Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting will open in 1 day, 20 hours
[X] Act normal

I agree that "run like hell" is the worst of both worlds: it goes loud but not in a way that's super defensible. But I don't see what Stand Your Ground actually accomplishes: we have no means to do anything, and I don't want to risk something bad happening to the caravan while we call all the muscle to our position.
 
I think it's possibble that the magic isn't being stored for any future event, but might be being actively used to make sure that the Vlag-Be-Gone spell sustains itself. For instance, perhaps rather than simply vanishing in one super-huge ritual, whatever happened here instead draws power from the waystone to keep Vlag vanished. And if this flow were somehow interrupted Vlag would return to existance.

And even if not, if this has been going to over 200 years by now, I doubt they're going to waste their accumulated bounty on our expedition. More likely they're saving it for something specific, or a much bigger opportunity than this. Only reason they would use it now would be if they realize we've figured things out and it becomes a use it or lose it situation.

I certainly imagine a portion is being diverted into whatever happened to Vlag, but why would you go to all this trouble just to steal a random dwarfhold?
 
I think it's possibble that the magic isn't being stored for any future event, but might be being actively used to make sure that the Vlag-Be-Gone spell sustains itself. For instance, perhaps rather than simply vanishing in one super-huge ritual, whatever happened here instead draws power from the waystone to keep Vlag vanished. And if this flow were somehow interrupted Vlag would return to existance.
That was one of my thoughts, yeah.
And even if not, if this has been going to over 200 years by now, I doubt they're going to waste their accumulated bounty on our expedition. More likely they're saving it for something specific, or a much bigger opportunity than this. Only reason they would use it now would be if they realize we've figured things out and it becomes a use it or lose it situation.
...
...
... Maybe they're using it to allow the Chaos Wastes to go as far south as to overtake Karag Dum? (My original guess was actually just going to be "Maybe it's being used to put Karag Dum in the time-slow :V" but then I thought 'Wait. What if it's the Chaos Waste itself being able to reach further down south?')

Maybe that is where the energy is going?

Maybe that is how the Chaos Wastes are able to overtake and gain territory?

By literally taking over the territory that the waystone network was on, and redirecting the energy to the North instead of to the Vortex?

This could potentially be big. Bigger than 'just' a 'Big daemon portal?' or 'Missing Karak?' If it's actually responsible for the Chaos Wastes being able to encroach further south into the world, by conquering and taking over parts of the Dwarf Waystone Network, then...

Karag Dum and Karak Vlag might not just be a huge deal for the Karaz Ankor, by restoring more power to the great Karak-runes of Valaya's protection. They might also be a huge deal for the whole world, too. The Dwarfs of Karag Dum might have been right all along, about Chaos trying something huge; not just an Everchosen invasion, but an invasion of the Chaos Wastes themselves a little bit further down south. The Everchosen failed, or at least did not succeed as much as they hoped for, but maybe they got at least some benefit out of it, in the form of 1 or maybe 2 parts of the Waystone Network being captured or subverted.

Maybe Karag Dum is still hanging on. While Karak Vlag was taken, and its waystone network energy being redirected. If so, Karag Dum falling and finally losing the Hammer of Fate and the Runemaster's Axe would be disastrous for the future of the world.

Perhaps that's even why Karag Dum held out where Karak Vlag did not. Because of having the Axe and Hammer.
 
So, remember cosnidering using our divinely granted ability to lie perfectly on the Grey College only to be told by Boney that it won't work, as they are way too fucking paranoid for it?

I guess someone didn't listen to Boney.
 
[X] Stand your ground

Twenty minutes later:
M: I found out what happened to the hold.
B: What happened? Stop making me wait.
M: Gazul put it in his pocket and accidentally took it to the underearth.
B: Bhuuu?!?!?
M: Don't worry now that he knows he did that he's bringing it back... Also, I think I made a new friend. :)
 
Hmm

Hmmmmm.


I am going to assume this beat is legitimate. In that case we have triggered a countdown to "something bad"

Playing cool cedes initiative to something that turned a mountain into a battery and hid it from the dwarves and The Mage Founder. If they are not attentive enough to realize we've seen the Portal, we can organize a much more thorough response. If they are, then we let them play Fiddly Plans with us.

Running alerts them immediately. We clear the blast zone, but they have full reaction time to set off *whatever* may be the brewing.

