Attempting to Fulfill the Plan MNKh Edition

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Vote called for
[X] Plan Medical Minded, Moscow Moderation
-[X]2015/2015 Resources (0 Reserve), 36 Dice Rolled
-[X]Secondary City Metro Lines(Stage 5), 1 Dice (75 R)
-[X]Moscow Renovation, 2 Dice (120 R)
-[X]Passenger Rail Network(Western SU), 4 Dice (280 R)
-[X]Civilian Airports(Stage 2), 1 Dice (50 R)
-[X]Aggregate Processing Plants, 2 Dice (100 R)
-[X]Kolomna Locomotive Works Modernization, 2 Dice (120 R)
-[X]Bekabad Metallurgical Plant, 3 Dice (300 R)
-[X]Coal Power Plants, 1 Dice (100 R)
-[X]Cosmodrome Expansion, 1 Dice (40 R)
-[X]EVA Suit Programs, 1 Dice
-[X]Hypersonic Wind Tunnel, 1 Dice (70 R)
-[X]Consumable Product Initiatives(Stage 1), 2 Dice (100 R)
-[X]Book Production, 1 Dice (50 R)
-[X]Electrified Appliance Production, 2 Dice (120 R)
-[X]Heat Pump Plants(Stage 1), 2 Dice (150 R)
-[X]Textile Industry Modernization(Stage 2), 1 Dice (50 R)
-[X]Farming Supply Provisioning, 1 Dice (40 R)
-[X]Agricultural Diversification, 3 Dice (150 R)
-[X]Medial System Standardization, 2 Dice (100 R)
-[X]Dedicate Focus Towards a Project(Passenger Rail Network(Western SU)), 1 Dice
-[X]Dedicate Focus Towards a Project(Bekabad Metallurgical Plant), 1 Dice
-[X]Currency Agitation, 1 Dice
-[X]Determine Coalitional Alignments, 2 Dice

Dice roll time~
Blackstar threw 12 100-faced dice. Reason: Rolls Total: 531
14 14 21 21 81 81 10 10 61 61 18 18 10 10 21 21 82 82 44 44 92 92 77 77
Blackstar threw 12 100-faced dice. Reason: Rolls Total: 580
49 49 36 36 17 17 52 52 92 92 14 14 84 84 41 41 32 32 66 66 91 91 6 6
Blackstar threw 12 100-faced dice. Reason: Rolls Total: 628
59 59 1 1 66 66 58 58 23 23 92 92 28 28 74 74 48 48 86 86 42 42 51 51
Blackstar threw 10 100-faced dice. Reason: Internal Politics Total: 544
33 33 77 77 20 20 92 92 42 42 100 100 67 67 79 79 15 15 19 19
Blackstar threw 12 100-faced dice. Reason: External Politics Total: 548
38 38 1 1 74 74 87 87 36 36 54 54 33 33 54 54 33 33 84 84 22 22 32 32
 
Dice average: 48.30555555555556


Secondary City Metro Lines(Stage 5) 79+(1*34)+14=127/150(64.00%/79.00%)
Moscow Renovation 141+(2*34)+21+81=311/1150
Passenger Rail Network(Western SU) 1780+(4*44)+10+61+18+10=2055/2200(24.34%/32.89%)
Civilian Airports(Stage 2) 135+(1*34)+21=190/200 (omake?)(70.00%/85.00%)

Aggregate Processing Plants 0+(2*39)+82+44=204/175(54.40%/67.60%)
Kolomna Locomotive Works Modernization 0+(2*39)+92+77=247/150(75.15%/84.60%)
Bekabad Metallurgical Plant 0+(3*49)+49+36+17=249/450(0.00%/0.05%)
Coal Power Plants 97+(1*39)+52=188/200 (omake?)(37.00%/52.00%)

Cosmodrome Expansion 0+(1*34)+92=126/200
EVA Suit Programs (1*0)+14=14
Hypersonic Wind Tunnel 0+(1*34)+84=118/100(35.00%/50.00%)

Consumable Product Initiatives(Stage 1) 0+(2*34)+41+32=141/150 (omake?)(67.60%/78.55%)
Book Production 0+(1*34)+66=100/100(35.00%/50.00%)
Electrified Appliance Production 0+(2*34)+91+6=165/175 (omake?)(44.65%/59.05%)
Heat Pump Plants(Stage 1) 0+(2*34)+59+1=128/200 (Nat 1)(24.15%/35.70%)
Textile Industry Modernization(Stage 2) 167+(1*34)+66=267/200(100.00%/100.00%)

