Changing Destiny (Kancolle)

Mention to FDR how the entire region between Chicago & Detroit had their industry shrivel and practically die by the '70s - '80s, killing the economy there for a time. Leave sealed briefing notes for future administrations to very adamantly support industries there, which back in 1940 were big enough to build entire warships. Literally a thousand miles away from the coastlines, where no WW2 carrier based 'bombers' could hope to reach. Aka, virtually immune to Abyssal attacks.
We still build ships in Wisconsin, you know. The Navy's new frigates are going to be built there.

As an aside, this once again runs into the problem of "Thompson does not have the sun total of human knowledge" shoved in his head. I personally could not begin to tell you why "the projects" went bad, or why manufacturing got offshored, besides high-level statements that are useless for forming policy. Thompson is unlikely to be any more knowledgeable.

I get the temptation to optimize things for the US, but it's not going to happen for good reasons Sky has already outlined, so kindly drop it.
 
@Sakuya's Butler always nice to meet a fellow Washingtonian!

Portland has an active shipyard as well although it is typically used for maintaining cruise ships like Pride of America, which often comes here for maintenance when Pearl is backlogged. The Navy knows they can use the yard as well as their reserve base is right next to it at Swan Island.

And just a side note, Portland has the second oldest official Fleet Week in the country! Only behind another PNW city, Seattle!
 
Maybe we should get that added to the Friendly Reminder. This has been a fairly consistent issue.
Lemme rephrase and/or drop the coup bits.

Detroit/Chicago is widely known public knowledge. Just watching the evening news occasionally, let alone a few PBS documentaries, would give you a general overview. Chicago's problems are literally that notorious. Quite literally the top 5 things I know about Chicago is: 1. Its windy. 2. Capone was an asshole & the Untouchables were badasses. 3. The Projects are hellholes. 4. Best damn pizza ever. 5. They dye the river green every year for St. Patrick's Day. I have to occasionally be reminded the Bears play there.

The 'rust belt' is taught about in middle school level US History classes covering the 1950-1980s. If you don't know about it, even vaguely, and were taught in the USA, I worry about your teachers. And again, I'm from WA state, yet know it from when I was a kid. Closer to the mid-West & East Coast, those lessons probably got hammered on even harder as moving industries 'cheaply' overseas infuriated a LOT of people there, from the '70s-'80s, who saw whole blocks upon blocks of factories be locked up and then abandoned wholesale. I might only know the barebones facts, but just commenting that 'its coming' will get gears turning if someone pays attention. And, historically, FDR wants the internal US economy going like a rocket to Mars.

-

As for the Great Lakes shipyards, yes, they do still exist.

Just vastly downsized, and at only a fraction of the industrial support infrastructure they had in the 1940s. That would be common knowledge to Thompson due to his OTL!Kancolle military position.

Most of the 'big' yards left in modern times are either on the Mississippi (very easy to sail right up to the yards), in Virginia (Newport News & Norfolk are both within shelling range of the coast, less than 6 miles iirc), Maine (Bath Iron Works, also within easy shelling distance of the coast), and so on. The only two yards left that would be surrounded by land for a couple hundred miles that could have shore batteries blasting Abyssals, is those up in the Great Lakes, and Bremerton (Puget Sound is a gauntlet, second only to the suicide run a fool would have to try that is the St. Lawerence River). Of those two, Bremerton is the only one big enough to construct carriers - no way in hell can you run a carrier the size of a Lexington, or bigger, up/down the St. Lawerence. Thompson, being a member of the modern Navy would know these facts. Intimately. Its his job. Especially post-Abyssals, who slaughtered the coastlines.

So its pretty much those two pre-existing yards, that the USA would be forced to rely on at first. Anything on the Mississippi COULD get moved much further inland, but that still means moving the yards. Something for a later date however.

