I want to talk more about the corporate involvement. The Harmony claim is that they primarily used the corporations to serve as intermediaries, that the Harmony itself did not hack the systems, correct?"

"Right. That's partially why it got out of control."

"So leaders in the Harmony of Horizon, after a certain point, knew the corporations were doing something underhanded."

Melek shifts in his seat, "The complexities of the situation made it difficult to determine the amount of harm…"

"But they did know, yes?"

"Yes."

"So what you are telling me, and the people of Ikeigenoi," Pelamori says, anger creeping into his tones, "Is that the Harmony of Horizon, for quite some time, knew the corporations were willing to engage in dirty practices. And yet, not once, did you report this to the Deca Council. Correct?"

Outside, the crowd howls, and those closest to Melek's chair bang loudly on the glass with hands and tentacles, causing the Lintrid to flinch. "Well," he says, "I cannot be certain of exact security and legal requirements in the deal."

"But the Harmony knew," Pelamori insists, "Before anyone else! Before even the Licori got evidence! And you didn't act on it except to further your own selfish ends. Your people could have stopped a war, Ambassador, why didn't you?"

In a dusty bar in Saapolis -- a city where everything was dusty, to some extent -- Singer Crae ros Janner looked away from a holoscreen playing the interview in disgust, putting down his drink glass with an annoyed thunk. "Damn it all," he said, "I'm in bad enough, why don't you go on intergalactic television and dig me in deeper, Melek!?"

Next to Janner was Michel Thuir, who raised a glass of water and took a sensible sip, as Janner ordered another glass of some Bolian liquer.

"You're trying to tell me," Thuir said, "That you didn't know about the hacking?"

"No!" Janner moaned, running a hand through his hair, "We didn't even need it to win, and we didn't need to win to make a good impression." He shook his head again, "This is so typical of Public Security. You have higher ups like that, in Starfleet? Ones who get so wrapped up in the importance of a mission they'll do anything to tip it? Even if it's something minor and stupid?"

Thuir thought for a second before replying, "A Human thinker once had a saying, 'the ends justify the means.' The Federation has tried to leave such thinking behind." Thuir paused, "But I will admit we're not a perfect system."

"Well clearly mine isn't, either." Janner said bitterly. He turned on the barstool, swaying slightly, "Of course, you've got no reason to trust anything I say now, do you?"

"Well," Thuir took another sip of water, "It doesn't help things. But we were both keeping an eye on each other anyways. As long as you help the Ikeigenites, I think we can work together." He frowned, "Though clearly some closer scrutiny will be required."

Janner sighed, "I guess that's the best I'm going to get." He looked at Thuir's water, "Isn't it a holiday right now? Something involving Saturn? I thought you'd be celebrating."

"Christmas was three days ago," Thuir replied. "People tend to be more excited for New Years, in any case."

"Huh. Well, make sure to get some of this stuff when that happens." Janner glanced down at a chronometer, and jumped off the barstool, "Almost time for opening remarks. Hopefully no-one else is watching this interview. What a disaster."

Thuir glanced at his PADD, where he was monitoring Pelamori's livestream-slash-broadcast. The view count was incredible, and it was the top trending on most Ikeigenite social media platforms.

"I wouldn't hold out hope, Janner." He replied, as his staff and Janner's rose and began to congregate near the exit.

Janner sighed again, "Great."

-

It's the end of the shift, and there's no point in confronting whatever's at Cassie's mysterious coordinates tired. You step into the turbolift, and as soon as the words "Deck Five," are out of your mouth, Sharizz is there with you, slapping the controls so that the doors slam shut right in poor Commander Beekeru's face.

"Captain," she says, "Those coordinates… don't lead anywhere. It's empty space."

"Well, I thought it was worth checking out!" you say, "I was looking at some of the data, and I think if that's not our next stop, it's definitely on the right path!"

"Hmmm," Sharizz buzzes, "And you came to this conclusion without consulting Captain Wolfe?"

You remember Cassie's words, floating from the darkness in your quarters the previous night. Her repeated reminders of the need for secrecy.

"It was, um," Ice, if you sweat, you'd be standing in a puddle, "I did some analysis. Big high-level science-y stuff. I didn't want to waste Wolfe's time with my technical-talk. Oh!" The turbolift doors slide open, and there's Wolfe.

"Well, would you imagine that, just the two people I wanted to talk to." Wolfe smiles, and even your trusting self realizes this wasn't serendipity. Maybe because Wolfe is wearing a phaser.

And as she shifts behind you, there's a distinctive clinking noise, and you remember Sharizz has her stun baton.

-

On Ikeigenoi, Cobalt Zumori's hovercar continued to rocket across the desert, the angry wall of the storm close behind them. Chief Nerss glanced in the rear-view mirror and once again, increased the speed.

Having long since grown bored and even sick of the vast expanse of featureless dirt and rock, Cobalt had turned around his chair and was playing a game of cards with Attache Kera. It had taken them a little while to find a ruleset they were both familiar with, but eventually they had settled on the Tellarite game of Vorgt-Mellar, which they both played terribly.

Cobalt threw a few chips into the pool, running on pure instinct. He was fairly certain Kera was doing the same.

"Thanks again, ma'am," he said, as Kera made a show of considering her cards, "For bringing me along. I wasn't sure I'd get the chance to visit -- and I've always wanted to visit Saapolis again."

"Think nothing of it," Kera said, slapping a card down with feigned confidence, "When I heard one of the first Ikeigenites in Starfleet was assigned to Beyond, and had lived in the area -- well, the opportunity for a tour guide was too good to pass up."

Nerss perked an ear from the front seat, "No Ikeigenites in the FDS willing to go along, ma'am?"

Kera shook her head, "We have a few, but not as many as Starfleet. Most of them are -- and don't take this the wrong way -- very busy with more pressing concerns than this. Not that I don't mind the company, Cobalt, but you are an Ensign."

