Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Oh yeah. I thought we'd have to half-sword for that, but I don't think it was ever specified that the activating force had to be focused on an edge, so the sword suddenly trying to force a two or three inch surface through our target's body probably would be the result. If we hadn't sprung for Gromril that'd snap it like a twig, wouldn't it?
Probably not. If the rune actually cared about physics, Mathilde's arm would shatter every time she hit something with it, so it probably negates that somehow.
 
Do we have any reason to believe this trait will come into play with available research options? I confess between months of forgetting the details of what happened and generally not touching multi-wind stuff, as well as "as long as other Wizards provide the other Winds" I've been worried that we made a poor choice back then.
It lets us work collaboratively with other wizards and make more complicated stuff, like towers that use multiple Winds. The issue is that winds in proximity interfere with one another and can cause Dhar. Windherder lets us avoid that; we still can't use it to make winds interact without causing Dhar, but we can at least make something that uses one wind to do one thing and another wind to do another thing.

This does not seem likely to benefit our research directly, as I argued back when we were voting on traits. It only seems likely to benefit applications.
Well, we do know that it will allow use of non-Ulgu effects on Ulgu-enchanted things, which could be useful. Uncertain but unlikely it would allow storing other-wind spells in an Ulgu Matrix, as useful as that would be.
(The already approved idea was using Ghur Master's Voice on an animal with a Ulgu Matrix+contained spell... useful spells would be Mathilde's mastery-enhanced Dread Shadows or Universal Confusion.)

Mathildes aren't known for their fine craftsthildeship. They are known for inexplicably annihilating enemy postions, doing crazy and concerning but effective stuff, and overdoing things. Good to have around, so long as around doesn't might right around.
The bolded seems to have got mangled. I have no idea what words should be there.
 
Impressing is worth it because we're not going to reach the bottom of what the elves can offer anytime soon.

It's one thing to have an invitation but personal tutoring from an Archmage or access to archives would be on another level entirely. Awe enough elves and maybe Teclis will feel nostalgic and give a couple tips in passing.

Point is the elves are the people for magic training unless we somehow manage to befriend a Slann.
Which still means that, if your hypothesis is correct, we have absolutely no need to train up to earn a permanent invitation, which was my point.
 
Irolinft said:
farian said:
and her tower, a superweapon capable of turning hundreds of thousands of orcs into ash in a split second.
...I'm shocked that nobody has commented on this. I didn't see anything like that in her blurb. Nor on the wiki for Karak Eight Peaks. Nor in any googling. Like, even beyond the simple fact that our boss apparently has a totally unexplained superweapon that nobody has any details on[1], what does this mean for the Vow of Poverty? Is... is it hers personally? Does it count as a necessary tool? Did she discover it somehow, or did she build it herself? If she built it herself, how in the world did she pay for it? Does living in a superweapon count as "lavish"? The boxes she's ticking have my playlist going Emperor Palpatine, not Ethan Hunt. "Oh, I'm afraid my kitchen will be quite operational when your lunchtime arrives..." I just can't even.

Footnotes:
  1. We didn't get anything about it in her character blurb or in the narrative, and I have to assume that if we'd learned absolutely anything about it it'd have shown up in the narration. You don't just ignore a literal explicit superweapon!
...I'm shocked that nobody commented on that. :p
 
Last edited:
Especially since several Grey Magister+ wizards were involved in the creation of said superweapon, so not knowing about it implies that in that Negaverse, someone is playing silly buggers with his assignment.
The fact that he's being asked to investigate Mathilde about how she holds to the vow of poverty, when IC we've been told what we're doing is AOK by the bursar herself, definitely makes the whole thing more suspicious.
 
Farian said:
Irolinft said:
...I'm shocked that nobody has commented on this. I didn't see anything like that in her blurb. Nor on the wiki for Karak Eight Peaks. Nor in any googling. Like, even beyond the simple fact that our boss apparently has a totally unexplained superweapon that nobody has any details on, what does this mean for the Vow of Poverty? Is... is it hers personally? Does it count as a necessary tool? Did she discover it somehow, or did she build it herself? If she built it herself, how in the world did she pay for it? Does living in a superweapon count as "lavish"? The boxes she's ticking have my playlist going Emperor Palpatine, not Ethan Hunt. "Oh, I'm afraid my kitchen will be quite operational when your lunchtime arrives..." I just can't even.

