Best of luck to you then. Thanks for the warning.
I was referring to your general acting throughout Day 3 and Day 2, not just while the Comi thing has been going on. Mind you, you have been a bit busy so it's understandable that you won't appear often, but I am not content to let you slip under the radar after you were scum last game without me detecting it. Therefore, I want you to tell me more of your thoughts over this game and the various people beyond merely the lynches going on.
These all feel like new player fishing, and give me a good feel. It feels like Meso is trying to figure out game mechanics and the setup rather than digging for specific info (aside from the bit on if Roleblocked=PR, but that is explained well enough for me)
Checked the posts before, this is the first mention of it for the day and is surprisingly on point from someone who supposedly isn't informed. I can see two possibilities. One is good, the other is alarming. Pretty sure it's the first but... Well, Certain Town or Certain Doom.
These are really early pushes for a claim from Absum, continuing off of Absum's Day 2 offering of claiming if about to be lynched. Somewhat concerning, but probably not actually bad? This is the only real role fishing I can see.
This is my first game, but I spent a while reading through the mafiascum wiki and I watched the last two games to try to prepare so my contribution would be somewhere south of 90% confused flailing.
I don't want to give scum any more information, but I am also pretty desperate for another source of information. Several players aren't posting much, we've lost three townies, and if my guess is right, we've yet to take out a member of the main scum team. I'd really like something firmer to go on so we don't lynch town, because we're almost certain to lose someone to a night kill tonight.
I tend to agree. The fluff surrounding LTTL's role really implied an outsider (savage beast person from the south and all that), and their faction name seems unlikely to be the generic faction name, given that the invaders are supposed to be "the black clad legions of Reim" according to the set up.
This.
What is your list, by the by?
@Absum
Clearly I need to recalibrate the mind control beam...
Fishing for Masons.
This is wine. I believe them when they say that they're in a Quicktopic, but I don't know their alignment. Either way, I really don't like this.
Really don't like this. Yes, I'm sure explaining to you why you have a bad feeling is such an easy thing to do for someone who isn't you.
Don't like this. Provide a reason, or admit that you don't have a reason.
The answer to 1KbestK's question " Are you going to explain yourself? ". Really dislike this answer. Voting someone for no reason, and when asked just says "no u".
I suppose I have to check 1KbestK to see if this is true, so...
These are all before Even voted for them. So, they didn't want to vote up the newbies, a position I am sympathetic towards, and didn't jump on -Rosen, someone who we now know were town. Either way, I don't think that this is enough of a reason for Even to lynch 1KbestK.
Right. Gonna split this one up.
This exchange.No, but I might by accident.
Well, you did willingly and knowingly antagonise them. Of course they would be prickly. I'd say that they had a reason.
Well, I'd say that that's more then Evenstar at this point of the game.
Miiight be fishing? Not sure. Dunno what to make of this one.
This one's just here if maybe someone else finds it usefull.
Firstly, just a stray thought that popped into my mind. Might be nothing though. At the start of day 1, Evenstar said that they got Witches in Twisted Miasma vibes. I didn't play that one, but I think it was about several quicktopics with some scum among them, right? Either way, I don't think that people could get invited into other quicktopics in that game, so if Evenstars "Mason" could do so, is that the vibe they would get? Either way, I don't know. The real thing I dislike is voting without a reason. Again.
NAI to me.
Just for posterity, really.
Well, it's a reason at least. Also a reason why did just abandoned their Nani Lynch. Well, so much to as "Looking off" is a reason.
Aaaand 5 posts later. Still not really giving a reason why they suspect Absum.
At least there is a reason for the lack of a reason this time. Not everyone got that luxury.
The lack of posting is understandable considering this, but I'm still unhappy about the lack of reasoning for Absum, and as mentioned earlier, I don't think their arguments towards 1KbestK holds any water.
Needless to say, I think that 1KbestK has a point here.
Once more. No reason for the vote on Nanimani. Interesting thing, during day three the roleblocker is scum for targeting Nani, despite the last thing Evenstar did day 2 was vote for them. Defending LttL might be scummy, depends on if LttL has a team. So it's up in the air at the moment.
Blatant fishing. Don't trust this a bit.
Continues to vote without providing a single reason.
More fishing. At least I'm also very suspicios of Comiturtle, slight town? Unless Comi is town, in which case it's just scum.
Once more, without stated reason.
More fishing?
I suppose that is a reason, but it's a pretty poor one. What's the basis for suspicion? Why Absum?
Already went over this in an above post. Not doing it again here.
While I like seeing a readlist, I also like seeing some basis for those reads. For example as the concerned party, I'd appreciate something other then a gut feeling. At the very least, quote a post and say, "I don't like this".
Maybe I'm just not understanding this post, but this one thing causes them to be on the top of town? And no Nictis effortpost is enough to win over that one single post? Really now.
So why 1K and Hobo?
Eva probably knows to never 100% Town Read me.
Eva, no. Please. Please do not try to suspect DG for putting effort into scum hunting. All his points against you are fair.
The progression Eva. It existed. Someone you suspect suddenly swinging a vote onto you is a pretty good incentive to start a dig, or a good excuse to make one as Scum. His points against you have all already been raised before, there's a legitimacy to them. There are good reasons for people to suspect you, or if not suspect you get annoyed.