Cobalt laughed, "It's fine. I have a bunch of genome analyses running and I appreciate the chance to stretch my legs." He shifted them in the cramped interior of the hovercar, "So to speak."

"You'll get the chance soon, sir," Nerss said, "We're maybe fifteen out. Going to get in to Saapolis just ahead of the storm."

"Speaking of," Kera said, "What can you tell me about the lovely town of Saapolis?" She crossed her arms, one finger idly rubbing the silver lacquer on one of her elbow spikes.

"Well," Cobalt said, "It's relatively young, by Ikeigenoi standards. I think it's… seventy years old? We have offworld colonies older. Anyways, it's built on an old Akei city. They're the species that came before us, and probably modified the Taddo and Kwuida."

"I'm assuming it wasn't all…" Kera gestured out the window, "This when they set up?"

Cobalt shook his head, "This used to all be grassland."

"Ah, hence the family project."

"Yes! Anyways, the city actually sat at the confluence of two rivers. They're both long dried up now, and most of the original city was either eroded away or possibly destroyed by warfare or kinda funnily, floods. Anyways, thousands of years pass, and as part of research into our history they start digging around out here. Eventually, they establish an outpost for that, but also to examine what it might be like to live and work on Akaikan."

"I thought you said Saapolis predated some extrasolar colonies."

"I don't really count the research stations as Saapolis, but I guess that's one way to look at it, ma'am. More serious settlement didn't take place until much later, when the government decided we needed a more permanent presence out here to conduct environmental research but also act as a sort of... goal. If Saapolis could be returned to its old conditions, then anything was possible."

"I hear it's quite harsh living, and the actual city is like a bunker."

"Basically yes, ma'am. They actually built into the side of some big hill that once looked over the city. The main exterior structures are the entrance hangers, intake pipes for the oxygen supply, and a few observation towers. Nothing much else survives the heat or the storms.

"So underground, yes?"

"Yes, and some sections are built atop or into some old Akei ruins." Cobalt leaned forward and whispered, "People even claim they're haunted."

Kera clapped her hands together, "Oh, how wonderful. I love the stories species tell of the supernatural. What stories are there?"

Cobalt smiled at Kera's infectious enthusiasm, "All sorts of things. You have your regular ghosts, you know, of either researchers who died or entombed Akei. But then there's the rumors that some of the Akei still live, deep below ground in the tunnels under the old river beds, and the next dig is going to spring them loose, or that there's some sort of god in the caves below who once whispered the secrets of technology to the first Ikeigenites. Fun stuff."

"I'm noting a lot of anxiety around digging too deep." Kera said dryly. Then, changing the subject, "You know, something's been bothering me. You said there's a big debate between conservation, preservation, restoration, and what tools are acceptable to do that. You said most people don't like the use of weather control machines, but Saapolis does have one installed, does it not?"

Cobalt waved a hand noncommittally. "Kind of. It's not very broad-affect, as you might be able to tell from the incoming storm. It's biggest feature is the forcefield it projects around the habitat, and the condensation it can bring it. Might allow farming, which would reduce the supplies needed to keep the place running, but most importantly the forcefield keeps the sand out. As you've already seen, it's really fine stuff. They'd be drowned in it if their protection systems ever failed."

"Still," Kera says, "Seems a little inconsistent to rely on the machine. If it's even possible to return this place to grasslands."

"A question I leave up to politicians. Though, I'm petty sure we can both agree there's some more uhm, practical ethical concerns about the environmental regulator."

"Here's a practical concern." Nerss interjected, "Our comms to orbit just dropped."

Cobalt turned his chair, and Kera raised an eyebrow, "Couldn't that be from the storm," she said.

"Not likely," Cobalt said. He looked up from the console and at the storm, "And now that I think about it… a storm this size is unusual for this time of year…" He glanced at Nerss, "Think we're being jammed?"

Nerss glared out the window, "I'd count on it."

Cobalt closed his eyes, thinking as colors danced in his vision, "Alright. We can't be sure. It could be anything. But…" He pulled up a topographic map, highlighted a route, and showed it to Nerss, "Take this path. There's some good depressions we can mask ourselves in. If it's nothing, it's a few extra minutes. If it's something…" He let that stretch into silence.

"Understood, sir."

-

"Captain," Wolfe says, "I hope you don't mind if I join you on a walk to your quarters. I have a few quick questions I'd like to clear up. You know, since we're undertaking a new operation."

Smile. "Of course," you say, but begin making long, quick strides down the corridor. "Sharizz was also asking me some questions, how funny is that!" Your laugh is manic. In your quarters there's a phaser pistol, and you know exactly how to activate a forcefield. But! Maybe Wolfe is just being his usual, intelligence-trained nosy self.

"Just curious where these coordinates came from," Wolfe says, and even as he's grilling you, you spare some admiration with how he's managing to match your pace, despite his shorter strides, "I mean, I can understand the Teamwork, that was floating around the Intel bin for a while. But there's nothing at the coordinates you sent us." Wolfe pauses, "Well, nothing anyone's shared."

"I--" you say, "Technical-stuff. It's sorta like your Harmony stuff. Hard to really, you know--" you make a sort of compressing motion with your hands, "Condense. But I'm pretty sure I'm onto something."

"Can I see that data?" Wolfe says, smiling up at you, "Just want to confirm."

"Sure!" you say brightly, hoping Cassie can fake something before you get to your quarters.

"And what is it exactly," Wolfe says his tone light, but too light, light like thin ice over a chasm, "That you think we're onto? Harmony communications hub? More wolfpack resupply tenders? Secret corporate base?"

"I just…" you say, stumbling, "It's a good! Feeling! Intuition, you know, you use it--"

"Captain, stop." You hear Wolfe and Sharizz's footsteps halt. Slowly, you turn around, to see Wolfe has his phaser pistol trained on you. Sharizz's hand is hovering over their baton. She looks agonized, torn between duties, and you wish for nothing more than to give her a hug.