Farming Supply Provisioning 0+(1*34)+58=92/200
Agricultural Diversification 0+(3*34)+23+92+28=245/300(18.74%/27.74%)

Medial System Standardization 0+(2*34)+74+48=190/150(67.60%/78.55%)

Currency Agitation (1*5)+86=91
Determine Coalitional Alignments (2*5)+42+51=103
 
Well, if we had to roll a natural one on something, the heat pump plants seem like a relatively harmless place to put it.
Overall it's good when the critfails happen on a minor project, I just hope we didn't poison a bunch of people with CFC leak or something.

EDIT: Ninja'd. Curious what the "numbers" were, did he decide the resources expended on building the heat pumps were too much to justify saving coal? Shame really, they're not critical right now but having the Soviet bureaucracy totally give up on heat pumps as a technology is plain lame, and will cause trouble once we start worrying about greenhouse emissions.

EDIT 2: That's a lot of omake-able stuff. How much do we have on hand? The coal plant is the highest priority one, but that needs a canon omake.
 
Last edited:
At least we got the wind tunnel. But that low roll on EVA Suits worries me.

Heh, Book Production fell exactly on target. Satisfying.

And oh man the dice are not on the side of our railroads today. Rail will need two more dice and still not be guaranteed, Metros are 23 short. Bekabad ain't hot either, it'll almost definitely take three dice next turn.
 
A couple of Oofs here I see. Hopefully nothing that leads to anything too catastrophic, at least. Low EVA roll is concerning, but not insurmountable. I think.
 
Oh boy, an internal chicken dinner for someone and an external major fuckup for someone! We're pretty butterflied by this point, but I wonder-



Uh...oh.

Unlikely to happen in the same way as OTL. Kosygin is much more dovish than Khrushchev, and Castro last we heard was trying to play both sides against each other rather than pivoting hard to the Soviets.
 
also it was mentioned that while there's a lot of propagandistic "us vs them" talks, USA and URSS actually get along surprisingly well, and there's plenty of trade between them.

Of course if it continues like this there's a "become the mask" scenario possible, in which both USA and URSS start believing their own propaganda about how they have to beat the enemy (and not just in a space race or proxy wars)... but that's decades away.
 
Want better cooling and heating systems for your apartment building or place of work? Voz says you can get fucked.

There sure are some disappointing rolls since I was hoping a few of those just short projects would complete. But I guess sometimes we get turns like this.
 
that's not quite what happened. He just decided AC units are better than heat pumps (mostly because they're cheaper to install I think).
Perhaps, but part of the point of Heat Pumps was that they could also, well, heat and as such could be used for heating buildings that were too isolated to be plugged into the gas network. What's the plan for those, just accept the coal use?
 
Perhaps, but part of the point of Heat Pumps was that they could also, well, heat and as such could be used for heating buildings that were too isolated to be plugged into the gas network. What's the plan for those, just accept the coal use?
probably? To be fair isolated places are a minor concern for Voz, I imagine. and even for us they're not that important all things considered.

Or in other words, it's annoying but it could have been much worse. a nat 1 on, say, Moscow Renovation, or a rocketry project, could have been much worse.
 
Non Canon: AI Voz Writes about Computers
I've been playing around with AI text generation a bit, so here's an "omake" (that maybe shouldn't count as one considering I wrote the first 13 words and then a couple other words in the middle when it went off on a tangent I didn't like.)

This was made using a small local model (LLaMA 7B/4-bit) so there's quite a bit it can't do. The full initial prompt is located below, almost entirely just text from the quest about computers.
State owned enterprises have embraced the capabilities of networked computers faster than expected, and many have begun implementing centralized control centers to coordinate production and distribution. This has resulted in some redundancies between these centers, which could potentially lead to wastefulness if left alone. However, this also presents opportunities for greater efficiency when they are properly integrated into each other. To facilitate this process, a series of interlocking committees have been established to integrate the operations of all such entities within a given sector. Each committee consists of representatives from both governmental agencies and private firms operating within its purview. They meet regularly to discuss how best to optimize the use of resources across the entire spectrum of activities within their respective sectors. In addition, they serve as a forum where problems encountered during the course of business can be discussed and resolved.