Bremerton is pretty much maxed for the size it can get due to terrain. No big issues there. Forts Casey, Flagler, and Worden were already built by 1880s to cover the Admiralty Inlet entrance to Puget Sound from three sides, and were heavily updated in 1940-1941. Just mentioning the Abyssals to FDR would have him make sure the USN & Army keep those three gun batteries in operation for decades, rather then turning them into the state/national parks they are today. Thompson, prior to getting yanked back in time, likely saw them directly, or heard about them, getting reactivated - the three locations really are perfect for setting up a killbox that would have decimated entire fleets trying to force their way in. And that was merely with 1940s disappearing carriage shore guns. Post-Abyssals? In modern times? *shudders*

But the Great Lakes? Nobody, but nobody, that isn't Canada, has a prayer in the world of getting a hostile force into those lakes, without 95% of their forces dying to a man. Unless they nuke the USA first. Its the one location in the continental USA where, barring CVs & BBs, you can build anything the USA needs, and unless they have ICBMs, they can't stop you. That, is how protected their locations are naturally due to being so far inland, and how easily the USA could build added artificial defenses for said river & lakes.

Yet those shipyards were practically thrown away post-war, and whittled down even further over the decades. IIRC, at least 2/3rds the construction slips were backfilled in by 1970 and are now either housing or commercial districts.

All the above is middle school level knowledge. Not 'sum total of human knowledge', nor 'sum of college doctorate courses'. nor even 'sum of high school elective classes'.

Middle school.

I did that from memory, and a trip out to my garage to find a faded old report I did in 1991 in 7th grade, my parents had kept. It was in the pile of old homework they handed over, in binders no less (heh, parents), a few years ago. I didn't even bother to look at Google or Wikipedia.

However, as I will attempt to limit this to just this page, I will end this topic here.
 
Assuming of course that there weren't some War of 1812 Age of Sail Abbysals running around on the Great Lakes.
 
Tell me, why should Thompson be worried about Abyssals possibly attacking when right now, the US is at war with two foreign powers? Sure, we all assume something like that might happen bc this is a KC story, but what about Thompson? There's been no sign of them so far, but there are the textbook pictures of evil fascist dictatorships in a state of war with his country. All of the above you're talking about is post-war issues, and most likely won't be seen as a major concern until later.
 
Tell me, why should Thompson be worried about Abyssals possibly attacking when right now, the US is at war with two foreign powers?
Imagine being at war with Nazis and the Japanese.

Now add the risk of the abyssals attacking and killing everyone in the mix.

There is also personal fear in this, if I remeber correctly Thompson, before he became a TTK, came from background of commanding a missile destroyer, so he might have be caught in the opening of the abyssal war and that might have left a impression. And adding his experiences throughout the war....
 
And what sign is he seeing that indicates that the abyssals are going to be a threat? The only thing that I've really seen it that indicates the possibility of them being around is that shipgirls are around as well, and that's not that great of proof for that. At this moment, Thompson is focusing on the Axis powers, as he should. They are the clear and present danger, not preparing for something that as far as he knows, won't be an issue for decades.
 
Will we actualy find out why and how he was sent back eventually or is it just going to be a forgotten point we won't get an answer to?
 
Detroit/Chicago is widely known public knowledge. Just watching the evening news occasionally, let alone a few PBS documentaries, would give you a general overview. Chicago's problems are literally that notorious. Quite literally the top 5 things I know about Chicago is: 1. Its windy. 2. Capone was an asshole & the Untouchables were badasses. 3. The Projects are hellholes. 4. Best damn pizza ever. 5. They dye the river green every year for St. Patrick's Day. I have to occasionally be reminded the Bears play there.
3. Yes, and Thompson probably knows the projects are hellholes. He probably doesn't know much else about it, so can't offer much advice on the subject. Heck, I don't know that much, other than the response to the bad publicity for Cabrini-Green was to tear it down and kick the residents out on the streets and they still haven't rebuilt new units to make up for what they tore down. Big improvement, just kick the riff-raff out on the streets and say "Cabrini-Green is why we can't have nice public housing".
4. No arguments there.
5. The dye never seems to go away since the river is still a dark green in December or any other time I've taken the train to Chicago. Granted in March they dye it a brighter green, but it stays a dark murky green all year.
 
Imagine being at war with Nazis and the Japanese.

Now add the risk of the abyssals attacking and killing everyone in the mix.