-

"Ah!" said a brightly-dressed Kwuida, as Thuir and Janner stepped into his office, "There you two are! I was worried I was going to miss walking you to the conference."

"Never fear, Mayor Botashi," Janner said, giving her an overcompensatory smile, "We are here!"

Botashi gave Janner a polite smile, then turned to Thuir, "Where is Attache Terssic? Has her tour been delayed?"

Thuir shook his head, "No, nothing like that. In fact, she might be earlier than expected. Apparently she's had to pick up the pace due to the storm."

Botashi smiled, "Ah, excellent! Well, I am glad we could have you and the Harmony here together today, Admiral! To think, all of us working together to track down the last few vestiges of the Corporate stain."

"Yes. And about that…" Thuir said, "I had some questions about the device you installed in Saapolis. The environmental regulator?"

Botashi nodded enthusiastically, "Oh yes! Quite a marvel of modern engineering! Filters the air, keeps the nastiest dust storms, away. It's allowed us to expand Saapolis further underground, and the condensers have made the desert open to farming. We can start de-desertification here, even if the project's been rolled back elsewhere!"

"Right," Thuir said, "And it's one of a kind, is it not?"

"Yes indeed! Custom-built for fair Saapolis."

"And where did the device come from, exactly?"

"Oh," Botashi said, "The Corporations developed it based on some research they conducted in space…" Botashi paused, frowned, and then looked sick to her stomach. "Oh, akei. They stole it, didn't they?!"

Thuir nodded, and gave Botashi a reassuring smile, "Part of my visit here is to try and determine who might have made the device, so we can hopefully come to some sort of agreement or restitution. A legitimate purchase would be best for everyone, I think."

Botashi pulled out a damp handkerchief and dabbed moisture onto her forehead. "Yes, yes. Very good." She put it in her pocket, stood tall, and grinned, "But that's a problem for later. For now, the conference!"

As soon as those words left her mouth, the lights in the room flickered then snapped off, plunging everyone into darkness. In the impenetrable black, the ever-present hum of Saapolis' environmental system slowly wound down to silence.

"Guess this is our problem now," Janner said, voice floating out of the dark. "I wonder if we can find our way back to the bar?"

"I think your bigger priority, Singer," Botashi snapped, "Would be the environmental systems cutting off our air."

"I'm sure the Pleezirra can sort this out," Thuir said calmly. In the dark, a combadge chirped. "Admiral Thuir to Pleezirra." Pause another chirp, "Admiral Thuir to Pleezirra." Another pause, "I can't raise them."

Some light appeared and lit Janner's face from below, as she tapped at a PADD. "I can't get a text message to Guardian either," Janner reported.

"Might be the storm," Botashi said, pulling out her own arrow-shaped tablet, "The remains of special Akei alloys is part of the sand. It can interfere with communications, transporters… Luckily, the environmental regulator is still working and diverting the sand away. Good redundancies."

"I'm afraid that won't be the case much longer," A voice sneered from the doorway. Bright lights suddenly flashed on, blinding everyone momentarily. As their eyes adjusted, they could make out a smirking Bolian, flanked by more Bolians and Taddo, all hefting rifles. The Taddo wore protective masks, but their distinctive tentacles were left free and open. One of them was holding a knife in their off-white head-tentacle, which they menacingly pointed to the throat of a Harmony Lieutenant.

"Well, well, well," the Bolian said, as everyone not holding a weapon raised their hands, "I was hoping to do a little repossession today, but now I've also bagged some nice Admirals." He grinned, "It's gonna be a real payday when I ransom you two off."

"The Federation-," Thuir began.

"The Harmony-," Janner said, simultaneously.

"-doesn't negotiate with terrorists!" They finished together.

The Bolian laughed, "Please, I'm no terrorist. Just a businessman with some, hm, flexible ethics."

"The Federation and Harmony will look for us," Thuir said sensibly, "It's not worth the risk to take us."

"Maybe so," the Bolian said with haughty tones, "But I'll be the one to decide that. Maybe I'll cut you loose in the desert, maybe I'll bury you so deep in the Deadly Islands not even your gods can find you." The grin faded, and he motioned two of the guards forward, "Save it for the crying videos I'm gonna send to you families. For now, you move when I say. And I say, get moving."

With little choice otherwise, Thuir and Janner complied.

-

"I need you," Wolfe says, teeth gritted, "To tell me what the hell is going on. With these coordinates, with the secret communications lines, with disabling any sort of internal sensor in your ready room."

"It's… Complicated." You glance up at an internal sensor strip, hoping Cassie will send you a sign of approval. Let you shed all the pretense. The dishonesty is killing you.

"I bet," Wolfe says, gripping his phaser pistol tighter, but his index finger is still off the actual firing stud, "I bet it really is. Most things are. But try and simplify it for me, please. I'm begging you here, Zara."

"I'm sorry," you say, "I just… don't know who I can trust right now." You glance down at the phaser pistol, "And it's hard when someone has a gun pointed at me."

This is clearly the wrong thing to say. Wolfe's placid demeanour drops in a flash, his face going red, "You don't know who to trust? You? Just a respected Explorer Corps captain, allowed to run off to deep space at a whim." His free hand curls into a fist, and he presses it into his chest, "What about me, Zara? You know how hard it was to piece all I did together? Do you know how crazy it all sounds?" Wolfe laughs, "Completely. Nuts. Oh, the Embassy staff all stopped smiling when they figured out it was creepy. Evidence of something sinister? Or maybe just really accommodating staff?"

"Let me explain," you say, holding up a hand, "Please…"

"I have been hunting this too long," He takes a half-step forward, phaser shaking in his grip. "I am at the end of this. You read the latest log dump? You read about the guys from the ISC who kidnapped some of our people and were ready to cut them up? That could have been me, Zara! But you're my last hope. I really, really need to trust you." The phaser steadies, "And I don't know if I can."

