Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
I believe the Articles require the College to provide such assistance as requested against magical/supernatural threats, within reason. So yes in theory an Elector could probably send a message to the Greys asking for a briefing, and the Grey would be obliged to send them an info packet at the least.

This sounds like something every elector count worth their salt should be doing every year.

Elector Count Hochten Von Hecktenstein IV: "Do the Greys think any gribblies are out eat my subjects, my money, or myself this year? Nein? Sehr Gut.

Friedrich, take half the money we were going to throw at the random beastmen incursions, Chaotic cult uprisings, Rat beastmen suppression, proscribed cult crackdowns, separatist movements, and civil war outbreaks.... and use it to fuck over Marienburg, somehow. I'm going to take a long nap."
 
See that is the problem with me. Rarely does someone stop skimming. I have seen these is real life. Greed always take hold and the person or persons keep skimming.

Hypothetically the relative of a person I worked with who was in a higher position than me used their expenses account to hire a company they owned. Now the company did something trivial but they used the company they technically owned to hire a third party who did it for less than what was payed. Now it did not get noticed till we did a internal audit and realized we where paying 5 times as much for a service and it cost the company so much that they did not hire some new employees because of cost. The fallout was immense and the owner fired a executive and pushed charges on the offender, hypothetically.

Now the thing is the EIC exist not to get rich but to supply the forces of order and be Mathilde spy network. If someone skims that means they are more likely to hide stuff or sell out the EIC. So every person stealing is potential someone who will turn coat or cost the forces of order something.
I agree with the general sentiment that those who steal small amount will also steal large amounts, and it's certainly something to usually be wary about, but it's a relative low priority given that we decided quite some time ago to focus on the bigger possible problems.

I'm sure there's a handful of individuals that are willing to embezzle some money - there's always one - but they'd have to be individuals who are willing to do so under the eye of the former Steward and Spymaster of an entire province (who built up this company on the bones of the Stirlandian League, which they decimated), both of which have only become scarier with time.

I think it's really funny, following in this pattern, that Mathilde's first act immediately after being promoted to Lady Magister was saving a bunch of dwarves from certain death by risking her own and followed that up by an expedition to Hell's Backyard, which had a lot of stress of its own.

A less-informed individual might think she actually has some sort of complex where she has to do her best at all times or DIE TRYING.
 
I'm just curious how much the Greys actually share around intel to people it might be relevant to.

Greys probably like sharing info - just not all the info.

It makes their job easier, it makes them trusted and it allows the Grey College to subtly shape the policy of a given Elector Count whilst staying within their legal lane.

Now the thing is the EIC exist not to get rich but to supply the forces of order and be Mathilde spy network. If someone skims that means they are more likely to hide stuff or sell out the EIC. So every person stealing is potential someone who will turn coat or cost the forces of order something.

The EIC absolutely exists to get rich - it is a trading company. It funds Mathilde's endeavours and also doubles as a spy network but that's also enabled by the EIC's primary get rich function because it just wouldn't be capable of supporting Mathilde's research or pay her spies.
 
I agree with the general sentiment that those who steal small amount will also steal large amounts, and it's certainly something to usually be wary about, but it's a relative low priority given that we decided quite some time ago to focus on the bigger possible problems.

I'm sure there's a handful of individuals that are willing to embezzle some money - there's always one - but they'd have to be individuals who are willing to do so under the eye of the former Steward and Spymaster of an entire province (who built up this company on the bones of the Stirlandian League, which they decimated), both of which have only become scarier with time.
I think it has more to do with the fact that Mathilde was barely getting paid a wage despite being Spymistress of Stirland. And despite being Spymistress of Stirland immediately from the start of her Journeying in a province where the single greatest recurring threat to the Empire within its borders reigns, she was still expected to repay her student debt in a timely manner.

She wasn't embezzling to get rich, she was embezzling a small amount (for her position) to avoid getting debt collectors hunting her down while she was scrambling to try and prevent Stirland (and herself) from falling apart/prey to necromancers.

When the spymistress for an entire province (especially a province with a historical "subversion by vampires" problem) enjoys such accomodations as "a small, musty room with a shitty bed" and assets as "literally fucking nothing, not even the documents, records, and feudal contract we kind of need to keep the province running", with such immediate tasks as "find those stolen documents before everyone finds out that we're up shit creek without a paddle", "figure out what the fuck your predecessor did, what they left behind, and what his name even was", "start building the utter basics of an intelligence network from thin air on a shoestring budget", and "oh yeah, there's a massive crime syndicate gutting our economy and not paying any taxes", 35 gold crowns per six months is a fucking pittance.

