Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
Just, like literally be everything. The entirety of existence, warp included. That's how you get max AP. Why limit to less? :D
So you're saying that instead of using Rebellion as our yuri reference guide to bringing back Abel, we should use Qualia the Purple?

Not a bad idea, but I am not entirely sure which of our friends that gets lifesaving surgery using a jungle gym.
 
Well. It has been 25 hours sense the last update and the thread now is talking about overthrowing God. Sounds about right.

Considering that of the top 10 gods, 6 are evil , 2 run on morality so blue and orange that the difference between it and evil is academical, and the last 2 are on spots so contested they are in a lower leauge altogether from the top 8 (I am not even sure which gods deserve these last 2 spots)... that is actually a good plan for saving the WHF universe.
 
Considering that of the top 10 gods, 6 are evil , 2 run on morality so blue and orange that the difference between it and evil is academical, and the last 2 are on spots so contested they are in a lower leauge altogether from the top 8 (I am not even sure which gods deserve these last 2 spots)... that is actually a good plan for saving the WHF universe.
We're not talking about Warhammer. I mean, making an apple pie from scratch in warhammer (and this quest), is easy. Watch:

"An apple pie"

:)
So you're saying that instead of using Rebellion as our yuri reference guide to bringing back Abel, we should use Qualia the Purple?

Not a bad idea, but I am not entirely sure which of our friends that gets lifesaving surgery using a jungle gym.
I regret, I have zero context in what those two anime are (I presume Rebellion is also an anime, it's a common name)... not that this should be taken as curiosity about them. I've not got time to allocate to new things for the next while however, so.. not very interested in learning more about them atm. "Qualia the Purple" is a pretty spiffy name though!
 
Last edited:
Considering that of the top 10 gods, 6 are evil , 2 run on morality so blue and orange that the difference between it and evil is academical, and the last 2 are on spots so contested they are in a lower leauge altogether from the top 8 (I am not even sure which gods deserve these last 2 spots)... that is actually a good plan for saving the WHF universe.
I agree with the sentiment but I feel that you are understating it a bit, though that may be down to differences in how we rank the gods. From where I am standing the top gods are the 4 chaos gods, Gork and Mork, the Horned Rat, Khaine, and then Asuryan with all of the various remaining pantheons having no clear pecking order.
 
The most dramatic mutation is that of the Bull Centaur, which are well-documented in the tome, but of most interest to you is the record of the vivisection of a Sorcerer with special attention paid to the petrification that had begun upon his body. His feet and ankles were entirely of stone, and displayed evidence of grouting to repair cracks and chips, but the spread upwards was uneven, with blood vessels completely petrified to the knees and showing increased rigidity as high up as the thighs, even as the flesh above it appeared unchanged. But nothing above the waist showed any signs of the transformation, which provides you with quite a bit of food for thought.

Magic as you know it flows primarily through the arms and chest, and under very few circumstances would it concentrate in the lowest extremities of the body. But you know next to nothing of the nature of the magic the Chaos Dwarves use. Is it Divine Magic that flows from below? Is their strange God physical, rather than ephemeral? Would that be related to their affinity for fire and molten rock and metal? If it is Arcane Magic of some sort, and they deliberately push what they cannot expel downwards? Or does something in the nature of it make it obey the call of gravity, rather than flowing through the air like the Winds? Or is seeking a logical answer a fool's errand when dealing with Dark Magic?

Too many questions, not enough data.

...

Dhar calls to Dhar, and in sufficient quantities it would be more than enough to draw in warpstone-infused shot. The crank only needs to begin and sustain the reaction, not power it entirely, and after the first few bullets have been fed through the backpack mechanism, the magical draw on the rest can be tapped into to restore the flywheel to full power once more.
I- hmmmm.
Dhar calls to Dhar, Warpstone is Dhar, all Warpstone originally comes from the two polar gates, the center of the earth is in between the two polar gates, and is straight down from the perspective of nearly anyone standing on the planet.
Is this planet cored with a gigantic mass of warpstone?
Thus dragging Chaos dwarf Dhar residue towards the ground, and affecting their feet first.