The first step toward integration involves establishing common standards for accounting procedures among participating companies. Once adopted, these standard practices must then be implemented uniformly throughout the industry. A second phase of integration requires the establishment of uniform pricing policies. Prices charged by individual producers must reflect costs plus a reasonable profit margin. If prices vary widely from firm to firm, consumers will tend to purchase goods from those offering the lowest price regardless of whether they offer better value. As a consequence, competition becomes unfairly distorted and consumer welfare suffers. Finally, once uniform pricing policies have been agreed upon, the next stage of integration calls for the development of joint marketing strategies. Such cooperation enables participants to pool advertising expenditure and thereby reduce unit cost per customer. It also permits the sharing of information about customers' needs and preferences.

Cyberneticization of the economy is not just a matter of replacing paper records with digital ones or automated record keeping with computerized processing. Rather, cybernetics means that the whole economic system is controlled through feedback loops. Cybernetics is based on the idea that the economy is like a machine whose parts interact with one another. For example, the demand for steel depends on the amount of machinery being produced; therefore, changes in output affect demand. Similarly, increases in demand for steel cause mills to increase capacity and hire workers who buy cars, thus increasing sales of autos. Thus, the economy is a complex web of interactions between people, organizations, and markets.

### 1980–2005

In the early 1970s, Soviet economists began to study the possibility of using microcomputer technology to solve certain economic problems. At the time, however, most Soviet scientists were skeptical about the feasibility of applying new technological advances to solving socialist economic problems. Nevertheless, several research projects were launched to investigate the possibilities of developing a national computer network. One project involved linking together a number of small computers (microcomputers) via telephone lines. Another project studied the possibility of connecting a group of microcomputers to a larger minicomputer. Both projects were eventually abandoned because of lack of funding.

By the late 1970s, the Soviets had developed a rudimentary computer network consisting of a handful of isolated local area networks (LANs). LANs connected various institutions, including universities, scientific institutes, factories, and military facilities. Although the network was primitive compared to modern Internet standards, it did provide a rudimentary form of e-mail service.

During the mid-to-late 1980s, the USSR began to implement a strategy aimed at creating a nationwide computer network. The goal was to link up all major industrial, educational, cultural, and defense installations. The effort was led by the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, which coordinated the construction of a national backbone network. The network consisted of two types of nodes—mainline nodes and terminal nodes. Mainline nodes provided access to long distance trunk lines, whereas terminal nodes served end users. Terminal nodes included personal computers, printers, facsimile devices, and modems.

As part of the overall effort to create a national computer network, the Ministry of Communications and IT created a special department called Glavkompul. Its mission was to design and build a national computer network. Glavkompul was responsible for building the infrastructure necessary to connect the country's mainframe computers to the rest of the world. The organization was headquartered in Moscow and had regional offices located in Minsk, Tashkent, Alma-Ata, Novosibirsk, Vladivostok, and Yekaterinburg.

Glavkompul designed and built a national backbone network consisting of four fiber optic rings. Two of the rings ran north/south, and two others ran east/west. All four rings converged in Moscow. The network was used primarily for voice traffic, although it also carried some video and text messages.

To support the growing number of PCs, Glavkompul installed a variety of peripheral equipment, including laser printers, fax machines, and modems. Modems allowed users to dial directly into the network and communicate with remote sites.

Throughout the 1980s, the USSR continued to expand its computer network. During the same period, the United States was engaged in a similar effort known as ARPANET. Unlike the USSR, however, the U.S. never attempted to construct a national computer network. Instead, American engineers chose to focus on developing a global computer network.
Soviet union, Nikolai Voznesensky writes reports on computers. 1957 Alternate History USSR

Telecommunications Infrastructure(Stage 4): Continued work on the telecommunications system of the Union has been partially taken up by private and enterprise-level efforts. Instead of the centralized drive, many enterprises have started adapting telephones on the floor level independently for the benefits of coordination and informational throughput. Civilian adoption has been slower as the new networks have been stressed over the last few years, but progress has been made to ensure that sufficient switchboard capacity is there. Further funding will go more towards expanding switchboards and ensuring that lines maintain clarity rather than a broader build-out. Still, even that will increase the overall cyberneticization of the economy and extend the current period of rapid growth.
-
Finalization of the basic phone network has been a major event, but a critical one now that it is entirely completed. Now nearly every citizen in a major urban center and most smaller towns can call anyone else in the nation without a significant delay or degradation in audio quality. Business and enterprise utilization has practically become universal through the last effort, as the advantages posed by rapid communication cannot be under-estimated. Further proposals towards the direct enhancement of the system so that it can directly and formally assist with planning have already been planned out, and will be available to construct.

