I cannot stress this enough but outside specific ideologies and situations going politics is a terrible idea. People seem to miss the fact that Imperium citizens have very different views to modern first world people. Space Marines were never meant to be political in nature as well.
See below for why, but I'm pretty sure the traits of the Chapter, the nature of the Chapter's Homeworld and the
location of the Chapter mean this Chapter is
not going to be able to avoid intense interaction with the Imperium's politics.
bigger question is what is the exact purpose of the chapter based on the emperor's desire not what we want. so politic might be a waste
They are near Sol and whilst they have an objective? They don't necessarily
need to do everything themselves. Politics training might very well be
essential because it means their presence near Sol and on one of the holiest planets which could be a Shrine World doesn't run into the issue of 'Other groups do all they can to cripple the Space Marine Chapter subtly and/or drive them off their homeworld'.
It
also has the advantage that the Chapter can then turn all those political games back onto their opponents/foes
and also take advantage of the other Imperial Institutions to boost their capabilities. Counter Espionage a bit lacking? Trade some favours with the Inquisition, Light Bringers Chapter and Synopticon so they fill in the gaps. Need to improve defences? Negotiate lessons with the Steel Champions, the Imperial Guard and the AdMech whilst also seeing what technologies and equipment the AdMech and Administratum can grant.
These guys are more or less
right in the Imperium's Political Heartland. Whilst politics
could go badly, it's also something where ignoring or discounting them potentially goes just as badly and finding success? Has the possibility to go
extremely well even before we factor in the traits which basically shout 'Chosen by the Emperor!' that the Chapter has.
For combat capabilities, I strongly favour grabbing Librarian Training. For 'do the task they are assigned as best as they can', I personally believe Politics Training might very well be nearly essential. Which just leaves a third Training option to boost whatever we want and there...
Well, I can see an argument for Techmarines (my personal initial choice) because that means they may be able to deal with the technology granted to them better, particularly when the Librarian training is factored in. If we want to secure against infiltration, then Counter-Intelligence Training would be useful but that also raises the question of 'might the opponents decide Fuck Subtlety?' if we hardened too well and we
should be getting decent support on that matter already from the rest of the Imperium (if the Chapter doesn't fuck up relations or have relations fucked up for them) and the Emperor's influence (however minimal that is, because he did order this Chapter made so as to reduce how much he personally has to focus on the matter).
Other combat training traits are... Frankly, I don't think that's what we should be aiming for with this Chapter. In a way, it goes against their role because their location means an invasion should be either
extremely hard and see them reinforced by a
lot of allied forces
or a sign that everything has gone to hell already. Which leaves Entrenchment as a 'special' sub-category of Combat Training that I've already covered why I believe it's not
critical that we have the Chapter innately trained to a superior degree in that, and the other Specialists up for debate.
I don't think this Chapter would benefit a significant degree from having Chaplain training. It just lacks some of the synergy though if we don't take Counter-Intelligence Training I can see a case made for it. Apothecaries however... Again, useful but are we sure that's what we want? Though I suppose Civilian Empathy and
maybe the Golden Dragons traits would synergise with Apothecaries...
So that leads me to supporting the following:
[ ] Librarians: The Chapter's Librarians are particularly well trained, and have far greater resistance to the temptations of the warp. They are far less likely to fall to Perils of the Warp, and offer more potent psychic support.
[ ] Politics: This Chapter has grown adept at manipulating the surrounding political landscape. A sad necessity, in the increasingly politically driven Imperium.
[ ] Techmarines/Counter-Intelligence Training/Apothecaries
And because I want to make sure,
@undead frog Just how politically involved does our Chapter's Homeworld and said Homeworld's location make things for them? Like, is this something where it's obvious that they can probably avoid political involvement or is it a case of 'Guys, read the description of the Politics Training Option and
consider where this Chapter lives' for what's going to happen?