Voting is open
What I want to know is what happened to NYC's water. It all originates from Upper New York. Does FCNY just pay Victoria through the nose not to poison it or something?

It's likely there is some element of that. NYC is very rich, Victoria is very poor, so I suspect that there are considerable payouts there. On the other hand, with the state lines dissolving and many of the other urban centers in the USA gone, there may be more available water southwards. With their recent defeat I suspect Victoria may try to extract greater tribute, a good reason for us to try to get in contact with NYC early.

On long term plans, I know we've been discussing expansion plans, but there is at least one other area I'd like to call attention to

---
[ ] Old Relics: The United States built a lot of heavy industrial presses back in the Cold War. None are in your territory, but their locations aren't exactly secret. Send out expeditions with the goal of studying these machines and gathering notes; perhaps, sometime in the future, you may be able to build your own. DC: 55. Successes Needed: 3. AP Limit: 1. Effect: Gain a group of experts capable of building heavy industrial presses for you; also confirm the status of the old presses.
---

I think this is an option that is very easy to overlook. At DC55 and 3Ap with a limit, it isn't the sort of thing we can throw AP at and end in a turn. On average we won't finish this without 6 turns worth of effort, and even then it only let's us build and find them, not have them. Given the lack of short term benefits, it's going to be very easy to overlook, especially with whatever crises turn up each turn, but I would really like to focus on this. It's a huge industry upgrade once we get it, and since it's only one AP a turn, we can't throw Ap at it to solve it quickly if we discover we really need it later. I think it's reasonable to wait post-libraries, as that has a good chance of lowering the dc, but after that, I'd like any plan we do to keep a point invested here.
 
Texas is going to be an issue though.
The descendants of the nutcases who helped bomb Atlanta are down there, which means there are Victoria friendly factions near our prospective arterial to the outside world. And we can't project power that far. Yet.
Going through the Mississippi puts us less close to Texas, which may or may not still contain a weaker version of Victoria. Like, we don't actually know what the internal politics of Texas is like very well, not in-character. We certainly don't know if they're as organized and hostile to other revivalist states as Victoria is.

While I get your argument that being so much closer to us makes Pennsylvania safer, I think this is very very situational and will depend on us learning the specific actual facts on the ground around the mouth of the Mississippi. Among other things, Miami may be a potential ally in keeping any malevolent Texans under control, whereas New York is poorly placed to help us with our Pennsylvania Problem.
If anything, Texas is less likely to provide any kind of organized hostility than the rest of the continental US. Not only does Victoria personally smash any organization there like they did to any other potential states, the whole Atlanta situation has ensured that the all their neighbors keep Texas down as well:

Also, the fact that the folks to nuke Atlanta were Texas Rangers is just gold for Victorian propagandists. Nobody listens to Texans, these days (I have nothing against Texans, but that is a big issue for any reforming Texan state). Sometimes, it's not even Victoria that steps in to prevent Texas from getting back on its feet.
Texas is a formidable resource, but Victoria knows that, too. They've made sure that everybody hates them and kills the shit out of them at every available opportunity.



What I want to know is what happened to NYC's water. It all originates from Upper New York. Does FCNY just pay Victoria through the nose not to poison it or something?
IIRC, they invested heavily in desalination plants to ensure Victoria doesn't control their water supply. Couldn't find the quote for that, though, so I could be misremembering.
 
Well from my point of view, it's just a soft target you're keeping way, WAY back to avoid letting it get damaged. There's a big difference between a "hard target" in the sense of "this target will be hard to kill even if you shoot at it" and in the sense of "this will be absurdly easy to kill if you ever, ever get within range, and it's visible from several hundred miles away."

In any event, airborne lasers are better for boost-phase and mid-course missile defense than terminal intercept anyway; there's a reason why the focus for terminal intercept has mostly been on missiles.
The threat is nuclear missiles and satellites.
One is unarmed. The other is something you can't harden yourself against.

