Voting is open
Here's another thing to consider, at what point in this civil war do they start feeling the pinch from the lack of food? Even if by some miracle they wrap up the civil war tomorrow, that's not a lot of time for having demobilization and getting everyone back to their field so that they can take care of their crops and then harvest them.

When does the pinch from lack of food kick in for Victoria?
 
They are also gonna want to rebuild there army while there economy is ruined, food is lacking, no industries to speak of, and lets not talk about a Victoria navy as its not a thing anymore and wont be anything in the future

That is why i want bandits and pirates to mess with the Victoria to give them on more problem to deal with
 
Here's another thing to consider, at what point in this civil war do they start feeling the pinch from the lack of food?
[deadpan]

About three months ago.

It's already happening to them; the war has already critically disrupted the Fall 2075 harvest and ensured that there will be a famine in their territory.

What the bad rolls ensure is that Blackwell will be forced to keep militias in the field, probably into and through the spring planting season, further amplifying the effects.

It makes it very hard to tell what anyone is thinking, which is going to be a huge problem in dealing with Victorian refugees. Their survival mechanism is "tell the men with guns what they want to hear", so the whole concept of truth is a rare luxury reserved for your nearest and dearest.

Corruption is going to be an issue, because any police officer or government clerk can simply demand bribes from them. Extorting these people is going to be obscenely easy.
On the other hand, getting them to denounce people is also easy, and while generalizing that concept to "report members of the occupying forces to other members of the occupying forces" may be abit of a stretch for them, It may cancel out if you plan for it.

I propose that we instead call Russia's catspaw "Cladem" as that translates into English as "Defeat" or "disaster".
I say we stick with the perfectly good plain-English "Defeatia."
 
Last edited:
I think he's really experiencing buyer's remorse with Victoria right now.
No he isnt. Why would he? He didnt BUY Victoria, he got them for free.

To date, Alexander has invested nothing of significance in Victoria. Some technical advisors, a lot of intelligence and intelligence agents. A couple arms shipments over four decades, including junk like T-34s. Rounding error stuff. When the Vics were preparing to declare war on the Commonwealth, Alex didnt buy them weapons; he made them pay for their own weapons from California, and made California give them a discount.

In return, he has had them terrorize the Eastern US and Canada for forty years.Used them to cripple the NCR.
Even Imperial Russian involvement in the real Vic economy primarily comprised of corporations taking over old US/Canadian/Chinese projects, and operating them at a profit.For decades.

If Victoria cripple themselves to hurt us, its a net profit to him.
If he walked away today, if Victoria crashed and burned today, it would still have been a wildly successful, wildly profitable scheme for him.


There is some obvious stuff like giving weapons and supplies to their opposition, starting an offensive against them and intelligence operations. But I question the value of that. They already lost almost the entirety of their army, are fighting a civil war and were forced to sign a peace treaty that made Brest-Litovsk look soft by comparison. What exactly would we gain by further undermining them?
Pretty much.

The lowhanging fruit with regards to damaging Victorian recovery speed has been plucked with the results of Operation Foil. Anything else would require increasing investments of both resources and PR and goodwill on our parts, as well as escalating levels of collateral damage and human misery on the part of the Vic population.

Some things are just not worth it.
Part of our peace treaty involved not supplying or helping the Crusaders in any way, and trying to do so would torpedo popular support for our government anyway. Our big thing to screw with Victoria will probably be exploiting the peace treaty to turn them into a captive market until they tear up said peace treaty. We kinda need the money from that to help fuel our industrialization and militarization programs.
This.
The Crusaders have an especially vile reputation among the already terrible reputations of Victoria's assorted military forces.
No one can help them as a matter of realpolitik without being tainted by association.

Its like when the US was giving diplomatic and intelligence support to the Khmer Rouge because they were fighting Vietnam.
After they killed 3 million people in the Cambodian Genocides.


I don't understand why people are arguing for Victoria rebuilding to threaten us. If Blackwell had won immediately, they might have been able to pose a challenge, but the nation that emerges from this war is going to be in ruins.
Because they are ideologues who are backed by a superpower.
Targeted aid and technical advisors, coupled to the Victoria regime's sense of mission, could regenerate post-war military capability pretty quickly. The economic capacity and population to wield that capability is much more variable, and depends on how much Vic ideology is willing to bend to reality.

Its been done IRL, with both small and large countries post-WW2. Both China and Israel went from civil war to nuclear power in less than twenty years, with Soviet and French help respectively. France went from occupied WW2 country that was bombed to rubble to its first nuclear test in 15 years. Nevermind West Germany.
I think that just about the only faction capable of putting a significant dent in Victoria by exploiting the civil war is the Free City of New York- they have got to be considering it.
Besides extending their intelligence network and meticulously monitoring any fighting to make sure its not coming their way, up to and possibly including daily satellite and drone overflights? They are going to be dealing with a refugee problem on their shared land border(and sea borders) with Victoria, and will be racing to expand down the eastern seaboard through lower Pennsylvania,New Jersey, Delaware and Maryland.

