Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting will open in 10 hours, 9 minutes
One thing to consider is that Panoramia seems to think that she knew of secrets that she couldn't not even confirm the existence of. That seems to heavily imply that Paranoth is either underplaying his hand for political reasons - he'd rather not empower the faction that has the secrets - or that they have kept secrets from him deliberately. And keep in mind that Panoramia comes frmo a very druidy part of the order, given her mother didn't want to break the mother-daughter chain from the beginning of time. She might be in a better place to know of such secrets than even the magister partiarch.
I don't think Panoramia got taught by her mother? At least I don't think it's been stated that such happened. @picklepikkl @Codex Oh thread loremasters, enlighten us please. When you've got the time.
 
Here's where I think The Gambler took effect:

Word reached Paranoth just as he happened to be close enough to journey to K8P. And the result is we met at a time where Panoramia happened to get praise and advice from her Order's leader.

Sure, I can agree with that take. However, it's not mutally exclusive, since mechanically Gambler applies up to two times, and given the bit discussed earlier about how the Gambler was applied to the Thorek recruitment action.

Edit: Made language less strong.
 
Last edited:
I don't think Panoramia got taught by her mother? At least I don't think it's been stated that such happened. @picklepikkl @Codex Oh thread loremasters, enlighten us please. When you've got the time.

It's from this update
"I had a Master - still do, I suppose - but it was always Ma that taught me. She didn't want to be the one that broke the link, mother teaching daughter since the dawn of time. I think Teclis broke that link when he revealed we'd been worshipping the Jade Wind instead of an actual deity, but I quickly learned not to get involved in that mess." She sighs, and then starts to unbutton her robes. "Anyway..."
 
Her canonical honorific title in the future is 'Jade Mother', so it's her name.
Ah GW. Making the honorific of the high priestess of the Green Mother be "A Different Shade of Green Mother" and then giving said title to a person called Daughter Greenfield.

Were any of the Warhammer RPG books ever translated into other languages?
 
Last edited:
"Hello. I am Daughter Green Field, Mother-Ruler of the Green Gemstone Order and Green Gemstone Mother of the cult of the Green Mother. No, that doesn't ever get confusing. Why should it?"



Edit: Yes I know, jade is technically not a gemstone and not even necessarily green.
 
Last edited:
[X] Yes
[X] Magister Tochter Grunfeld

The way I figure, what knowledge the old cult has will be in the form of "do this to get this result", rather than underlying theory. Ergo, having someone who best understands what remains of those traditions on a practical level will give us the best basis to study the meat of the Cult's waystones knowledge: first-hand demonstration and stick poking!

[X] Egrimm, to celebrate his imminent promotion and gauge his reaction to it.
[X] Elrisse, to get to know the most recent contributor to the Project.
[X] Cython, to talk obliquely of what it means for a God to have offspring.
[X] Belegar, to discuss who has been made Loremaster after you.
[X] Stirland, to see for yourself how the war against Sylvania is progressing.

As for social, first three are basically mandatory. The remaining two... my feelings aren't super strong or anything, but wouldn't you just love to see the poor dawi who has to fill our old shoes? After all the horse shit we pulled while basically defining what the position does I actually feel a bit sorry for anyone who has to face the expectations of our our office.

Only a bit, though.
 
Found a lonely typo.
Grand Masters of one of the demigryph orders to speak for both
It should be just one Grand Master representing both orders.

And, with shocking abruptness, one morning he answers your command before you actually give it, and you peer at him through tired eyes and see the thick strands of magical energy that flow from you into him, and then flow with redoubled potency back into you.

[The All-Important Roll To Play With Your Puppy: 99]
May I ask what the target DCs for this roll were?
 
Last edited:
Literally, I don't think there was anything in the passage itself firmly saying if he was a man or Dwarf.
Though, there are Imperial Dwarfs that pick/are given human names to fit in. Josef Bugman for the most famous example.

I feel like the main point against him being a Dwarf is that he didn't give any kind of clan name or patronym.

I think that the main point against him being a dwarf is that he pulled his tunic to show his scar, no mention of armor.

