Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Actually, we might want to spend some favour on learning from Rangers lol.
They are pretty good at our kind of warfare; and learning how to use, idk, a crossbow, or generally being a good shot could not hurt.

Not sure it's as high priority as lessons in how dwarves look at magic in general, or spending favours on chapterhouse of College in dwarven hold, or a cool sword-staff, but it's an option, I suppose.
 
Actually, we might want to spend some favour on learning from Rangers lol.
They are pretty good at our kind of warfare; and learning how to use, idk, a crossbow, or generally being a good shot could not hurt.

Not sure it's as high priority as lessons in how dwarves look at magic in general, or spending favours on chapterhouse of College in dwarven hold, or a cool sword-staff, but it's an option, I suppose.

If we really wanted to learn, shouldn't we in the future be looking to working with Huntsmen or better yet, Elves like Waystalkers and Shadow Warriors? Of course both of the latter options are way way way out of our way and quite likely not possibly achievable in our lifetime.
 
Last edited:
If we really wanted to learn, shouldn't we in the future be looking to working with Huntsmen or better yet, Elves like Waystalkers and Shadow Warriors? Of course both of the latter options are way way way out of our way and quite likely not possibly achievable in our lifetime.

Hm. Yyeah, point, but elves are far away and dwarves are, like, right here.
And if we somehow acquire enough favours with Elves, I'd rather spend them on learning from their wizards, that's for sure.
 
[X] Remain here and help Ulthar make sense of the reports flowing in.
Yeah, this might mean more with such a young dwarf around, and we have the trait for it. Might as well use it. If we can make sure a third front goes well for the dwarves, that help's quite a bit, and it shows off Mathilde's expertise, which will only help. I'm a bit nervous about those missing Squigs.
 
We have to remember that as much as we like the dwarves, our goals are not their goals. The dwarves need help taking K8P and we're helping with that, because we like them, but also because it'll get us Dwarven Rep we can use to get dwarven goodies. Their victories are only tangentially our victories. If we have an opportunity to help out in a way that benefits us, the only reason not to take it is if the difference in Rep we expect to earn elsewhere outweighs it.

We can help here, be seen to be helping here, and learn about fog of war warfare, which we're interested in. I don't believe helping in the Underway will be so glorious that extra rep earned there (if any!) outweighs this rare opportunity to learn how the dwarves do things for free.
 
[X] Remain here and help Ulthar make sense of the reports flowing in.

This both gives us a chance to assist in the generaling and respond if things turn sour. Sounds good to me!
Unfortunately Maria doesn't know how to create illusions so she can't help with herding them directly.

Who's Maria? Maria is not a shorthand for Mathilde. Is your autocorrect not recognizing Mathilde as a proper name?
We have to remember that as much as we like the dwarves, our goals are not their goals. The dwarves need help taking K8P and we're helping with that, because we like them, but also because it'll get us Dwarven Rep we can use to get dwarven goodies.

Don't forget that the dwarves taking K8P is a huge boon on the strategic scale. If you really wanna talk mercenary, recall that we're conveniently avoiding sticking around the Empire during a brewing (stupid) religious civil war.
 
Here is an idea for us getting a better sword, we simply need to get enough Empire reputation that the Emperor chooses to let us use Beast Slayer. I mean surely the Runefang of the Drakwald would be a great upgrade!!

But yeah unlikely, still I can dream.
 
Here is an idea for us getting a better sword, we simply need to get enough Empire reputation that the Emperor chooses to let us use Beast Slayer. I mean surely the Runefang of the Drakwald would be a great upgrade!!

But yeah unlikely, still I can dream.

Even if it could be done I'd say we do not wnt that amount of imperial attention. Between the Book That Must Not Be Named and just being a magister of the grey College, the very shiny title of Hero of the Empire does not suit us.
 
Something else to consider is that staying here allows us to get to know another member of Belegar's council, one that we're likely to be working with closely through the rest of the campaign.

We have to remember that as much as we like the dwarves, our goals are not their goals. The dwarves need help taking K8P and we're helping with that, because we like them, but also because it'll get us Dwarven Rep we can use to get dwarven goodies. Their victories are only tangentially our victories. If we have an opportunity to help out in a way that benefits us, the only reason not to take it is if the difference in Rep we expect to earn elsewhere outweighs it.