And they are rearming to boot.

I doubt they have the effort to spare, and wont want to give Blackwell or the Crusaders propaganda fodder anyway.
Furthermore, the Crusaders are explicitly some of those guys who used to stage cross-border razziahs into PA and the Appalachians as training missions to blood the troops. Given that FCNY is looking to expand into, or at least establish strong influence there, any aid would be a bad look.

Do note however that the GM has previously stated that the FCNY has broadcast networks dedicated to beaming news INTO Victoria, and has for most of the last three decades, almost as soon as they could afford it. The Inquisitors tried to jam them early on and basically got crushed by the combination of money and modern technology.

The Inquisitors are reliant on the internal broadcast system to control the population, which is a key advantage over the Crusaders.
But they are not the only purveyors of information on the airwaves, and FCNY has no incentive to censor anything about the war.

An entire war where FCNY news proves to be more accurate and timely than Vic radio, where people rely on FCNY radio for literally lifesaving info, is going to critically damage Vic media credibility among the local population.
That is likely to be a medium to longterm Vic problem if Blackwell wins.


Yes absolutely. Even if they don't, is there anything stopping them from taking control of everything up to the border with Victoria? Without the the threat of the Victorians they have nothing stopping them from rearming as they've got the money and people to do so. Wasn't the Free city of New York super cramped as well? So yeah New York probably already has a couple of new suburbs.
The people living there. Its not empty.
FCNY is not Victoria; cant just walk in and declare the clay yours.

Good point about the CMC's number problem. I do wonder if they are really just 2 divisions against a whole country though...
Two mechanized divisions armed with T-55s and BMPs; given they actually had a professional logistics doctrine for the CMC, assume they are a little bigger than standard Army divisions to account for the logistics train. 12-13k, say, instead of 10.
So call that 20-25k for two divisions.

Abraham Division took around 20,000 men from Buffalo when they left the city.
Assume David Division acquired that same number in conscripts. Of that combined 30,000 troops number they could have raised two regular Army divisions of 10k each, with the rest being forced into a logistics role. Especially given all the techs and logistics workers they looted from Buffalo.

45,000 combat troops. 20,000 logistics.
They really could win a civil war with that many troops. IF they could secure a reliable logistics supply line
ISIS almost bumrushed Iraq and Syria with those numbers.
 
Last edited:
Two mechanized divisions armed with T-55s and BMPs; given they actually had a professional logistics doctrine for the CMC, assume they are a little bigger than standard Army divisions to account for the logistics train. 12-13k, say, instead of 10.
So call that 20-25k for two divisions.

Abraham Division took around 20,000 men from Buffalo when they left the city.
Assume David Division acquired maybe half that in conscripts. Of that combined 30,000 troops number they could have raised two regular Army divisions of 10k each, with the rest being forced into a logistics role. Especially given all the techs and logistics workers they looted from Buffalo.

45,000 combat troops. 20,000 logistics.
They really could win a civil war with that many troops. IF they could secure a reliable logistics supply line
ISIS almost bumrushed Iraq and Syria with those numbers.

Also, professional troops have just an enormous advantage over unskilled militia. That the CMC have pretty much every professional soldier in the Vick civil war is a huge advantage, even though they can't replace those soldiers.

The Crusaders are the warrior-heroes, praised in propaganda and held up as exemplars.

It's just that the Inquisitor branch of the CMC controls the propaganda machine, and they're also in charge of keeping people in line. Which makes them hated, yes, but it also means that ordinary Victorians are accustomed to doing exactly what the Inquisitors say. They're the ones who know where your families live.

The Crusader faction has a strong narrative; Christian Warrior-Heroes fight Decadent Rear Echelon Cowards is a story deeply embedded in Victorian mythology. They just don't have the people with the skills to spread that narrative properly. Victorians will be listening to official radio broadcasts and reading official newspapers controlled by the Inquisitors, and the Crusaders can't build a proper apparatus of control in the middle of a war. Also, as several people have pointed out, it is unclear how much the commons actually believe in the Official Narrative, and defectors can expect Very Bad Things to happen to their families. The "safe" decision is to keep obeying the Inquisitors, at least until it becomes obvious that they're going to lose.

The CMC was absolutely in charge of Victoria because they had hard power through Crusader mechanized divisions and soft power through the Inquisition's secret police and propagandists. Now the CMC has split, and the Crusaders simply don't have the soft power to win this war. Even crushing victories diminish their limited stocks of modern weaponry, while Blackwell will keep throwing farmers with shotguns at them until he drowns the Crusaders under a mountain of corpses.

The people in Victoria can be skeptical about the regime's propaganda, but it is still the water and they are fish. It's pretty much impossible not to be affected by the unconscious assumptions of a culture, even for those who question every one of their assumptions.

There's only so much time in the day after all.