You heard that Weber was involved in destroying a Waaaagh with seven digits worth of participants, but details were incredibly hard to come by in the Hochland College of Sorcery, with speculation among the apprentices being that it was related to counterspelling somehow and the official word from the higher-ups being that the specifics were classified. The general word on the street in Karak Eight Peaks itself is that the sun itself changed position, at which point every orc in the shadow of Karag Nar burst into flames. It sounds somewhat like Burning Shadows, although that spell shouldn't have that drastic an effect, and in fact shouldn't be able to be applied to a terrain feature like a mountain at all. You can sense some very powerful bound spells in the tower at the top of that mountain, although not any of their specifics. Predominantly Ulgu, but there's some other winds there too.

The actual specifics seem to be a state secret of Karak Eight Peaks.

:p

The way I see it, although far too many people have seen the operation of the Eye of Gazul for it to be truly secret, K8P's position of "in the ass end of nowhere" means that it's actually pretty hard for news to spread out from it - and since the actual details have a big fat CLASSIFIED stamp on them, it doesn't strain credulity for a Grey Perpetual in Hochland to not know the specifics of how Mathilde cleared a Waaaagh, but quickly surmise that the tower is a superweapon when arriving and comparing eyewitness accounts and what their own magic senses are telling them.

He's there for the money, specifically, so no need to know. From my reading, he doesn't know about the Black College either.

He definitely doesn't know about the Black College, that was slapped with a Top Secret classification straight from the Emperor's desk.
 
Last edited:
He's there for the money, specifically, so no need to know. From my reading, he doesn't know about the Black College either.
Literally ever resident of K8P knows something is up with Mathilde's tower (or at least, some big project she's involved in) that let it turn an invading Waaaagh to ash, so there's zero point in not telling him since he'll learn about it anyway. And more to the point, telling him about it keeps him from wasting any effort looking in that direction for money oddities. A competent briefing should include any important non-classified background information about the area, and the existence of the Eye (if not its exact functionality) definitely qualifies, as would things like the We.

Alakazam's little necromancy prep school, meanwhile, is a completely different matter unrelated to K8P or Mathilde's money in any way, and is a topic that could be very damaging to the colleges if news of its existence leaked. It makes sense not to brief him on that topic.
 
Last edited:
So I'm rereading the wiki section on the fall of Eight Peaks.
I think that gas mask Johann stole could be really useful to reducing Dwarf casualties across the old world, if we can get it copied, and accepted for use on the sort of scale it'd need to be.
 
So I'm rereading the wiki section on the fall of Eight Peaks.
I think that gas mask Johann stole could be really useful to reducing Dwarf casualties across the old world, if we can get it copied, and accepted for use on the sort of scale it'd need to be.
We'll need to remove/replace any warpstone components, figure out a work-around for the fact dwarves have massive beards that keep it from sealing, and then take a few centuries of testing to get it up to dwarf standards, but in theory at least you're right.
 
So I'm rereading the wiki section on the fall of Eight Peaks.
I think that gas mask Johann stole could be really useful to reducing Dwarf casualties across the old world, if we can get it copied, and accepted for use on the sort of scale it'd need to be.
as long as it actually works properly.

When it comes to Skaven safety equipment 'keep you alive until after the battle' is 'good enough'.
 
as long as it actually works properly.

When it comes to Skaven safety equipment 'keep you alive until after the battle' is 'good enough'.
That's the standard when it comes to safety equipment for other skaven. Your own gear has to be the absolute best available.
 
Hazmat suits would get around the beard issue...
Those are kind of unwieldy to move around in though, especially if you wanted armour on top, and they're absolutely horrible when it comes to heat and stamina issues. I've seen fairly fit people come out of them absolutely dripping with sweat even in relatively cool weather- I don't even want to imagine what it'd be like trying to run and fight in one.
 
Those are kind of unwieldy to move around in though, especially if you wanted armour on top, and they're absolutely horrible when it comes to heat and stamina issues. I've seen fairly fit people come out of them absolutely dripping with sweat even in relatively cool weather- I don't even want to imagine what it'd be like trying to run and fight in one.
Dwarves can probably handle that better than humans, but such suits still wouldn't be popular with anybody who wasn't actively being attacked by Clan Skyre. The real problem would be getting them to adopt it instead of sticking with whatever solution they already use, even though it is probably runecraft and therefore logistically hellish.
 
