Beneath Black Cloaks
Eighth Day of the Seventh Month 293 AC
The helmet clanged against stone, the sound shockingly loud in the stillness of the small room. "What the fuck did the North fight for if we're all back to crawling before dragons!" said Benjen Stark, First Ranger of the Night's Watch, youngest son of Rickard Stark lord of Winterfell, and he hated himself for them. He hated that he had lost control before his bothers, he hated that he had spoken of the oaths to kith and kin though he should have none, though he deserved none. Most of all he hated that he sounded pleading.
Again silence reigned save for the slow drip of melting ice sliding off Benjen's mail and on to the stone floor. The firelight threw wavering shadows onto the faces of all present—Ranger, Commander, and the ancient Maester of the Watch. And he the youngest as ever, a faint shiver of self-depreciating humor offered feeble refuge to a mind in turmoil.
The Old Bear's expression was stern as he had seen it a thousand times before when chiding one brother or another for failing to uphold their oath in word and deed. He opened his mouth to answer, then to the younger man's surprise he closed it and sighed and shrugged off his black cloak and hung it near the door. "It will be there waiting for me when we are done talking," he explained, then looking towards the First Ranger he added: "You look cold in yours, Ben. Maybe you should leave it by the fire for a while."
Subtlety was not a word often used to describe Jeor Mormont, not indeed any other of that house, but the message was clear. In this place and for a little while they would speak as men and not as brothers of the Watch.
Feeling as unbalanced as a stripling boy talking to his father, Benjen did as he was asked.
"I think I'll keep mine, the cold bites keenest into old bones," the Maester said, his smile deepening the web of lines that crisscrossed his face. "Count it a deed done in spirit."
A weak shaky laugh passed Benjen's lips, much to his further surprise. He did not think he had it in him.
"I can't answer why every man in the North rebelled," the Old Bear began. "I can make some fair guesses, but that's neither here nor there. What I can tell you for certain, Ben, is why I would have fought the Mad King if I hadn't already taken the vows. I would have fought because he made a mockery of justice before men and gods, because he proved by his deeds that had not the wits to rule a kennel much less a kingdom."
"Oh but Rhaegar was the Silver Prince, perfect as you please, and his brother is the bloody Last Hero come again, is he?" again the anger surged to Benjen's lips unbidden like a black bubbling tide.
"I never met Rhaegar, though we exchanged letters a few times," Maester Aemon replied softly. "He seemed to me a man who lived too often in tales and not in the world that is, looking to history and prophecy for answers and letting the now slip by. In that he appeared no more perfect to me than any other man." His words held not a whisper of rebuke, only kindness. With a sigh he added, "Sometimes I wonder if I should have guessed what passed through his mind to offer some counsel to save him from himself."
"Lyanna was willing. I knew, I
helped her..." Benjen could not believe the words he had just spoken, the secret he had kept for so long from all save Ned.
Gods, he had just blurted it out like he was some child brought to task. He opened his mouth to speak but no words came out.
"Many had though she went willingly," Jeor Mormont replied at length. "But I'd not say she was willing at the end. Think it through, would she had stayed in godsdamned
Dorne meek as a dove when news came of the evil that had been done to her father and bother?"
"I don't..." He could not being himself to say it. He could not say he did not know Lyanna, that he did not trust her, even after all these years. "No, no she wouldn't."
"The war would have been fought some other way," Aemon interjected, voice just as soft as before but firm for all that. "T'was like a boulder rolling down hill and all the Seven Kingdoms in its path. The only thing that might have been different would have been if the rebel lords would have quarreled among themselves, and mayhap Aerys would have won his bloody victory from the fray. I cannot imagine truly imagine what he would have done then, but you can be sure his vengeance would have been savage, enough to sow the seeds of another rebellion among all right-thinking men. The evils of the war are not yours to bear anymore than they are Lady Lyanna's. You were all as children then, and for that you suffered."
"I was five-and-ten, near enough a man," Benjen answered stubbornly.
"Perhaps that is so," the old Maester shrugged. "Five-and-ten seems a much smaller number when you have seen four-score more years than that."
Silence reigned for a moment as the First Ranger tried to see himself as the other men must, but found that he could not, regret clung closer to him than his own shadow. To change the subject he said: "
He is only two years older than that, the Dragon King. Do you say he is a boy?"
"I would not dare hazard a guess for I know him little," Aemon seemed to shrink inside himself ever so slightly, though perhaps it was but a trick of the light. "But this I can say for certain—he has his own challenges as we have ours, and none of us have the luxury of a future that will move as we expect."
Slowly, almost painfully, Benjen nodded.
"Best get out there and make sure we and the Seven Kingdoms have a future at all," the Old Bear said, and though his words were grim the tone was resolute, almost cheerful.
OOC: Well here you go, a look into not only Benjen's character but indirectly Aemon and Jeor's too.