There is also personal fear in this, if I remeber correctly Thompson, before he became a TTK, came from background of commanding a missile destroyer, so he might have be caught in the opening of the abyssal war and that might have left a impression. And adding his experiences throughout the war....

And what sign is he seeing that indicates that the abyssals are going to be a threat? The only thing that I've really seen it that indicates the possibility of them being around is that shipgirls are around as well, and that's not that great of proof for that. At this moment, Thompson is focusing on the Axis powers, as he should. They are the clear and present danger, not preparing for something that as far as he knows, won't be an issue for decades.


In a word, Utah.

Speaking to spirits aside, Thompson Knows that Shipgirls can manfest thanks to Utah.
This means he Knows that Abyssals Can manifest, Thanks to Utah
In point of a fact, an Abyssal very nearly Did manifest - Utah

It is not a merely theoretical risk anymore - it happened, and was only defused by pure luck.

And that's the one he knows about. He does not know about the state of ship spirits in other navies, especially Axis Navies, but he knows they are there.
He knows that their treatment on OTL caused many of them to go Abyssal; therefore, if the treatment remains the same, there is the risk that the next one will not be luckily defused.
And that's without anyone trying for it deliberately, Like Himmler and his Thule society buddies.

He has reason to be worried. The worry may not be rational; as mentioned, the Rational worry is the Axis, rather than the not-yet-seen abyssals, but worry is not necessarily rational, and the Axis is an easier threat to get a handle on, and therefore easier to dismiss mentally. Tha Abyss has the added fear of the unknown to make it mentally stickier and harder to let go of.
Plus, as he mentioned to Sara, ...they are his friends, still, in his own mind, even if in the current reality he hasn't met them; it's bad enough he is at war with them, but if they start Abyssalising on top of that?
Guilt isn't a rational emotion either.

As for the future knowledge thing?
I assume part of the reason he has been allowed to return to Saratoga is that all of his immediately useful, 'known' Knowledge has been picked up in debrifings, and he has standing directives to log and report (probably in person only due to security issues) the sort of stuff that pops up unbidden, the "I didn't know that I knew that" stuff as and when it happens, just in case it turns out to be useful even though it may be so mentally trivial to Thompson that he doesn't realise it's there til he gets a stray thought.
 
I'm fully expecting the first Abyssal to be summoned by Germany after Himmler does some occult ritual. Most likely when when the war in Russia starts turning and Nazi Germany begins looking for desperate measures.
 
and most likely won't be seen as a major concern until later.
I mean there's the Detroit Race Riots in 43, but that's so much an institutional racism problem that a *segregated* army had to tell DPD to fakking chill.
Speaking to spirits aside, Thompson Knows that Shipgirls can manfest thanks to Utah.
The Illiad, la? Also he could see the girls before they manifested, knowing ahead of future times that the ships can "Manifest," because he had English conversations with them over the wireless lel.
 
Re: knowing how they ended up in the past

Much as with Purple Phoenix, we strongly believe that some mysteries are often better left *as* mysteries. It loses the impact if you have some scene of a curiously bat-shaped alien musing over how they're bored and want some entertainment by playing with the human squishies. If the story is about how the people adapt to their situation, it often doesn't need to be explained.

Sometimes it works better to just be in the dark like the characters. And move forward anyway.

To us, anyway :V
 
Last edited:
I agree. It doesn't strike me as something that has to be from a conscious actor, and it doesn't seem to be relevant to the story.
 
tbh I don't really care as to why Thompson ended up in the past, it was a thing that happened, and we ain't gonna know why it did.
I am perfectly happy with not knowing the why or how.
 
I'm sorry, but your attempt to get the last word in is flatly rejected.

Detroit/Chicago is widely known public knowledge. Just watching the evening news occasionally, let alone a few PBS documentaries, would give you a general overview. Chicago's problems are literally that notorious. Quite literally the top 5 things I know about Chicago is: 1. Its windy. 2. Capone was an asshole & the Untouchables were badasses. 3. The Projects are hellholes. 4. Best damn pizza ever. 5. They dye the river green every year for St. Patrick's Day. I have to occasionally be reminded the Bears play there.