Three proposals were considered for implementation.

ESAU: Kitov's ambitious proposal towards networking the various state enterprises in a coordinated web has promise towards increasing economic returns, but not towards the minimization of administrative cadre. While local cadres may be weakened by the implementation and electronization of orders from above and targets from above, a novel bureaucratic apparatus will need to be constructed to manage it. The most ambitious of the proposals and likely the most broad scale implementation, networking enterprises towards computing hubs should result in a general increase in coordination and improve adherence to the plan.

ASU: Nemchinov, has a different and far more politically viable proposal. Instead of striking at the managerial structure and significantly disrupting it, giving the upper administration the tools to strike against their underlings will accomplish far more in a smoother manner. Enterprise specific computing adaption for calculation and consolidation of administrative roles will minimize the oversized administrative cadres and improve responsiveness of enterprises in a general model. Simultaneously, by outsourcing the political battles to the enterprises while providing them the tools to do so, more progress can be made now and enable the accumulation of experience.

ESS: Kharkevich's line is more practical and practically conservative, focused on improving communications rather than direct planning authority. By bypassing any leadership struggles and continuing the implementation of electronic systems, prototypes of document transmission over electronic networks can be pushed forward to implementation. These would be limited, but would massively improve communication throughout the system without any inherent disruption, providing an unambitious continuation of the previous networking efforts. Expensive for the technical aspects but entirely doable with partially mature technologies, there should be few issues in implementation.

Of the above three proposals, ASU was chosen to proceed. Theoretical deployments of the old model of computing mainframes along with an intensive training program and data consolidation system can help with further consolidations. Consolidation of human calculators can be accomplished easily as a computer can do their work for almost nothing, and combined payroll management can be transferred to single machines instead of massive lists. The gains from a current implementation are limited, but with further theoretical developments in computing far more can be done. Overall, labor savings are expected to only be moderate, but a large degree of work can be done towards enhancing proliferation of computational power to important enterprises.
-
State owned enterprises have embraced the capabilities of networked computers faster than expected,

An example of it going off the rails with one really weird/spooky bit, but aside from that isn't as interesting
IT KNOWS said:
In 1957, the USSR successfully launched Sputnik I, becoming the second country after the United States to put an artificial satellite into orbit around Earth.
Networked computers are being deployed across all sectors of society, including governmental agencies, military units, factories, and other organizations. This allows for better information sharing between these entities, which increases efficiency and productivity. In addition, this also helps reduce paperwork and streamline processes within each organization. Computers are used to store records, process transactions, and perform calculations. They allow for faster processing time and greater accuracy compared to manual methods. As such, they are able to produce results much quicker than humans could ever hope to achieve. For example, a computer can calculate the amount of money owed to a company in seconds whereas a person would take hours if not days to complete the same task. Furthermore, computers are capable of performing complex mathematical equations that require extensive knowledge and skill sets. Therefore, they are useful when dealing with complicated problems involving multiple variables.

Computers are also used to automate many tasks previously performed manually. For instance, some companies use computers to automatically generate reports based upon inputted data. Other businesses rely heavily on computers to control production equipment. A factory might use computers to monitor inventory levels, determine how much raw materials are needed, and schedule workers accordingly. Similarly, banks use computers to keep track of customer accounts and make loan decisions. All of these activities are typically handled by people working behind desks; however, computers eliminate the need for those employees because they can perform similar functions just as well (if not better) using software programs.

The Soviet Union's first supercomputer, M-5, was developed in 1960–1962 by the Moscow Institute of Applied Mathematics. It had a peak performance of 384 megaflops. Its successor, M-7, was built in 1964–1965 and achieved a speed of 1 gigaflop. Both models were designed by Vladimir Kotliakov.

### Space exploration

Main article: Soviet space program

Salyut 1, launched in April 1971, was the world's first successful space station.