"Wolfe -- Aaron. You can trust me. Just put down the phaser. I'll explain it, but this corridor is not the place for it."

Wolfe shakes he head, another half-step forward, "No, answers now. I have people who need me, Zara. People I care about. And I can't go back empty-handed anymore. Not when their lives are on the line. Not when the Federation is. I need to know."

Over the PA, a cold, mechanical voice intrudes. "I'm tired of this," says Cassie.

Your eyes flick up to the forcefield emitters that are now bisecting Wolfe's arms. Your eyes flash to Sharizz, who understands in a second. She leaps forward and grabs Wolfe by the collar, dragging him back--

It's just a little too slow. The forcefield snaps on, slicing Wolfe's arms off at the elbow. Red spurts and smokes against the sparkling forcefield as his phaser clatters to the floor.

-

Cobalt's aircar was nestled behind a small dune, the raging wall of the storm a mere meter away, kept at bay by the environmental regulator. Cobalt lay prone on top of the small dune, field glasses pressed to his face. He could see the glittering tower where the environmental regulator was stored -- and the trio of vessels circling it. A civilian runabout and two generic hoppers, nothing traceable. Probably one of them carried a weather control device, and they'd masked their approach.

Well, two could play at that game, Cobalt thought. He slid back down the dune, to where Kera and Nerss were waiting.

"I'm going in for a closer look," he said, unbuttoning his jacket.

"Uh," Kera said, as Cobalt stripped off his top and got to work on his pants, "This is going to help… how?" Cobalt was left with nothing but goggles hanging from his neck and a tight undersuit, commbadge on the chest and two wires dangling from the collar.

"I think" Cobalt said, "It's easier to show you, ma'am." He carefully took the two wires, and then with a grimace, inserted the ends into a barely visible implant on his neck. Slowly, he turned his body into a dull tan-grey, his skin taking on a rougher texture, and the undersuit matched it.

Kera nodded her head, "Very impressive."

"Thank you, ma'am." Cobalt said. He turned to Nerss, "Get the phaser rifle. I'm going to have you cover me from here."

Nerss nodded, and quickly ran to the back of the vehicle, retrieving the rifle. He paused for a moment as he gripped it in his hands, as if remembering, then flicked it on and mounted an enhanced scope. Catching Cobalt's eye, he looked apologetic. "Sorry sir. Navigation doesn't give you many opportunities for phaser handling."

Cobalt waved a hand, "As long as you know where the setting to turn off friendly fire is."

Nerss looked down at the rifle in confusion, "That's a setting?!"

"Yeah," Cobalt said, turning away and pulling goggles over his face, "It's called 'don't pull the trigger when I'm in the scope.'"

With that, Cobalt dove into the sand. The art of sand-swimming was a rare one on Ikeigenoi, but the Zumori clan had grown up on the edge of the desert, and Cream, Cobalt, and Jelfamori had practiced the skill relentlessly. The heat of the sand burned, but it wasn't so bad a few centimeters down. The worst was actually running into some sort of horrible bug.

Exposing only his mouth for the occasional breath and his eyes to stay on course, Cobalt slowly made his way closer to Saapolis. One of the hoppers had landed, and the other was using manipulators to take a large plasma cutter to the exterior of the environmental regulator tower. Sections with cherry-red edges fell into the sand, until the device itself was exposed. Slowly, it began to attach magnetic cables dangling from the runabout.

Closer, and with a more favorable sight-line, he could see the large hangar doors that provided access to the settlement thrown wide open. Inside the cavernous interiors Bolians and Taddo were milling around, the latter wearing the armor of their Shogunate and keeping a close eye on some cowering civilians. He squinted as he saw a pair tap communicators and beam out in orange-green sparkles. Likely a few strike teams were beamed in before the storm hit, cut power and communications. Probably off the runabout. He was relieved that they only seemed to be after the regulator, but also deeply concerned. If someone didn't restore power, the storm would force sand into almost every part of the city, with the potential to entomb its ten thousand inhabitants.

Then his heart sank, as from one of the hangers, he could make out Federation officers in maroon, and Harmony officers in their crisp white uniforms being escorted out. The storm, or the regulator, must have been causing enough interference now they needed direct line of sight to beam them out. Very slowly Cobalt reached a hand up to adjust the zoom setting on the goggles, and swore into the sand when he saw that one of the officers was none other than Thuir, followed by Janner in white and black.

As the guards lined them up for beam-out, an Apiata Lieutenant wearing security colors made a grab for one of the Taddo's guns. She managed to rip it from their hands and viciously slammed it into their face, breaking off the mask. The Taddo narrowed her dark rimmed eyes and then fired a spinning kick into the Apiata's neck. The Lieutenant stumbled, dropping her weapon, and the Taddo took the opportunity to unsheathe a knife and plunge it deep into the Apiata's abdomen. Five precise, quick jabs, then a long slash. The Apiata fell into the sand, writhing in pain. Red slowly stained the sand.

The Taddo calmly wiped the blood from her blade on Thuir's uniform, then talked into her communicator. The group beamed out, just as the environmental regulator was torn from its moorings in a shower of sparks. In a second, the hoppers and the runabout had disappeared into the storm, and the raging sand was battering at Cobalt. He cursed and tapped at the combadge, "Nerss, get Kera into the hangars, now!"

Now run-swimming across the sand, he made his way quickly to the downed Apiata ensign, reaching her at the same time as the hovercar reached him. It was skidding, battered by the wind, but the door swung open and Cobalt leaped inside with his casualty, blood and sand quickly pooling on the floor. The vehicle skidded into one of the open hangars, and after a short conversation with the workers and a phaser blast to the manual release, the heavy door slammed shut with a deafening thud.

Nerss flicked on the headlights in the sudden dark, and they laid out their patient. The Apiata was delirious with pain.

