Question for the math people on this thread: if somebody joined the Outer Sect with Talent 8 and botched most of their social/resource gathering rolls, where would their cultivation be at the end of the year? How about Talent 9?
In setting people can't just get a numerical read on other people's talent. To some extent they have to infer it from your growth rate. Ling Qi has gone from completely impoverished, knowing nobody, and zero cultivation to Green/Bronze + full Green art suite in one year. I wonder what kind of talent that indicates for somebody who didn't nail their key early social rolls and have a team working with spreadsheets to optimize her cultivation.