This could have serious implications as far as figuring out how Nagash originally planned to power his world-converting necromancy spell, or for reducing the taint of regions, or combating mutation in the population from ambient Dhar.
It would also explain why chunks of the Chaos Moon keep falling on Malus periodically, rather than spinning off into space, and might explain why the chaos moon occasionally draws much closer to the world seemingly of its own accord.
If that is true then confirming this, and figuring what you can place in the middle to halt the attractive effect might make the moon spin off into space.

edit: and I suppose that leaking this might redirect the resources that would otherwise go into the Skaven space program.
...
Also, this discussion of how Skaven ratling guns are essentially steam weapons, and the previous work of that one duckling on steam-launched weapons, makes me wonder if we're going to start seeing something similar, with ice propellant ammunition and maybe bits of rock or metal caught in the ice to make sure something goes all the way out without melting. scratch this, ice wouldn't flash-boil well enough. We already saw the limitations of steam-driven projectile speeds starting from water.
 
Last edited:
I agree with the sentiment but I feel that you are understating it a bit, though that may be down to differences in how we rank the gods. From where I am standing the top gods are the 4 chaos gods, Gork and Mork, the Horned Rat, Khaine, and then Asuryan with all of the various remaining pantheons having no clear pecking order.

The ones I mentioned were the big 4, the horned Rat and Nagash as evil, Gork and Mork as the blue and orange morality ones (or rather... the green morality ones).

Khaine, honestly, doesn't seem that dominating tbh. Sure, he is stronk, but not stronger than Sigmar, Morr, the other elven gods, the dwarven ancestors, etc. He plays at their tier.

Asuryan... maaaybe, but I am not sure why, other than the elves sense of superiority, he would be stronger than other "king" gods.
 
This one...we can do with magic.
Cheating with AV aside, a firing pin loaded with Flashboil and water filled bullets should be able to produce a similar phenomenon.

Might be a good time to rope Adela in, we're looking at several significant engineering problems with proximate solutions nearby
Maybe? the magical part could be substituted for water heated by a propane metal-cutting torch?
I'd be willing to bet the dwarves have that technology.

I think it's be a much less energetic phenomenon, though. And the feed is basically non-reproducible.
A gravity-driven feed might work if you're actually firing balls that have part of their mass boil off. Maybe feed in eggshell-like sphere-like objects with bits of metal suspended(with wires) in the water in the middle, then rely on the fact that whichever side of the shot comes in contact with the heat source first will be the part that produces the propelling reaction?

Or maybe just make the loading mechanism steam-driven if we're already messing around with having the shot be steam-driven. Running a boiler-driven automatic weapon seems like a much more efficient use for a steam-producing spell than those already experimented with.

Automatic grenade launcher?

the dwarves wouldn't still be using organ guns for their fixed defenses.
I'm being struck by a memory.
I'm not sure of the proper name, but I'm remembering organ guns that were developed as a successor to swivel guns on ships and fixed positions, and were beach loading, the point was that you could slide in a whole clip-like row of pre-loaded bottoms for the barrels from the side, then spin a screw clamp to tighten them against the rest of the assemblage of barrels, fire them off, loosen it, and slide in a new row of shots.
Then someone else would collect and reload the discarded rows.
With them being limited to a relatively small size because this style of early breech-loader couldn't handle the high barrel pressures of real cannons.
I think Johann would be a lot better off developing something like this, rather than trying to copy the Skaven.

Might edit in a picture later if I can find the book I got this from.
 