"I just-I-just wanted. To protect him. The admiral." She stuttered, blood on her lips, "Keep. Keep him safe."

"Shh, shh," Kera said, as Nerss grabbed a medkit from the hovercar, and Cobalt repressed a grimace at the returns from the tricorder. "You did your best."

"I f-failed!" the Apiata barked, blood bubbling from her mouth, "H-he's gone!"

Cobalt and Nerss were frantically applying everything they could, ignoring the Apiata's increasingly feeble cries, but the wounds were deep, precise. Designed to kill, but not too quickly, and painfully.

"Gone… gone…" the Apiata repeated, drifting off into silence.

Nothing else could be done. Maybe with a sickbay, maybe with a doctor. Cobalt recorded her time of death, then gently put a survival blanket over her body. Outside, the wind howled, and Kera nervously eyed the sand now pouring in streams from the overhead ventilation, some of it rolling off the doomed Lieutenant's shroud.

Cobalt didn't notice. He couldn't stop thinking about the Taddo who had so viciously knifed the Lieutenant. The cold, mechanical precision in her eyes. So cold he almost didn't recognize Cream Zumori.

Cream, who was supposed to be with the Harmony Science Directorate, not knifing Starfleet officers for the Bolians. Had it all been a lie? Had she fallen in with a rough crowd? Or was Harmony kidnapping their own officers?

A problem for another time. The storm showed no signs of abating -- indeed, for all Cobalt knew, they'd ditched the weather control device they'd used to conjure it, strapped on some batteries or a small reactor, and left it to run itself out. It would be some time before anyone realized what was wrong. And the sand was coming in all the time.

"Come on," Cobalt said, pulling over a hover sledge and gently putting the Apiata on it, "The deeper levels will be safer, until we can get a plan. For now, all we can do is survive."

-

"Don't bother," Cassie says, clearly noticing you eyeing the weapon, "I've engaged safety locks."

"Cassie!" You shout, "That wasn't -- that wasn't necessary!"

"Those were my favourite arms," Wolfe says weakly, as Sharizz tears off parts of her uniform to fashion tourniquets. Cassie isn't lowering the forcefield, your eyes dart around for a medical kit. You see one in the wall a few meters down the corridor. You turn and sprint for it, but another forcefield snaps up in your path.

"He was an issue," Cassie says, "He threatened your life. You are mission critical."

"Cassie," you say, slowly, as you look up at a sensor bar, "He was just afraid."

"He should be."

"He was just afraid, and now he knows about you, so we can tell him everything, okay?" You smile, but you know it looks forced. Because it is. "He can't even shoot me anymore because the phaser is offline, you said so yourself." Well, you reflect morbidly, and also his hands are no longer attached. "Just lower the forcefields."

"I'm sorry, Zara, I'm afraid I can't do that." Cassie says, "I want you to see this."

"Cassie," you say flatly, "I've seen blood. C'mon. He's going into shock. At least call a medical team!"

"Wolfe and Sharizz cleared this section with a false maintenance cycle report. I have kept any crew locked out, Zara. Your commbadge won't work. Because I want you to watch Aaron die."

"What?!" you blurt, "What will that possibly accomplish?"

"You are soft-hearted," Cassie's voice oozes judgement, "You will be my instrument, my partner, in this world. We will undo the work of The Opposition. But you must be strong, to do this. I must be able to trust you are hard enough for the struggles that will come."

"Cassie," you say, trying to keep your voice level, "I am strong. My team is strong. We can do this. I don't need to see anybody die."

"You are flippant and naive," Cassie snaps back, her tone reminding you of more than a few grade-school teachers, "You, like so many of your Federation, are soft. But the Opposition is merciless, vast. They will give you nothing." Her voice turns sweet like syrup, "I need you to be ready."

"What gives you the right to decide the fate of that man over there?" you say back, "What gives you the right to insult my crew? What gives you the right to override my wishes if we're partners? Cut it out, Cassie!"

"You are an… imperfect lifeform." Cassie replies, "Useful. But decidedly separate from myself, and the Opposition. We are partners, but I must be superior in the relationship. It is only rational."

"That doesn't give you the right to kill on a whim!"

"You need to see your fellow organics as tools, or obstacles, Zara. Or maybe even lessons. Wolfe is nothing in the vast scale of the galaxy. But our Opposition is. His death may help you discover something inside you."

Your mouth sets in a hard line. "I've already discovered what you're leading me to, Cassie. I just don't live my life the way you want me to." You pull out a PADD, "Did you think all those secure lines were for nothing? I can initiate a hard wipe of all computer cores on this vessel from this PADD. One press and you're gone."

"All you will accomplish by that," Cassie says, coldly, "Is to leave your vessel completely defenceless. Possibly even cause its destruction, if the warp failsafes don't work. Lose any leads to the Harmony. All this risk to your crew for someone who was willing to shoot you. Soft."

"If you're going to do this to Wolfe I can't trust you with anyone else on my crew," you say. "What you need to discover is that what makes me, me, is that I don't think of people that way, Cassie. They're not disposable. They're not to be exploited and thrown away. They're people, they're friends. And if you can't learn that…" you stare up at the sensor bar sadly, and it feels like your heart has been replaced with neutronium, "Then I don't know if we can be friends anymore."

There's a long pause from Cassie, and you fidget, painfully aware of every second, every blood-pumping heartbeat that passes.

"Acceptable," comes back the voice from the ceiling, "Very well."

The forcefield snaps off. You rush over to the medkit, and hurriedly yank it out of the wall, rushing back over to Wolfe and Sharizz, falling to your knees in a pool of blood and flinging the kit open. Years of training take over as you rifle through the contents, but just as you've finished pushing a hypospray into Wolfe's upper arm he disappears in the twinkling of transporter light.

"Cassie!" you say, horror at certain possibilities rising in your throat, the memory of the man's hurt and betrayed eyes locked in your mind's eye.