Also, I don't think the CMC will be entirely clueless about propaganda, even if they lack the Inquisition's specialist training. And if they win enough battles to break people's fear of the inquisition, that record will speak for itself.

fasquardon
 
Here's another thing to consider, at what point in this civil war do they start feeling the pinch from the lack of food? Even if by some miracle they wrap up the civil war tomorrow, that's not a lot of time for having demobilization and getting everyone back to their field so that they can take care of their crops and then harvest them.

When does the pinch from lack of food kick in for Victoria?
The interesting thing about the Vics is that they could always feed themselves. 1930s level productivity can manage that just fine.
The only reason they import food as tribute from the Farmer's Federation, the only reason farmers in Victoria come up short, is because of deliberate ideological policy to limit domestic prosperity as a means of societal control.

Suffering is good for the soul /sarcasm

I would not be surprised to find there are stockpiles of food squirelled away by the governments of yesteryear, just like there were stockpiles of gold that we demanded as reparations. And that Blackwell is currently using it to feed his troops, and the carrot to keep conscripts in the military.
Retroculture is precisely the sort of ideology to mandate going hungry and stockpiling gold and silver and ammunition and non-perishable food.

If the war ends, Alex/Russian banks will happily give them a loan to cover food imports for a year or two.
The World Food Program aid program to Yemen is allegedly requesting a minimum of 1.9 billion dollars for 2021 to feed 13 million people. Its not that much money for a nationstate, even the Vics.
 
Also, professional troops have just an enormous advantage over unskilled militia. That the CMC have pretty much every professional soldier in the Vick civil war is a huge advantage, even though they can't replace those soldiers.
Also, they quartered those professional troops in cities.
Cities full of technical workers used to doing what light manufacturing and repairwork exists in Victoria.
AND their portable equipment.

The Crusaders literally picked the city of Buffalo clean of working-class men.
People who used to work in the shipyards and railyards, unload the docks, and manage imports from the upper Great Lakes. A walking logistics corps of maintainers and supply specialists, just waiting to be picked up by anyone callous enough to conscript random civilians.

Man, whoever planned this coup's details was probably shot for putting the Abraham Division there.
Or sent to command a unit of militia, which amounts to the same thing.
 
Buffalo region is done for as a productive region, as they have lost so many people to the Crusaders, loyalist militia and people leaving with our army
 
Man, whoever planned this coup's details was probably shot for putting the Abraham Division there.
Or sent to command a unit of militia, which amounts to the same thing.
I think the Abraham Division was plunked down there before it became apparent to the Inquisitors that the coup would be desirable or necessary.

On the other hand, totalitarian regimes are often quite happy to backstab some poor fucker whose only "mistake" was to do something that made sense at the time but backfired, so the 'getting shot' part could still have happened.
 
So I think our involvement in the civil war should be based on deniable assets conducting assassinations and destroying important buildings.
 
So I think our involvement in the civil war should be based on deniable assets conducting assassinations and destroying important buildings.
No, our involvement with the civil war is based on taking in refugees.

Primarily those who make it to Commonwealth territory, or a Commonwealth evac point, but if the Free City of New York is willing to pay us to resettle some of those refugees who are undoubtedly showing up at their land border or crossing the ocean to land on their shores, I'll happily take it.
Human capital will turn us a profit down the line as long as we invest in them.

Also?
Its good domestic and international PR for a Revivalist state, and improves the chances of defeated Vic soldiers and civilians surrendering in any future conflicts. That's all. Thats all I'm willing to countenance.

We are not currently at war with the Victorian state. We literally signed a peace treaty. We do not have the expertise or the funding to conduct covert operations in a country at civil war. We have no capacity for followup should events snowball. The risk of blowback should we be caught attempting sabotage operations during peacetime is extreme, and there are undoubtedly Russian agents on the ground in Victoria.

Your proposed course of action is going to exacerbate the human misery currently ongoing while doing fuckall to further our foreign policy and domestic policy goals, while possibly making things harder for us down the line by poisoning the population.
Do recall that our endgoal is to assimilate and purge New England of retroculture, not to burn it to the ground.

Not to mention that we have better things to do with our resources than pulling accelerationist shit in a civil war that is already raging hot.
So no. I would not support any such suggestion.
 
Last edited:
No, our involvement with the civil war is based on taking in refugees.

Primarily those who make it to Commonwealth territory, or a Commonwealth evac point, but if the Free City of New York is willing to pay us to resettle some of those refugees who are undoubtedly showing up at their land border or crossing the ocean to land on their shores, I'll happily take it.
Human capital will turn us a profit down the line as long as we invest in them.

Also?
Its good domestic and international PR for a Revivalist state, and improves the chances of defeated Vic soldiers and civilians surrendering in any future conflicts. That's all. Thats all I'm willing to countenance.

We are not currently at war with the Victorian state. We literally signed a peace treaty. We do not have the expertise or the funding to conduct covert operations in a country at civil war. We have no capacity for followup should events snowball. The risk of blowback should we be caught attempting sabotage operations during peacetime is extreme, and there are undoubtedly Russian agents on the ground in Victoria.

