Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
The problem is it doesn't explain Borek's actions. Assuming that he knows that this beastman is to be trusted, he doesn't let it stroke hi like it's family.

Actually, that's another point - Morghur stroked Borek in a manner of great intimacy specific to the dwarves. It would be weird for anyone not familiar with Dwarven customs to even know that this was a thing to do.

The only explanation that explains Borek's actions is that he's personally familiar enough with the being appearing as Morghur enough to consider them family.
Actually, I think this can be explained by merging parts of a few theories together, with a bit of new material for mortar.

[] THEORY: The specifics are hazy, but this is a known contingency plan that Borek is entirely aware of, but hoped hadn't been enacted. The result breaks all Dawi notions of acceptability, but Karak Dum survives in some capacity and continues to inflict attrition on every local and visiting Chaos force that want to take a swing at them, so it is considered a lesser evil by the pragmatic Karak Dum. From their extensive study of Chaos, they had previously figured out how to deliberately induce Morghur's reincarnation into a specific body, even that of a dwarf. To contain and control Morghur after his induced reincarnation, the Dwarves of Karag Dum did something to burn away the taint of Chaos, much as your Belt of the Unshackled Mountain does, but on a far grander scale. Burning out the taint of a demigod named "the Corruptor" is likely why there's a desert and fewer mountains here. The forest was created by the purified Morghur, and the beastmen were attracted to serve him as they are inherently bound to do. The rulers of Karag Dum would not force such a fate onto any of their subjects, so this "Morghur" was likely a member of the royal clan who was pre-selected in case this contingency needed to be activated, and was personally known and loved by Borek, explaining the greeting and his reaction to it.

This is now my preferred theory, incidentally - going to go back and edit it into my votepost.
 
Last edited:
We know from Chaos Dwarves, that enslaving demons is a possibility. We have, from our Runic Belt, an example of high scale anti-chaos runes in action, effects that match with the local environment

We know the Local Tribes have lost favor with chaos. We know they view attacking the mountain as a method to regain that favor.
"All are welcome against the Dum" he said.
Beastmen are attracted to herd stones. The Karak is removing dhar. The Karack has become a giant herdstone, *that purifies dhar*

Two holds within the grip of chaos. One within the very realm of demons, the other at its gates.....

A herdstone that purifies dhar isn't a herdstone.
 
[X] THEORY: The Dwarves of Karag Dum did something to burn away the taint of Chaos, much as your Belt of the Unshackled Mountain does, but on a far grander scale. Perhaps it had an effect on the Beastmen here, Cor-Dum included.
@Garlak has me convinced
But also
[x] THEORY: I think I still owe Borek like 1800 gold.
 
Variations on 'big' and 'far'. If it turns out we really need a topographical map I'll sit down and make one but I'm terrible at 'eyeballing' that sort of thing. The mountain looks like a normal mountain, but that's common for Karaks, apart from the entrance (which would be somewhere under the treeline) Dwarves prefer to preserve the natural beauty of a mountain. The slope is fairly gentle, sand doesn't allow that steep an incline. Nothing is visible on the other edges from here.
I really have a hard time imagining the whole scene of Borek walking to Morghur. Here's why:

We go to the edge of a crater and that's the first time we see something that's being described as a "mountain" (as opposed to hill or rock or rugged fortress). That means that the crater is either masssively wide or really really steep.

We can see Cor-Dum bleating at said mountain (or at us?), but we can not clearly see his fellow bleating beastmen.
Does that mean that Cor-Dum is the only living being that's in the desert area instead of the forest and that he happens to be on our sode of the mountain/forest area?
Or does it mean that Cor-Dum, with his >3 meters, is taller than the (tiny?) trees?

Borek walks (without running) to Cor-Dum. Mathilde stands there dumbfounded while a few Rangers trickle in to ask what the fuck. Borek reaches Cor-Dum. How long did this take? In rough order of magnitude numbers. Because from an elevation a mile doesn't look like far, but walking that distance still takes longer than I'd imagine Mathilde to stand around saying "I don't know" repeatedly.

How far have Borek and Cor-Dum gotten while holding hands walking towards the forest? Did they pull some comic/western trick of disappearing into the horizon in less than a song's time? Because, well, we have a Shadowsteed.


Oh, and you didn't answer my question about how Karak Dum (or what's left of it) looks when compared to a normal mountain and/or a Dawi-worked Karag.
All I can say is: a Grudge on Borek for not explaining anything.
Clan secrets...
 
Is it possible Borek's mind was altered or somehow enchanted? Do we have any reason to suspect he left by anything but his own free will?
 
Is it possible Borek's mind was altered or somehow enchanted? Do we have any reason to suspect he left by anything but his own free will?
At this point, damn near anything's possible. I wouldn't say that it's likely- we didn't notice any magic being worked on him, nobody else was affected by any such impulse, etc- but it could have happened.
 
Last edited:
Does that mean that Cor-Dum is the only living being that's in the desert area instead of the forest and that he happens to be on our sode of the mountain/forest area?

Yes.

Borek walks (without running) to Cor-Dum. Mathilde stands there dumbfounded while a few Rangers trickle in to ask what the fuck. Borek reaches Cor-Dum. How long did this take? In rough order of magnitude numbers. Because from an elevation a mile doesn't look like far, but walking that distance still takes longer than I'd imagine Mathilde to stand around saying "I don't know" repeatedly.

Asking me for the time elapsed is just asking me for the distance in a slightly different way. You don't have to like the answer, but that doesn't mean you should keep asking until you get a different one. And it's not like Mathilde had any other important appointments that would take precedence over watching Borek marching to meet a demigod.

Oh, and you didn't answer my question about how Karak Dum (or what's left of it) looks when compared to a normal mountain and/or a Dawi-worked Karag.

I think that got eaten when I was trying to stitch together different replies. Apart from the entrance, which would be below the treeline, Dwarves prefer to maintain a mountain's natural beauty.
 
[x] THEORY: The Dwarves of Karag Dum did something to burn away the taint of Chaos, much as your Belt of the Unshackled Mountain does, but on a far grander scale. Perhaps it had an effect on the Beastmen here, Cor-Dum included.

Also, speaking of Horstmann and studying Dhar, this bit got overshadowed by the whole Gotrek thing earlier:
"Remember to take notes, we don't get many chances to accumulate data on this phenomenon." Egrimm looks downwards at where the plummeting Winds terminate. "And to prove it, that's a much-debated phenomenon we can confirm the existence of. Natural Dhar. There's plenty that argue that it only comes about as a result of unnatural influences or ill intent."
But it implies that Egrimm always always questioned Dhar's inherent unnaturalness and malevolence, since he doesn't seem to be including himself among those who thought it necessarily came from Chaos or malevolence.

So I'm quite curious what he's going to make of all of this. Perhaps seeing Morghur defending Karag Dum will be a formative experience for the fella.

Using magic to bind an abomination that exists only to kill into your service would be-

(Glances at Mathilde's notes on Apparition-binding.)

Ah! Well, nevertheless.
To be fair, whether the abomination in question is Chaos-free (Apparitions), Chaos-tainted (Beastmen), or literally made of Chaos (Daemons) seems pretty relevant.
 
Random theory time! Maybe Karak Dum bound Cogsworth (as other people have theorised), and somehow the process altered his aura in a 'fuck chaos/dhar' effect (it used Valaya's runes, or something)?
 
Voting is open
Back
Top