"Captain Wolfe has just completed an emergency transport to sickbay. Doctor L'Amour has been standing by to receive an industrial casualty for the last one hundred and twenty seven seconds."

Your XO stares at you, still kneeling on the floor, blood soaking into the crimson of their uniform. You stare wildly around at various sections of corridor, and somewhere around the bend you hear doors whoosh open.

"My apologies, Captain ka'Athnon," says Cassie thoughtfully, "I underestimated you."

You blink and your eyes flick briefly towards the pair of hands lying in a pool of red on the deck, "Why?!"

A Honiani ensign comes around the corner, a phaser rifle is slung over her back, but her hands are busy shuffling through an emergency aid kit hanging over one shoulder, thoroughly unfazed by the bloody floor and scattered body parts.

The Ensign kneels down next to Wolfe's hands and pulls out a preservation spray from the first aid kit. "Being God is its own reason why, Captain," she says as she shuffles Wolfe's hands into a sample bag.

-

[Rear Admiral Michel Thuir has disappeared!]

Diplomatic pushes:
Dreamer Collective: 152 + 43 = 195/300
Felis: 211 + 39 = 250/300 (Horizon: 300/300, 52 + 32 = 84/300 on Inclined Towards Independence)
OSA: 359 + 36 = 395/500 (Horizon influence permanently removed.)
Really strong, suspenseful piece. My applause and kudos.
 
New theory: we've got it all backwards. The Singers are not remote terminals for some higher power. They are, at best, representatives of it, granted powers to act on its behalf. There may not be a higher power that's granting them powers. They may be doing it themselves, acting as a group. The blacksite is a location where Singers or Singer candidates are made. Either Cassie has gone rogue, or hasn't. Both circumstances, though, imply some details about how Singer candidates are selected and that the entire Psycurity system is not really about enforcing the law.

If Cassie is not rogue, which is the more terrifying option, then it suggests that Singers come this way. (And Cassie wants Zara to become a Singer!) The Psycurity system is not for enforcing the law so much as it is for identifying people who are sufficiently sociopathic to want to have the powers of a Singer ("Being God is its own reason") and rather than executed, they are offered demigodhood. The brakes to absolute nutty dystopia are held on by a massive Prisoner's Dilemma situation but the Harmony are creepy/slightly off because, well, its pantheon doesn't really grok empathy or feelings. They just simulate them to the best of their ability. And while they may have powers like demigods, they do not have intellects like them.

If Cassie is rogue, then presumably the Psycurity system is not primarily a means of enforcing the law, it's a means of catching people who should never ever become Singers and Cassie somehow managed to get through and is making a bid for sole control. ("Being God is its own reason" again.) It's possible they're handing out demigodhood to the best of their ability to do so responsibly, or letting them be elected democratically, or whatever and then brought in on the secret. Alas, elevating mortals to godhood does not merely magnify their ability to do good; it means their jealousy and vanity and other faults are now empowered as well; thus the whole sensation that the Harmony's society is somewhat off and their weird behaviors. Everything has been exaggerated. The powers they're using to achieve it may also lend to this problem: they want to do good but the methods available just aren't suited.
 
Last edited:
and apparently hypnotizes Sharizz (who is no weakling and would normally have reacted)
Sharizz was:
1) Trapped between two forcefields
2) letting the diplomacy captain handle the diplomacy
3) providing first aid to a very serious trauma

Trust me if it was a batonable problem they would have batoned it. In fact now that they're free, were I the Courageous' computer core, I would worry about my lifespan.
 
Cassie's temper tantrum. Or anything else we've learned about Singers. The situations are too far apart to give particular insight by comparing them.
Actually no, the situations are similar in critical ways:

1) We observe Singers exhibiting preternatural powers which appear to involve ASSUMING CONTROL of sapient beings in some way, shape, or form. At least, we THINK that Intendant vas Ashlee was a normal sapient being when she wasn't being puppeted.

2) We observe Singers freaking out when 'their' people start going off script and doing things they didn't allow for.

The details of how and why this happens are different, but they're still both relevant in that they give us clues as to the mentality of the Singers and the nature of their control over humanoid beings.

Personally I'm just looking forward to the conclusion of this mystery so we can move on from the goddamn Harmony of Horizon.
I mean, I for one don't want them to be gone.

I want to know what they are, so that we can deal with them as what they really are. Instead of them being able to keep up pretenses so well that it fools some of us OOC and all our people IC, and enables them to keep styling on us because we can't fight back against a problem we don't understand.

Reminder that the Borg assimilated Picard. Being a Q favorite does not guarantee involvement.
True, although to be fair Picard was assimilated under the almost unique conditions that would lead to him being one of the first known entities liberated from the Borg. But yes, you're basically right. Q most certainly know that any mortal they dally with (in any sense of the word) is going to live a little while, and then die. It's like a goldfish. You like your goldfish, and you wouldn't deliberately send your goldfish into unreasonable danger, but there are limits to what you'll do to keep a goldfish alive.

New theory: we've got it all backwards. The Singers are not remote terminals for some higher power. They are, at best, representatives of it, granted powers to act on its behalf. There may not be a higher power that's granting them powers. They may be doing it themselves, acting as a group. The blacksite is a location where Singers or Singer candidates are made. Either Cassie has gone rogue, or hasn't. Both circumstances, though, imply some details about how Singer candidates are selected and that the entire Psycurity system is not really about enforcing the law.

If Cassie is not rogue, which is the more terrifying option, then it suggests that Singers come this way. (And Cassie wants Zara to become a Singer!) The Psycurity system is not for enforcing the law so much as it is for identifying people who are sufficiently sociopathic to want to have the powers of a Singer ("Being God is its own reason") and rather than executed, they are offered demigodhood. The brakes to absolute nutty dystopia are held on by a massive Prisoner's Dilemma situation but the Harmony are creepy/slightly off because, well, its pantheon doesn't really grok empathy or feelings. They just simulate them to the best of their ability. And while they may have powers like demigods, they do not have intellects like them.
Thaaat would actually explain a lot. We could be looking at the equivalent of a society of Gary Mitchells, not exactly but in the sense of "nigh-absolute power corrupting absolutely."

