Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
Insubordinate...definitely, though at the very least he seems to have gotten that under control in recent years.

Racist. I don't think so personally. His personality is grating, at times but no more than a usual elf and certainly by the standards of Caeldor he's actually got surprisingly few biases.

Notably Caledor is one of the most anti dwarf places in Ulthuan (Caledor II cloak of beards etc.) and when we went to recruit him I expected that to be a problem, but he's fine doing jobs with dwarfs and so forth as long he gets paid and he charges everyone the same seemingly (a shit ton). At the very least by the standards of the Asur you can call him many things, but racist isn't one of them.
I mean, I find the guy fun and I interesting to talk to.

but the dude literally doesn't consider humans people unless they are very elfy (wizard lords) or powerful enough.
 
I mean, I find the guy fun and I interesting to talk to.

but the dude literally doesn't consider humans people unless they are very elfy (wizard lords) or powerful enough.
I guess I missed that bit?

Near as I can tell he seems able to get along with humans well enough, even though he finds them too short lived to get enough done (like a lot of elves/dwarfs) and generally primative, but is less patronising about it due to living amongst em for so long and is has found them capable of surprising him and being interesting (for example Anton).

The reason he likes the colleges so much is that he considers them a tweek to the nose of Finbur and also they can speak Eltharyn more than anything.
 
no more than a usual elf and certainly by the standards of Caeldor he's actually got surprisingly few biases.

Just gonna point out that we've got almost nothing to judge what a "usual" elf is like, and so going with a blanket 'they are all arrogant pricks' is really not giving them the benefit of the doubt.

@Codex , I loved your read of the king and his general, and I am here for that headcannon.
 
The reason he likes the colleges so much is that he considers them a tweek to the nose of Finbur and also they can speak Eltharyn more than anything.

Although if I remember correctly, only the Grey collage made Eltharin mandatory, and that's only because several of their ciphers and codes use it as a base. I'm not sure if any of the ducklings speak it themselves.

I could be wrong on that, though.
 
Finubar resumed normal relations with the rest of the Old World, respects humanity, and has a cool Ind sword.

Asarnil is an insubordinate racist.

I know exactly who I'm backing in that fight.
I do feel the need to point out the quote that people use to say that Finubar Respects humans actally says that he slightly fears them and their growth.
... fear is a kind of respect?
 
Asarnil is an Elf, a Caledorian Elf, a Dragon Prince, a Deathfang-riding Dragon Prince, has a myriad history of significant accomplishments, and there's a chip on his shoulder over his exile. It's a wonder his arrogance isn't a physical force.
 
Asarnil is an Elf, a Caledorian Elf, a Dragon Prince, a Deathfang-riding Dragon Prince, has a myriad history of significant accomplishments, and there's a chip on his shoulder over his exile. It's a wonder his arrogance isn't a physical force.
Maybe it's what powers his amulet?
 
[X] The Eonir of Laurelorn: Esoteric Dwarven (150 gc), Beastmen: Extensive Imperial, Extensive and Antiquarian Dwarven (300 gc), Waystones and Henges: Esoteric Imperial (150 gc and 4 CF)

More Books is always a good thing!
 
I do feel the need to point out the quote that people use to say that Finubar Respects humans actally says that he slightly fears them and their growth.
... fear is a kind of respect?

To be fair given that humans are by far more vulnerable to Chaos than any other major order power he likely has reason to fear them. Not to mention that it was a human, Nagash who invented a whole new sort of world ending threat in necromancy.
 
Kragg isn't really arrogant, though. He holds everyone and everything to a very high standard (and most of the time most of the things come short), but he holds himself to that standard too and also comes short sometimes.

...Can you explain how that is actually different and not just a rephrasing of 'but we like Kragg!'

Because it seems to read an awful lot like being terminally arrogant and just acting out the resulting scorn differently. I'd point to how he treats the other runelord as my main evidence.
 
Kragg isn't really arrogant, though. He holds everyone and everything to a very high standard (and most of the time most of the things come short), but he holds himself to that standard too and also comes short sometimes.

Oh he is definitely arrogant, it comes with thinking he is the best of the best and possessed of lore too precious to pass on because no one else is worthy of it. The thing is he is also self-loathing, because he is convinced that even his towering skills are no match for the glories of the past.
 
...Can you explain how that is actually different and not just a rephrasing of 'but we like Kragg!'

Because it seems to read an awful lot like being terminally arrogant and just acting out the resulting scorn differently. I'd point to how he treats the other runelord as my main evidence.
Kragg disapproves, of everything, including himself.
Asarnil most certainly does not disapprove of himself.

