Remove ads

Warhammer Fantasy: Divided Loyalties - an Advisor's Quest

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting will open in 8 hours, 1 minute
Reader mode
picklepikkl said:
Awesome catch. Boney, does this work for a Serenity action or no? If so, I definitely favor that over starting the AV book.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Mathilde's contribution to it can be done as a Serenity action. You'd be asking Egrimm to write the paper in his free time instead of on the clock, which is normal for the Colleges but does mean that Mathilde will get the relevant malus for having a coauthor.
 
Boney said:
Mathilde's contribution to it can be done as a Serenity action. You'd be asking Egrimm to write the paper in his free time instead of on the clock, which is normal for the Colleges but does mean that Mathilde will get the relevant malus for having a coauthor.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
If she's getting a malus, does that mean that Egrimm will get more credit than if it were on the clock?
 
Awesome. OK then, I think I now support delaying the AV book by one turn: assuming we finish AV on T43 (either by doing liminal realms T42 and orbs T43 or by doing both on T43), we can do Windfall this coming turn, AV part 1 on T43, and AV part 2 on T44. That way we don't start the book until after we've done all the research, which means there's no risk we need to go back and rewrite it, which some people were worried about. The "downside" is that we lose a bit of potential CF gain (which, like, whatever at this point), but as Andres's followup question established, that means Egrimm gets more credit which is what we wanted anyway, so it's all upside as far as I'm concerned.

Cue the fights over whether we want a third WEB-MAT action to be Windherder or some other artifact investigation, but honestly that's a good thing to fight about.

Back to this vote:
Deathbybunnies said:
I respectfully disagree. The former says nothing about any motivation beyond looking for her next job/goal, and the latter is not only explicitly vague and not pinning down Mathilde's motivations, but the options also don't indicate that Mathilde has any problem with the Altdorf ecosystem at all. As well it shouldn't; it's never given Mathilde any trouble.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I see where you're coming from; I'd always interpreted that part of Mathilde's story as her being uncomfortable in the Empire, which is why I wrote what I did, but I can see how it can be parsed differently. I don't think it's a big deal, though; worst-case scenario, Mathilde exaggerates her discomfort levels a bit in order to be #relatable with the new kid.

I am surprised there are so few distinct votes, though, as well as so few votes in general; it's been open two and a half hours and we only have 21 voters. With how popular Sofia was as a social option, I kind of assumed this would be a very contentious vote. Maybe Americans are just busy on Saturday night? I'd be unsurprised to learn that the readers of Divided Loyalties are extremely cool people with rockin' social lives.
 
Mopman43 said:
Does Mathilde know how common a type that is?

Mainly asking because Barbitus found it basically impossible to find relevant resources on his type, so I was wondering how likely it would be to be able to find relevant material for Eike.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Uncommon, but not nearly as so as Barbitus' visceral. The problem with Intuitive is that there's not really anything you can communicate and compare, you can't say 'Dhar looks like slime' or 'Dhar smells like rot', it just feels like Dhar.
 
Boney said:
Uncommon, but not nearly as so as Barbitus' visceral. The problem with Intuitive is that there's not really anything you can communicate and compare, you can't say 'Dhar looks like slime' or 'Dhar smells like rot', it just feels like Dhar.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Are books on Windsight covered under Sevir, or a different category?
 
picklepikkl said:
I am surprised there are so few distinct votes, though, as well as so few votes in general; it's been open two and a half hours and we only have 21 voters. With how popular Sofia was as a social option, I kind of assumed this would be a very contentious vote. Maybe Americans are just busy on Saturday night? I'd be unsurprised to learn that the readers of Divided Loyalties are extremely cool people with rockin' social lives.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Write-ins scare voters off, plus this one is a kind of important vote. Well, that's my excuse at least, given it's a sunny Sunday morning for me.
 
[JK] Offer her a pint of dwarven ale.

"Apprentices can't be scared of you if they're unconscious!"
 
picklepikkl said:
I am surprised there are so few distinct votes, though, as well as so few votes in general; it's been open two and a half hours and we only have 21 voters. With how popular Sofia was as a social option, I kind of assumed this would be a very contentious vote.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Might be people are hesitant on how to vote on a fairly delicate social matter.

It's not as clear-cut as 'I want to see Mathilde interact with this person', it's 'oh god oh god, how do I navigate this conversation?'
 
Hold on a moment, Maximilian's last name is de Gaynesford. He's Bretonnian. Did his parents smuggle him out so they wouldn't have to give him up?
 
[X] Plan K8P Is Special, Remove Hat
-[X] Remove hat.
-[X] Introduce self as Panoramia's romantic partner
-[X] Explain that Karak Eight Peaks has been a good place for wizards who, for one reason or another, were uncomfortable in Altdorf to develop their unique talents and interests, Mathilde included

[X] Plan Redshirt v1, Remove Hat
-[x] Remove hat.
-[x] Introduce yourself as Panoramia's romantic partner, and mention that between WEB-MAT and Panoramia, you'll be coming in and out of K8P pretty regularly. You're pleased to meet Panoramia's apprentice.
-[x] Explain that Karak Eight Peaks is generally very welcoming of wizards and has been a good place for a lot of wizards who didn't "fit in" in the Empire to get a fresh start. You hope that Sofia can benefit from that as well.
--[x] Ask if Panoramia has given her the overview of the facilities yet - if she hasn't, run her down the basics the same you did for the ducklings - where the labs are, where the practice range is, how to access the library, etc.
---[x] Include your own recommendations on the best shops and restaurants in Karag Nar and the Valley.
--[x] Just as it was for the other wizards who came to Karak Eight Peaks, your door is open if she wants information or advice from you.

[X] Plan Friendly Welcome, Remove Hat
-[X] Remove hat.
-[X] Welcome Sofia to the Karak Eight Peaks Wizarding community
-[X] Tell her she'd welcome to come ask questions and peruse the library (pending Panoramia's approval for any magical subjects)
-[X] Emphasise that whatever troubles she's had in the past, this is an opportunity to leave them in the past with a mostly fresh slate
 
Last edited:
[x] Plan Redshirt v1

I really don't think this is overly detailed, and I don't get the "arranged in a specific sequence" criticism. Like, these are just items, they can be trivially rearranged if the conversation demands. Mathilde is introducing herself in enough detail to figure out she's here because of Pan, telling a bunch of things about K8P (I'm not very sure about the favorite places part, feels too personal yet, but not that bad), and saying that her door is open (not that Sofia is likely to go to us, but imo saying that is a prerequisite for her ever considering it).
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Voting will open in 8 hours, 1 minute
Remove ads
Back
Top