Going by the last time we had a sudden windfall a simple "I looted/earned this stuff retaking a Karag" will be enough for the 'how did you get it' side of the equation.
Just to pick up a point from a while back: This isn't quite true. Per Grudgelore, dwarf-on-dwarf grudges still happen fairly commonly - there's examples like a grudge levied against a clan because they brought shoddy supplies to the stores for a campaign. It's simply that, because everybody involved is nominally on the same side and understands the importance of grudges, the matter is usually resolved diplomatically rather than through violence.
It's south-north (or was it north-south?). GM said so somewhere recently. Either way, it's not blowing towards the citadel.
I've noticed that it's not unusual for people to conflate WH Fantasy Orcs with 40k Orks. With 40k Orks, the argument that they aren't capable of changing themselves away from being psychotically violent does hold water. In 40k, Orks are an (possibly incomplete) Anti-Necron/C'tan bioweapon that effectively hasn't changed at all in the 60 million years since the fall of the Old Ones. Whether they're people and capable of self-reflection is actually tangiental to the core of the issue: all that 40k Orks are capable of doing with self-reflection is reaffirming how nice and fun a proper Waaagh! is. The only thing that's "changed" in 60 million years is that regular "Orks" are pretty much the larval stage of their species' life cycles and they're being culled aggressively and early enough that it's really rare for them to actually reach the more mature stages (and sizes) they used to reach when they were the Krorks of the War in Heaven. Which begs the question of whether Orks are still people if they're literally incapable of changing their nature away from the design intended by the Old Ones.
Do we know how much a Share is in gold?
Actually, there's a factor you're not considering, which is common to both 40k and Fantasy. The psychic gestalt. Orcs and Goblins can't self reflect because of the giant voice of every other orc/goblin in their heads telling them to Waaagh!
True, but would he have been capable of it if he'd gone against the grain of his species' collective consciousness and the gods with a direct claim on his soul? Or would his mind have been squashed by the weight of the tide?
That Dwarf rep she's been earning has a point...
Word of GM said the idea works.
Theres enough individuality around to bust that.
We know whats up with our shadow. Its a well known Ulgu arcane mark and theoretically its some corner of our soul(or some Ulgu warp structure/creature we've fused to) having a fine old time wriggling about.
So less that grudges don't happen much and more that they don't escalate much. And if then, deliberately so rather than accidentally so.
I mean, if you don't want to use good spirits, I'm sure someone back in our homeland could teach us how to summon exclusively bad ones. Sure, listening without reflexively swording them might prove difficult, but maybe they could write their notes down in a book or similar.
It'd be pretty orky to stand up and tell the Waagh to fuck off. Heck, I'm willing to bet that naturally arising Warbosses and Shamans are usually those with enough imagination and will to seize control of the Waagh rather than being dragged around by it.
He can be sad about things, like the end of a good fight and I guess deaths. What he's not allowed to do is, say, decide to become a pacifist, or something else that is really against the tenets of Greenskins. If he did that the direct connection between him and other greenskins, and between him and Gork and Mork, would kick his ass so hard he'd never sit still again.
Oh, there's some control. But it's riding the current of the Waagh, not fighting against it. That why they're orc pirates and mercenaries, not orc merchants and farmers.