Your proposed course of action is going to exacerbate the human misery currently ongoing while doing fuckall to further our foreign policy and domestic policy goals, while possibly making things harder for us down the line by poisoning the population.
Do recall that our endgoal is to assimilate and purge New England of retroculture, not to burn it to the ground.

Not to mention that we have better things to do with our resources than pulling accelerationist shit in a civil war that is already raging hot.
So no. I would not support any such suggestion.
Fair enough, but the reason I specified deniable assets was for the exact issues you brought up. Whose going to notice if one or two extra buildings get blown up, or this or that person gets assassinated in the middle of a war?
 
The interesting thing about the Vics is that they could always feed themselves. 1930s level productivity can manage that just fine.
The only reason they import food as tribute from the Farmer's Federation, the only reason farmers in Victoria come up short, is because of deliberate ideological policy to limit domestic prosperity as a means of societal control.

Suffering is good for the soul /sarcasm

I would not be surprised to find there are stockpiles of food squirelled away by the governments of yesteryear, just like there were stockpiles of gold that we demanded as reparations. And that Blackwell is currently using it to feed his troops, and the carrot to keep conscripts in the military.
Retroculture is precisely the sort of ideology to mandate going hungry and stockpiling gold and silver and ammunition and non-perishable food.

If the war ends, Alex/Russian banks will happily give them a loan to cover food imports for a year or two.
The World Food Program aid program to Yemen is allegedly requesting a minimum of 1.9 billion dollars for 2021 to feed 13 million people. Its not that much money for a nationstate, even the Vics.
No they couldn't. We deStroyed a huge portion of their navy, which includes the big fishing boats that can feed them. In canon, we told they fed themselves through the lean years via fishing and farming potatoes, with hunting of deer. Even in an era where we reversed climate change, we not going to reverse overfishing and overhunting of deer. We seen this happen before in Easter and the Southwest. By some miracle, the Victorian's haven't deforested the Confederacy yet but this winter? Their populace is reduced to eating their seed , hunting everything AND getting wood for fuel. Add in militias and the crusader plundering everyone for vittles as per their supply doctrine and Victoria is undergoing a massive food crisis.

Unless Russia props them up now with food aid, which to be honest was probably one of the things Russia was doing anyway since the Collapse will have destroyed modern farming networks and the best way to ensure it remains a collapse is to keep it that way.

Also hint at the crucial nature of our own farming networks, including trade.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, but the reason I specified deniable assets was for the exact issues you brought up. Whose going to notice if one or two extra buildings get blown up, or this or that person gets assassinated in the middle of a war?
If our quite inexperienced spy agencies are operating on a large enough scale to mean anything? People will notice.

If they're avoiding notice, they're probably actually doing nothing important enough to justify the effort. Adding an extra fart's worth of damage in the middle of a hurricane of civil war isn't worth it.

Don't think of "amount of damage done to Vicks" as a number on a spreadsheet that needs to be maximized. Think about the situation.

No they couldn't. We deStroyed a huge portion of their navy, which includes the big fishing boats that can feed them. In canon, we told they fed themselves through the lean years via fishing and farming potatoes, with hunting of deer. Even in an era where we reversed climate change, we not going to reverse overfishing and overhunting of deer. We seen this happen before in Easter and the Southwest. By some miracle, the Victorian's haven't deforested the Confederacy yet but this winter? Their populace is reduced to eating their seed , hunting everything AND getting wood for fuel. Add in militias and the crusader plundering everyone for vittles as per their supply doctrine and Victoria is undergoing a massive food crisis.
Okay, there's a lot of going on here.

The key point is that New England (including upstate New York) is relatively fertile territory. With the massive urban population of New York out of the picture and the overall population of New England diminished since the Collapse, the region can, in principle, grow enough food to feed everyone. Victoria's medium term outlook for agricultural production and food security, once the immediate crisis is over and unfucked, is pretty good.

This is the root of @uju32 's comment that "they could always feed themselves." Absent immediate ongoing disasters, there is enough agricultural land in Victoria for Victoria to be self-sufficient in food.

In the short term, they have a devastating famine on their hands, of course, due to the disruption of this year's harvest and (in all likelihood) next year's spring planting. That is a different point.
 
f our quite inexperienced spy agencies are operating on a large enough scale to mean anything? People will notice.

If they're avoiding notice, they're probably actually doing nothing important enough to justify the effort. Adding an extra fart's worth of damage in the middle of a hurricane of civil war isn't worth it.

Don't think of "amount of damage done to Vicks" as a number on a spreadsheet that needs to be maximized. Think about the situation.
Agreed. Our operatives are incredible valuable assets, running operations during a civil war is risky and the damage that could be inflicted is negligible compared to what the civil war will damage anyways. We also have much better chances of infiltration once we can use the free trade and free migration clause, meaning once the civil war is over. We can use traders to bribe locals, give us update on Vick propaganda, even monitor troop movement and mobilization to a limited degree. Having good intel on Victoria will be important after the war, since it is the basis for our preparations for the Second Erie Campaign. I would rather not compromise that ability in order to light a match while the state is already on fire.

