Voting is open
I wonder if Hod died. If he didn't, then we might need to expect trouble soon. He already had some beef with us upon hearing our surname (Steinarsdottir), so perhaps Steinar messed with his parents in the past or something. Either way, I imagine almost killing him wouldn't help very much.
 
Dunno, we should Change plan and talk about it with dad. Asap. Like my new plan Val Halla suggest.

Why would dad know?

All of this falls under 'weird magic crap', I think, rather than the normal way warriors use orthstirr (we spontaneously manifested seidr mid-combat...that's not normal). The witch we're trying to talk to might know (if we can find her), but I'm skeptical anyone else will have anything more substantive than the vague guesses the thread has already made.
 
Last edited:
Well. That was a thing.
Point in favor of that being fylgja-related, it seems to have broken a tendon independently from us. Seems like the sort of thing our spirit companion could do if boosted enough to affect the material directly.
12?! Did gaining Orthstirr in the middle of the fight give us a full refill? Or did whatever did that have its own reserves? (Probably best not to count on that happening again.)
 
Why would dad know?

All of this falls under 'weird magic crap', I think, rather than the normal way warriors use orthstirr (we spontaneously manifested seidr mid-combat...that's not normal). The witch we're trying to talk to might know (if we can find her), but I'm skeptical anyone else will have anything more substantive than the vague guesses the thread has already made.
He is someone experienced who we know to be on our side. And who we can reach reliably.

And there could be lots of information we don't know (ic and ooc) which is obvious to an adult like Steinar.
Like 'Frami, Virthing, and Saemd' were before Winter 1 Turn 3.
 
12?! Did gaining Orthstirr in the middle of the fight give us a full refill? Or did whatever did that have its own reserves? (Probably best not to count on that happening again.)

Probably the latter. And yeah, we shouldn't count on...whatever that was.

He is someone experienced who we know to be on our side. And who we can reach reliably.

Well, he's not gonna burn us as a witch or anything, but asking him about something he has literally no idea about doesn't seem very useful either.

And there could be lots of information we don't know (ic and ooc) which is obvious to an adult like Steinar.
Like 'Frami, Virthing, and Saemd' were before Winter 1 Turn 3.

Sure, but seidr isn't one of those things, and we know that's involved. Mom is more likely to know about that than dad is, since it's 'women's magic'.
 
Probably the latter. And yeah, we shouldn't count on...whatever that was.



Well, he's not gonna burn us as a witch or anything, but asking him about something he has literally no idea about doesn't seem very useful either.



Sure, but seidr isn't one of those things, and we know that's involved. Mom is more likely to know about that than dad is, since it's 'women's magic'.
Yeah, Mom may know about seidr.
But, her relationship to us is friction that we should be more womanly. Asking her about "that thing where something took control of us and helped us dismember someone" may cause ... issues.
Mother: (4/10) You and your Mother... You don't get along. She wants you inside, learning how to weave cloth and make food while you want to go outside and play with your friends.
Father on the other hand is MUCH more likely to react helpfully and give us all the context a general adult would know about it.

Sure the Seidr would (probably) be out of his expertise, but that could be just a little side thing our possessor did, merely a hint at who could have been it.

Or it could be something we look into after we got the general information.
Father: (10/10) He loves you more than life itself. He would rather die than see harm come to you. However, he's starting to come to terms with the fact that he won't always be there to protect you.
 
Yeah, Mom may know about seidr.
But, her relationship to us is friction that we should be more womanly. Asking her about "that thing where something took control of us and helped us dismember someone" may cause ... issues.

We should work to improve said relationship. Asking her about seidr seems well within the scope of that, given it's considered a 'womanly art'. We don't have to give her the full context and honestly, doing so doesn't seem super useful. My point was not to ask her about the possession, just noting that even she would likely have more info than dad did on the subject.

Father on the other hand is MUCH more likely to react helpfully and give us all the context a general adult would know about it.

Sure the Seidr would (probably) be out of his expertise, but that could be just a little side thing our possessor did, merely a hint at who could have been it.

Or it could be something we look into after we got the general information.