Going through Pennsylvania puts us close to Victoria, literally right on their doorstep.
I'm aware.
Being far from Victoria doesn't help if our route passes through or adjacent to a Victoria ally we have to fight to keep the river clear.
Thing is, we don't have sufficient knowledge about conditions to make a judgement at this time.

The Missouri is an obvious boon for the southern route, but the majority minority cities of the Eastern seaboard are reliable foci of anti-Victorian sentiment to anchor logistics points on. With New Orleans gone the only other Mississipi port I'm seeing is Baton Rouge. And I dont know if it can break a blockade of "pirates" running out of the Texas coastline.

We'll see.
What I want to know is what happened to NYC's water. It all originates from Upper New York. Does FCNY just pay Victoria through the nose not to poison it or something?
Desalination plants.
All the international support they allegedly have is probably invested in infrastructure projects. Just like most of New Yorks power comes from dams currently under Vic control, which is intolerable from a security perspective.

Fusion would probably help, if it exists. Else they're investing in vanilla fission plants.
Probably from India, which was doing interesting things with thorium.
 
Anyway, these would be a great target for intrigue and sabotage. Even today, we barely have the capability to replace these kind of generators and turbines, and sabotaging them from the inside is easy. As an example, one reactor at the Doel Nuclear power plant in Belgium was taken offline by an unknown person activating the emergency oil drain lever, which drained the oil and caused the turbine to seize. They had to ship the turbine all the way to China to repair it.
While this sabotage might be a tempting move, it sounds like these power plants are more window dressing than useful to Victoria. Blowing one up would be a propaganda goldmine to Victoria, and having a second Chernobyl in the hands of people that live relatively close by and have less capabilities to clean up/bury the mess seems like a bad idea. We gain little to nothing from sabotaging Victoria's power supply; they're not using much of it anyway. Now, sneaking guys in to steal the blueprints might be nice, but we can probably just pick up the plants if/when we invade.
 
*rocky pops up*

Thats a nice, really nice, expensive, vital tidal station you got there.

It would, eh, be a shame if something were to happen to it. A real shame...

If you want, me and the boys could help protect it for you, ya know, insurance in case of any unforeseen accidents were to befall it.

EDIT: So does this mean that the bay of fundy tidal station is a great big giant soft target painted on the back of the Vickies who cannot, like, shoot down any of our potential cruise missiles seeing as they are retro cultural fetishists?
 
Last edited:
Blowing one up would be a propaganda goldmine to Victoria, and having a second Chernobyl in the hands of people that live relatively close by and have less capabilities to clean up/bury the mess seems like a bad idea

Well maybe not blowing it up but those plants are key targets to sabotage. Nothing gets a populace questioning their government more when the lights go out for good. If we want to sabotage them we should aim for a stuxnet 2.0 or just plain subterfuge and sabotage to knock them off line.
 
Last edited:
Well maybe not blowing it up but those plants are key targets to sabotage. Nothing gets a populace questioning their government more when the lights go out for good. If we want to sabotage them we should aim for a stuxnet 2.0, use malware or just plain subterfuge and sabotage to knock them off line.

Just shoot a cruise missile at it. What anti-missile defenses do the vicks actually have? Considering where they are who their neighbors are, etc?
 
EDIT: So does this mean that the bay of fundy tidal station is a great big giant soft target painted on the back of the Vickies who cannot, like, shoot down any of our potential cruise missiles seeing as they are retro cultural fetishists
Russian corporate property.
Espect a "private security company" with a couple SHORADs and lasers to set up shop around Russian corporate assets once the Commonwealth demonstrate staying power and 80s level combat potential.

I mean, if point defense lasers are a thing, and you're planning defense of a power station, the synergy is obvious.
 
Last edited:
Russian corporate property.
Espect a "private security company" with a couple SHORADs and lasers to set up shop around Russian corporate assets once the Commonwealth demonstrate staying power and 80s level combat potential.

I mean, if point defense lasers are a thing, and you're planning defense of a power station, the synergy is obvious.

Specially one surrounded by water, cheap heatsinks!
 