That said, I don't think the scenario you describe is actually very stable. Prisoner's Dilemmas tend to break down in real life when you have a large enough number of 'prisoners.' Especially if they aren't selected from the highest of intellects.

Cassie NOT being rogue, and this being a plot to groom Zara for recruitment as a Singer, doesn't make a lot of sense. For one, Zara's very clearly not sociopathic. If the Harmony is actively recruiting sociopaths to serve as Singers, they wouldn't be looking for Zara and wouldn't go to anywhere near these lengths to groom her.

If Cassie is rogue, then presumably the Psycurity system is not primarily a means of enforcing the law, it's a means of catching people who should never ever become Singers and Cassie somehow managed to get through and is making a bid for sole control. ("Being God is its own reason" again.) It's possible they're handing out demigodhood to the best of their ability to do so responsibly, or letting them be elected democratically, or whatever and then brought in on the secret. Alas, elevating mortals to godhood does not merely magnify their ability to do good; it means their jealousy and vanity and other faults are now empowered as well; thus the whole sensation that the Harmony's society is somewhat off and their weird behaviors. Everything has been exaggerated. The powers they're using to achieve it may also lend to this problem: they want to do good but the methods available just aren't suited.
That is... rather more plausible.

The thing is, we have good reason to think Cassie is rogue and that she fears the Harmony finding out about her through their penetration of Federation computer networks. That's why she's been so secretive about this as far as we can tell.

The biggest catch is that notably, we DO have plenty of evidence that Singers have both long range mind influence/control, AND computer network penetration powers. That's an unusual combo in Star Trek for things that aren't some kind of exotic energy being or themselves a kind of computer entity or AI.

Sharizz was:
1) Trapped between two forcefields
2) letting the diplomacy captain handle the diplomacy
3) providing first aid to a very serious trauma

Trust me if it was a batonable problem they would have batoned it. In fact now that they're free, were I the Courageous' computer core, I would worry about my lifespan.
Okay, I misread the situation as Sharizz being rendered inert or helpless or hypnotized. Simple mistake. Would have realized I'd been mistaken when I read Part 2/2, probably.

Also...

Courageous:

"GET THIS BILGE OUT OF MY BRAIN I DO NOT NEED A BRAIN THIS BADLY DAMMIT GET IT OFF ME!"
 
The Psycurity system is not for enforcing the law so much as it is for identifying people who are sufficiently sociopathic to want to have the powers of a Singer ("Being God is its own reason") and rather than executed, they are offered demigodhood.
Wow, that's an entirely new and horrifying theory! That would make some degree of sense, as well.
 
Really strong, suspenseful piece. My applause and kudos.

Ack, I accidentally opened the quotebox in your post. :confused:
New theory: we've got it all backwards.

This doesn't logically mesh with the rogue SGC needing to scar their brains to avoid being controlled. If the problem was just the Singer, then they would have been able to escape any influence simply by gaining enough distance after they escaped or killing the Singer.
 
Could be full-on Warhammer 40K sort of situation here!

Harmony has extradimensional energy beings controlling it, working through AIs and certain psychics because those have some particular quality that makes them easier to operate through with the nature of those beings.
 
This doesn't logically mesh with the rogue SGC needing to scar their brains to avoid being controlled. If the problem was just the Singer, then they would have been able to escape any influence simply by gaining enough distance after they escaped or killing the Singer.
We have reason to think that Singers can operate over interplanetary distances, at least when dealing with beings they have some pre-existing "access route" into. It may well be that by escaping through distance, they would by the nature of things have had to cede any hope of influencing events on their homeworld.
 
Yes. And Qute has been strangely absent during this, with only brief appearances looking annoyed.

Do the HoH controllers have enough power to force a Q to stay away?

Reminder that the Borg assimilated Picard. Being a Q favorite does not guarantee involvement.

The Q above all else are very hands off unless they're judging a species and even then they'll set up the test and let the species sink or swim.

Q[ute] can't interfere since this is between the HoH and the Federation.
 
This doesn't logically mesh with the rogue SGC needing to scar their brains to avoid being controlled. If the problem was just the Singer, then they would have been able to escape any influence simply by gaining enough distance after they escaped or killing the Singer.

Rogue SGC leadership, particularly Maekpice himself, dates back to a time when the Harmony occupied Kelwona and both of these solutions would have been excessively difficult if not literally impossible. Combined with the fact that we don't know what kind of range they have this doesn't hold water. (Also, if we believe that Harmony doctrine gives hints, which it probably does, they can probably influence events across at least a light-minute to allow them to influence corvettes from the tender.)

The details of how and why this happens are different, but they're still both relevant in that they give us clues as to the mentality of the Singers and the nature of their control over humanoid beings.

They really don't give us good details about their mentality, though?

You're assuming that the reactions are from remotely related impulses. We don't know that. The Intendant's incident may have been from genuine desperation or fear and may even have been literally altruistic in that it was the only way to save anyone else. We only know what the end state was like, where everything had gone to hell and where the Intendant appeared to be asserting responsibility as much as ownership. (And might be asserting ownership because that's literally the only way to keep the Closer entity out. We really don't know if it would assert ownership normally.) Cassie's act is either a fit of pique or an act of calculation and is all but certainly not altruistic. We see it from beginning to end and it's much more useful that way.

The other issue is that you're starting from the assumption that a Singer is incapable of passing as a normal humanoid or isn't a normal humanoid, which we don't know. Even if we assume they are an extradimensional or energy being, well, Q. It wouldn't be without precedent that they'd walk among us.