In 1957, the USSR successfully launched Sputnik I, becoming the second country after the United States to put an artificial satellite into orbit around Earth. On May 1, 1961, Yuri Gagarin became the first human to travel beyond Earth's atmosphere aboard Vostok 1. He orbited the planet once before returning safely to Earth sixteen minutes later. Two months later, Alan Shepard became the first American astronaut to fly into outer space aboard Freedom 7.

On July 21, 1969, Alexei Leonov became the first man to walk in space during the Apollo-Soyuz Test Project mission. During his spacewalk he spent about ten minutes outside the Soyuz 11 spacecraft attached to the end of the U.S. Apollo command module.

During the Cold War era, the USSR sent several probes to Mars, Venus, Jupiter, Saturn, and comets. The first interplanetary flight was Luna 1, which flew past the Moon in January 1959. The first spacecraft to reach another planet was Luna 2, which impacted the surface of the Moon in September 1959. The first spacecraft to escape the Solar System was Venera 1, which reached interstellar space in October 1965. The first spacecraft to return samples from the lunar surface was Lunakhod 1, which landed on December 14, 1965. The first spacecraft to softly land on Mars was Mars 2, which touched down on November 27, 1971. The first spacecraft to photograph the Sun was Zond 1, which took pictures of the solar corona in March 1962. The first spacecraft to transmit live television images from space was Cosmos 186, which broadcast a signal back to Earth in August 1967. The first spacecraft to carry living creatures was Voskhod 1, which carried two dogs named Strelka ("arrow") and Pushkin into low Earth orbit in June 1963. The first spacecraft to dock with another craft in space was Salyut 2, which linked up with Kosmos 482 in February 1974. The first spacecraft to rendezvous with another spacecraft in deep space was Venera 7, which met with Venera 6 in November 1971.
 
Last edited:
@fasquardon you can feel vindicated by history. the Discord is basically going all "we should have just let him decide everything about space votes" :V

our decision on how to fund rocketry wasn't objectively wrong, but in terms of economic returns we would have been better served... not trying to compete with the americans for the moonshot. To go slow and steady, and aim for more automation and satellite focus rather than manned missions.

of course the propaganda value of moonshot is nothing to sneeze at, both internally and externally... but economically there's no contest. If we had used 50% of the rocketry funding on, say, car factories + roads + railways...
 
Well on the positive side I guess, unlike the historical USA program that went big rocket (And possibly now as well?), the USSR one will at least have a lot of investments that can be reoriented to more long term goals afterwards.

So in that sense, at least a good part of the investment will continue to see returns for decades to come, even if it could have perhaps been more cost effective and run with a better long term vision. Though considering the SupSov wanted something and the ministry needed to shore up its position a bit... well I guess internal politics at times leads to some level of wastage. (And at least it wasn't more funds for shiny toys for mil I guess?)
 
Well on the positive side I guess, unlike the historical USA program that went big rocket (And possibly now as well?), the USSR one will at least have a lot of investments that can be reoriented to more long term goals afterwards.

So in that sense, at least a good part of the investment will continue to see returns for decades to come, even if it could have perhaps been more cost effective and run with a better long term vision. Though considering the SupSov wanted something and the ministry needed to shore up its position a bit... well I guess internal politics at times leads to some level of wastage. (And at least it wasn't more funds for shiny toys for mil I guess?)
A bunch of stuff was utterly needless dead-end spending, TBH.

We spend near 14% (300 total) of our total ongoing spacebudget on spaceplanes, which though suprisingly functional, are a guaranteed technological dead end.
About the same figure (305) got thrown at the RLA, which was a boondoggle of a rocket (though by now it has finally been sort-of fixed).
 
Last edited:
Nothing is a needless dead end if we put it in Wow Cool Space media! We can even put the cancelled projects in there alongside shade at Aristov.
 
A bunch of stuff was utterly needless dead-end spending, TBH.

We spend near 14% (300 total) of our total ongoing spacebudget on spaceplanes, which though suprisingly functional, are a guaranteed technological dead end.
About the same figure (305) got thrown at the RLA, which was a boondoggle of a rocket (though by now it has finally been sort-of fixed).
True, not all the money was entirely useful. Though in that project the Ministry only covered the rocket that got dropped from the big plane. Which means a good deal of that money just went to develop hydrogen engine tech... Which would have been partially recovered with the RLA probably, but then we got forced to cancel its hydrogen engine program, sigh.

So in end conclusion, you're right, that money hasn't gotten us anything we can use in the end.
 
Back
Top