This is an important thing to keep in mind while reading Chinese classics, or else all the jade-skinned beauties are... well...
I thought it was about texture, not color?
 
[x] Yes
[x] Perpetual Apprentice Culloch
[x] Egrimm, to celebrate his imminent promotion and gauge his reaction to it.
[x] Elrisse, to get to know the most recent contributor to the Project.
[x] Belegar, to discuss who has been made Loremaster after you.
[x] Panoramia, to talk about how well her project in the Eastern Valley seems to be going.
[x] Stirland, to see for yourself how the war against Sylvania is progressing.
 
[X] Yes
[X] Magister Tochter Grunfeld

Annoyingly it looks like none of the people that Paranoth recommended to us seem to be obivous members of the druids. The battle wizard has nothing notable about their affiliations, Cryston - like PanPan - stays out of the religious mess, and Culloch is secular rather than a member of the druids. The only one with plausible connections is Grunfeld, but I suspect they are not actually a member of the druid faction. Otherwise why say an expert in rituals that descended from druidic rites, rather than an expert in druidic rites. I suspect he's picking people who know enough to be helpful, but are still members of his faction, which might mean that there are deeper secrets in the jade order that will still be hidden from us due to Paranoth's politics. I suspect his goal is to ensure that his faction is placed to claim - or at least share in - any benefits of this project, so that he can either make gains on the druid faction, or at least keep the balance from shifting towards them. Still, while Grunfeld doesn't seem like they are directly connected to the druids, he's the one most likely to be useful to the project, so I'll go with that.

[X] Egrimm, to celebrate his imminent promotion and gauge his reaction to it.
[X] Elrisse, to get to know the most recent contributor to the Project.
[X] The Gold College, to see what's become of their research into Skaven technology.
[X] Follow up on your donation of the Skaven organ-vat, and see what has been made of it.
[X] Middenland, to see how the Ulricans are going with their new Eonir coreligionists.
[X] Cython, to talk obliquely of what it means for a God to have offspring.
 
What you initially take to be her staff is instead (also?) a spear with a wicked jagged point of some sort of glinting black volcanic rock.
The Jade Journeyman has the silver sickle of their rank on their belt, and their staff still bears leaves and cherries upon it, and if they stand still for too long their staff begins to put down roots and needs to be convinced to release its grip on the earth. And, to your surprise, she's heard of you.
Two Journeywomen with their own Wizard Staff and the Grey College couldn't even provide one for a Magister.

Also, should it maybe be "her staff" in the second paragraph? Not that there's a problem with the singular they, but it says "she's heard of you" in the same paragraph.

"We truly did plan to strike into Sylvania, but the horrors of that place! Mordheim was supposed to be long dead, but it was a battleground between Beastmen and Vampires and swarmed with the dead and with chaos alike. By the time it was pacified and every last building was pulled down, Stirland's campaign was over and the Drakenhofs had fallen."
So that happened. I either missed or forgot that Mordheim isn't a thing anymore in Quest canon. Probably the latter.
She squeals, and breathlessly quizzes you about the campaign, and when Asarnil is mentioned she dashes off to her bags and comes back with a copy of his memoirs and you reluctantly sign it. You manage to squeeze a few questions in directed back at her, and she gives her name as Panoramia, apparently named after one of the most skilled potion-makers of her order. She admits her own abilities in that with some reluctance, but says that she couldn't bring her bottles due to their fragility so it's unlikely she'd be able to make more on the road; you admit that you have spells to generate heat (or, technically, to concentrate sunlight) sufficient to melt sand into glass, and she starts squealing all over again. Most of her spells seem focused around plant growth, and she's hoping to find new and exotic types of plants on the expedition, but rapid plant growth does have combat possibilities to go along with the logistical boon they represent.
Panoramia has changed a lot since then. And not just in how she sees Mathilde. Have we ever seen her this excited again? Or otherwise act like a teen ever since the Citadel had been reconquered?

You find the first of the Gold Order Wizards is named Maximilian and is nestled inside one of the dwarven carts; apparently he's bartered transportation for himself in exchange for 'fuelling' the portable forges the dwarves have brought with them. He seems barely more than a teenager, and is disdainful towards you until, after quizzing you on your abilities (which, you suppose, is only fair, since you're also quizzing him on his), he learns that you've some ability as an enchanter. After that, he treats you with respect.