This is the root of @uju32 's comment that "they could always feed themselves." Absent immediate ongoing disasters, there is enough agricultural land in Victoria for Victoria to be self-sufficient in food.

In the short term, they have a devastating famine on their hands, of course, due to the disruption of this year's harvest and (in all likelihood) next year's spring planting. That is a different point.
How well they recover hinges on various factors, most importantly how inclined Alexander is too help them. He doesn't care about the Victorian population, nor the Victorian state. They are useful insofar as they prevent a emerging USA. The annihilation of their army has reduced that ability. The big question to what extent Alexander will change his North America policy in light of recent developments and how he will handle Victoria in the future.
While I can absolutely see Alexander allowing starvation in order to teach Victorian leadership a lesson about not being brain dead lemmings and to force social change, I think he wants to prevent Victoria from collapsing. They are uniquely good as a puppet. Their insane domestic policy makes them necessarily dependent on him for support and forces them to raid their neighbor. The societal insanity is useful, since it keeps them eternally dangling from his strings. The military insanity is less useful, but it also prevents them from becoming too militarily potent.
In short, the speed of Victorian recovery depends on the exact Russian plans and how gracious Alexander feels towards people that can't even execute a coup properly.
 
If our quite inexperienced spy agencies are operating on a large enough scale to mean anything? People will notice.

If they're avoiding notice, they're probably actually doing nothing important enough to justify the effort. Adding an extra fart's worth of damage in the middle of a hurricane of civil war isn't worth it.

Don't think of "amount of damage done to Vicks" as a number on a spreadsheet that needs to be maximized. Think about the situation.

Okay, there's a lot of going on here.

The key point is that New England (including upstate New York) is relatively fertile territory. With the massive urban population of New York out of the picture and the overall population of New England diminished since the Collapse, the region can, in principle, grow enough food to feed everyone. Victoria's medium term outlook for agricultural production and food security, once the immediate crisis is over and unfucked, is pretty good.

This is the root of @uju32 's comment that "they could always feed themselves." Absent immediate ongoing disasters, there is enough agricultural land in Victoria for Victoria to be self-sufficient in food.

In the short term, they have a devastating famine on their hands, of course, due to the disruption of this year's harvest and (in all likelihood) next year's spring planting. That is a different point.
Obviously post crisis isn't the problem here. However, I do submit that the destruction inflicted by the Detroit and Operation foil is enough to have imposed a food shortage on its own.

The regular army is a raider based army effectively and their logistic train is based around draining food, vehicles and manpower to supply them. Any vehicles requisitioned temporarily is now wrecked. Levies of men to move supplies since they have no organic logistic tail? Taken away from the farms and now either dead, prisoners of war or sucked into the civil war.

Fishing would have been a very efficient protein subsitute for food, but their policy on non environmentalism meant they didn't keep the sustainable fisheries of the 90s around. Indeed, we told that cod made up their basic protein and also part of their exports in our world building.

Lastly, we reversed climate change, but the cod fishery has long been precariously balanced.
www.nationalgeographic.com

Warm Water May Spell the End of New England’s Iconic Cod

New England’s stocks of cod—the fish that fed colonists and launched the United States’ first industries—have collapsed almost …

I'm pointing out that Victoria lack of environmentalism would have destroyed their existing abundance and made it more and more precarious, more labour intensive, a move worsened by Retro culture . They still can feed Victoria if there isn't a bad year.

The losses at Buffalo and etc alone is enough to make it a bad year. The civil war? Just pushed it into crisis.


As for the food aid bit, that's more.... Economics rather than geography. The move to cash crops for economies like Ethiopia (to fund industrial growth) eventually led them into a cash trap, where they needed to sell coffee for food.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but I think we should work on penetrating Victoria as soon as we can.

This is something I'm heavily in favor of, there is no better time to start seeding intelligence assets through Victoria.

1. Their intelligence apparatus is currently busy trying to be a officer corps for a war.
2. Their people are currently desperate and easily bribable
3. Their ideology is shattered, and vulnerable to turning
4. The change in leadership as created a lot of 'winners' but and 'losers'. People who have lost power in the shift*, and are likely feeling resentful and willing to strike back.

*They will kill the most obvious of these, but there are going to be some left who know to keep their heads down as hail the new regime

Fair enough, but the reason I specified deniable assets was for the exact issues you brought up. Whose going to notice if one or two extra buildings get blown up, or this or that person gets assassinated in the middle of a war?

Deniable assets rarely end up such especially when the intelligence assets aren't experienced.
 
Last edited:
Basically, what @Simon_Jester said.
Obviously post crisis isn't the problem here. However, I do submit that the destruction inflicted by the Detroit and Operation foil is enough to have imposed a food shortage on its own.

The regular army is a raider based army effectively and their logistic train is based around draining food, vehicles and manpower to supply them. Any vehicles requisitioned temporarily is now wrecked. Levies of men to move supplies since they have no organic logistic tail? Taken away from the farms and now either dead, prisoners of war or sucked into the civil war.