I'm pretty sure his speculations will be basically identical to those of the thread, maybe with a few more technical details on possession. Or at least not much better informed or more likely to be correct. Making this action largely wasted. Actions are valuable and we're better served asking someone about the possession when we have someone more knowledgeable to ask.
 
Last edited:
[X] Use 'Plan Say Hi To Mom'

Seems still good for me.

Learning how to use seidr sounds good, though I'm not sure mom can teach it..... But we are probably gonna be grounded after this anyways.

Our friends did protect us, so they are safe, and Abjorn was saved by Halla as well, so that might mitigate some of the tongue lashing we are gonna get.

I'm sure that mending palm gonna be handy. Maybe we can learn from the village doctor if we have one?

Also, this
(Hamingja (???): 4, 5, 6) Five Successes
Hamingja is luck, right?
Did we spent, gained or neither?

Whatever happened, this will be the talk of the village for some time for sure.
 
I wonder if Hod died. If he didn't, then we might need to expect trouble soon. He already had some beef with us upon hearing our surname (Steinarsdottir), so perhaps Steinar messed with his parents in the past or something. Either way, I imagine almost killing him wouldn't help very much.
No, it is precisely if Hod died that we should expect some very bad trouble. Osborn's family is currently only about one ally away from being able to start a minor war.

There have been some light scuffles between the Burissons and the Stein-Vid-Ker alliance in the past. They've never tried anything overt, though, not with most of the other families in the valley not particularly liking them.

Osborn and the rest of the Burissons had a poor reputation. Nobody could prove that they were the ones stealing wool and milk, but everyone in the valley knew it was them.

However, none of the allied families are especially large, only just about equaling the Burissons in number. If the new family in the valley weren't aware of the Burissons' bad habits, or worse, benefited from them, then they might be inclined to allying with the Burissons.

Which would tip the scales in their favor.

Which might mean war.
If we killed one of the new family's children -even if it was legal-, they're probably going to throw in their lot with the Burissons. Which means that our peaceful times might be coming to an end.

Besides, even if Hod died, his brother definitely didn't and would presumeably have the same beef regarding Steinar did.
 
[X] Use 'Plan Say Hi To Mom'

I won't say we've started a war, but it's definitely raiding season unless someone from town comes up into the valley and realizes weregeld may need paying.
 
No, it is precisely if Hod died that we should expect some very bad trouble. Osborn's family is currently only about one ally away from being able to start a minor war.

I know? But there were planning to go through with war, anyway. It's just that Hod (and presumably his family) has a particularly vendetta against our family, rather than just wanting to take over the whole area.

Edit: Oh, I see what you mean. Well, I don't think Hod's family would've joined us anyway, since they have a problem with Steinar.

Whatever happened, this will be the talk of the village for some time for sure.

Depends on if any of us actually go around telling people what happened.

Asking her about seidr seems well within the scope of that, given it's considered a 'womanly art'.

Seidr is seen as a 'womanly art' yes, but I don't think your dime-a-dozen peasant woman/farmer's wife would actually know any more than the men when it comes to seidr, and if our mother actually knew any, she'd most likely be called a witch. I don't get the impression that people casually practice seidr, either. Like, if someone knows seidr you'd expect them to commit to being a Witch, rather than just learning some and then becoming a farmer's wife.
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure his speculations will be basically identical to those of the thread, maybe with a few more technical details on possession. Or at least not much better informed or more likely to be correct. Making this action largely wasted. Actions are valuable and we're better served asking someone about the possession when we have someone more knowledgeable to ask.
I feel like that is ignoring a great deal of difference in understanding the setting between Halla (and us ooc) on one hand and her father on the other.
Like, the basic stirring we only learned last turn.

What happened to us could be something well understood by the warriors of the age and we would never have heard of it anyway as we weren't considered to be growing up as a warrior until the thief incident.

We should work to improve said relationship.
Sure.
Asking her about seidr seems well within the scope of that, given it's considered a 'womanly art'. We don't have to give her the full context and honestly, doing so doesn't seem super useful.
If mom knows about seidr beyond 'common knowledge'.
If mom doesn't go 'learn womanly basics before asking questions about advanced things like that'.

My point was not to ask her about the possession, just noting that even she would likely have more info than dad did on the subject.
Possible, but I'd strongly doubt it.
 
