- Location
- Actually pretty lost
What metagaming? Replace "Mathilde's trait" with "Mathilde being very very good at this."
Warhammer Fantasy: Divided Loyalties - an Advisor's Quest
- Thread starter Boney
- Start date
- Fantasy Users' Choice!
Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Considering they are throwing at least 100k at Eshin, and have at most 10 times less in the Under-Caldera, Mors might be fully moving there.
BungieONI
Seven gremlins in a trench coat
- Location
- Lickwidget
- Pronouns
- She/Her
We don't really have the forces. We have enough to hold the Citadel and the Cordon in Under Karagril and use the rest to attack the Under Caldera but we don't have commanders that are as capable as Kazador and Mathilde and can really only sustain two attacks with good commanders. If we want to take Mohnar, we could do it after attacking the Caldera if our forces are okay.
- Location
- Russia
If that is the case then it has to be recent development, since Mors likely captured Moulder breeders during Karagril assault.
There is no connection that we know of. That doesn't mean that there cannot be one, since no one paid much attention to the Sentinels after confirming that they are empty.
This is pretty much exactly what I'm thinking.
- Location
- Brazil
This presumes that Mors are not going to dig in and reinforce their position, instead of going for full Eshin extermination.
Which is possible, if the guess about Mors breeders being all dead checks out, but counting on that is... IDK.
I think everyone is getting paranoid about the Sentinels for literally no reason.
- Location
- Southampton, Great Britain
- Pronouns
- He/Him
No, you are just taking the logic to a stupid extreme to strawman an argument that you are opposed to it. It is far more plausible that an unidentified faction of unknown capabilities that is apparently doesn't attack the trolls moved into the empty Sentinels via Kvinn-Wyr then it is that they broke into Karag Nar and made it all the way into Mathilde's tower undetected.
- Location
- Mexico
Whatever else we do this turn, it's time to check Mhonar.
Regarding attacking, I say we let Kazador lead the attack on the Caldera, with full ranger support, while we go back to Mors/Eshin and decapitate Mors, or ... Deshoulderate? Kill the captains, leave Sleek be unless he is wounded or something.
Regarding attacking, I say we let Kazador lead the attack on the Caldera, with full ranger support, while we go back to Mors/Eshin and decapitate Mors, or ... Deshoulderate? Kill the captains, leave Sleek be unless he is wounded or something.
On the defensive it could dominate the main Underway route from any of the Karags, but the area is riddled with other tunnels that could bypass them.
- Location
- being near locations is my passion.
If I were desperate (and Mors have a +10 desperation roll in eirler battles against Eshin), I'd keep my elite troops in reserve to try and protect my strategic assets against the assassin's.
I suggest we fortify the under-karagri and under citidale, let the Mors reposition to attack us, and hopefully the Eshin will expend assets to try and destroy the Mors for us.
Because frankly, I find Eshin scarier than Mors, and,.now this might be a bit mad of me, am hopeful that we can get the orcs of Rhyn to attack Yar.
With regard to the trolls.... I dunno. Stick some more artillery there if we have any, incase whatever scary thing in Mhonar decides to return.
- Location
- The Middle of the Howling Wilderness
Literally the only piece of evidence that whatever is in Mhonar could have moved to the Sentinels is the idea that the secret passageways the Dwarves used in canon are being used by someone else now. Mathilde has never heard of secret Dwarven passageways, so basing our conclusion that the Mhonar gribblies are using them to move around is pretty clearly drawing on out-of-universe knowledge -- metagaming.
TaliesinSkye
Occasional Editor
- Location
- Northeast Ohio, United States
My understanding is that they're already engaged with Eshin; there's a massive battle going on.
They had slaverats when Mathilde was scouting the Under-Caldera and stole the gromril.
Hazardine
Asura of Darkness
- Location
- Somewhere in Florida
So just notice we apparently have a skill in *Googles* Library Sciences!?
Was this in the pre-war update or recently?
Chimeraguard
We do deserve to exist.
I think we got it after stealing from Eshin.
- Location
- Mobile, Alabama
If we do take the Under-Caldera, we will have 5 realistic fronts in the underway; Drazh, Rhyn, Yar, and two for Mhonar.
I'd say 7 fronts but -
*Earth trembles*
Zilfin is basically handled to the point of only needing a few grapeshot cannons covering the approaches.
I'd say 7 fronts but -
*Earth trembles*
Zilfin is basically handled to the point of only needing a few grapeshot cannons covering the approaches.
- Location
- Spain
That is what Scouting is for...
If we take the Under Caldera and prevent the messengers to reach Mors in Zilfin we have the chance of basically crushing the survivors of Zilfin under a Boot of Steel.
Last edited:
They are about to take under-Yar; were predicted to in 1-2 hours... 1 hour ago. But Eshin also has upper Yar. From that point onward they and Eshin are going to have a choice of stopping the fight at this natural breakpoint between upper and lower bits of the mountain or continue going for each other's throats.
- Location
- Brazil
What do you guys think about leaving only Thorek to guard above-ground Karagril, move the Miners (which have 20 tripod-mounted crossbows as fire support) to guard Under-Karagril, and move Huzkul + Azul + Mercs on the assault?
The Trench is massive, and Mors will be fighting tooth and nail there. We can't afford to leave 10k warriors behind, and I want the mercs to soften the dwarf casualties.
We really want a truly crushing force to swiftly take the Caldera, so like we did here, we can get on with the looting and, in that case, sabotage.
The Trench is massive, and Mors will be fighting tooth and nail there. We can't afford to leave 10k warriors behind, and I want the mercs to soften the dwarf casualties.
We really want a truly crushing force to swiftly take the Caldera, so like we did here, we can get on with the looting and, in that case, sabotage.
We were told it was quite possible the invading skaven brought no breeders.
The massive battle is still in Under-Yar, once they boot Eshin out of that location they have the choice between pushing to Upper-Yar or being satisfied with their gains.
Last edited:
The thing in Karak Mhonar did not attack the Rangers, so I am not particularly worried about it potentially moving into the Sentinels.
I would go with Abhorsen's Plan
I would go with Abhorsen's Plan
- Location
- Spain
We predicted 2-3 hours one hour ago...