I consider it unlikely for him to manifest directly.
In most places I'd think so too, but he is a god of Fire and this is the Plane of Fire. Might be close enough to his metaphysical home that he actually can manifest at decent strenght without expanding too much power?
Besides, he needs something there to finish her off, if he gets the chance and zhings that can permanently kill even minor gods are rare enough that he won't have many options besides himself.

[X] Crake
 
[X] Wish her good fortune

We geared her out. All of the people she'll find of use, are of better use somewhere else.
Seriously, we are handling a lot of stuff next month.
 
No offense, but looking at the turnplan notes, I'm pretty sure all we can spare is a big fat "nothing".

We have Norvos/Qohor as Free Action for anyone remotely powerful enough to take part.
We have CoS for anyone remotely combat-capable.
We have Slavers' Bay for Intriguers and sneaky-sneaks.
We have PoW and Summer Isles for diplomacners (non-Companion).
If it's a single battle, namely the opening assault to bring down the walls, that's doable. I'm fairly sure we're not getting a shot at Ymeri herself simply thanks to how long this is expected to take, but with this we should be able to contribute enough to bargain with R'hllor for the fealty of the fire fey to be transferred to us.
 
No offense, but looking at the turnplan notes, I'm pretty sure all we can spare is a big fat "nothing".

We have Norvos/Qohor as Free Action for anyone remotely powerful enough to take part.
We have CoS for anyone remotely combat-capable.
We have Slavers' Bay for Intriguers and sneaky-sneaks.
We have PoW and Summer Isles for diplomacners (non-Companion).
Either we give token support (I'm not sending Mel away with a big fat "nothing". She's worth more than that to us), or we give real support, but we are going to do something about this for the next turn vote.

And I think most of us are eager to drop whatever we're doing if it means we get to shank That Bitch.
 
Either we give token support (I'm not sending Mel away with a big fat "nothing". She's worth more than that to us), or we give real support, but we are going to do something about this for the next turn vote.

And I think most of us are eager to drop whatever we're doing if it means we get to shank That Bitch.
Definitely not drop what we're doing, considering that's a double conquest, but I do want the chance to shank that bitch. That said I'm not counting on it, so the next best thing is contributing enough to bargain with R'hllor for the fire fey.
No, mechanically, it is not.
Unless we want people to suffer more RnG at their tasks, which are even more important at the moment than Ymeri is long-term.
It's what we did this turn. It's how we had companions in Slaver's Bay and Sarnor simultaneously. They just teleport in for the battles while working on other things.

[X] Crake
 
And I think most of us are eager to drop whatever we're doing if it means we get to shank That Bitch.
Well, we are in disagreement, then.
I find Ymeri to be... inconsequential.

She has never been much of a threat.
An annoyance, for sure, but not a threat.

And, even if she's not dead next turn, she's diminished to the point of not mattering.

Handling the momentary shitshows of CoS, Slavers' Bay and Quohor is of far higher priority and interest in my opinion.
 
It's what we did this turn. It's how we had companions in Slaver's Bay and Sarnor simultaneously. They just teleport in for the battles while working on other things.
No, that's because Richard, Mereth and Viserys had no action assigned for the turn. With Sarnor being Free Action, they could join in SB.
Dany got there because she overshot her Research Progress at the start of the month and was free otherwise.

EDIT: sorry, partial misread, lemmie do a do-over

EDIT EDIT: Everyone (of decent enough power) takes part in Qohor/Norvos. They take part in big battles, and then go back to their scheduled actions without losing progress.
If we are to try and assign them on halping Mel, they will lose progress, we can't give two Free Actions a month.
 
Last edited:
Well, we are in disagreement, then.
I find Ymeri to be... inconsequential.

She has never been much of a threat.
An annoyance, for sure, but not a threat.

And, even if she's not dead next turn, she's diminished to the point of not mattering.

Handling the momentary shitshows of CoS, Slavers' Bay and Quohor is of far higher priority and interest in my opinion.
It would be OOC for Viserys not to offer aid against Ymeri. We have history with her, including eating her Herald. Zherys and Teana would probably also like to have an opportunity to take part in the assault, considering Ymeri's recent history with Volantis, not to mention temporarily snagging a piece of the latter's soul.

[X] Crake
 
No, that's because Richard, Mereth and Viserys had no action assigned for the turn. With Sarnor being Free Action, they could join in SB.
Dany got there because she overshot her Research Progress at the start of the month and was free otherwise.

EDIT: sorry, partial misread, lemmie do a do-over

EDIT EDIT: Everyone (of decent enough power) takes part in Qohor/Norvos. They take part in big battles, and then go back to their scheduled actions without losing progress.
If we are to try and assign them on halping Mel, they will lose progress, we can't give two Free Actions a month.
You're right, progress on whatever research actions they have this turn would probably have a penalty, but this particular month is mostly just battles.

Purging Qohor of all traces of Shub Niggurath.

Crushing all resistance in Norvos.

And then an opening assault on Ymeri's fortress to earn our bargaining chips with R'hllor.

It's afterwards that they'd need to sit down and consolidate.
 
Yeah, alright, I'll leave it to y'all to think how to best assign people on Qohor and Ymeri-hunt as Free Actions without risking people by having too little force on either.
Good luck with that.

*salts*
 
Yeah, alright, I'll leave it to y'all to think how to best assign people on Qohor and Ymeri-hunt as Free Actions without risking people by having too little force on either.
Good luck with that.

