Forge of Destiny(Xianxia Quest)

Also, what's the tally looking like right now?

Hmm.

Fire is 11, Housesitting is 10.
Adhoc vote count started by TheLastOne on May 22, 2017 at 7:25 PM, finished with 8001 posts and 33 votes.

  • [X] Plan With All the Strength of a Raging Fire
    [X] Plan Housesitting Pretty
    [X] Plan Double Break
    [X] Plan Housesitting Pretty
    [X] Two Red Stones
    -[X] Look into how Su Ling and Li Suyin are doing and cultivate at the vent
    --[X] Give Su Ling the Lotus Root Pin and Li Suyin the Skirmisher's Anklets. They aren't gifts, they're just paying them for all the help they've given us - we wouldn't have claimed the arive pass without their support.
    --[X] Offer Su Ling the Qi Foundation pills in trade - she hunts beast cores for Li Suyin. For the next two weeks she can hunt them for us too.
    --[X] Spiritual
    -[X] Go House hunting with Bai Meizhen
    -[X] Talk to Han Jian see if he has any advice about the current 'political' situation
    -[X] Breakthrough to Yellow if at peak red, silver otherwise
    --[X] Finish Breakthrough if first roll succeeded. If we failed, spend some time with Gu Xiulan try to work out what has her so bothered by Li Suyin.
    [X] Plan With All the Strength of a Raging Fire
    [X] Resources used
    ---[X] Two Red Spirit Stones, Argent Accumulation pill, Qi Foundation Pill
    -[X] Look into how Su Ling and Li Suyin are doing and cultivate at the vent
    --[X] Spiritual
    ---[X] Give your gifts to them, they deserve it
    -[X] Go House hunting with Bai Meizhen
    [X] Breakthrough Yellow
    ---[X] If not Peak Red, cultivate spiritual
    [X] Cultivate on your own
    ---[X] Argent Soul
    [X] Plan all aboard the big team train, Yellow Ranger.
    [X] Plan This is not a harem plan
    [X] Resources used
    --[X] Two Red Spirit Stones
    -[X] Look into how Su Ling and Li Suyin are doing and cultivate at the vent
    --[X] Give Su Ling the Lotus Root Pin and Li Suyin the Skirmisher's Anklets.
    --[X] Spiritual
    [X] Spend some time with Gu Xiulan try to work out what has her so bothered by Li Suyin
    -[X] Go House hunting with Bai Meizhen
    [X] Breakthrough to Yellow
    [X] Plan Double Break
    [X] Resources used
    --[X] Two Red Spirit Stones
    -[X] Look into how Su Ling and Li Suyin are doing and cultivate at the vent
    --[X] Spiritual
    ---[X] Give your gifts to them, they deserve it
    --[X] If they could use them and refuse because they don't want a gift, offer to loan the stuff to them indefinitely.
    [X] Breakthrough Yellow
    ---[X] If not Peak Red, cultivate spiritual
    -[X] If not Peak gold, cultivate physical
 
Alright, no need to consolidate just yet then. I basically just don't want Double Break to win, since I think it fails to accomplish a number of important things (talking to people, mostly).
 
Yeah, I'm a bit surprised my plan was the only one that's trying to do this. It seems pretty important.
Frankly, the politics of the situation are such that there is nothing we can do at the moment to change them. What could we do with that knowledge? Avoid people who don't like us, try to make friends with important people, try to challenge people who are weak but politically important. Knowledge of how politics works only helps if we can use the politics to our advantage, and I'm not seeing that happening yet.

I do acknowledge the point about how politics are affecting our life right now, and more knowledge about them would be useful, especially regarding the major players who showed up at the end of the battle.

It has been pointed out to me that we could ask Meizhen what went down politically in that last battle in between walking around searching for houses, and it would give us a conversation to talk about instead of awkward silence.

However, I'm not sure if that would be double dipping into the Han Jian action.
What would be people's reaction to a change that added, ---[] talk to Bai Meizhen about the politics of the battle, underneath house shopping with Bai Meizhen?
 
Last edited:
Frankly, the politics of the situation are such that there is nothing we can do at the moment to change them. What could we do with that knowledge? Avoid people who don't like us, try to make friends with important people, try to challenge people who are weak but politically important. Knowledge of how politics works only helps if we can use the politics to our advantage, and I'm not seeing that happening yet.

Seems a little bit short sighted. We don't even know what we don't know. They are unknown unknowns, not known unknowns, so we can't even avoid problems right now.
 
@drake_azathoth Your plan has us breaking through yellow 4 times, two of those should be silver.
Not sure how that was missed for so long but fixed, thanks.
Actually, given the way she said it ("Once you break through into the Yellow Soul, or Silver Physique however… there is something you can assist me with," Bai Meizhen seemed slightly uncomfortable with making the request.) it's very likely not fighting alongside her that she's talking about. To me, it seems more likely that she's talking about a technique or maybe sparring or something along those lines.
That's kind of dubious. I might buy it if she said 'once you break through into Yellow Soul' or 'once you make Yellow Soul AND Silver Physique' or something specific like that, but there are no techniques with Silver Physique I'm aware of and even then the either/or nature of 'Silver OR Yellow' seems to just be an indication of 'once you're strong enough to make a difference in a real fight'. Note we promised not to make her wait long on that.
 
Last edited:
Shall I propose a compromise plan.

