Orc Quest; or, A Critical Examination of Agency Through in Interactive Fiction (Warcraft)

Seriously where was this fuck the Alliance energy a while back when we had a choice in our adventure of exile?

We are officially friends with them with a letter signed by their bigwigs for safe passage in their lands.

It would be detrimental now to burn and rip that to pieces now.
My issue was putting us against orcs and trolls. I still don't like giving Aliden for Balnazzar to puppet, but it's an easier pill to swallow, and the Syndicate is on our way to where the Blackrock ruins should be located anyway.
 
They basically wanted us to repeat what we'd done previously, recruit/pacify the populations, murder was an option, but not one we delved into either time. Why do people think this was going to be different?
 
My issue was putting us against orcs and trolls. I still don't like giving Aliden for Balnazzar to puppet, but it's an easier pill to swallow, and the Syndicate is on our way to where the Blackrock ruins should be located anyway.
With the orcs I expect some negotiation to take place just like in Hammerfall.

The trolls are another story when Grok and warband had no problem dealing with elements of that one tribe in the Arathi highlands to get back that capital.

They basically wanted us to repeat what we'd done previously, recruit/pacify the populations, murder was an option, but not one we delved into either time. Why do people think this was going to be different?
It seemed to work out well. Not sure on the second try.

@Doomed Wombat could do with some grumbling. Any thoughts on the totally not a dreadlord in disguise offer?
 
Last edited:
All that investment and then get rid of a rising star? Honestly seems more like thanks to the raid, Danrothan gets to clear the old guard more so more radical heirarchies can be established.
Saiden Dathrohan is canonically pretty racist, he's one of the reasons the Crusade was so exclusionary. In this quest though for some reason Dathrohan doesn't seem to care as much about race. Weird that. It's it nice of Balnazzar Dathrohan to do that?

Does the horde under Thrall have claims on the Eastern kingdoms?
Claims are very complicated. There's an argument to be made that they have no claims whatsoever, because they're mostly invading genociders. However, the Horde do have some claim to teh Forsaken and Troll claims. The Alliance would acknoledge that certain parts of EK are 'Amani lands' etc.

But the orcs, no, no way lol.

Of course, that's legally, there's something else to be said for reality
If Grok doesn't take the offer then @FractiousDay will Danrothan find someone else to be the hatchetman in Alterac? Someone less friendly to the horde?
Maybe, but Grok is convenient and effective. A human force wouldn't be as much. While it's inconvenient for Dathrohan to have to guard his supply lines as much, he might prefer to do that rather than send an ineffective captain. Ideally he wants everyone working together to summon the legion fight the scourge, rather than having to destroy potentially useful tools allies
Also is Lordaeron and Undercity under crusade control?
Most of Lordaeron is, save for a few scourge holdouts which are difficult to dislodge. Those are seiged and picketted though and will fall eventually. The Undercity is a flooded ruin, so there's not much to control really there, the Forsaken are all gone, so I suppose in the absence of anyone else, sure the Crusade are in control
Seriously where was this fuck the Alliance energy a while back when we had a choice in our adventure of exile?
I mean people did choose the most alliance heavy option. But I also do want to enable people to choose different things. Grok isn't really personally involved in any of this so he can decide to go when he likes
At the same time if we run around Alterac looking for clues about the death night we will probably run into the syndicate anyway, so I don't know ...
Indeed this may be so. Circumstances may force a confrontation anyway ,which may be disadvantageous etc.
involving ourselves in political and teritorial disputes doesn't help protect the world
CARDIO BEATS CHAOS

Dathrohan would argue that it is indeed helpful, as you secure your supplies to go on continent spanning expeditions etc. But yes, that's rhetoric you can disagree with
 
Saiden Dathrohan is canonically pretty racist, he's one of the reasons the Crusade was so exclusionary. In this quest though for some reason Dathrohan doesn't seem to care as much about race. Weird that
That's why a better reason to decline than out of dislike of the alliance is don't trust Danrothan. It's a better reason because he has been quite busy being manipulative.

He has been helpful to Grok but when Tirion says he thinks his old colleague has changed that's quite IC to reject a reward that maybe poisoned.
Claims are very complicated. There's an argument to be made that they have no claims whatsoever, because they're mostly invading genociders. However, the Horde do have some claim to teh Forsaken and Troll claims. The Alliance would acknoledge that certain parts of EK are 'Amani lands' etc.

But the orcs, no, no way lol.