Asarnil has an incredibly high opinion of himself, and not that high opinion of most others.
But i like him anyway, largely because he backs up his high opinion of himself by being that good.
 
Kragg isn't really arrogant, though. He holds everyone and everything to a very high standard (and most of the time most of the things come short), but he holds himself to that standard too and also comes short sometimes.
Kragg is so arrogant that he has judged every other runesmith, from apprentice to Runelord unworthy of his knowledge.

Kragg is so arrogant that he would not even dignify Mathy with speaking with her and instead forced a master runesmith to be a mouthpiece when they first meet.

Kragg is so arrogant that he still refuses to admit that AV is useful even at the expense of it being able to smash Master runes as if he was doing a drum solo. Just because it would be admitting he was wrong.

l love grumpy Grampa, but I'm not blind to his Falults
 
Last edited:
Kragg disapproves, of everything, including himself.
Asarnil most certainly does not disapprove of himself.

Asarnil has an incredibly high opinion of himself, and not that high opinion of most others.
But i like him anyway, largely because he backs up his high opinion of himself by being that good.

Kragg still believes he is the best in a fallen world, he is plenty arrogant. I would argue that the culture of the Guild of Runesmiths breeds arrogance since it presupposes that a master runesmith will actually know if someone is worthy of them or not just by looking at them and that it is always the right course of action for them to withhold their lore unless it is proven otherwise. It is this combination of garment rending self-effacement before the past/the Ancestors and disregard towards the future/ their descendants.
 
...Can you explain how that is actually different and not just a rephrasing of 'but we like Kragg!'

Because it seems to read an awful lot like being terminally arrogant and just acting out the resulting scorn differently. I'd point to how he treats the other runelord as my main evidence.
Kragg is arrogant, but it's more of a 'you must prove you're worth my time before I'll deal with you' arrogance than a 'look how much better I am than you, mongrel' arrogance. It's generally easier to deal with the former than the latter, because it's far less in your face and obnoxious. It helps that Mathilde actually has proven she's worth Kragg's time too, so we don't actually see much of Kragg's arrogant side aimed at us anymore and so it's easier to overlook (as opposed to the start of the expedition, where he did things like drop off our belt and not even bother to explain it).
 
Last edited:
We saw things from Thorgrim's perspective twice now, and people were sympathetic and understanding to him at first.

Then he refused to tell Belegar that K8P's Waystone network was back online, and people understandably went back to hating or disliking him for making stupid decisions because Belegar now despises him over a misunderstanding.

Which is a silly thing to hate a Dwarf over, oaths are oaths are oaths, after all, and he is sworn not to reveal such secrets. You just gotta accept that to Dwarfs, it's better to be hated over a misunderstanding than to violate an oath in the process of clearing up said misunderstanding.

...Can you explain how that is actually different and not just a rephrasing of 'but we like Kragg!'

Because it seems to read an awful lot like being terminally arrogant and just acting out the resulting scorn differently. I'd point to how he treats the other runelord as my main evidence.

The truly arrogant think themselves the best thing ever. Kragg thinks himself a sad excuse for a runesmith compared to those of yore.
Or in other words, Kragg comes off as too sad and depressed at his core for the thread to think of him as super-arrogant.
 
...Can you explain how that is actually different and not just a rephrasing of 'but we like Kragg!'

Because it seems to read an awful lot like being terminally arrogant and just acting out the resulting scorn differently. I'd point to how he treats the other runelord as my main evidence.
It isn't arrogance so much as the logical conclusion of terminal perfectionism. One doesn't necessarily have to be arrogant to look at the work of oneself or others and find it falling short of the level needed, a perfectionist simply sets that bar beyond anyone's reach.

Which I think is also the foundation for the greater popularity of dwarves compared to elves on SV, because while both peoples talk down to humans a lot, in the case of the dwarves it is in most cases out of a borderline pathological perfectionist streak, one they apply to themselves just as harshly more often than not.
 
The truly arrogant think themselves the best thing ever. Kragg thinks himself a sad excuse for a runesmith compared to those of yore.
Or in other words, Kragg comes off as too sad and depressed at his core for the thread to think of him as super-arrogant.

One does not preclude the other. You know how a lot of religions have the concept of original sin, of living in a fallen world? Kragg is like that he thinks all the world is fallen and he still thinks he is the best at what he does and is beyond questioning by anyone alive.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top