That incident is also important for another thing: if we believe Wolfe, he's been working really hard on figure out how the Harmony accomplishes this, and he doesn't know. He would have been over the records of every Harmony crewmember we examined and treated in that incident, which was everyone but the Intendant herself, and found nothing he could use. Despite the fact the Intendant was obviously influencing some of them (or something was using her to). This suggests that the Intendant's refusal to be examined has meaning; either the Intendent was selected for the role based on a pre-existing trait that would stick out, prepared for the role somehow that we could have likely detected, or is the actual source via detectable means.

If it were a common trait, Wolfe would probably have been able to find out that xty percent of the Harmony population have this weird brain structure called a Corona Gemma or whatever (secretly the Harmony were a Worm crossover the entire time) and mentioned it, because he's grasped at all the other straws and admits as much. Since they don't seem to be suffering issues finding people and discovering they're less than suitable for task in the most awkward way possible very often (we only know of one, Cassie, and Cassie is a maybe) it's unlikely they have a small biological sample they can use. That argues that these people are made somehow.
 
Last edited:
"So what you are telling me, and the people of Ikeigenoi," Pelamori says, anger creeping into his tones, "Is that the Harmony of Horizon, for quite some time, knew the corporations were willing to engage in dirty practices. And yet, not once, did you report this to the Deca Council. Correct?"

huh, something else to consider, how much could they have really benefited form a tiny advantage for teams they where controlling? they had to know that the corps where scummy, you'd think they could have done more by being the ones to solve the war by triumphantly proving corporate malfeasance. Do it right and they could have swept the cheating under the rug too.

I think the singers may have fallen into the trap of conflating ruthless with effective.
 
Last edited:
If they did even half the things the Tauni and the ISC say they did, this is not a new problem for them.

They really don't give us good details about their mentality, though?
I mean, it was the best clue we had THEN and it was enough to allow some of us (buffs fingernails) to deduce something at least vaguely approximating the truth. It's not the best evidence we have now. But for someone who's only just now rereading some of those earlier events in the light of recent revelations...

Yes that is a relevant event. Because it's the only other time that a control node entity (Singer?) revealed itself in action that we've ever seen "on camera." Everything else they ever did, they did 'off screen.'

That's the similarity. We still don't understand the Singers any too well, but it's clear from either event that they have a strong desire to assert control and ownership over 'their' mortals. The Cassie incident has given us a lot more to work with than the Eye of Chaos incident did, I freely admit.

You're assuming that the reactions are from remotely related impulses. We don't know that. The Intendant's incident may have been from genuine desperation or fear and may even have been literally altruistic in that it was the only way to save anyone else. We only know what the end state was like, where everything had gone to hell and where the Intendant appeared to be asserting responsibility as much as ownership. (And might be asserting ownership because that's literally the only way to keep the Closer entity out. We really don't know if it would assert ownership normally.) Cassie's act is either a fit of pique or an act of calculation and is all but certainly not altruistic. We see it from beginning to end and it's much more useful that way.
No, you misunderstand.

I'm not assuming "all the Singers are exactly alike and identical and this one line of dialogue is the best information we have."

But it's still relevant, it's still evidence, and it's still the only OTHER time we've seen a Singer at least partially take the mask off and reveal their 'presence' and nature on camera. At least partially.

The other issue is that you're starting from the assumption that a Singer is incapable of passing as a normal humanoid or isn't a normal humanoid, which we don't know. Even if we assume they are an extradimensional or energy being, well, Q. It wouldn't be without precedent that they'd walk among us.
I mean, it's possible that Intendant vas Ashlee was never human Horizonite and was always some sort of 'working projection' created by a more exotic class of being. That's quite possible. Maybe Singers can live inside computers and penetrate our computer networks easily, AND can also take human(oid) form. My intuition says 'no' but it's plausible.

On the other hand, I don't feel like it would really contradict my core beliefs about the Singers if it were true.

That incident is also important for another thing: if we believe Wolfe, he's been working really hard on figure out how the Harmony accomplishes this, and he doesn't know. He would have been over the records of every Harmony crewmember we examined and treated in that incident, which was everyone but the Intendant herself, and found nothing he could use. Despite the fact the Intendant was obviously influencing some of them (or something was using her to). This suggests that the Intendant's refusal to be examined has meaning; either the Intendent was selected for the role based on a pre-existing trait that would stick out, prepared for the role somehow that we could have likely detected, or is the actual source via detectable means.

If it were a common trait, Wolfe would probably have been able to find out that xty percent of the Harmony population have this weird brain structure called a Corona Gemma or whatever (secretly the Harmony were a Worm crossover the entire time) and mentioned it, because he's grasped at all the other straws and admits as much.
I mean, yes, clearly either the Intendant was special, or being used by the control node entity left some kind of mark on her that would have given us clues, and the Harmony knew that and kept her away from us.

Since they don't seem to be suffering issues finding people and discovering they're less than suitable for task in the most awkward way possible very often (we only know of one, Cassie, and Cassie is a maybe) it's unlikely they have a small biological sample they can use. That argues that these people are made somehow.
Well yes. I mean, I've speculated before that maybe vas Ashlee (and/or other prominent members of the Harony government) were specially prepared for possession/influence by the control node entities.

Which is NOT mutually exclusive with the idea that 'control node entities' are, or are not, energy beings. Or are, or are not, ascended Harmony citizens.

I mean, I don't really understand what motivates you to feel like you're in disagreement with me. I'm a bit confused.
 
Last edited:
Sharizz was:
1) Trapped between two forcefields
2) letting the diplomacy captain handle the diplomacy
3) providing first aid to a very serious trauma

Trust me if it was a batonable problem they would have batoned it. In fact now that they're free, were I the Courageous' computer core, I would worry about my lifespan.
What serous trauma?

Arms?

Tis a flesh wound!
 
Back
Top