Mathilde basically got thrown into the equivalent of a job where, on a provincial level, she had to build up a state military from literally fucking nothing on a shoestring budget ASAP, and that would just be her second priority because someone stole the Runefang and no one had a clue where it was or who had taken it, and it really needed to be found before anyone noticed that the Elector Count didn't have the symbol of his office. Oh, and go and find some random, shitty room with a crappy bed to sleep in.

That's the kind of job you shouldn't feel comfortable saddling a mere Magister with, given how high the stakes would be, let alone a brand-spanking-new Journeywoman whose only armament is a single knife.

I think it's really funny, following in this pattern, that Mathilde's first act immediately after being promoted to Lady Magister was saving a bunch of dwarves from certain death by risking her own and followed that up by an expedition to Hell's Backyard, which had a lot of stress of its own.

A less-informed individual might think she actually has some sort of complex where she has to do her best at all times or DIE TRYING.
I think it's less a quirk and more of how the extreme stress, pressure, and high-stakes Journeying she got forced on her put her in a literal do-or-you-and-lots-of-other-people-die situation for years on end. She struggled and scrambled and was in so far over her head for so long that she developed a deeply skewed sense of normality and expectations.

And while De Verezzo's execution was fully justified, the sheer suddenness and shock of it all probably contributed to this. The dire situation Stirland was in throughout her entire time as Spymistress also hammered home the sense that she couldn't just do "good enough", because the buck stopped with her on such a huge scale that countless people would suffer if she didn't do great. And then the Purge of the Haunted Hills and the campaign against Drakenhoff traumatically hammered home how going way above and beyond for her job was not just important, but life and death on a way that would echo throughout history.

But wait, there's more! Remember when she called on the Colleges for help in the campaign against Drakenhoff, and got help from a Light Magister, the Amethyst Patriarch, and two Amethyst Battle Wizards? And how when the big battle came, the Light Magister miscasted so badly that he blew himself and a quarter of the city up? And how the Patriarch disappeared to do his own thing somewhere else, got killed, and then his two Battle Mages disappeared with his corpse, basically contributing literally fucking nothing, including providing desperately needed healing? And then Kasmir, despite being capable and trying his best twice, couldn't get a healing miracle to work on Abelhelm? How when she and Abelhelm charged with what should have been the entire army at her back, everyone else completely failed to follow behind them?

She couldn't rely on anyone else to get the job done. She had to take command when even Gustav had lost heart. She had to be the only dispel/counterspelling available when assaulting Castle Drakenhof because she was the only one that was left. Even Kasmir had stayed behind in Drakenhof, broken and having a crisis of faith. The dwarves were seriously worried that Mathilde was basically going to go Slayer.

It's no wonder that she approaches tasks with such an overachieving, overwhelming, over-prepared manner. Her Journeying brutally etched into her the notion--explicit and implicit--that failure is not an option, and that anything less than great success and overwhelming resources/might brought to bear for a given task is sufficient because people will fail you when you need them most.

The entire Alkharad affair shows the flipside of this: she didn't just figure out what Alkharad was doing, how he was doing it, and then run to Altdorf to bring in enough might to reliably take on whatever Alkharad could muster. She personally got so mad about a vampire necromancer making weekly assassination attempts against the daughter of Abehlem that she went Doom Slayer on his ass, murdering his entire College of Necromancy one by one and then murdering Alkharad himself, before taking the key documents and burning all the rest. She then delivered his fucking skull to Roswita, along with Alkharad's trade ledgers, then flew to Altdorf to call in the cavalry to help Roswita exterminate the remaining vampires in Sylvania with extreme prejudice.

I think the reason she handles stuff like that so much better than the stuff she did as Spymistress is because she is so much more at ease with problems that you can just hunt and kill (academic tasks she has always found really interesting, though). When Mathilde had speedrun the extermination of all enemies within Karak Eight Peaks (with another million greenskins from Karak Drazh, as an encore), Belegar had to find things for her to do because typical Grey Wizard stuff isn't really useful in a Karak and Mathilde hates typical Grey Wizard stuff anyway.
 
I almost entirely agree, though I don't think she hates typical Grey Wizard stuff so much as its been sorta normalized to her as that's what being a Grey Wizard is. She likes the mindgames, the stealth, knives in the dark (or at least doesn't disdain them), its just those are all steps in seizing control over a situation. And Mathilde when she feels she has a grasp on a problem, is usually brutally thorough and direct in solving it.
 
Voting closed, writing has begun.

Adhoc vote count started by Boney on Dec 30, 2023 at 5:34 AM, finished with 1000 posts and 64 votes.
 
Does the "[dwarf] No purchase" under the college header mean that we didn't make a purchase, or did we just not vote no there and the tally just took the dwarf vote?
 
The entire Alkharad affair shows the flipside of this

The Alkharad affair showed the 'level' difference.

