Remove ads

Warhammer Fantasy: Divided Loyalties - an Advisor's Quest

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Voting is open
Reader mode
If it does apply we need to do it, using the eye is the single most important roll in the coming battle, getting a 1 would be a disaster
 
BoneyM said:
The last 20% or so is about a 45-degree incline, but the second-to-last 20% is pretty close to being a sheer cliff.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
So, that actually makes me think that defending the Wyvern Caves would be possible. The only problem would be if the orcs have siege weaponry, or a lot of fliers. Even then, charging a fortified position up a 45-degree slope, after climbing a cliff, into a whole bunch of crossbows... I doubt even orcs would consider that fun. That said, we don't know how much area would have to be defended, and getting material and forces there would be a trick, since I imagine some routes through Zilfin to the Caves are still full of poison gas. And, we'd have to kill them all the conventional way, which would be rather tiring. Still, worth considering.
 
Come to think of it, "Battle of the Caldera" doesn't quite describe the past day. Aside from the bit of action at the start, the vast majority of the fighting didn't happen in the Caldera.

Suppose it'd be more accurate to call it "Battle/Reclamation of Karak Eight Peaks."


Jyn Ryvia said:
anyone else have ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I'd probably stick around with Belegar. Also uninterested in a College, but Karak Drazh will be pretty drained after this battle. Maybe if we help things along we'll see another Hold reclaimed, or at least the Red Fang crippled to the point that it'll be generations before they're a threat.

Not to mention we still have so much more to research and study here.
 
Jyn Ryvia said:
So assuming we win.

while I don't see us as done by any level, (take K8P's was the first part, keeping and stabilising is the second.) I can see the future going in a few ways.

1: one we stay on the council. and keep in the peaks mostly full time. work on K8P college and the dwarf cold war ( hopeful cold war anyways)

I don't really want to do the College, the more I think about it, the more boring it seems.

2: we step back a bit, possibly give the loremaster job to Kragg if he fully jumps on bord the Belger train. we will still be around a lot as this is where our towers* is. but we will have room to do other stuff.


what I can see as possible things to happen is..

Empire: with Striland and K8P's we probably have a bit of a rep for dealing with Provence size crises. and might be asked nicely* to come back for a while to deal with something.

whats the posable difficulty increases?
--- incompetent boss
--- active problems rather then neutral-ish (Stirland) or offence ( K8P) we will start off on the back foot rather than the ones making the first move.

Dwarf: Get asked to help with another Hold as we did so much for K8P's

---- more traditional king, not so much that he couldn't ask for man help, but we can't really get away with what we can in K8P's because of our relationship with King-Bro.

Elves: we go straight for the internship and then work from there.

--- inherently elves are higher level, we will be working in an environment where +20 is constered standard competence at your job.

Bretonnia? : long shot, but maybe go look at those damsels and their ability to use two or more lores.

---- we will be going into a mystery we don't even know where to start.

--- Misogyny, its bretonnia.

Skink turns up on our doorstep politely telling us that an ancient stone tablet said we have to talk with a magic frog.

---- WTF

anyone else have ideas?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Building up more satrapies in the Border Princes for Karak Eight Peaks and generally working towards improving the stability of the area between the Skull and Blood Rivers and Karak Eight Peaks and Barak Varr. It'd be a long term, and very beneficial option that keeps us close to home in Karak Eight Peaks.
 
Quest said:
@BoneyM there was that one gold spell that Johann used to help the dwarven artillery crews. Would that be any helpful in firing the Eye of Gazul?

If yes, how much does Math think it'd help?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

No. There's nothing to guide. You point it in a direction and turn it on.

Chimeraguard said:
Come to think of it, "Battle of the Caldera" doesn't quite describe the past day. Aside from the bit of action at the start, the vast majority of the fighting didn't happen in the Caldera.

Suppose it'd be more accurate to call it "Battle/Reclamation of Karak Eight Peaks."
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

I named it before all the dominos started falling. Battle for the Caldera might be a better fit.
 
BungieONI said:
Building up more satrapies in the Border Princes for Karak Eight Peaks and generally working towards improving the stability of the area between the Skull and Blood Rivers and Karak Eight Peaks and Barak Varr. It'd be a long term, and very beneficial option that keeps us close to home in Karak Eight Peaks.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Probably should focus more on between the Skull and the Howling. Between the Howling and the Blood is Iron Rock, which might be a harder nut to crack than Black Crag.
 
Jyn Ryvia said:
Skink turns up on our doorstep politely telling us that an ancient stone tablet said we have to talk with a magic frog.

---- WTF
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Actually, I kinda really want to see this happen, because that might lead to us showing off Av for the Slann, who could probably use it best. We might also get to study Old Ones tech which would be awesome as fuck.
 
Mopman43 said:
Probably should focus more on between the Skull and the Howling. Between the Howling and the Blood is Iron Rock, which might be a harder nut to crack than Black Crag.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
This is true, though I'm most familiar with the geography around Iron Rock since I was looking at it recently which is why that was my first suggestion.
 
[X] FIRST LINE: Caldera
[X] SECOND LINE: Withdraw
[X] THIRD LINE: Eastern Valley

We've been slavering after our weaponised mountain ever since we settled in here - let's get our narrative money's worth.
 
You know, I bet our resident runelords could throw some barriers making it harder for the Orks to exit the tower kill zone in the conventional artillery phase. Anything that steers the Orks out of the safe bits would help. Hell, just seeding the Caldera with caltrop equivalents would be huge—slow down the leading edge of the charge and we'd have way more Orks grouped up in the death zone when it's fry time.
 