The 'rust belt' is taught about in middle school level US History classes covering the 1950-1980s. If you don't know about it, even vaguely, and were taught in the USA, I worry about your teachers. And again, I'm from WA state, yet know it from when I was a kid. Closer to the mid-West & East Coast, those lessons probably got hammered on even harder as moving industries 'cheaply' overseas infuriated a LOT of people there, from the '70s-'80s, who saw whole blocks upon blocks of factories be locked up and then abandoned wholesale. I might only know the barebones facts, but just commenting that 'its coming' will get gears turning if someone pays attention. And, historically, FDR wants the internal US economy going like a rocket to Mars.
Y'know, if you had read my posts instead of assuming that I know nothing about this subject you might have noticed I distinctly said that I know precisely what the problems you outlined are. I can tell you about the declining fortunes of Detroit, I can tell you about the hellhole that was 1970s New York, I can tell you about the absolute shitshow that's been public housing here in the States and in Europe, I can even point to some of the causes like manufacturing going overseas in search of cheaper labor; the trends of suburbanization, white flight, and the racism inherent in such.

However, and this is the point I was trying to get across to you, is that all of this is useless for informing policy. Oh, yeah, great, we can tell FDR about all this. What the hell is he supposed to do without being told why that all happened? And in the kind of excruciating detail that's normally reserved for multiple papers; not that all that detail will make it to the President's desk, but anything that ends up there has had a metric fuckton of thought and planning put into it.

As such, it falls under Sky's general moratorium on Thompson providing information outside his expertise. He's a naval officer, not a socioeconomic historian. He doesn't know nearly enough to be useful on these topics. Period. End of story. Shut up about it, and I do mean shut up. Don't try a last word gambit by dumping another wall of text in and then attempting to stop. Just stop.

As for the Great Lakes shipyards, yes, they do still exist.

Just vastly downsized, and at only a fraction of the industrial support infrastructure they had in the 1940s. That would be common knowledge to Thompson due to his OTL!Kancolle military position.

Most of the 'big' yards left in modern times are either on the Mississippi (very easy to sail right up to the yards), in Virginia (Newport News & Norfolk are both within shelling range of the coast, less than 6 miles iirc), Maine (Bath Iron Works, also within easy shelling distance of the coast), and so on. The only two yards left that would be surrounded by land for a couple hundred miles that could have shore batteries blasting Abyssals, is those up in the Great Lakes, and Bremerton (Puget Sound is a gauntlet, second only to the suicide run a fool would have to try that is the St. Lawerence River). Of those two, Bremerton is the only one big enough to construct carriers - no way in hell can you run a carrier the size of a Lexington, or bigger, up/down the St. Lawerence. Thompson, being a member of the modern Navy would know these facts. Intimately. Its his job. Especially post-Abyssals, who slaughtered the coastlines.

So its pretty much those two pre-existing yards, that the USA would be forced to rely on at first. Anything on the Mississippi COULD get moved much further inland, but that still means moving the yards. Something for a later date however.

Bremerton is pretty much maxed for the size it can get due to terrain. No big issues there. Forts Casey, Flagler, and Worden were already built by 1880s to cover the Admiralty Inlet entrance to Puget Sound from three sides, and were heavily updated in 1940-1941. Just mentioning the Abyssals to FDR would have him make sure the USN & Army keep those three gun batteries in operation for decades, rather then turning them into the state/national parks they are today. Thompson, prior to getting yanked back in time, likely saw them directly, or heard about them, getting reactivated - the three locations really are perfect for setting up a killbox that would have decimated entire fleets trying to force their way in. And that was merely with 1940s disappearing carriage shore guns. Post-Abyssals? In modern times? *shudders*

But the Great Lakes? Nobody, but nobody, that isn't Canada, has a prayer in the world of getting a hostile force into those lakes, without 95% of their forces dying to a man. Unless they nuke the USA first. Its the one location in the continental USA where, barring CVs & BBs, you can build anything the USA needs, and unless they have ICBMs, they can't stop you. That, is how protected their locations are naturally due to being so far inland, and how easily the USA could build added artificial defenses for said river & lakes.