Of course, that's legally, there's something else to be said for reality
Naturally. Quite a problem in the anglo saxon of the claim.
Maybe, but Grok is convenient and effective. A human force wouldn't be as much. While it's inconvenient for Dathrohan to have to guard his supply lines as much, he might prefer to do that rather than send an ineffective captain. Ideally he wants everyone working together to summon the legion fight the scourge, rather than having to destroy potentially useful tools allies
Fair. Good case to be made when a trusted orc can solve things faster.
I don't get it.
 
Seriously where was this fuck the Alliance energy a while back when we had a choice in our adventure of exile?

We are officially friends with them with a letter signed by their bigwigs for safe passage in their lands.

It would be detrimental now to burn and rip that to pieces now.
It's not like this is Grok'maw dropping a disstrack on them and kicking everyone he comes across as he walks out. It's just "I see your point but I have other priorities for now."
 
Was specifically a reference to this, but basically the idea that wars are won by logistics and organisation, not individual martial skill or heroics. Came up here etc too.
I mean its true. The Orcs from most perspectives should beat the tar out of most enemies, and if the war song were as good at logistics as they were at raiding and stabbing then they probably would.

Anyway hi again, vanished for a bit again.

What was the conclusion reached on the whole "accidentally becoming war chief" thing? Cause I have some thoughts even if its too late to give them.

Otherwise, the way I look at it I feel like I'd rather interrogate "Dathrohan" on this more, but that isn't an option. On balance I'm inclined to refuse, in many ways it feels like this would be an anchoring and there's shit to do.

Also damn Bolvar's dead. Stormwind is not doing so hot and infiltrators must be having a fucking field day ATM.
 
[X] Accept an Alliance commission to take Alterac, guaranteeing cooperation from local Alliance forces, and support from Dathrohan's Crusade.

I'm like 60/40 split, after the clarification. Dathrohan that chummy fella, he keeps making it convenient, that's how they get ya.
 
I mean if we leave we don't get to expose him as an infiltrator. Grok may be a tad more chill on the fel as a whole, but he's still violently anti-legion.
 
Seriously where was this fuck the Alliance energy a while back when we had a choice in our adventure of exile?
Back then we were going to go fight the scourge and we didn't know OOC that two major alliance factions were controlled by enemy infiltrators :p

Still I wonder what effect this will have on the Lich King's plans long term? The scourge has always been rather magical logistics IMO, but I always thought that they were generating new corpses primarily from the plague lands, what with northrend not exactly being the most populous place in the world. Sure there's plenty of dragon skeletons and ice crown makes for great storage, but a majority of new bodies presumably have to come from somewhere with more people breathing still.

Though I'd be unsurprised if there's a general look away from the scourge since the plague lands were also their major outpost beyond Northrend so people are likely less inclined to pay attention to them until they become a problem again...mmm maybe plague 2.0?

Furthermore, fingers crossed the forsaken being closer to the rest of the horde lets them integrate better and stops that plague doctor from making plague v2.0.

I mean if we leave we don't get to expose him as an infiltrator. Grok may be a tad more chill on the fel as a whole, but he's still violently anti-legion.
Grok's got the intrigue of an concussed Rhino, if someone exposes him I doubt it'll be us :p
 
The only question I do have is what the Frostwolf and Drek Thar reaction would be to it all.
By my understanding of things Drek Thar would likely approve of our attempts to make nice with the humans, since he's got a lot of guilt about things like that.

On the other hand, I imagine the dark shamanism thing would be more complex, since while he is likely familiar with it, he's kinda the originator of Thrall's reforms.

The frost wolves as a whole, who knows I fear.
 
For me, the option where we capture Alterac is more of an opportunity to try to create legal / recognized orc lands in the Eastern Kingdoms, in which they have the right to live, and at the same time are integrated into local life, and not just being hired guards or a tribe on the outskirts.

I still suspect that this may end in problems or that we will be betrayed, but it's still a pretty obvious and interesting path that can help orcs, and Grok, and Azeroth.
 
Back then we were going to go fight the scourge and we didn't know OOC that two major alliance factions were controlled by enemy infiltrators :p

Still I wonder what effect this will have on the Lich King's plans long term? The scourge has always been rather magical logistics IMO, but I always thought that they were generating new corpses primarily from the plague lands, what with northrend not exactly being the most populous place in the world. Sure there's plenty of dragon skeletons and ice crown makes for great storage, but a majority of new bodies presumably have to come from somewhere with more people breathing still.

Though I'd be unsurprised if there's a general look away from the scourge since the plague lands were also their major outpost beyond Northrend so people are likely less inclined to pay attention to them until they become a problem again...mmm maybe plague 2.0?

