I mean her big brother who she loves a lot is leaving and she is jealous he is going without her. So is it that surprising she's being a bit mean and having some anger at that fact.
NorseQuest (A Norse Xianxia)
- Thread starter I.F. Ister
- Start date
- Original Fantasy Action
-
- Tags
- norse mythology (mythology) original xianxia cultivation western cultivation ask sirihand did your mother tell you anything? discussion pleases yggdrasil farming gloating gets people killed granary management hubris is a coward's word you will die norsemen do not die when they are killed the qm has a bad memory the qm is bad at math viking courtroom drama (legal drama) vikings
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I've added a variant plan avoiding Shatter-Wrist Trick but otherwise pretty similar to my plan post under the following name:
[ ] Plan A Good Clean Fight
I voted for both because I'm not actually that invested in one over the other.
EDIT: Voting for both apparently doesn't work so for the moment I'm voting for the original plan.
It was stated that anything short of maiming could be healed fairly readily. He'll be fine by the time he heads out. The dick move is how painful it is, and it being a bit of a cheap shot, not that he won't fully recover.
[ ] Plan A Good Clean Fight
I voted for both because I'm not actually that invested in one over the other.
EDIT: Voting for both apparently doesn't work so for the moment I'm voting for the original plan.
It was stated that anything short of maiming could be healed fairly readily. He'll be fine by the time he heads out. The dick move is how painful it is, and it being a bit of a cheap shot, not that he won't fully recover.
Last edited:
- Location
- some computer lab
[X] Plan A Good Clean Fight
- Pronouns
- He/Him
The QM has made it clear we would not need to do this. I'm cool with a clean fight, but he'll heal and be fine either way. This is just fighting slightly dirty, not actually risking crippling him or anything.
Did you vote for it in the quotex post, too?
That would cause issues with the "Newest votes only" setting where only the votes in the newest post with votes by you count.
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I did not. I tried to vote for both in the same post which normally works, but they just combined into one plan which was weird.
Eternal_0bserver
(Unverified Bookworm)
- Location
- Earth, Northern Europe
[X] Plan A Good Clean Fight
-[X] Tap frami, virthing, and saemd (+17 Orthstirr)
-[X] Assign 3 orthstirr to Defend (-3 Orthstirr)
-[X] 7 Attack
-[X] 6 Defense
-[X] Use Hone Trick on the last 6 attacks, and first two defenses (-8 Orthstirr)
-[X] Tactics
--[X] Get in close, make one attack, and then use Inertia-Arresting-Throw (-6 Orthstirr) to trap his spear when he attacks back with it
--[X] Stay close to keep his Wind hugareida less useful and go to town with our Honed axe
We do not need to go to any lengths to win this battle. Even if Halla loses, it will be a valuable experience for her. I would even say that she is more likely to learn something in this case.
-[X] Tap frami, virthing, and saemd (+17 Orthstirr)
-[X] Assign 3 orthstirr to Defend (-3 Orthstirr)
-[X] 7 Attack
-[X] 6 Defense
-[X] Use Hone Trick on the last 6 attacks, and first two defenses (-8 Orthstirr)
-[X] Tactics
--[X] Get in close, make one attack, and then use Inertia-Arresting-Throw (-6 Orthstirr) to trap his spear when he attacks back with it
--[X] Stay close to keep his Wind hugareida less useful and go to town with our Honed axe
We do not need to go to any lengths to win this battle. Even if Halla loses, it will be a valuable experience for her. I would even say that she is more likely to learn something in this case.
Last edited:
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I mean, I give at least 50/50 odds that what we learn if we lose with the Good Clean Fight (and what our dad and/or Hallr tell us is the lesson is) is that we should've used all our advantages rather than holding back. Like, it's actually bad training to fight differently than you would in a real fight. It's believable because he's, y'know, our brother, but it honestly makes it much worse training for both of them.
Like, in real life you sometimes have to hold back to avoid injury, but holding back any more than that actively makes the training worse, and that's what we're doing here: Holding back more than necessary.
There's an argument that this is just a friendly spar and so we shouldn't take it seriously, and that argument is fair enough, but it's much worse for learning how to actually fight if we're pulling our punches so I don't buy any argument involving it being better for training. Better for our relationship with Eric? Very possible. Better training? Not a chance.
Last edited:
Eternal_0bserver
(Unverified Bookworm)
- Location
- Earth, Northern Europe
Halla can practice tricks, fighting against his father. What she lacks is the experience of combating an equal enemy, which is Eric. Therefore, in my opinion, an equal struggle of strength and skill is more appropriate here. In addition, Eric is not going to fight not so much, so I do not think that victory will teach her anything at all.
Also, relationships are important and complex, especially with a brother who is away for an unknown amount of time.
- Pronouns
- He/Him
You don't gain experience 'combating an equal enemy' if you intentionally sandbag by not using your full skills. I suspect either victory or defeat will be equally instructive...but more so if she's actually trying her hardest.
As I said, I have no problem with this argument. Prioritizing the relationship over this spar as a whole is entirely reasonable. That just includes prioritizing the relationship over better training. Which is fine, it's a single spar so it's not gonna be the end-all be-all of our training no matter what, but it's sure as Hel not better combat training to avoid using a relevant tactic because it might make for hard feelings.
Which is to say, I'm fine with going Good Clean Fight (I did try to vote for both plans, remember), but its advantage is diplomatic and relationship-based, not being better training.
Sirrocco
Pedantic
...how? This is Viking Cultivator land. Maiming blows... just don't matter. They simply aren't significant enough to be a bad omen.
Still an injury as he leaves his home to start his own life in another village.
It doesn't need to be crippling for something to be a bad omen, like a black cat crossing the road or stepping on cracks.
Hell, Friday 13th is just a cultural baggage after a crusade that went wrong, iirc.
Edit: forgot the quote
Last edited:
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I'm pretty sure the injuries that determine who 'loses' are already gonna be worse than an injured wrist (they're halfway to knocking someone unconscious after all), just less specifically targeted.
I feel like the only bad omen here would be if we beat him even while we weren't trying our hardest. That might be rough.
I feel like the only bad omen here would be if we beat him even while we weren't trying our hardest. That might be rough.
I.F. Ister
Fortifying The Thread
- Pronouns
- He/They
Voting will be called in an hour-and-a-half, so if you haven't voted, do so soon!
Plan A Good Clean Fight has 9 votes
Plan Disarming Aggression has 10 votes
Plan A Good Clean Fight has 9 votes
Plan Disarming Aggression has 10 votes
Last edited:
[X] Plan Disarming Aggression