Last edited:
Those are kind of unwieldy to move around in though, especially if you wanted armour on top, and they're absolutely horrible when it comes to heat and stamina issues. I've seen fairly fit people come out of them absolutely dripping with sweat even in relatively cool weather- I don't even want to imagine what it'd be like trying to run and fight in one.
-Beard decorations worth the time of unknown.
-A mouthpiece and a nosepiece that seal tightly with a looser fit around the chin.
-Masks enchanted with hammerspace, like algard's desk. Of course we'd have to build a machine to automated the enchanting process. But this is by far the best solution :V
 
-Beard decorations worth the time of unknown.
-A mouthpiece and a nosepiece that seal tightly with a looser fit around the chin.
-Masks enchanted with hammerspace, like algard's desk. Of course we'd have to build a machine to automated the enchanting process. But this is by far the best solution :V
The mouth and nosepiece idea could work, but it'd still be uncomfortable and I'm honestly not sure if you could get it to seal properly (or at least consistently). In real life one solution for people who don't want to shave their beards is positive air pressure systems- air is pumped into a hood that fully encloses the head, coming either from an external source or through a carried filter/fan device, and that creates an air-flow out of the edges of the hood that stops anything from getting in and means you don't need a tight seal- but we'd need to completely invent that from scratch (as I doubt the skaven gear uses that principle), and I'd be wary about trusting it with something like warpstone poisons regardless.
 
Last edited:
Oh yeah. I thought we'd have to half-sword for that, but I don't think it was ever specified that the activating force had to be focused on an edge, so the sword suddenly trying to force a two or three inch surface through our target's body probably would be the result. If we hadn't sprung for Gromril that'd snap it like a twig, wouldn't it?
Probably not. If the rune actually cared about physics, Mathilde's arm would shatter every time she hit something with it, so it probably negates that somehow.
Wouldn't be surprised if that "Unstoppable Force" rune applied on every atom in the weapon individually in order to keep it's coherency.
 
We'll need to remove/replace any warpstone components, figure out a work-around for the fact dwarves have massive beards that keep it from sealing, and then take a few centuries of testing to get it up to dwarf standards, but in theory at least you're right.
In WW1 they had some weird gas masks, including these leather hoods with a drawstring you'd tighten around the neck and glass eye pieces. Only problems were that the eye pieces absolutely wouldn't stay properly in front of your eyes, and if you tightened the drawstring too much you could choke(and sometimes people wouldn't tighten it enough because of comfort issues, and would get gassed anyway)
A little like this
But different

A leather hood, with a special shape allowing for a beard pouch inside the mask, and a respirator attached by hose would probably work best for Dwarves. Maybe use an elastic drawstring to make sure the seal is decent? Do dwarves use elastic or is rubber a purely Skaven thing?
 
Last edited:
AV cannot be a form of Qhaysh. Qhaysh is eight winds. AV is undifferentiated warpstuff, that can be (but isn't yet) split into eight winds. This has been said repeatedly.

Until we trapped the asp in the box, undifferentiated warpstuff had never existed in the material world. Certainly not since the existence of the polar vortex. As such, AV is necessarily unrelated to every other form of magic in existence except possibly dwarven runes and possibly Slann magic, because those are the only forms of magic still in existence that predate the forming of the polar vortex and the existence of the eight winds.
It's just the blood of a Wisdom's Asp, isn't it? Have daemons never bled in the material world before?
Yes they most certainly do, because the snotty noble in question is the Phoenix King, whose law defines where in Ulthuan humans may or may not walk. And if him being the ultimate ruler of Ulthuan is not enough obedience to the Pheonix king is the defining difference between Shadow Warriors and their Druchi kin. So no they won't be defying the law of the land 'because they are competent operators/loose canons'. That would cut against their very identity.
Just to remind everyone, Asnarnil's memoirs are super popular in Elfland, specifically because the Phoenix King forbade it.
Lets keep some perspective here: I think the King of Barak Var had something like 25 Stewardship?

And that's an old dwarven king in the Karak with the greatest specialization in trade and business.

So, add 10 points to the scale because they are elves, but don't forget to then subtract like 8 or so because they are elves.
Admittedly, Byrrnoth got his job by cutting his way out of a sea dragon's guts, not through stewardship and statescraft. But 25 is nothing to sneeze at.
 
It's just the blood of a Wisdom's Asp, isn't it? Have daemons never bled in the material world before?
I believe that normally, daemon blood and body parts banish when the daemon is slain and sent back to the Warp. Because normally daemons are slain, rather than get captured in some ridiculous contraption.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top