*salts*
Depending on how it shakes out we can show up at the beginning of the month for an opening assault on Ymeri, spend a few days there, and then the rest of the month spent stamping out the abominations in Qohor while crushing Norvos under our heel. We don't really need to split our forces here. The ones that could even survive participating against Ymeri are easy enough to move back home en mass in time for Shub Niggurath.
 
What do we have on the larder? How about we pledge a sacrifice to R'hllor to formally sanctify the Temple at SD. Then simultaneously do it with all the he temples across all the cities with live mirrorcast on the day of the assault.

It would probably give Burny a huge power boost to shank that bitch, and we might get something good in return.

It would also be a great research material on how a deity gains power on a mass scale due to human interaction. It could help later with the Imperial Deity...
I'm imagining Spirit Bomb from DBZ as a special attack from it.

[X] Crake
 
Last edited:
Depending on how it shakes out we can show up at the beginning of the month for an opening assault on Ymeri, spend a few days there, and then the rest of the month spent stamping out the abominations in Qohor while crushing Norvos under our heel. We don't really need to split our forces here. The ones that could even survive participating against Ymeri are easy enough to move back home en mass in time for Shub Niggurath.
You misunderstand.
The main actions we re about to send out most proficient assets on are fighting Court of Starts and counter-intriguing Devils.
Do these things sound like something we could afford much to skimp on Progress or hope for good RNG when DP rolls for diminished results?

I'm looking at it from a purely mechanical side, and all I see is unnecessary work from me risking RNG from quest's mechanics for doing an action that doesn't seem like it would impact us much strategically regardless of how it goes.
 
You misunderstand.
The main actions we re about to send out most proficient assets on are fighting Court of Starts and counter-intriguing Devils.
Do these things sound like something we could afford much to skimp on Progress or hope for good RNG when DP rolls for diminished results?

I'm looking at it from a purely mechanical side, and all I see is unnecessary work from me risking RNG from quest's mechanics for doing an action that doesn't seem like it would impact us much strategically regardless of how it goes.

When it comes to mechanical advantage I should note that R'hllor remembers his allies not just his enemies. You will not leave empty handed after helping him out.
 
You misunderstand.
The main actions we re about to send out most proficient assets on are fighting Court of Starts and counter-intriguing Devils.
Do these things sound like something we could afford much to skimp on Progress or hope for good RNG when DP rolls for diminished results?

I'm looking at it from a purely mechanical side, and all I see is unnecessary work from me risking RNG from quest's mechanics for doing an action that doesn't seem like it would impact us much strategically regardless of how it goes.
Not particularly, no, but consider this -- participating in this assault and potentially getting a bunch of Fire Fey would probably make fighting the Court of Stars easier on us. Additional XP for our champions, a lot of minions, etc. Hell, we can even bargain with R'hllor to back us in our coming war against the fey if we give him a good enough sacrifice. I certainly won't say no to divine fire backing our attack and smiting the Court of Stars.
 
When it comes to mechanical advantage I should note that R'hllor remembers his allies not just his enemies. You will not leave empty handed after helping him out.
Is that going to directly affect the Progress on all other actions taken during the month?
No?
Then it's not really the thing I was talking about.

I have no doubt we can snatch some Good Stuff™ from Ymeri-fighting.
I'm arguing against it because by quest's mechanics we take a hit on every action the people we send to Ymeri unless we take them off Qohor, and that place is strategically important to deal with.
 
Is that going to directly affect the Progress on all other actions taken during the month?
No?
Then it's not really the thing I was talking about.

I have no doubt we can snatch some Good Stuff™ from Ymeri-fighting.
I'm arguing against it because by quest's mechanics we take a hit on every action the people we send to Ymeri unless we take them off Qohor, and that place is strategically important to deal with.

Fair point, that sort of judgement call is for you guys to make. I'm glad this is getting player engagement. It's been too long since we had decisions with some weight to them.
 
When it comes to mechanical advantage I should note that R'hllor remembers his allies not just his enemies. You will not leave empty handed after helping him out.

Ok, this would be an incentive for some nice boons for the empire. A proposal, everyone:

[X] Pledge a Day of Fire on the day of the assault, wherein all Red Temples across the Major Cities (SD, Volantis, Braavos, the Sisters) would sacrifice to R'hllor (larder contents here, preferrably daemons) simultaneously in Mirrorcast to boost the assaulting forces
-[X] Offer to participate in the case of breach of Ymeri's defenses and time enough for you to reinforce her. You can't guarantee personal support through a long siege, though you will deploy assets at the start of the month to support her own efforts once you have determined what you can spare, but you would be inclined to face down Ymeri face to face if given the opportunity.
 
Is that going to directly affect the Progress on all other actions taken during the month?
No?
Then it's not really the thing I was talking about.

I have no doubt we can snatch some Good Stuff™ from Ymeri-fighting.
I'm arguing against it because by quest's mechanics we take a hit on every action the people we send to Ymeri unless we take them off Qohor, and that place is strategically important to deal with.
Conquering Qohor is less in the way of Progress Points and more in the way of killing everything in sight in the midst of a grand assault. What kind of penalties are you expecting here?
 
Conquering Qohor is less in the way of Progress Points and more in the way of killing everything in sight in the midst of a grand assault. What kind of penalties are you expecting here?
Misunderstanding here again?
Qohor is free action.

Main actions are Slavers' Bay and CoS.
depening on RAs we have done this month, we gonna assign more actions of less import, but we definitely are having some set on cleaning up the rest of Sarnor, and maybe Targ Isles. And/or finishing prevouslky assigned stuff, like braavosi swamps.
 
Back
Top