Reynal said:
You know, I bet our resident runelords could throw some barriers making it harder for the Orks to exit the tower kill zone in the conventional artillery phase. Anything that steers the Orks out of the safe bits would help. Hell, just seeding the Caldera with caltrop equivalents would be huge—slow down the leading edge of the charge and we'd have way more Orks grouped up in the death zone when it's fry time.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
It's hard to set anything up in only a few hours that'll cover a sufficiently large area to matter.

If we had Lord Magister Jade Wizards or something, I'd have suggested a Ritual-boosted Father of Thorns.
 
picklepikkl said:
I don't actually believe this. I think it's pretty likely that, if we choose to hold the line and keep the orc forces trapped in range of the citadel, that they will not be able to break through before our double runelord + heavy artillery + air support devastate them. Given the limited frontage of the mountain entrances and the fact that the Waaagh will have just had a sizable portion of its constituents blotted out by the Eye of Gazul, I am pretty sure we can break their morale.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
The two options seem like a pretty straightforward 'hold land at cost of Dwarven lives' and 'give up land to preserve Dwarven lives' choice.

I don't think the Runelords can yeet rune-magic over to Mhonar and Karagril from the Citadel. They couldn't during the Broken Toof YOLO. We also know we can't Eye them once they reach Mhonar and Karagril.
Redshirt Army said:
Of course. But the zone between "safe from our mountain because it's in the citadel's shadow" and "far enough away from artillery to be safe" is going to be very narrow if it exists at all, and crucially, the orcs don't know about the mountain to know they need to thread that needle.

Odds are that they'll charge at Karagril, the place they see as theirs and home to those ratties they want to take revenge on, instead of fruitlessly rushing at the sheer cliff that is the approach to the Citadel, but the potshots we take at them may cause them to switch their primary target to the Citadel.

Either way, whichever they charge at, they'll be exposed to artillery on the approach. Being quite wise in the ways of applied brutality, they'll very quickly grasp that rushing in single file isn't going to cut it, so they'll park outside of the artillery and wind up for a knockout punch.

It's hypothetically possible that some amount of them will poke at the other mountains while this is happening, although it's not that likely due to the lack of an obvious fight, with Zilfin being the primary contender on account of some of them potentially wanting to tussle with a dragon.

It seems unlikely to me that these piecemeal efforts will make any significant progress on mining open the entrances to those mountains if they occur at all - if by some stroke of luck they do manage to pry Zilfin (or Yar, or Mhonar) open before enough of them accumulate for the rush on Karagril or the Citadel, it should be obvious to Mathilde due to the theatre level movements swiveling towards that peak, so we'll just fire the Eye early and thus buy time to re-seal the mountain.

Otherwise, if things go as I'd expect them to, we should wait to fire the Eye right for when the first mass attack on Zilfin or the Citadel launches that we don't expect to be easily turned away by the artillery.

If we're very, very unlucky, this should still buy enough time for ~25% or so of the enemy force to be in the killzone, and has decent chances of decapitating their leadership. Effectiveness goes up from there on better rolls.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I'm pretty sure the update gave us the number '3%' if we fire almost before they reach the safety of the caldera lip? Not '25% if we're really unlucky.'
 
Guile said:
I'm pretty sure the update gave us the number '3%' if we fire almost before the reach the safety of the caldera lip? Not '25% if we're really unlucky.'
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
That's if they constantly stream right for the Citadel as soon as they get through.

If they pause to bunch up so that some will make it past the Citadel's artillery, we could get more.
 
Chimeraguard said:
Come to think of it, "Battle of the Caldera" doesn't quite describe the past day. Aside from the bit of action at the start, the vast majority of the fighting didn't happen in the Caldera.

Suppose it'd be more accurate to call it "Battle/Reclamation of Karak Eight Peaks."



I'd probably stick around with Belegar. Also uninterested in a College, but Karak Drazh will be pretty drained after this battle. Maybe if we help things along we'll see another Hold reclaimed, or at least the Red Fang crippled to the point that it'll be generations before they're a threat.

Not to mention we still have so much more to research and study here.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I think I'm just mostly bored with Dwarfs, I miss the intrigue panics and paranoia of the early days that Dwarfs are just to straight forward to incite.

tis why I want to play in the empire and elven lands more.

(for the sake of transparency, I also was against staying in K8P to begin with. though I've warmed up to it a bit. just wish we didn't pick being on the council and where just the local wizard that help when she was around and disappeared every few years on a adventure)
 
Guile said:
The two options seem like a pretty straightforward 'hold land at cost of Dwarven lives' and 'give up land to preserve Dwarven lives' choice.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
The catch being, of course, that if we give up the land we'll inevitably be spending dwarven lives to get it back.

The big question is which of these two options is buying land at the worse rate.
 
I think we are to invested in K8P to leave now we might take a turn or two off for research and training but that is still years away at this point.
 
[X] FIRST LINE: Caldera
[X] SECOND LINE: Hold
[X] THIRD LINE: Eastern Valley

@BoneyM will we be able to extricate the holding forces via gyrocopters if things get too hot?
 
Guile said:
The two options seem like a pretty straightforward 'hold land at cost of Dwarven lives' and 'give up land to preserve Dwarven lives' choice.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Sure, but giving up the land to prevent immediate death won't necessarily result in less total death - because we're still going to be fighting those forces eventually, and conceding the most defensible positions in order to buy time means we're instead defending somewhere somewhat less defensible.
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Voting is open
Remove ads
Back
Top