Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting will open in 4 hours, 11 minutes
Are they still crimes if it's a LM doing them? Matthilde is considered Actual Nobility at this point and lots of things that would be crimes if other people did them are now 'eccentricities'.
I'm pretty sure there are still some things that are illegal or at least will make your life quite miserable if you get caught doing it, even for nobles. I don't think Mathilde has actually done much of that, besides keeping the Liber Mortis (and the ring notes, and other forbidden texts).
 
I'm pretty sure there are still some things that are illegal or at least will make your life quite miserable if you get caught doing it, even for nobles. I don't think Mathilde has actually done much of that, besides keeping the Liber Mortis (and the ring notes, and other forbidden texts).
There was also her early embezzlement while she was in Stirland and killing the Tzar.
 
We really ought to teach Eike Khazalid. She lives in a dwarf karak and is our apprentice.
Instead of teaching her directly it might be more efficient to have her immerse herself in Dwarven culture like she did with the Eonir and potentially pick up points in the Karaz Ankor Diplomacy skill in addition to the Khazalid language skill.
 
@Boney is Mathilde's god sense intuitive like Eike's wind sense is?

Instead of teaching her directly it might be more efficient to have her immerse herself in Dwarven culture like she did with the Eonir and potentially pick up points in the Karaz Ankor Diplomacy skill in addition to the Khazalid language skill.
Won't work. She could immerse herself in Eonir culture because she could speak Eltharin. She can't speak Khazalid, so she can't immerse herself in Dawi culture.
 
Won't work. She could immerse herself in Eonir culture because she could speak Eltharin. She can't speak Khazalid, so she can't immerse herself in Dawi culture.
A large chunk of K8P's Dwarf population also speaks Reikspiel as a second language, especially among the clanless immigrants and the formerly clanless Clan Huzkul which probably have a large Imperial Dwarf demographic within them. That might be her in to Dwarven culture without needing to speak Khazalid.
 
A large chunk of K8P's Dwarf population also speaks Reikspiel as a second language, especially among the clanless immigrants and the formerly clanless Clan Huzkul which probably have a large Imperial Dwarf demographic within them. That might be her in to Dwarven culture without needing to speak Khazalid.
If we're doing one or the other, she'd learn Khazalid faster by getting properly taught it, rather than incidentally picking it up from people who'd largely speak to her in Reikspiel. A combination would probably yield the best results, letting her pick up Khazalid faster and in doing so allowing her to familiarise herself with Dwarf culture faster.

Tying into that, I want to pick up Imperial/Dwarven navy books, which serves three purposes: firstly, Eike really likes the subject so it'd be fun for her; secondly, having dwarf books on a subject she likes will make her learn Khazalid faster; thirdly, it'd help us set up a paramilitary river navy, which we want to do now that the canal's complete. (Eike herself would be helpful with that thanks to having the River Tactics skill.)
 
Last edited:
Okay yes the latter part is true, but also irrelevant because literally nobody is talking about the imperial second fleet doing that. The imperial second fleet will only be actively acting on druchii information for druchii raids on the empire itself as a matter that is basically self-evident. These are not that common but also not nonexistent.

(If the empire is "barely a naval power" to the degree you are declaring, then even if you ARE right, any "unrecoverable" losses are basically still no big deal, because clearly the empire isn't doing anything that matters with that nonexistent naval power anyway. "Wow after fighting that druchii ship, instead of a navy that can't do anything that matters, we have a navy that can't do anything that matters.")
Then there's no point in really trading with the Druchii at all, because the whole reason the Empire is ok with it is that since they lost Marienburg, the Druchii don't really attack the Empire. Like Boney made a whole post on why the Empire would be interested in working with Naggaroth, which really does depict it as barely a naval power at all:
The thing about the Druchii is they're very very bad news if you live on a coastline or try to travel by sea, but are almost never a concern if you don't. So, here's Point One of modern Empire Naval Policy:

Fuck Marienburg.

How much coastline does the Empire have? Less than any non-Dwarven polity on the planet. Why? Because Marienburg took two thirds of the coastline when it seceded. See Point One.