Yet those shipyards were practically thrown away post-war, and whittled down even further over the decades. IIRC, at least 2/3rds the construction slips were backfilled in by 1970 and are now either housing or commercial districts.

All the above is middle school level knowledge. Not 'sum total of human knowledge', nor 'sum of college doctorate courses'. nor even 'sum of high school elective classes'.

Middle school.

I did that from memory, and a trip out to my garage to find a faded old report I did in 1991 in 7th grade, my parents had kept. It was in the pile of old homework they handed over, in binders no less (heh, parents), a few years ago. I didn't even bother to look at Google or Wikipedia.

However, as I will attempt to limit this to just this page, I will end this topic here.
Again: as I stated wrt to the previous topics you've raised, knowing that there's a problem is not enough. Yes, Thompson would absolutely know of the problems the US Navy is facing wrt to its shipbuilding infrastructure. Obviously. I know of these problems, thank you very much.

The problem is, again, knowing what the problem is is not enough. Sure, Thompson has an easier time here because he can point to the Abyssals and the strategic problem they raise as a reason. However, Roosevelt, or someone in the Executive Branch, is going to question why the hell all this capacity up and evaporated - and even if Thompson can answer that, that leads to a new problem: all of that infrastructure evaporated for very good and rather hard to change reasons. Namely, that it wasn't being used. Part of it was just that, without WW2 levels of warship orders, not everyone could stay open - a lot of Navy-owned shipyards closed in the 1960s for precisely this reason. The bigger problem was that American civilian shipyards got outcompeted by Japanese, and the Korean and Chinese.

So in essence Thompson is asking the United States Government to maintain, in peacetime, a vast excess of shipbuilding capacity, that's not being used, on the government dime, for the next seventy years. Either directly or by extreme protectionist measures for the civilian industry. Through the Cold War, where every dollar has to be spent on something to keep up with the Soviets, and then after the Cold War when budgets contract even further.

Thompson can argue this to Roosevelt until he's blue in the face. By probably the 1980s even if he succeeds Thompson will be retired, and a new administration will come in and wonder what the hell they're spending all this money on nothing for and sell off the land anyway. And, frankly, it would be the right decision.

As an aside, fixed fortifications? Are you kidding me? In this day and age.
 
Thompson can argue this to Roosevelt until he's blue in the face. By probably the 1980s even if he succeeds Thompson will be retired, and a new administration will come in and wonder what the hell they're spending all this money on nothing for and sell off the land anyway. And, frankly, it would be the right decision.
And even if he succeeded with FDR, who knows if the next administration would be as accommodating.
 
I think it's reasonable that Thompson will have been debriefed on myriad topics so that the 40s USA has a good idea of what the situation was in the 21st century and what he knows about how things got from where they are to where they would be.

However, that is not likely to include 'here is a master plan to avoid those problems' and what he sees as problems may not be seen as either something to be addressed now, or even necessarily as problems. A three generation change in perspectives is going to matter. Many things he sees as normal might be repugnant to many of his 1940s contemporaries.

Thompson may know that, for example, that the War on Drugs did not in fact stamp out drug use any more than Prohibition stamped out alcohol consumption. However, Roosevelt is not going to do anything about it and by the time it becomes an issue (assuming it ever does because history is already diverging), the administration at that time will make its own decision - which may be 'we know that that won't work, but what else do we do?' or 'well clearly they just didn't carry it out right, but forewarned, we can do better'.
 
I forget if it was Halsey or Nimitz, but at least one of them qualified as an observer rather than a pilot to get command of a carrier.
It was Nimitz. Halsey took the full course to earn his wings.
Nimitz never commanded a carrier...his only major command (O-6 command of a large ship of cruiser size and above) was Augusta. Halsey commanded Sara and A-Hole Ernie commanded Lex. Leahy commanded New Mexico for a year, and Spruance commanded Mississippi.
 
Phew, finally caught up. Found this great story and binged through all the pages. Now I too can join at bullying Sky!

www.pixiv.net

サラトガさん

2021/12/30 ワンドロより
Now to read Holding the Line.
 
Back
Top