[X] Plan Sitting Pretty With All the Strength of a Raging Fire
-[X] Resources used
--[X] Two Red Spirit Stones, Argent Accumulation pill, Qi Foundation Pill
-[X] Look into how Su Ling and Li Suyin are doing and cultivate at the vent
--[X] Give Su Ling the Lotus Root Pin and Li Suyin the Skirmisher's Anklets. They aren't gifts, they're just paying them for all the help they've given us - we wouldn't have claimed the arive pass without their support.
--[X] Offer Su Ling the Qi Foundation pills in trade - she hunts beast cores for Li Suyin. For the next two weeks she can hunt them for us too.
--[X] Spiritual
-[X] Go House hunting with Bai Meizhen
--[X] talk to Bai Meizhen about the politics of the battle
-[X] Breakthrough Yellow
---[X] If not Peak Red, cultivate spiritual
-[X] Cultivate on your own
---[X] Argent Soul
 
Last edited:
Seems a little bit short sighted.
I wouldn't say shortsighted, but it is also not ideal. Ideally, we would figure out who to avoid and why, but I see little interest in politics beyond that. However, we have the current understanding of pretty much-avoiding everyone other than our friends, and I'm not sure how much additional knowledge would change that. Also, I did make an edit to the post you quoted talking about adding an addition to the "House Search" option which would have us talking with Meizhen about the politics of the battle.

I am still unsure if I should make that change as it could be considered double dipping to the Han Jian action.
 
That's kind of dubious. I might buy it if she said 'once you break through into Yellow Soul' or something specific like that, but there are no techniques with Silver Physique I'm aware of. Silver Physique OR Yellow Soul sounds much more like she's talking about fighting strength.

I disagree, but given that there's no hard evidence one way or another I can't say much more than that.
 
Not sure how that was missed for so long but fixed, thanks.
That's kind of dubious. I might buy it if she said 'once you break through into Yellow Soul' or something specific like that, but there are no techniques with Silver Physique I'm aware of. Silver Physique OR Yellow Soul sounds much more like she's talking about fighting strength.

I saw it but thought that it was try to breakthrough and use actions to rebuild for another try if it fails.
edit: rather then try to breakthrough in two different areas.

An action to max spiritual
an attempt at the first breakthrough pass/fail
recovery to return to max or shot at the second breakthrough
try to break through the first again recover from the second fail or complete and become yellow.
 
Last edited:
Seems a little bit short sighted. We don't even know what we don't know. They are unknown unknowns, not known unknowns, so we can't even avoid problems right now.

Is Housesitting yours?

Do you think we could add a specific 'would it be appropriate to thank Cai/Gan' for helping us/what would be an appropriate thank you' sort of thing? Or do you think that's an implicit part of picking the action?

Or are you making no assumptions in case the Cai and Han families are not friends?

Yes, I *do* think the Gan Guangli action would be worth it. But at the moment I'm staring at it with the same trepidation that I stared at the 'let's go steal a necklace on Cui's word'. It could backfire quite horribly, depending on how many people saw the gutter rat try to offer Gan Guangli lunch. :V
 
Is Housesitting yours?

Do you think we could add a specific 'would it be appropriate to thank Cai/Gan' for helping us/what would be an appropriate thank you' sort of thing? Or do you think that's an implicit part of picking the action?

Or are you making no assumptions in case the Cai and Han families are not friends?

Yes, I *do* think the Gan Guangli action would be worth it. But at the moment I'm staring at it with the same trepidation that I stared at the 'let's go steal a necklace on Cui's word'. It could backfire quite horribly, depending on how many people saw the gutter rat try to offer Gan Guangli lunch. :V

Eh, I don't want to ask because that would direct the conversaion away from what we need to know, which is WTF is going on here and are there some spike traps ahead or swords of damocles above.
 
Oh.

Is buying Heart Bloom Brooch at 40 Red Spirit Stones to expensive to consider at this point?
Some people were mentioning Pill week the next week after, so I am assuming that's why people aren't going for that?
 
Oh.

Is buying Heart Bloom Brooch at 40 Red Spirit Stones to expensive to consider at this point?
Some people were mentioning Pill week the next week after, so I am assuming that's why people aren't going for that?
It's because until we get to Yellow it's not significantly better than what we have.
 
Remember folks! Vote [] Raging Fire for the dream of having EPC earlier than otherwise possible!

Is buying Heart Bloom Brooch at 40 Red Spirit Stones to expensive to consider at this point?
Ummm, no not really. We just got 85 more spirit stones than we were expecting to have. Our Current reserves are far from depleted. A pill week will take about 20-30 spirit stones so we would still have enough for quite a few pill weeks.
 
That's... really not my top priority right now. Honestly, it's not even in my top 3 priorities.
Really? What is your top three priorities if I may ask? Because plan [] Raging fire has social, making sure that Meizhen doesn't make more enemies, a breakthrough to yellow as well as getting good progression with AS 5.
 
Really? What is your top three priorities if I may ask? Because plan [] Raging fire has social, making sure that Meizhen doesn't make more enemies, a breakthrough to yellow as well as getting good progression with AS 5.

My top three are maintaining our various social links (my big problem with Raging Fire for that is that it doesn't include talking to Gu Xiulan -- although, granted, it seems to have only 4 actions unless the yellow breakthrough bit is meant to be two actions, in which case it should probably say so), keeping our ear to the ground to see what the rest of our "class" of disciples are up to so we don't get surprised, and breaking through (I'd prefer silver before yellow since we're already there, but it seems that most people disagree with that).
 
Back
Top