Attempting to Fulfill the Plan MNKh Edition

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
These mediocre results depress me, and I hope there will be a way to correct the situation. Moreover we'll go through the next round with more or less the same plan as we haven't completed much. I console myself by saying that at least my omakes did help you.
 
@notgreat I think you erroneously included some negative HI modifiers in your tally. But otherwise, yeah. I feel what Terminator57 feels, it's frustrating when most of next turn will be just redoing our failures from this one. With expensive Sevastopol crammed in, and the loan mostly burnt through.
 
All I have to say is don't be too discouraged, from discussions in Discord (which still aren't definitive mind you, but still) next turn will definitely warrant some popcorn cause ooooh boy this was a year when a decade went past. Next turn will inspire a lot of feelings, so depression will be practically a side note. No spoilers though. And our malus will drastically improve and we will have plenty of projects near completion to finish so I expect next turn to be productive.
 
Last edited:
All I have to say is don't be too discouraged, from discussions in Discord (which still aren't definitive mind you, but still) next turn will definitely warrant some popcorn cause ooooh boy this was a year when a decade went past. Next turn will inspire a lot of feelings, so depression will be practically a side note. No spoilers though. And our malus will drastically improve and we will have plenty of projects near completion to finish so I expect next turn to be productive.
I mean, this ain't nearly the worst thing we've ever faced. Anybody remember the Stalin/GPW days? We barely had an economy to have a recession back then.
 
Might be it just got deleted by the site, since it might not do image hosting.
I did as expected by putting a link though. I'll try to check the resolution and repost it tomorrow.
You @Vi'Talzin who managed to post an image without crashing through your "The Iron Curtain: Europe and Adjacent Territories in 1946", if you have a method to do that, I'm taker.
 
Last edited:
Hope Mr atomizing can take down a majority of the corrupt and clown filled SupSov with him when they fire/try to jail him as a distraction for the public.
 
I did as expected by putting a link though. I'll try to check the resolution and repost it tomorrow.
You @Vi'Talzin who managed to post an image without crashing through your "The Iron Curtain: Europe and Adjacent Territories in 1946", if you have a method to do that, I'm taker.
Was a while ago, but I posted it on imgur and made it so you can view by link, then put in the link on the image displayer for SV iirc

I think SV also takes images pulled from Discord so that's another option.
 
China was always going to split, they would never sit well being No. 2. Even with Mao dead early and their far more shaky and unstable politics. What we (and by we I mean the USSR) can do is make sure it never gets as tense or over the top as it did in OTL. We don't need a Khmer Rouge vs Vietnam situation.
We don't need a Khmer Rouge, period; they're an embarrassment. Getting someone in the CMEA to sort out a bunch of lunatics like that is better than letting them fester until the country they're wrecking collapses.

Feels like we're on a cusp of a lot of action soon, this very very Cold War might soon be heating up more in Africa and the middle east.
Well, Kosygin liked to keep things quiet, and Kosygin's hitting the limits of his political influence and longevity, so... things are getting less quiet.

Just wondering, why?
Speculation as to the reasons:

Because while the Americans may get their shit together and land a man on the moon and thus one-up our sample return mission, they're very unlikely to one-up our Venus lander program. Also, because it really does represent a "reached frontier" of scientific exploration in general, even if it can be dismissed as insignificant.

Hypothesis:

The spirit of Russian winter hates and resents all competition from air conditioners and conspires to ruin us whenever we touch the subject.
 
Did a little searching in order to find out how well the factions have done for themselves in these last few turns, and came up with this:

Podgorny's Faction: Around 80, Good, None (96,94,98=288/300)
Kosygin's Faction: Around 450, Acceptable, Acceptable (36,83,20=139/300)
Masherov's Faction: Around 340, Good, Poor (60,83,80=223/300)
Abramov's Faction: Around 380, Good, Excellent (48,30,18=96/300)
Voznesensky's Faction: Around 150, Decent, None (8,51,46=105/300)
Ashimov's Faction: Around 80, Poor, None (17,70,58=158)
Kleshchev's Faction: Around 70, Excellent, Poor (7,79,88=174)

Do note the numbers above are outdated, and are of the Supreme Soviet as seen by Abramov directly after the elections. Below, I ordered them from best to worst performers.

