alid610
Light of the Revolution
- Location
- Pakistan
And she did mentally attack the president/ruler so dosent that get death penelty or jail for life?
If thats true then eternal imprisonment in Tartrus is going easy on her when death is on the table.
With This Ring (Young Justice SI) (Thread Twelve)
- Thread starter Mr Zoat
- Start date
- Status
And she did mentally attack the president/ruler so dosent that get death penelty or jail for life?
If thats true then eternal imprisonment in Tartrus is going easy on her when death is on the table.
- Location
- Hampden Park
How were you planning to kill her, exactly? And how certain are you it would stick?
The Grey Mage
Certified Team Flare Hater
- Location
- Parallel Universe 43-j
Isn't she immortal though?
She's immortal, can shapeshift, can alter immense amounts of land at will, teleport at will and is a being of fiction who's sustained by magic... The likely hood of anyone holding her is non existent without something that can completely neutralize her powers.
Killing immortal beings ... ask Paul nicely to be executioner and use the Sword of the Fallen? It ... might stick. (That's what we're calling the Sword of Second and Third right?)
Which makes that thought a bad one... Tartarus it is!
Well, has that ever come up in the original YJ canon? Because "mental attacks" are not exactly something real world law has ever had to concern itself with.
Pretty much any attack on the president is going to result in you winding up dead.
- Location
- Kansas
So, what will Paul need to do for Hades to get him to take a prisoner that isn't dead yet? Cause that isn't his normal MO.
Actually it is; many of the punishments in Greek Myth occur in Tartarus. It started as a prison for the Titans after all.
frozenchicken
Does not have a custom title.
Anyone else think this is just a convoluted way of letting OL see Melinoe again?
Stop: No - This Is Not Okay
- Location
- Australia
FTFY!
no - this is not okay
Hello there, everyone!
There are limits to the sort of advocacy of violence you can openly wish upon someone on this board, regardless of how downright unpleasant, awful, or otherwise deserving you may think they are. For the reference of everyone in this thread (and hello again, readers of WTR, fancy meeting you all here) the line is way before you start to advocate feeding someone through a woodchipper feet first in any given state of consciousness. @frustratedbuffa, @Godogma, please do not do this again in future. For everyone else, please be mindful of what you are posting, even when your temper is up.
There are limits to the sort of advocacy of violence you can openly wish upon someone on this board, regardless of how downright unpleasant, awful, or otherwise deserving you may think they are. For the reference of everyone in this thread (and hello again, readers of WTR, fancy meeting you all here) the line is way before you start to advocate feeding someone through a woodchipper feet first in any given state of consciousness. @frustratedbuffa, @Godogma, please do not do this again in future. For everyone else, please be mindful of what you are posting, even when your temper is up.
With that said, carry on, posters!
Oh good. Queeny will fit in perfectly on the forum.
Do those rules even apply to fictional characters?
Gratuitousness violence is a part of comic-book setting. If the Punisher can feed dudes into wood-chippers or set bears on them, then we should be free to talk about it here.
Edit: Yeah yeah, not the place to talk about mod rulings. Point still stands.
- Location
- Australia
Even if all this is true for Earth-16, Paul usually goes over his options at least mentally, going through his opponent's powers and seeing how he can or cannot overcome them.
Here he makes no effort to see how she could be fixed or rehabilitated, or pretty much any comment of her at all. Considering how this is his first opponent that is in custody after spending any amount of time wiping the floor with him, the fact that he completely bypasses his usual habits and goes straight to 'eternal stay in hell', it leads to unfortunate implications on just how much he believes his own argument.
Empiricist2
Let's play doctor!
- Location
- Baton Rouge
Diana's speech should be full Orange because it's coming from the ring
I think he second 'are' shouldn't be there.
Funny that this comes up so shortly after it being discussed in thread.
Warning: Warning
- Location
- The Hague
- Pronouns
- He/Him
warning
The Community Compact explicitly states that rule 2 applies to fictional and historical persons. While that application is somewhat relaxed in cases of fictional characters, about the time that people are talking about their preferred method of torturing a fictional character is about the time people should be told to get a grip. Because, seriously, get a grip.
As I recall this isn't the first time we've had to warn people against the advocacy of gratuitous violence in this thread, and to be perfectly honest I don't want to have to keep sending moderators in here to get people to chill out. I don't care about the time that Black Adam killed a whole bunch of people or the Sentry tore those guys in half or whatever messed up thing happened in Punisher MAX. SV has rules so just wind it all back a little, peeps.
iamnuff you can take a week off from this thread under rule 5. If you know not to go about these things in this way, just don't.
As I recall this isn't the first time we've had to warn people against the advocacy of gratuitous violence in this thread, and to be perfectly honest I don't want to have to keep sending moderators in here to get people to chill out. I don't care about the time that Black Adam killed a whole bunch of people or the Sentry tore those guys in half or whatever messed up thing happened in Punisher MAX. SV has rules so just wind it all back a little, peeps.
iamnuff you can take a week off from this thread under rule 5. If you know not to go about these things in this way, just don't.
- Pronouns
- she/her
I don't know. If he's flying her down himself, it seems like it absolutely is a starting point for further character development, redemption, therapy, and spreading that bloody CCG of his throughout the Greek-speaking world.
Edit: oh no, does the CCG count as a potential home for her? oh no
Hestia&theCourt
Turns out we're plural too.
- Location
- In transition
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Probably. The bigger problem is that if OL sticks her there, he'll never be able to play the game again.
If he stuck her in the game sure; not if he stuck her in Tartarus and taught her to play the game.
- Location
- Hampden Park
That only happens in ring-communication mode. Here it's making normal sound.
Thank you, corrected.
- Location
- madison
I think its more he doesn't think she can be rehabilitated, she isn't misguided she has an alien mindset that makes her immensely dangerous and enough power that she could do a lot of damage If she decided to follow the wrong story. For example lets say she makes NORAD act out Dr Strangelove. So since she can't be rehabilitated Paul has no desire to show her mercy since there is no return on it.
- Location
- Australia
Considering we see his thoughts and feelings, that should still be shown somewhere.
Atm he goes from treating everyone with "This is how things could be less shit for you and/or society, here's your chance to decide to be a better person." to "You fucked with me; eternal damnation for you."
pheonix89
Wants to be Seven Of Nine
- Location
- North American Plaguelands
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Possessing the CCG would make her play by Babylon Five rules. And one of the Babylon Five rules is that ancient inscrutable beings with powers beyond mortal ken manipulating us for their own inscrutable reason always lose. It takes a while, but they lose. Tricking her into possessing a work that doesn't allow her to win is a pretty good trick.
- Status