How many significant towns does the Empire have on that coastline? Only one. Why? Because Marienburg sabotaged the other two towns that the Empire tried to establish on it. See Point One.

Is that one town at all vulnerable? No, because half the fleet is based there because there's only two places in the Empire that can actually maintain seagoing vessels any more because most of that infrastructure was in Marienburg. See Point One.

How much naval force projection does the Empire try to do? Not much, because the other half of the fleet is based in Altdorf and has to pay ruinous tolls to get out to sea. See Point One.

How much naval trade does the Empire try to do? See above, and then see Point One.

So, do the Druchii connect to the Empire's foreign policy in any other way? Well, they're infamously opposed to the Asur, whose involvement in the Old World involves sending three dudes to protect the Old World against the Everchosen and then sending a fuckload more dudes to help slaughter an Imperial Army in the Battle of Grootscher Marsh to support Marienburg's secession. See Point One.

Which is particularly prominent in a lot of minds currently, because the only reason Marienburg feels confident to threaten a full blockade of the Empire in response to the canals is because of the continued protection of the Asur. Which also means that in a lot of minds right now, Point One of Empire Naval Policy is echoing very loudly.

Which means that right now a concussed toddler could make major diplomatic inroads on behalf of Naggaroth if you could teach it to reliably babble those five syllables in the correct order.
 
Yeah, it's one of the thread's bugaboos that I really don't get. I've been putting it down to cultural differences, but there's definitely an underlying assumption that religion is inherently an extremely private thing never to be discussed with anyone that strikes me as more intensely alien than any of the other topics that commonly make the rounds.

Buuuut, it's very clear that this assumption is deeply and authentically held, and that elements of religious instruction in the story would make an apparently sizeable part of the voting readership uncomfortable. There's really no reason to push at that spot, then, when there's so much else to be done.

Ah yes directly and blatantly snub the assassin who just killed your father in a picture perfect kill just how you asked them to. What Could Go Wrong? :V
 
Last edited:
The Second Fleet existed to protect Marienburg and its trade routes, and in the late 2300s Leopold Unfahiger allowed the burghers of Marienburg to take over its maintenance and operations. Needless to say, the second official attention turned elsewhere (towards the Fourth Parravon War and Waaagh Gutstompa) the Second Fleet was carved up like a turkey and its ships, guns, and sailors portioned out to the Great Houses. By the time Marienburg bought its independence, the Second Fleet existed only on paper, and after that it really didn't have a reason to exist any more for all the above reasons. That it was rebuilt from scratch, and that the First Fleet has been enlarged with oceangoing vessels, is entirely a matter of revanchism: they might need it to recapture Marienburg, and they'll definitely need it after they've recaptured Marienburg and all those trade routes are going to be generating tax revenue for the Empire once more.
 
Be Gay Do Crimes
Liber Mortis
Be Gay Do Crimes
Liber Mortis
Be Gay Do Crimes
Liber Mortis
Mathilde in a Nutshell
Wizard Power
I say, this is most one-sided and narrow-minded way of looking at Mathilde.





After all there are plenty of other crimes, "crimes" technically not crimes and I-can't-believe-these-are-not-crimes she has commited. :V
 
Van Horstmann's Speculum says goodbye to our sword skills. He too has weird abilities and surprises and traits. The protagonist centric ability focus is simply wrong many times over.
I'm not sure the Speculum exists yet. We do, after all, have the vote option to try to Windherd its creation with Egrimm.

Or rather I think its existence is currently undefined, in that if we never take that option then Egrimm will have done it offscreen at some point before the scene that requires it and if we do take the option then it's a joint venture instead.
 
Would the Speculum even work on Mathilde? Firstly, it's an enchantment, and those can be dispelled and counterspelled because there's no will behind them, secondly we're protected by the spellburner rune, and thirdly wouldn't the rune of superior skill break the enchantment?
 