"I," he says with some self-importance, "am a craftsman. Temporary transmutation is a skill known to any of my Order, and permanent transmutation is sought after by all. I have found it in creation. Permanent transmutation is achieved when that which is transmuted is used to create." He waves a hand at the marching dwarves around you. "It is said that dwarves are among the greatest of craftsman. As such, I intend to learn from them, and aiding them in retaking their Karak will be the coin with which I purchase an education." He claims as much ability with martial weapons as he has with the blacksmiths hammer, and says that he forges new weapons for himself with some regularity. You spend some time discussing swords, and your esteem grows in his eyes as you match his knowledge; when the topic moves to blackpowder weapons and you show him your revolver, he goes quiet with awe. "This," he declares, "is the artistry I wish to emulate."
Same goes for Max. Though to be fair, I don't have much of a read on his current personality. We haven't really hung out with him outside of work (except that one time during the Ranaldian gambling night) or seen him talk to third parties on screen after the expedition (interactions with Johann directly were always just mentioned in post in the chapters and when they have dialogue with Mathilde they both talk to her instead of to each other).


By the way, @Boney, which one was the one that joined the expedition before Mathilde and which one only joined after we delivered a last moment letter?


His staff is topped with the skull of a minotaur preserved in brass,
Another thing I missed the significance of back then. What does a Dwarf Runelord use a staff for and why does Kragg have the actual head of a creature of Chaos upon his?
 
Another thing I missed the significance of back then. What does a Dwarf Runelord use a staff for and why does Kragg have the actual head of a creature of Chaos upon his?
It's straight from his 4th edition entry.

The Runestaff has the Runes of Furnace, Spellbreaking, and Passage on it, making him immune to fire, able to automatically dispel one spell per battle, and be able to move through difficult terrain*. The head is from a minotaur he killed when he was just 100 years old.

(Back when the Empire hadn't hit it's first millenium yet...)


*These effects taken straight from his 4th edition entry, they might do different things now- I'm pretty sure Furnace and Spellbreaking are actually on Mathilde's belt?
 
Last edited:
The Runestaff has the Runes of Furnace, Spellbreaking, and Passage on it, making him immune to fire, able to automatically dispel one spell per battle, and be able to move through difficult terrain*. The head is from a minotaur he killed when he was just 100 years old.
I guess with rune magic the effects are stable and predictable no matter what, though a minotaur head trophy at the top still seems fanciful and impractical. But if I ever saw a Human Wizard with a staff that channels magic through the head of a Dhar-touched gribbly I would be seriously worried.
 
Last edited:
May I ask what the target DCs for this roll were?

After almost four years, I've forgotten.

Also, should it maybe be "her staff" in the second paragraph? Not that there's a problem with the singular they, but it says "she's heard of you" in the same paragraph.

Narrative flair, the change from the gender-neutral pronoun to the specific denotes the point where she becomes better known to the PoV, which is abrupt because her having heard of Mathilde makes the transition abrupt to Mathilde.

So that happened. I either missed or forgot that Mordheim isn't a thing anymore in Quest canon. Probably the latter.

An oddity of the Mordheim game is that it seems to go out of its way to avoid bringing attention to the fact that it takes place in 1999. Canonically it was picked completely clean of warpstone by 2010 to fuel Vlad von Carstein's war machine.

By the way, @Boney, which one was the one that joined the expedition before Mathilde and which one only joined after we delivered a last moment letter?

Maximillian before, Johann after.

What does a Dwarf Runelord use a staff for

Bearing Talisman-Runes.

and why does Kragg have the actual head of a creature of Chaos upon his?

You'd have to ask GW, but if there's anyone you should trust to be 100% sure that a component he's using has been completely cleaned of Chaos taint, it's Kragg.
 
My theory is that Khorne pissed Kragg off somehow and he made his staff like that (Brass encased minotaur skull) specifically to spite him.
 
Voting will open in 10 hours, 9 minutes
Back
Top