- Location
- Missouri
Because it's about dignity.
Not dignity as some abstract fundamental right to have pride, but rather, dignity as the concept of having the natural right of being treated as a human, regardless of circumstances.
The cultist might have been mad, she might have had the intention to commit evil and certainly deserved grave punishment. That said, by being dismissive of her pain, by ignoring her broken arm and already treating her like a walking corpse, our Inquisitors denied her dignity. They denied her humanity.
This act of dehumanization shows a critical crack within the institution of the Inquisition. If they make a habit of dehumanizing their targets, then they no longer give their actions the self-reflection and judgement that they desperately need. The Inquisition wields a tremendous amount of power. They can easily decree the life or death of many. As such, it is crucial that they are at every moment aware of their actions, and asking themselves - Is this truly necessary? Is this truly the right choice?
When you dehumanize your opponents, or by default put your goals above any means you might employ, then you do not do that. She becomes "just a cultist", not "just a human who coveted with demons". There is a huge difference between the two, because one is a caricature, and the other is a living being with emotions and sapience - the same kind of being you are. To kill a cultist is easy. To kill a human, even when the circumstances might justify it, is not.
If the Inquisition cannot be bothered to do something as simple as ensure that their prisoners do not have to suffer unduly, then why should we trust them with the power to spy and intervene in the life of Imperial citizens.
Now I understand your point here, but I have to say that when a random person who is debasing themselves before the Great Dark and sacrificing their own dignity for the amusement of the Abyss so that it will do what they want, I feel like that whole argument is lost as they no longer have that dignity. There is also the fact that when a cultist is in the middle of some spooky-ass chant that causes the paint to literally peel off the walls, it doesn't really engender feelings of comradery or basic human rights as no one wants to see themselves in such a dark mirror. Usually, you tend to try to interrupt said spooky chanting and end the threat before it reaches a certain point, don't go full Dumbledore on this man, you should never go full Dumbledore.