Would the Speculum even work on Mathilde? Firstly, it's an enchantment, and those can be dispelled and counterspelled because there's no will behind them, secondly we're protected by the spellburner rune, and thirdly wouldn't the rune of superior skill break the enchantment?
1) "Live" spells can be counterspelled too - there's no guarantee either way, but it has to have a chance of working on someone whose skills are worth stealing, so I'd guess it'd be non-trivial;
2) Very good point, anyone who tries to open with a powerful spell is in for a nasty surprise - although those (if any) who know that the spellburner rune needs 12h to recharge after use can work around it;
3) If we hit the enemy, probably yes?
 
Not sure why the Eike vote is so popular. It seems kind of out of nowhere to be honest. Was there a reason the thread wants to poke at her about gods, or is it just "we always like to do Eike social actions" and this one was available?

Poking at someone's religion is kind of a sensitive topic, even if it might be written so that Eike brings it up with Mathilde.
i like eik
 
Then there's no point in really trading with the Druchii at all, because the whole reason the Empire is ok with it is that since they lost Marienburg, the Druchii don't really attack the Empire. Like Boney made a whole post on why the Empire would be interested in working with Naggaroth, which really does depict it as barely a naval power at all:
They raid coastal villages and Empire would probably like them to stop and second fleet is strong enough to handle such lone raiders and might even profit from capturing them. Both loot and prestige is useful in their own ways.
 
Mathilde hasn't tested it, but it doesn't seem likely. One of the major properties of the liminal barrier is that souls can pass through it, this is what dreaming and dying is and how miracles work. The Winds cannot pass freely through the liminal barrier, they require a preexisting hole, and if magical energy passing through a hole was enough to keep it open then any portal to the Warp would be permanent.
So this implies that either daemons don't have a soul, or whatever they have as a soul works in very different ways, because they can't pass, and they can't keep a tear open by passing.

I'd tentatively say it's the second, based on the fact that daemon princes used to have a soul, and also probably can't keep a portal open (though that's far from certain, because you don't become a daemon prince if you're the type to take the unglorious but pragmatic option like sitting in the doorway while others do the exiting stuff).

One interesting experiment to shed some more clarity on this would be to see if spirits can keep the tear open. Apparitions probably fall under daemon behavior. Testing with the one we have bound might be interesting on a general basis, but the fact that it is bound means we can't generalize.
I say, this is most one-sided and narrow-minded way of looking at Mathilde.

After all there are plenty of other crimes, "crimes" technically not crimes and I-can't-believe-these-are-not-crimes she has commited. :V
Hell, even the Liber Mortis is not a crime, it's technically-not-a-crime-but-we'll-burn-you-on-principle.
 
So this implies that either daemons don't have a soul, or whatever they have as a soul works in very different ways, because they can't pass, and they can't keep a tear open by passing.

I'd tentatively say it's the second, based on the fact that daemon princes used to have a soul, and also probably can't keep a portal open (though that's far from certain, because you don't become a daemon prince if you're the type to take the unglorious but pragmatic option like sitting in the doorway while others do the exiting stuff).
I think Daemons might be souls or at least soullike entities, possibly in a similar way that Gods seem to be giant souls. Whenever there is an intelligent being without a soul there is a void which a Daemon can fill, which is why creating intelligences without souls is such difficult and potentially dangerous task.
"Anything that thinks and feels without a soul invites something to fill the void where a soul should be," Elrisse says.
In addition Daemonic possession works by replacing the target's soul but leaving their mind and body intact.
"Zhuf-soul. Possession is the same body, same mind, but replaces the soul. Still Zhuf-soul, still her."
So Daemons seem to be souls or soullike entities. The fact they can manifest physically in the material world is odd but given that beings like Cython and heavily marked Wizards seem to blend the borders between spirit and body not completely unprecedented. They're fragments of their Gods and if the the spiritual anatomy of Chaos Gods is anything like Ranald's which prior to his Cease and Desist letter we confirmed appeared to be a giant soul without any apparent differences from a normal soul other than its size then Daemons may just be fragments of the giant souls that are the Chaos Gods themselves.
 
It should be important to note that souls can pass through the barrier, from the material to the immaterial.
But doing it the other way around seems to require help, a pre existing hole, or other special circumstances.
Same is true of daemons.
 
Voting will open in 4 hours, 11 minutes
Back
Top