Well, yes and no. Being seen by the dwarves not to have a selfish agenda and simply to have come to fulfil the terms of the ancient pact between the Men of the Empire and the Dwarves or Karag Ankor is likely to accrue favours at a faster pace than being seen as being more obviously grasping.

More strategically, having an agent of the Empire's central government being a key part of successfully retaking of Karak Eight Peaks is diplomatically very useful, both internally and externally. Externally, as far as dwarven relations go, Mathilde's contributions should easily cover for the fact that the Emperor only 'sent' wizards. Internally, it should strengthen the position/legitimacy of the Emperor vis-a-vis the Elector Counts, as he sent aid to the dwarves and they didn't. The Empire is still lately feudal, and this kind of obligation is the lifeblood of relations between and within the various strays of society. If people see you not fulfil their obligation to help someone else, it will make them doubt whether you'll fulfil their obligation to you, so they'll look for other allies or sponsors. Plus, the religious aspect I mention later will have implications for the Emperor and Elector Counts.

This may well earn her College Favours, as the Emperor will owe the Colleges for saving face for him, and the Colleges will owe Mathilde. Not to mention the amazing advertisement that she's been for the potential of Imperial Wizards to the dwarves. Within a few years sufficiently sensible Imperial Magisters may well find dealing with dwarves a lot easier, which will be worth a lot, particularly to the Gold College.

There's also a religious aspect here, as helping the dwarves is an obligation according to the Cult of Sigmar. We may earn favour with them as a result, which may similarly be parlayed into College favour.

Even if it could be done I'd say we do not wnt that amount of imperial attention. Between the Book That Must Not Be Named and just being a magister of the grey College, the very shiny title of Hero of the Empire does not suit us.

On the other hand, there are many ways to be a Grey Magister. The brightest light casts the deepest shadows, after all.

I think the book is a non-factor to be honest, particularly if we set up shop at Karak Eight Peaks for the medium term.

If Mathilde is an instrumental part of the initial retaking of the peaks, I could easily see the Empire reinforcing success, jumping on the bandwagon by sending more troops. That's the point where for she might be declared a Hero of the Empire for political purposes, to make it clear that she's been operating in an official capacity.
 
Last edited:
[X] Remain here and help Ulthar make sense of the reports flowing in.
A thought about the spiders though. They're very unlikely to have torches in their tunnels, because of their webbing.
Webbing shouldn't actually be flammable; that's a DnD thing for the web spell, unless it's been transferred over. Real webs just sort of shrivel.

Edit: Well, unless you meant that the spiders wouldn't be lighting any torches, because they are spiders?
 
Last edited:
I think the book is a non-factor to be honest, particularly if we set up shop at Karak Eight Peaks for the medium term.
I've only started reading this quest recently, but I was surprised at how previous voters have done nothing with the book or the Quaysh juice. There's an awful lot of potential in both. Were we waiting for something?
 
[X] Continue downwards to the Grand Avenue.
[X] Go to the Mushroom Caves...
-[X] And join the attack.
 
I've only started reading this quest recently, but I was surprised at how previous voters have done nothing with the book or the Quaysh juice. There's an awful lot of potential in both. Were we waiting for something?
It's sort of like how a few of us wanted to go see Kragg do magic things, but everybody else wanted to keep annihilating goblins and stuff. It's acknowledged that there are all these cool magic things we can learn about, but they keep getting sidelined in favor of getting more tangible things done.
 
It's sort of like how a few of us wanted to go see Kragg do magic things, but everybody else wanted to keep annihilating goblins and stuff. It's acknowledged that there are all these cool magic things we can learn about, but they keep getting sidelined in favor of getting more tangible things done.

I mean.
It's never wrong to murder some more gobbos lol.
 
[X] Remain here and help Ulthar make sense of the reports flowing in.

Mathilde makes for good reserves. And while she could be of use either terrifying goblins into fleeing, or going Substance of Shadow and blendering spiders in the dark, this gives the most flexibility.

Mathilde: "I used to worry about those stories where plucky maidens go into dark tunnels and encounter monsters. Now they worry about me."
 
Back
Top