Fishing would have been a very efficient protein subsitute for food, but their policy on non environmentalism meant they didn't keep the sustainable fisheries of the 90s around. Indeed, we told that cod made up their basic protein and also part of their exports in our world building.

Lastly, we reversed climate change, but the cod fishery has long been precariously balanced.
www.nationalgeographic.com

Warm Water May Spell the End of New England’s Iconic Cod

New England’s stocks of cod—the fish that fed colonists and launched the United States’ first industries—have collapsed almost …

I'm pointing out that Victoria lack of environmentalism would have destroyed their existing abundance and made it more and more precarious, more labour intensive, a move worsened by Retro culture . They still can feed Victoria if there isn't a bad year.

The losses at Buffalo and etc alone is enough to make it a bad year. The civil war? Just pushed it into crisis.


As for the food aid bit, that's more.... Economics rather than geography. The move to cash crops for economies like Ethiopia (to fund industrial growth) eventually led them into a cash trap, where they needed to sell coffee for food.
-The Detroit War involved only professional troops; their civilian militia got home fine. It would not have affected their food supply. Other production, maybe, but not food. The civil war is the cause of their food shortage. Operation Foil was restricted to the Buffalo area. The rest of New York State was relatively untouched other than where fighting was ongoing. The St Lawrence Valley area in occupied Quebec is reputedly very fertile as well.

In addition? Winter snows came late, since we had good weather till the end of Operation Foil, so the time period for harvest was actually extended.
They had the female half of their population at home, who have clandestine experience at running the agricultural sector, but who could not work openly for fear of Inquisitorial attentions.

Its entirely self-inflicted injury here.

-Climate change has not been reversed. Its been stalled at close to RL levels.
Not quite the same thing.

-Raider army?

Bullets dont grow on trees. RPG-7s arent harvested from farmland, and the Vics would be right quick to wreck the face of anyone who tried to set up large-scale manufacturing of firearms. Flannel shirts, military boots, MANPADs, grenades, mortar shells, military radio, fuel for their technicals....all those things are recurring costs that were paid for from the Vic military budget and transported from home.

Sure they do their best to live off the land while on campaign, but besides food and water and alcohol, there is very little you can loot from a farming community in the middle of Bumfuck USA. The cities arent making enough to supply large numbers of soldiers engaged in military activity as a result of declared retroculture policy to deindustrialize the US .

And while food and water are critical supplies, they are a relatively small percentage of the costs of operating a professional army of almost 200,00 men(12 Army + 1 tank + 3 CMC divisions). The stories the Vics tell about themselves fall apart very quickly if you actually look at them critically.

-I think I've made this point before: Victoria is a RICH country. Certainly by in-universe North American standards.
Occupied Quebec alone has 60 hydroelectric plants generating over 36,000 megawatts of installed hydroelectric generating capacity, presumably being exploited by Russian megacorps for shit like alumina refining and possibly hydrogen production an export.

Then there's the mines, which produced ~7 billion dollars in exports in 2010.
The bioforestry is even more profitable; Quebec's paper and pulp industry alone generates 18 billion dollars a year IRL in exports.
And its renewable.

Victoria pays for a standing army of almost 200k for the last 30 years that has been perenially engaged in expeditionary warfare.
Even with tribute from the Farmer's Federation and loot elsewhere, that is a significant obligation that they managed to meet while doing things like tearing down Montreal.

There's a reason Alexander sounds so offended when he says he offered them help back in the Old Monsters update.
Blackwell felt rage pouring up his throat at that dismissal, but he choked it down. Oh, how he choked on it. I know the truth of things, and that is enough. God stands by my shoulder in this, and that is enough. Alexander is not one of us. He is useful, but he is not one of us. I must tell him what he wants to hear. To everybody, what they want to hear, so they give me what I need to have. He swallowed again and spoke. "My lord, our material deficiencies overcame us. Our mortars were overcome by waves of long-ranged artillery. Our supplies now rest at the bottom of Lake Erie thanks to Commonwealth vessels. Our men were cut apart and slaughtered by fast-moving elements on standardized trucks." He gritted his teeth. "We need support. We must have support, and..." He nearly gagged on the words, but just barely, he managed to say, "The teachings of Rumford have led us wrong, and are unsuited to this manner of war. We need to learn from you, my lord. We need your help. I need your help. My government will never work with me without your word. My own comrades will turn on me and cast me down without your support."

His soul rebelled against every syllable. Not wrong! he screamed internally. Misapplied, yes! Not wrong! When fighting men, it remains preeminent, but we face a machine now!

But the Tsar, of course, was uninterested in that line of thinking. Instead, he heard only what Blackwell said. He gazed at the man without a change in expression. "So that is it? Your idiocy finally comes home to roost and you come pelting home, screeching for what I have tried and failed to push on you for decades?"

Blackwell winced. "Your Majesty-"

"Enough. You merely confirm what I have already heard." The Tsar turned away. "You have no new information to offer. You are dismissed."