Last edited:
Asuryan... maaaybe, but I am not sure why, other than the elves sense of superiority, he would be stronger than other "king" gods.
That is easy actualy, just ask yourself, wich other ''king'' gods can you even think about ?
Human gods don't realy have any established hierarchy and the dwarf gods are mostly family working together, closest was Nehakara but Nagash fucked everything for everyone there, so Asuryan is pretty much the only god who is king of his own pantheon
 
That is easy actualy, just ask yourself, wich other ''king'' gods can you even think about ?
Human gods don't realy have any established hierarchy and the dwarf gods are mostly family working together, closest was Nehakara but Nagash fucked everything for everyone there, so Asuryan is pretty much the only god who is king of his own pantheon
Whoever heads the Celestial Bureaucracy of Cathay.
But honestly they only exist in the theoretical sense here, as something off the map that occasionally tosses things onto the map.
 
Clatterguns rapid-fire somehow.
I suspect clatterguns are something like high-powered paintball guns in operation. The steam engine is tapped for a high-pressure stream of air and roundshot is fed into said stream from a magazine for a rapid fire burst while strafing. Then the gyrocopter pulls up and circles back around for another pass, giving the engine time to regain pressure while doing so.
 
Whoever heads the Celestial Bureaucracy of Cathay.
But honestly they only exist in the theoretical sense here, as something off the map that occasionally tosses things onto the map

Honestly, for someone who didn't want us to go to Cathay because he didn't know how he'd handle it due to lack of established material, Boney has put quite a lot of worldbuilding this quest's Cathay. Obviously, its not the books and books of material established places have, as it still lacks all the history and the geography and most of the theology, but still, it feels as if it is a real place far away rather than some nebulous place that sometimes exist.
 
I regret, I have zero context in what those two anime are (I presume Rebellion is also an anime, it's a common name)... not that this should be taken as curiosity about them. I've not got time to allocate to new things for the next while however, so.. not very interested in learning more about them atm. "Qualia the Purple" is a pretty spiffy name though!
I don't know about the second, but Rebellion refers to the sequel movie to the Madoka Magica anime.
 
It'll be easier to make regular metal bullets and water feeding mechanism, or just plain steam feeding mechanism.
Water feed is slower and more fiddly than a shell filled with water with a wax seal to vent the steam directionally
Maybe? the magical part could be substituted for water heated by a propane metal-cutting torch?
I'd be willing to bet the dwarves have that technology.
The hard part is instantaneous heating
 
Water feed is slower and more fiddly than a shell filled with water with a wax seal to vent the steam directionally
Wait, so, like: A cartridge style bullet, but instead of gunpowder it's water, and the firing pin has Flashboil on it, and when it punches through the wax the water instantly expands at precipitous speeds?
 
Water feed is slower and more fiddly than a shell filled with water with a wax seal to vent the steam directionally
Okay, so we're imagining this bullet as a hollow cylindrical or conical shape, y'know an essentially bullet-shaped bullet, with water on the inside and a wax seal on the back, but how long does the bullet have to be before it contains enough water to get it up to a firearm-comparable speed once that water is turned to steam?

Are we talking crossbow-bolt sized bullets? Should we be considering having a bomb with the low-velocity impact fuses that were used in the payload of that other steam weapon?
Is it practical or insane to try to make it so the same weapon can fire both the low-velocity impact-fused bombs, and higher-velocity longer ranged shot? Possibly by having one variant of shot that mostly contains water and another variant that contains a lot of weight of explosive and much less of water?
Are we sure we can get the enchanted firing pins for this?

edit: also this technology could be the absolute weirdest lead-in to Minié ball style bullets I've ever imagined a tech-tree taking.
 
Last edited:
If you can instantly turn water to steam the expansion value is 1 to 1700 so less than you would think but you would need some really good metals and construction to contain it.
 
We can turn lukewarm to boiling, which the expansion rate for is, I'm given to understand, four percent, but on the other hand it is *instant*, which sounds like some pretty extreme motion to me. You'd need dwarven precision to get anywhere with it, but once you've got it, watch out.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top