- Location
- Chicago
- Pronouns
- She/They
*Elder Race cough* I think it is fair to say that both the dwarfs and elves were building libraries long before the ancestors of those Verenans were even literate. This is not just me being glib mind, but a reminder that this is a library in a dwarf Karak where the Verenans would have practically no support for any sort of 'institutional capture'.
Do dwarves open their libraries to other species? Do they have a mandate to share knowledge?
No. They don't.
And so the things I'm concerned about Verenians doing to our library- restricting access and clamping down on who gets to see what- are EXACTLY the same sort of things dwarf librarians would do too.
The dwarves aren't going to serve as a counterweight to these concerns because they agree with them, culturally.
Please address the content of our concerns instead of just trying to shoot them down as irrational.
This is an assumption that is not based on fact, because Verenans revel in the differences between them. I'm 100% sure we can find someone who matches our belief and principles of what a library should be and happens to be a Verenan. That is just what it means to be a Verenan, that they're not a monolithic entity with a central structure that tells them what and how to think and believe.
Sure. It also means that literally every agreement we negotiate is going to be with that specific branch of the cult, not the cult as a whole.
If this is true, then we won't be able to negotiate to get books from "Verenians", it'll have to be specific Verenian temples. Because no monolithic central authority.
On the other hand, IF we can get an agreement from the cult as a whole, it pretty strongly implies enough centralization that my concerns can't be waved away.
and as rude as this is, they dont matter in the politics of the karak, at least as far as we and the library are concerned
And this is what causes resentment and political trouble between halflings and others.
It is rude. Being rude to your neighbors is stupid, if you want their help and buy in. Because bluntly, the entrance to the library doesn't face a dwarven Karak- it faces a halfling village inside that Karak.
Last edited: