Everyone answers at the same time. Everyone has a different answer. Sarvoi said his own name.
Ooh. Now I'm curious who Thorek considers the most charming.
And Elrisse.
And Hatalath.
And Niedzwenka.
And Cadaeth.
And Egrimm.
...Whoops. That's everyone I can't already guess myself.
As for the rest, Aksel liking Zlata and Zlata liking Aksel seem like sure enough guesses. Tochter is bound to appreciate Cadaeth's charm, even if it isn't outright attraction. As for Mathilde herself, it's either Cadaeth or Egrimm, with Niedzwenka as the runner up, judging purely by my memory of the vibes I've felt from thread participants, myself included.
But joking aside, Thorek is in fact the one I'm most curious about, in the hope that his reaction in this hypothetical scenario would not just be grumbling about how both Elgi and Umgi engage in utterly foolish games and contests.
Please don't make me actually work out a unique answer for everyone, that sounds like one of those maths problems that someone came up with three hundred years ago and only got solved in the last couple of decades.
Aww. I'll try it myself then.
Thorek actually enjoys Elrisse, though she wouldn't notice. His reaction to the question was grumbling about non-Dawi foolishness though.
Elrisse hates the question. She thinks the correct answer is Sarvoi. After all Sarvoi has the most self knowledge and picked himself. And yeah, he ticks all the boxes, as far as she can tell from experience.
Hatalath used an Eltharin nickname that could theoretically apply to a full half of the participants, depending on how you interpret it.
Niedzwenka considers both Zlata and Hatalath for completely opposite reasons. She picks the one she's actually attracted to. Max and Johann are also quite fetching, but alas, they are not eligible for this little contest.
Cadaeth knows she's the most charming (it's her job to be) but isn't as gauche as Sarvoi and thus doesn't say it out loud.
Egrimm likes Mathilde, but doesn't think it expedient to admit it here, since she's his boss. No, this isn't wishful thinking at all. I don't know what you mean.
Zlata and Aksel just look at each other and smile. They've been an item for a while now and have made it all but official towards every other Project member. Except for Mathilde. Obviously the Grey Wizard already knows. And evidently approves, or they wouldn't have been sent on that little two person excursion together.
Tochter unabashedly says Cadaeth. Those momentary frustrations during the ritual creation only made her seem even more charming.