They have Russian-owned nuclear power stations. They are not cold fusion.
I imagine this got started when Alexander started getting fed up with the Victorians around that time the way you mention. The Russians begin setting up a new testbed reactor, something risky that would have a good chance of going catastrophically wrong and leaking radiation everywhere, because it sets up a win-win of either getting Russia a superior power generation method or screwing Victoria over by letting them deal with the fallout of some form of radiological disaster cleanup. Then the Victorians hear "yadda yadda fusion science science" and their train of thought hears the word fusion, combines it with, I dunno, a slightly cooler month or something like that to spit out "cold fusion" as a tech breakthrough they're taking credit for.
 
It could also be leftover old US fission reactors or research the Russians were grabbing. Honestly I am surprised the Russians let the Victorians keep them even if under Russian control considering their former nuclear terrorism I would not trust them with nuclear material.
 
Vanity project.
The Robert Moses Niagara Falls Dam already produces 2600 MW of hydroelectric power.I'm assuming Toronto held on to the Adam Beck Hydroelectric power station on the other side of the river. Not sure why a retroculture society needs all that power.
Well, for starters, from what I remember, they use electric vehicles... powered by lead-acid batteries... for many civilian applications Short-ranged as hell, and power-hungry.

Secondly, "Retroculture" isn't (by Lind) intended to mean "we don't actually have electricity." Winding back the clock to before rural electrification is a bridge farther than they want to go.

Thirdly, Victoria's autarky fetish and refusal to tolerate industrialization outside their borders means they have to run a bunch of energy-intensive factories and production facilities (like steel mills) that in real life long since migrated out of New England.

Fourthly, I suspect that they sell electricity to New York, and that this is a major source of their power over New York beyond the simple brute force threat to invade, along with being a significant source of foreign exchange.

Loot I guess, assuming we get that far.
We already have lots of reason to capture the Niagara Falls power generating facilities. The tidal power is just icing on the cake.

Between those, the Niagara Falls Dam, the Blenheim-Gilboa plant, Victoria is awash in cheap energy.
Just noone to sell it to, to the frustration of the corporations who own them. Because the FCNY would have prioritized achieving independence from the New York Power Authority in the wake of the Victorian takeover.
They'd have made it a priority but I'm not sure they'd be allowed to succeed. We need more information about that situation, which in turn will involve us coordinating with New York to make sure that our wars don't black out their city.

What I want to know is what happened to NYC's water. It all originates from Upper New York. Does FCNY just pay Victoria through the nose not to poison it or something?
Very possibly.

It's likely there is some element of that. NYC is very rich, Victoria is very poor, so I suspect that there are considerable payouts there. On the other hand, with the state lines dissolving and many of the other urban centers in the USA gone, there may be more available water southwards. With their recent defeat I suspect Victoria may try to extract greater tribute, a good reason for us to try to get in contact with NYC early.
I like the cut of your jib.

On long term plans, I know we've been discussing expansion plans, but there is at least one other area I'd like to call attention to

---
[ ] Old Relics: The United States built a lot of heavy industrial presses back in the Cold War. None are in your territory, but their locations aren't exactly secret. Send out expeditions with the goal of studying these machines and gathering notes; perhaps, sometime in the future, you may be able to build your own. DC: 55. Successes Needed: 3. AP Limit: 1. Effect: Gain a group of experts capable of building heavy industrial presses for you; also confirm the status of the old presses.
---

I think this is an option that is very easy to overlook. At DC55 and 3Ap with a limit, it isn't the sort of thing we can throw AP at and end in a turn. On average we won't finish this without 6 turns worth of effort, and even then it only let's us build and find them, not have them. Given the lack of short term benefits, it's going to be very easy to overlook, especially with whatever crises turn up each turn, but I would really like to focus on this. It's a huge industry upgrade once we get it, and since it's only one AP a turn, we can't throw Ap at it to solve it quickly if we discover we really need it later. I think it's reasonable to wait post-libraries, as that has a good chance of lowering the dc, but after that, I'd like any plan we do to keep a point invested here.
Oh, it's definitely something we need to do. It's another one of those industrial actions.