Podgorny's Faction: Around 80, Good, None (96,94,98=288/300)
Masherov's Faction: Around 340, Good, Poor (60,83,80=223/300)
Kleshchev's Faction: Around 70, Excellent, Poor (7,79,88=174)
Ashimov's Faction: Around 80, Poor, None (17,70,58=158)
Kosygin's Faction: Around 450, Acceptable, Acceptable (36,83,20=139/300)
Voznesensky's Faction: Around 150, Decent, None (8,51,46=105/300)
Abramov's Faction: Around 380, Good, Excellent (48,30,18=96/300)

As you can see, Podgorny suddenly became a political mastermind, and Masherov had, anti-corruption debacles (the first two turns went horribly and we cucked him in the third) aside, a stellar entrance into Soviet politics. Kleschev managed to net in a sligthly above average performance, doing badly at first but then more than recovering from the political missteps of his first turn. Ashimov came in with an average performance overall, with Kosygin following suit. Voznesensky did not do too well at first, and his average performance later on was probably not nearly enough to recover much from his fall from grace in 64 and Smellyakov being caught up in anti-corruption in 65. And last, and least, Abramov. Our boss ate shit, he had an ok start, but then things went downhill from there.

Another aspect of Soviet Politics however, were the Supreme Soviet dice we were assigned as a compromise for letting Klim take charge of the Soviet economy. And the results in it are an indicator of how well each faction of the Troika was able to deliver their political programme:

Bread Program Cancelation 34 (Abramov?)
Cooperatives Reform 71 (Kosygin)
Undo the Wage Freezes 45 (Masherov?)

Unified Passport Zone 75 (Kosygin)
Resumption of Punishments 6 (Abramov)
Codify Convertibility 78 (Kosygin)
An Expanded Food Program 35 (Abramov/Klim)

Labor Reserve Reforms 27 (Masherov)
Inflation Control Measures 41 (Kosygin)
New MNKh Deputy 68 (Abramov)

Now, we don't know for sure exactly which faction pushed what policies, but we can make an educated guess. With than in mind, Kosygin clearly won out, with his initiatives being received well in general with the exception of inflation control measures, which still did ok. Masherov and Abramov were neck to neck in terms of averages, 36 and 37.6 respectively. But I think Abramov kinda loses out since while the labor reserve project which brought Mash's averages down did not do super well, they rolled enough to get something passed I am guessing, while the resumption of punishments did nothing for Abramov asides from getting him tarred as having Stalinist tendencies. One anomaly is that in the second turn Masherov didn't seem to get anything in (Abramov did the punishments for sure, and both Passport and Convertibility seem like a continuation of Kosygin's initiatives), but I think that's explained by the fiasco his anti-corruption initiatives led to.

Anyway, my read from all of this, is that Abramov steadily expended his political power in stuff like appointing us and the bread program, whilst steadily losing control of his faction as his appointee in the MNKh presided over the greatest economic crisis in over 20 years. Meanwhile, Masherov's attacks on corruption were bungled, leading to an event which freaked out the entire CPSU, but Babkov's vision of foreign policy has been working and his undoing of the wage freezes came at an opportune time. It looks he was able to make good headway in the Supreme Soviet and the Party, recovering from those issues pretty decisively. At this point, he needs to only wait one year for Kosygin to retire and he will probably become General Secretary barring any disasters. In the meanwhile, Kosygin successfully did most of the things he wanted to do before he plans to retire while doing ok at keeping his faction together, but probably losing supporters to Podgorny and Masherov from the fact he is going to be out of politics soon.

Also, the leftmost parts of the Party are acquitting themselves well. Ashimov did pretty decently and Kleschev did well. I've been reading the former's autobiography (which is in Kazakh so its slowgoing), and from what I've read so far he was a idealistic, very personable man who made friends everywhere he went, one of whom was Kleschev himself, who was first secretary in some organization while he was second secretary, so they probably have a good working relationship. He was also extremely interested in agricultural issues (his village suffered greatly from collectivization, being forced to relocate and facing starvation, which led him to leave his home at 15 with no food and water and undergo a days 150km trek on foot to a city so they would have one less mouth to feed. He greatly distrusted the state's involvement in agriculture, and he was even accused of coming from a Kulak family (which was false)). He also supported the August Coup, sending Yazov a letter saying his arrest was an injustice, so he probably has some hardliner tendencies in the internal sphere.
 
Last edited:
These mediocre results depress me, and I hope there will be a way to correct the situation. Moreover we'll go through the next round with more or less the same plan as we haven't completed much.
There's often a huge difference between the turn plan when you start a bunch of critical projects, and the turn plan where you're just investing dice to finish them.

I mean, this ain't nearly the worst thing we've ever faced. Anybody remember the Stalin/GPW days? We barely had an economy to have a recession back then.
Yeah. The Stalinism was so bad that "just saying, five million angry Nazis with guns are coming this way" came as a relief. Because, for better or for worse, at least it was one problem and nobody was gonna shoot us for coming up with a better way to solve it. Except the Nazis themselves, of course, but that was a problem that could be solved by solving the problem, whereas "anything Stalin" was not.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top