@Imperial Fister
How much will Halla tell her dad if we don't explicitly choose to spend time with him?

Halla wouldn't try to keep the killing a secret, right?
(*vaguely gestures at the concept of murder and nid*)
And Halla wouldn't leave her dad to find out about it from the pissed parents of the slain, right?
 
Seidr is seen as a 'womanly art' yes, but I don't think your dime-a-dozen peasant woman/farmer's wife would actually know any more than the men when it comes to seidr, and if our mother actually knew any, she'd most likely be called a witch. I don't gey the impression that people casually practice seidr, either. Like, if someone knows seidr you'd expect them to commit to being a Witch, rather than just learning some and then becoming a farmer's wife.

Oh, I'm not necessarily saying she knows anything about it (I honestly think it's highly unlikely she knows more than the very basics...I'm not clear on how common the basics are, so she might or might not know those), I'm saying it probably doesn't hurt to ask and she's probably the most likely person we currently know to have some idea about it.

Though I will also say...how would we know what Halla's mother's reputation is? We don't ask around about it and I don't think it's come up once in text. She could have a reputation as a witch and neither we nor Halla might be aware. I'm not saying that's the case (it's probably not), but it could be in theory.

But the primary reason to spend time with mom is just to improve the relationship with her. Any other benefits are incidental and secondary.

I feel like that is ignoring a great deal of difference in understanding the setting between Halla (and us ooc) on one hand and her father on the other.
Like, the basic stirring we only learned last turn.

What happened to us could be something well understood by the warriors of the age and we would never have heard of it anyway as we weren't considered to be growing up as a warrior until the thief incident.

This is technically possible, but I consider it so unlikely it's not worth wasting an action on. Like, if it's that common, we probably get talked to about it during training (which we are still doing with dad no matter what), and if it isn't he probably doesn't know.

Sure.

If mom knows about seidr beyond 'common knowledge'.
If mom doesn't go 'learn womanly basics before asking questions about advanced things like that'.

Sure. The point of hanging out with her is to improve our relationship. Given recent experiences asking about seidr doesn't hurt, but she may well know nothing, which would be fine.

Possible, but I'd strongly doubt it.

My assumption, and what the vote is based on, is that neither of them really know anything about the possession...my comment on mom being more likely to know than dad was not intended to say she's likely to know anything, it was intended to point out how unlikely dad knowing anything was. Like, it was intended to emphasize the profound unlikelihood of him knowing things, not argue that she was actually likely to know them.
 
how would we know what Halla's mother's reputation is?

I imagine it would've been brought up as an offhand comment in an update - Halla does actually interact with the people in their village, as evidenced by her grumbling about how many people find her 'unwomanly' and don't like her as a result. We just don't see those interactions.

That, or it'd be on our character sheet, since it does explicitly mention that Steinar is a farmer and I imagine that our mother being a witch would be noteworthy enough to put on our character sheet.
 
Last edited:
I imagine it would've been brought up as an offhand comment in an update - Halla does actually interact with the people in their village, as evidenced by her grumbling about how many people find her 'unwomanly' and don't like her as a result. We just don't see those interactions.

That, or it'd be on our character sheet, since it does explicitly mention that Steinar is a farmer and I imagine that our mother being a witch would be noteworthy enough to put on our character sheet.

I mean, we know Steinar is a farmer because we see him farm and help him on the farm (though, actually, him being a farmer isn't on the character sheet). Most people don't talk to kids about their parents all that much (they're more likely to ask, since they assume the kid knows) and us missing a minor part of one of our parents' reputation seems plausible to me. I don't think she really is a witch, mind you, but her having some sort of thing going on that we just aren't aware of seems pretty plausible.
 
Last edited:
and us missing a minor part of one of our parents' reputation seems plausible to me. I don't think she really is a witch, mind you, but her having some sort of thing going on that we just aren't aware of seems pretty plausible.

Sure, I agree with you there. She could have some small secret that she's hiding from us. It's just that I see being a witch as a pretty big deal, and I don't see any reason why our mother wouldn't tell us about it if she really was one.

This isn't directed at you, by the way - I'm aware you don't really think she's a witch. More like I'm explaining why I think we'd know if our mother was a witch or not.
 
Voting is open
Back
Top