The main thing to point out is that as you note, Libraries has a good chance of lowering the DC... but so do other industrial actions. For example, Infrastructure Projects will help us set up the facilities to even transport bulk industrial equipment. Actions gated behind the Subsidize Industry action we took last turn may help us set up facilities capable of receiving or duplicating the kind of heavy industrial facilities we'd be looking for under Old Relics.

I'm definitely going to support taking at least one firmly industrial action that expands or increases our industrial base, preferably more than one, every turn starting from Turn 4. I think that barring major disasters we'll have the AP budget to support such investment too. Old Relics isn't first on my list of priorities, but it's on there.

...

The thing to remember is that we explicitly chose a "high bonus high malus" start, where we voluntarily accepted a lot of penalties that have given us a very high pressure start. If we'd taken a more... sedate... plan, we'd have had a lot fewer crises to resolve in the short term. On the other hand, we'd have had to spend AP just to get some of the things that "IRL" we now have. So, complexity is complex.

The threat is nuclear missiles and satellites.
One is unarmed. The other is something you can't harden yourself against.
You don't understand what I'm getting at and frankly I don't have the energy to keep explaining it when it's a totally moot point.

I'm aware.
Being far from Victoria doesn't help if our route passes through or adjacent to a Victoria ally we have to fight to keep the river clear.
Thing is, we don't have sufficient knowledge about conditions to make a judgement at this time.

The Missouri is an obvious boon for the southern route, but the majority minority cities of the Eastern seaboard are reliable foci of anti-Victorian sentiment to anchor logistics points on. With New Orleans gone the only other Mississipi port I'm seeing is Baton Rouge. And I dont know if it can break a blockade of "pirates" running out of the Texas coastline.
As others have pointed out, pro-Victorian pirates along the Texas coastline would probably be getting their balls kicked in by everyone, including Miami which almost certainly has a much better developed navy than we do.

If we really try, and if we have the support of local communities that want to see these notional enemy Texans defeated, I'm pretty sure we'll be able to handle it. As we are now it would be a problem, but as we are now the idea of our forcing a land route through central Pennsylvania and Ohio would be totally out of the question too. By the time we're capable of pushing east over the Appalachians towards the Mid-Atlantic Seaboard, we will assuredly be capable of fighting a river and coastal campaign down around the mouth of the Mississippi. If we need to, which I doubt.

Desalination plants.
All the international support they allegedly have is probably invested in infrastructure projects. Just like most of New Yorks power comes from dams currently under Vic control, which is intolerable from a security perspective.
A boatload of nuclear reactors on Long Island is definitely a possibility. On the other hand, this is an area where the Victorians likely struggle hard to limit New York's independence, and where they are in a good position to supply cheap water and energy to New York under normal conditions.
 
I wouldn't be surprised to hear that Victoria (or, Russian companies based in Victoria) sell electricity to NYC, but even if they aren't self sufficient they definitely have their own backup grid, probably nuclear but maybe like tidal or something.

On the other hand, I doubt they import water from Victoria.
 
What is the status of Hydro-Québec's power installations?
Anyway, these would be a great target for intrigue and sabotage. Even today, we barely have the capability to replace these kind of generators and turbines, and sabotaging them from the inside is easy. As an example, one reactor at the Doel Nuclear power plant in Belgium was taken offline by an unknown person activating the emergency oil drain lever, which drained the oil and caused the turbine to seize. They had to ship the turbine all the way to China to repair it.
Honestly, those two things taken together make me think that the big pieces of power infrastructure were sabotaged. Lind was convinced that the NC had a dire power crisis, and while it's likeliest that he was talking out his ass, it actually makes sense that there'd be plenty of, ah, conscientious objectors with the knowledge and ability to critically fuck over their new overlords during the early years.
 
Honestly, those two things taken together make me think that the big pieces of power infrastructure were sabotaged. Lind was convinced that the NC had a dire power crisis, and while it's likeliest that he was talking out his ass, it actually makes sense that there'd be plenty of, ah, conscientious objectors with the knowledge and ability to critically fuck over their new overlords during the early years.
I wonder how much money and effort Victoria spends on a bunch of useless dams.

