Does that mean if we choose Prisoner we would have turned into Giacomo Casanova?
I'm pretty sure everything would just be
more on fire.
Assuming we were still female...
Bai Meizhen
might have accepted our invitation to be housemates, but would have probably murdered/thrown us out/declared blood feud after a few days due to our inability to act respectful. Sun Liling would have almost definitely liked the cut of our jib, but probably only in small doses. Ideally, we'd pick a house of our own and defend it against all comers because I can't imagine a scenario where a roommate wouldn't eventually just get fed up and try to kill us in our sleep. (Writing Ji Rong made me realize he is the
worst possible roommate to have, he'd leave dirty dishes out all the time, randomly destroy things while cultivating, practice arts and leave scorch marks all over the place, etc.)
Han Jian is the real wildcard here, would he have associated with us? Maaaybe. Fan Yu would have definitely encouraged him to let us go. Gu Xiulan's relationship to us would be very different, Thief Ling Qi hates the spotlight, Prisoner Ling Qi doesn't give af. I would say it could go either way: we might reinforce our worst aspects, or butt heads over everything.
In the end, I'd say that Han Jian relationship would have probably been over before it began solely because our own pride would make us look down on an indecisive pansy like Han Jian and since he already doesn't really like Fan Yu, having Poor Criminal Fan Yu around would have just made him roll his eyes and avoid us altogether.
Li Suyin... probably would have been accepted, but we would have magnified her insecurities as well as been quite rude about her beliefs in the essential decency of cultivators. Likely as not we would have gotten along with Su Ling though who shares a lot of our essential traits (hostility towards most cultivators, blunt speech and mannerisms, ostracism).
So, in the end...
1) No roommate
2) I think we would have tried to join Sun Liling's team for Zhou's test. Sun would have become our substitute-Bai. The competition would have been
cruuuushed.
3) Li Suyin would have still tried to get us to help her practice cultivation, but it's Su Ling we would have become adequate friends with.
4) Huang Da would have become relevant earlier on. Probably would have had to deal with him right after Zhou's test and we got some sort of reward.
5) We are likely better at maximizing the effects of drugs than Ji Rong is. I can see us having managed to get Silver/Yellow before the truce ended. If you remove the numbers, then taking drugs is a lot of 'well, this one makes me slightly better at cultivating wind arts, yeah, idk, let me take a few of these pills and a few of those pills.'
6) The number of people we'd have pissed off just trying to make friends would have been
legion. Which is probably why we would have given up before we even started.
7) Sun Liling is hoping we catch up real quick because she wants to have a match with us. Like, this isn't the Bai and Ling Qi relationship of peers that are nicely encouraging each other, this would be closer to Hisoka from HxH hoping Gon is gonna git gud soon because it'll be an awesome fight.
tl;dr everyone wants to kick our ass