Blackwell's head came up. "But, Your Majesty, what about-"

"That is not your concern at this time, General," bit out Alexander. "You have your own affairs to look after before you can concern yourself with the Commonwealth." He began stepping away, slowly, held back by age.

"But what of me, my lord?" asked Blackwell. "Will you help me to convince Victoria to accept the changes we need to win this war?"
They have the money, they have the assets, to cover any required loans for food imports.
For teching up, even.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, but the reason I specified deniable assets was for the exact issues you brought up. Whose going to notice if one or two extra buildings get blown up, or this or that person gets assassinated in the middle of a war?
-Deniable assets arent. We all knew damn well who put Stuxnet in Iran, or NotPetya in Ukraine. Even when we didnt catch them redhanded.
And the notable flubs, like the use of novichok in Salisbury to poison Skripal, the use of polonium in London to kill Litvinenko, and the use of VX in Malaysia to kill Kim Jong-Nam, demonstrates that even secret squirrels practiced with assassinations do fuck up and essentially signpost their work.

-Either its significant enough to have a material effect on the war, in which case EVERYONE paying attention to the civil war notices?
Or it is not significant, and makes no difference to ongoing events, in which case the question that arises is Why Are You Wasting Time and Resources Doing This?
 
Last edited:
So if Loyalists win this civil war with the Crusaders any chance that the Loyalists go into a new civil war spilt between the Old guard and Blackwell new guard? or will they be purged
 
Basically, what @Simon_Jester said.

-The Detroit War involved only professional troops; their civilian militia got home fine. It would not have affected their food supply. Other production, maybe, but not food. The civil war is the cause of their food shortage. Operation Foil was restricted to the Buffalo area. The rest of New York State was relatively untouched other than where fighting was ongoing. The St Lawrence Valley area in occupied Quebec is reputedly very fertile as well.

In addition? Winter snows came late, since we had good weather till the end of Operation Foil, so the time period for harvest was actually extended.
They had the female half of their population at home, who have clandestine experience at running the agricultural sector, but who could not work openly for fear of Inquisitorial attentions.

Its entirely self-inflicted injury here.

-Climate change has not been reversed. Its been stalled at close to RL levels.
Not quite the same thing.

-Raider army?

Bullets dont grow on trees. RPG-7s arent harvested from farmland, and the Vics would be right quick to wreck the face of anyone who tried to set up large-scale manufacturing of firearms. Flannel shirts, military boots, MANPADs, grenades, mortar shells, military radio, fuel for their technicals....all those things are recurring costs that were paid for from the Vic military budget and transported from home.

Sure they do their best to live off the land while on campaign, but besides food and water and alcohol, there is very little you can loot from a farming community in the middle of Bumfuck USA. The cities arent making enough to supply large numbers of soldiers engaged in military activity as a result of declared retroculture policy to deindustrialize the US .

And while food and water are critical supplies, they are a relatively small percentage of the costs of operating a professional army of almost 200,00 men(12 Army + 1 tank + 3 CMC divisions). The stories the Vics tell about themselves fall apart very quickly if you actually look at them critically.
Except the problem isn't militia troops, rather, it's the logistic TAIL.

We do know how armies without a significant organic logistic arm overcome the issues of logistics. They levy civilians to move the stuff for them.

That's what I said was lost at Detroit and Buffalo. They levied civilians vehicles, manpower, fuel and etc to move stuff for them.
The IJA for example readily levied civilians bicycles and boats to help shift their forces in Malaya .One of the factors leading to the food shortages in occupied Malaya and Indochina was the breakdown in food transport due to Japanese levies.
 
Last edited:
Turn Five: Word About the World
[X][FEUD] Pitch a Hail Mary and see if they'll listen to you if you try to mediate their disputes. Prompts a roll, DC 43.

[X][COMMIES] Guarantee the Commune's independence. Another friendly power on Lake Erie is hardly a bad thing to have.

[X][RIVER] Agree to the alliance. The Kingdom isn't a large problem, but it could definitely cause issues for your plans for the Mississippi. You're happy to limit their opportunities for expansion.

[X][MEDIATE] Oh, but it is. You have no immediate interest in Minnesota but whatever's going on between Bemidji and Manitoulin intrigues you, and you very much do have a medium-term interest in resolving this conflict to your west before it becomes your problem, later. You will have the option to organize this mediation.

Turn Five

Word About the World
The amount of information reaching your ears has graduated from a trickle to a fire hose.

In some ways, this is a good thing.