Furthermore, fingers crossed the forsaken being closer to the rest of the horde lets them integrate better and stops that plague doctor from making plague v2.0.
If I would choose differently when IIRC I wasn't there until after the scarlet crusade was chosen I'd pick finding the storm reavers or going to troll country. The former allows getting more necrolytes while the latter helps the horde or it's likely allies because they're trolls.

Though..... the story is not beholden to the status quo. Even before Grok's arrival things had changed with Calia's discovery, the forsaken under siege and Varian Wrynn's warrior side dying in the gladiator pits.
 
If I would choose differently when IIRC I wasn't there until after the scarlet crusade was chosen I'd pick finding the storm reavers or going to troll country. The former allows getting more necrolytes while the latter helps the horde or it's likely allies because they're trolls.

Though..... the story is not beholden to the status quo. Even before Grok's arrival things had changed with Calia's discovery, the forsaken under siege and Varian Wrynn's warrior side dying in the gladiator pits.
I thought you were there and you wanted to go to the tomb of Sargarus (which frankly I also want to go too now that I'm slightly more confident we can handle it.)

Oh yeah totally, as I said a while ago now we are well off the rails.
 
I think I started joining after that one.

I did bring up the choices later to discuss them. Wouldn't go into the tomb but open to finding the necrolytes on the isle.
Opposed to finding the necrolytes, would be interested in trying to blow up the tomb and ensure the avatar within is destroyed, what with it being a ticking time bomb.
 
Opposed to finding the necrolytes, would be interested in trying to blow up the tomb and ensure the avatar within is destroyed, what with it being a ticking time bomb.
That was the objective of the option. Find if the stormreavers survive and see if they want to come back into the fold. If the tomb is found mark it but leave it alone for later.

[ ] The Broken Isles
You once considered that the Stormreavers, the old clan of Gul'dan, might somehow be salvageable and persuaded to serve the Horde again. Journey toward the Broken Isles, a place of great mystery and danger and seek them out.
Claims are very complicated. There's an argument to be made that they have no claims whatsoever, because they're mostly invading genociders. However, the Horde do have some claim to teh Forsaken and Troll claims. The Alliance would acknoledge that certain parts of EK are 'Amani lands' etc.

But the orcs, no, no way lol.

Of course, that's legally, there's something else to be said for reality
My main hope is by being useful, it'll make them amendable towards negotiating orcs and horde co. squatting especially by getting friendly relation with people higher up on the totem pole to consider the question of horde members settling in the EK.

The reason why I ask if Danrothan values Grok a lot is so that he can give Grok a delayed commission. Basically Grok wants to check the situation in Alterac more before he accepts so he's taking the hard path. Once he does get the full info he then considers accepting the commission towards the nearest Alliance post there.
 
Last edited:
What was the conclusion reached on the whole "accidentally becoming war chief" thing? Cause I have some thoughts even if its too late to give them.
Vark has brought the very valid point up that Orcs commanding large diverse forces are warchiefs, they are commanders of multiple clans etc. This doesn't however automaticlaly make you a claimant to the warchief title, of which currently there's Rend and Thrall.

Grok acknoledges the point, but as he's not actually claiming to be a new polity currently, it's not as relevant. However, this doesn't stop others perceiving it as much. Certainly the Blackrock Orcs under Rend would view Grok as a potential challenger, but that doesn't necessarily mean Thrall does.

At some point, not this arc but eventually probably as Grok continues to grow in power and influence, there would be a serious question regarding whether Grok does want to assume the title, or whether it might be thrust upon him. For example, if you walked up to Blackrock Mountain and Mak'gora'd Rend, you would naturally assume his title following victory.
@FractiousDay how much does Danrothan value Grok?
Depends! I won't be massively clear here because I don't really want to give away loads about Balnazzar Dathrohan's intentions, but so far Grok has proved a very useful tool, both as a good fighter and military asset, but also as a political actor, especially because of his ability to intercede between the Crusade and the Horde. Grok therefore has a lot of potential, but that potential isn't necessarily realised, and Grok is also very anti-Legion

Of course, I say he's anti-Legion, but he's been going about looking quite pro-Legion to others tbh. For example helping Feldad get the magic battery to Varimathras, or fighting the Scourge, who are the Legion's rebellious tool.
 
…I dunno why for sure, but I don't trust Dathoran's words here. Like May or may not be a Dreadlord aside, I feel like I don't care for the cut of his job offer.
Just Constable?
*shakes head* Noo thanks. Especially since a Grok who has his men dismissed from service is likely to learn they went bandit, and probably can't without violating honor anyway…

[X] Refuse the commission. You dislike embroiling yourself further in Alliance politics, no matter how convenient it is for Dathrohan. This will make getting through Alterac more difficult for a number of reasons.
 
Back
Top