Stand Ground. Remain in the Blast Zone. Summon Dragon immediately, and see if they had countermeasures prepared.

Hmm. The poet in me wants to kick this off with a bang. The Pragmatism wants to see the Big Tanks kill demons.

[X] Act normal
[X] Stand your ground

I think either of these is the right play. Commiting to stealth, or the element of suprise are the strongest of our elements.
 
[] Run like hell

I dont think trying to outsmart chaos is feasible so no act normal. But refuge in audacity doesnt necessarily means to fight with less than optimal force. The mountain is there for 200 yrs, it got plenty of time to prepare, a few more moments shouldn't change much?

Edit: I will hold my vote for a while. There is to much to take in account.
 
Last edited:
Also, unless I'm missing something in the update, there's no particular reason to think that the energy being gathered here is going to be unleashed now. It's been gathering for nearly two centuries, so it being huge and concentrated isn't exactly indicative of anything. The only reason Mathilde thinks something might happen is that the convoy is a big target. But there's no particular reason to think that anything that requires an immediate response will happen now.

And even if something bad is coming, it would be better to concentrate the expedition's forces, rather than get into a fight with our forces split, when we have no way of even accessing the waystone buried under a lot of rock. Prepare for the potential fight as a unified group, so that we can present our strongest defence, rather than trying to fight with nothing but Mathilde herself, the Rangers, and maybe Asarnil depending on how fast he gets here, compared to how fast a hypothetical opponent reacts.
 
[X] Run like hell

I dont think trying to outsmart chaos is feasible so no act normal. But refuge in audacity doesnt necessarily means to fight with less than optimal force. The mountain is there for 200 yrs, it got plenty of time to prepare, a few more moments shouldn't change much?
Its a very hard choice.
I mean, if anyone could outsmart chaos by pretending nothing was amiss it'd be Ranald's favorite. It's probably the plan He would approve of.

My major concern is that it assumes that seconds aren't critical, which might or might not be the case. If seconds do matter, we need to either run (if we can't fight whatever's coming) or summon the expedition with whatever horn tone is 'extreme emergency send everyone' and fight (if we can).
 
Last edited:
[X] Act normal.

Whatever it is, maybe it goes back to sleep, or whatever for the time being, or lose interest and we can go back and warn everyone about it then.
 
guys, I really see 'Act Normal' as the instinctive action, and understand why people would lean to it.

but it does nothing, we know something is in motion, faking ignorance will not slow it down.

if we knew we hand time to get back and plan, then yes, 'act normal' is a good choice.

but going slow if we don't know if we have days or minutes is not a good idea.
 
Last edited:
And apparently it was 9 options on a grid?

It looks like so. And we got the upper-middle one.

Which, they all might be different scenarios, or just degrees of a single one. Knowing Boney, they should be 9 different ones. The three indicates that this shouldn't be so bad, while the two is a middle ground. I don't expect anything disastrous, but some trouble anyway.
 
guys, I really see 'Act Normal' as the instinctive action, and understand why people would lean to it.

but it does nothing, we know something is in motion, faking ignorance will not slow it down.

if we knew we hand time to get back and plan, then yes, its a good choice.

going slow if we don't know if we have days or minutes is not a good idea.
What makes you think the thing in motion is in motion on a scale of minutes rather than hours or days?
 
"The Dwarves summon an Elven Dragon Rider" isnt a contingency that gets planned for.

Better yet, its another unique Mathy based solution, wholly grounded in her unique set of skills.

Skills which now make her a nightmare for people like this.
 
Wonder if whatever is tapping into the Karag Vlag's Warp Energy node is feeding a massive ritual to keep the Chaos Wastes extended farther south than its normal state.

Whatever the case, I want to know more.

[x] Stand your ground
 
[X] Stand your ground

Twenty minutes later:
M: I found out what happened to the hold.
B: What happened? Stop making me wait.
M: Gazul put it in his pocket and accidentally took it to the underearth.
B: Bhuuu?!?!?
M: Don't worry now that he knows he did that he's bringing it back... Also, I think I made a new friend. :)
We kind of already are friends with Gazul though. Or at least familiar, considering he's ridden our soul once.
 
[X] Act normal

Let's face it, this wouldn't be the first time Mathilde looked nonchalant while screaming internally.
 
Voting will open in 1 day, 20 hours
Back
Top