Commonwealth
  • CFLP Rallies!
    • Representative Maggie O'Shay, leader of the Commonwealth Farmer-Laborer Party, has managed to restore order in her party, following the turmoil resulting from the party's hardline opposition to Operation Foil. Despite serious backlash in the wake of the operation's success, O'Shay has managed to keep her party intact, even in the face of wing elements threatening to split off. While polling suggests that there has been some loss in public support, the party remains intact, and thus, the left-wing opposition remains united.
      • Note from Sara: Maggie's a clever girl, gotta admit. I don't think I could've kept a party together through that, not when it's already such a big tent.
  • Foreign Ships In Chicago
    • Following the clarification of trade policies in the Midwestern Conference, and the proper opening of the Welland Canal, enterprising traders from abroad have already started coming into the City of Chicago to unload goods. Surprisingly, after the initial rush, many traders have come hawking food-- food bought by government officials, overwhelmingly, which then tends to leave swiftly...
      • Note from SecDev Aguilar: Turning cheap foreign crops around to sell to Victoria when we're on the edge of famine ourselves sits wrong, but the money we get is enough to buy even more, should we so decide. The irony is not lost on me, I will admit, but I will admit that selling food to a desperate government pays. The funding is welcome, given the work ahead of us.
North America
  • Victorian Civil War Intensifies!
    • Many commentators, for months, have been predicting that the Crusaders would be crushed if ever caught out. These prediction have halted, however, after the news of the recent months, carried by refugees fleeing to any safe port that would take them. Crusader forces have come down out of the Appalachians, finally making contact again with Loyalist forces in Maine itself. With Loyalist militias largely disbanded to try and recover some of their harvest, Crusader troops managed to push all the way to Augusta, routing the reconstituted 1st Army Division and sacking the city before departing. FCNY observers report heavy smoke clouds visible from the sea. Gideon Blackwell's government and high command were able to evacuate in advance of the city's fall, but they have yet to return, suggesting that Augusta may now be unfit for use as a center of government. Crusader forces have since withdrawn again, evading the closing trap of militia forces and reputedly wrecking rail lines and other infrastructure as they pass over it to hamper pursuit.
      • Note from SecSec Ralson: Buffalo isn't good for much anymore, but it can service refugees, and with us shipping grain over at a steady clip, there is shipping space available. Having Victorians coming out is a godsend for intelligence gathering -- and the contacts don't hurt, either.
  • Miami In Federation Talks
    • For what is presently disputed as either the seventh or twentieth time, Miami has hosted a summit of the various communities making up the strange state to discuss the possibility of a closer and more binding federation. This time, there seems to be success, as the talks have lasted between two and thirty times longer than the next contender, depending on how one defines duration. The condition of federation has been set as a supermajority of 64% of attendees voting in approval, and somewhere between 49% and 83% of attendees have voted in approval.
      • Ambassador Kuhn has also lodged seventeen requests to be reassigned. We have thus far declined, as we are having trouble sourcing volunteers to replace her.
  • Revivalist Spring
    • With Victoria's defeat in the Erie War, Revivalist movements across the Old Country have received a potent shot in the arm. Governments all over the Country are experiencing increasing unrest as Revivalist agitators begin advocating for their agenda. Among states with formally Revivalist governments, meanwhile, there have been talks of organizing a conference to discuss the future of the movement. Many have called for the talks to be held in Chicago, on the Fourth of July. Given the Commonwealth of Free Cities's present preeminence in the Midwest and significance to the Revivalist movement, they will certainly be able to host the event, if they choose to.
      • Note from SecState Harris: Oh, God, I don't even know. That puts a target on us the size of Moscow. Can we even beg off?
Abroad
  • Standoff In the South China Sea
    • Last night, naval forces from the Pacific-Asian Cooperative Sphere, the Empire of Japan, and the Republic of China engaged in a tense standoff. The standoff began when Japanese and PACS forces encountered one another in the Balabac Strait, each accusing one another of violating the agreed-upon border through the center of the strait. Neither side backed down, and as the sun began rising the next day with the standoff persisting and more distant warships being redirected, Chinese Republican Navy forces began to set out from Hainan to the Japanese-held Paracel islands. Japanese forces withdrew from the Balabac Strait an hour later, sailing north. CRN forces turned back hours later.
      • Note from SecState Harris: This one sounds closer than it was. There might be superpower levels of heft getting thrown around out there, but there's no intent to it. Grandstanding. Nobody can domestically tolerate looking weak. With three of them in the region, at least it means that everybody has a way out of these with a win that doesn't involve fighting.
  • Brazil And Chile To Discuss American Investment
    • Brazil and Chile have reportedly scheduled a summit to discuss strategies for investment in the Americas, citing unspecified recent paradigm shifts that have changed the calculus on the continents. While sources have not confirmed that the summit's purpose is to discuss how to acquire interests while Victoria is incapable of interfering, one did confirm that the cities of New Orleans and Baton Rouge were likely to be topics of conversation. The conference is scheduled to go ahead in September of 2076. The government of Argentina has protested not being included in this summit; negotiations are reportedly ongoing.
      • SecDev Aguilar: From what I've heard, I expect Argentina to get a seat just fine. This will have implications for our plan for the Mississippi...


Yup, a rumor mill post.

I don't really like these things, but there's just so much happening that it'd be a colossal pain to write it all out narratively, and I want this out. Turn update imminent!
 
Last edited:
Voting is open
Back
Top