A top tier Magister Mathilde with a masterwork sword made by Kragg and a divine artefact and all the knowledge of the Liber Mortis made short work of a threat that would have taken young Mathilde an epic campaign to solve.


Mathilde's independent career started at that level - she had to get really good very fast in order to survive... which had the benefit that challenges didn't really get more difficult compared to Mathilde's increased abilities.

Like, the K8P campaign was also really hard but Mathilde had not just more 'oomph' but also the aid of Kragg and Belegar alongside a number of very competent peers and subordinates (and even Ranald offered a hand when needed).

Mathilde's traditional grey wizard sensibilities finally died at the hands of Mork.

Cunning Brutality, all in a 4'11 package.

Considering that Greys have Pit of Shades and the Pendulum in their battle magic list it can be argued that Mathilde is very much in touch with traditional grey wizard sensibilities.
 
So a Floating dragon chair =/= cannon delivery device? :V
This insight remains as true on (converted) land(-ships) as it is at sea!
Six, only one more than they had two years ago, but in the center of the column is one wider and taller than the others that you presume to be the newest addition. It lacks the swivel-cannon that the others have but more than makes up for it with the dragon that is perched atop it, watching the terrain crawl past with disdain.
Urmskaladrak: Dragon perch, no swivel-cannon.
Alriksson, Magnus, Kriestov, Alexis, Volans: plenty swivel-cannon.
 
Mathilde ultimately does solve a issue in a traditional grey wizard method. The method is "here's my toolbox, here's my problems, how can I solve these problems with this toolbox". That toolbox does in fact include some damn fine grey wizard skills, but for Mathilde it also includes what is most likely the strongest great sword in existence, and the skill to wield it appropriately. We are less likely to ask for help but that's less because we don't want it and more because we rarely need it and getting more people involved in our affairs, unless they're monstrously skilled and powerful doesn't help us
 
most likely the strongest great sword in existence

Unless you play the 'if it's not from the Carroburg region of Reikland it's technically a sparkling longsword' card, Branulhune would really struggle to make the top twenty. There's the Sword of Khaine, the Fellblade, Mortis, and the Slayer of Kings duking it out for the podium, then there's the twelve Runefangs, Tyrion's Sunfang, the Sword of Teclis, Finubar's tulwar, Malekith's Destroyer, Hellebron's Deathsword, Settra's Blessed Blade of Ptra, the Green Knight's Dolorous Blade, Katarin's not around to wield it but Fearfrost is still tucked away somewhere, Mannfred von Carstein's Sword of Unholy Power...

Not to undermine your point, it is a very nice sword, but 'strongest' is a very strong word.
 
I think the better statement is that it's the best possible greatsword for Mathilde.

...Though, I was pretty sure several of the ones Boney just listed were longswords until just now. I know that on the tabletop abstraction level they're mostly all just Hand Weapons because they're cool and magic that way, but it feels weird to look at Teclis and hear "yeah he carries a greatsword".
 
I think the better statement is that it's the best possible greatsword for Mathilde.

...Though, I was pretty sure several of the ones Boney just listed were longswords until just now. I know that on the tabletop abstraction level they're mostly all just Hand Weapons because they're cool and magic that way, but it feels weird to look at Teclis and hear "yeah he carries a greatsword".
If we're going strictly by tabletop rules, Mathilde doesn't wield a Greatsword either.

Only hand-weapons can have Runes placed on them.
 
Well, here comes the knife fight vote to decide the little details this really important turn coming next.

I am really looking forward to the updates (not the knife fights)
 
I think the better statement is that it's the best possible greatsword for Mathilde.

...Though, I was pretty sure several of the ones Boney just listed were longswords until just now. I know that on the tabletop abstraction level they're mostly all just Hand Weapons because they're cool and magic that way, but it feels weird to look at Teclis and hear "yeah he carries a greatsword".

Between fantasy illustrations (and subsequent models) being rather overzealous when it comes to how big the swords should be, the way a definition based on whether something can be wielded one-handed or not gets very iffy when superhuman strength is extremely common, and how the rules of the setting say that any magic weapon counts as a hand weapon no matter its actual size, sword taxonomy in Warhammer is even more of a crapshoot than usual. Teclis' sword is usually depicted as long as he is tall, and his model had him waving it around in one hand.
 
If we're going strictly by tabletop rules, Mathilde doesn't wield a Greatsword either.

Only hand-weapons can have Runes placed on them.
Trueee. One edition did kinda have Kragg's rune let you keep the two-handed property of a weapon, but it was weak compared to the Str 10 rune.

Edit:
Teclis' sword is usually depicted as long as he is tall, and his model had him waving it around in one hand.
I guess he would at least have the excuse of using ithilmar...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top