Because if it is as little as I fear, then we have a collection of ticking time bombs.
 
Well, for starters, from what I remember, they use electric vehicles... powered by lead-acid batteries... for many civilian applications Short-ranged as hell, and power-hungry.
Huh.

Fourthly, I suspect that they sell electricity to New York, and that this is a major source of their power over New York beyond the simple brute force threat to invade, along with being a significant source of foreign exchange.
This is not a situation I think NY would allow to persist.
Even if they were initially tempted, Victorian assholery would have them pull the plug a couple times to flex muscles. At which point NYC would go hard into solar, wind and tidal, as well as nukes, whether fusion or fission.

NYC is dependent on foreign support.
Energy infrastructure investment would go some way to explaining what form that support takes.
They'd have made it a priority but I'm not sure they'd be allowed to succeed. We need more information about that situation, which in turn will involve us coordinating with New York to make sure that our wars don't black out their city.
Not something the Vics have influence on.
New York would just do the public-private partnership thing with a bunch of international corporations from Europe, India, South Ameroca and Australia. Give multiple nations a stake.

And it would be intensely profitable for them; New York consumes 11,000 MW of power a day.
Add whatever you need for powering desalination plants.
As others have pointed out, pro-Victorian pirates along the Texas coastline would probably be getting their balls kicked in by everyone, including Miami which almost certainly has a much better developed navy than we do. If we really try, and if we have the support of local communities that want to see these notional enemy Texans defeated, I'm pretty sure we'll be able to handle it. As we are now it would be a problem, but as we are now the idea of our forcing a land route through central Pennsylvania and Ohio would be totally out of the question too. By the time we're capable of pushing east over the Appalachians towards the Mid-Atlantic Seaboard, we will assuredly be capable of fighting a river and coastal campaign down around the mouth of the Mississippi. If we need to, which I doubt.
Well see I guess.
Here's hoping you're right.
A boatload of nuclear reactors on Long Island is definitely a possibility. On the other hand, this is an area where the Victorians likely struggle hard to limit New York's independence, and where they are in a good position to supply cheap water and energy to New York under normal conditions
Like I said, existential threat. You don't leave a knife at your throat.
Same reason I expect the New Yorkers would rather import food from Europe or South America than from up north. Though I expect much of their food comes from New Jersey.

Regardless, tne canon omakes I see for NYC are too belligerent for them to be dependent on Victorian largesse that can be cut for geopolitical pressure. Plus, I will point out that it doesn't actually suit Alexander for Victoria to establish a state of quasi-stable foreign income independent of him; they might get ideas.

And every time Victoria has gotten ideas, Alexander has developed ulcers.
Honestly, those two things taken together make me think that the big pieces of power infrastructure were sabotaged. Lind was convinced that the NC had a dire power crisis, and while it's likeliest that he was talking out his ass, it actually makes sense that there'd be plenty of, ah, conscientious objectors with the knowledge and ability to critically fuck over their new overlords during the early years.
This actually makes a lot of sense.
Especially given how you need skilled workers to operate those things. And I think New York State is only about 50% non-Hispanic whites, so the purge would have hurt a lot of people and capabilities.

FCNY has to have held a (small)chunk of either New York State or New Jersey to have remained viable tho.
And they actually have the population for it; with a starter population of 8.3 million people and several million more in refugees, they are big enough for Victoria to have actively balked at attempting to tackle before things stabilized.

Not that Victoria can't beat them now. It will cost, but FCNY is only (officially)armed with manportable weapons.

Probably going to expand hard into New Jersey now that we have firmly fixed Victoria's attention westwards.
And reach out to Philadelphia; with the two of them anchoring either border, they can secure New Jersey as a safe space, and build a military capability in there.
 
Last edited:
*rocky pops up*

Thats a nice, really nice, expensive, vital tidal station you got there.

It would, eh, be a shame if something were to happen to it. A real shame...

If you want, me and the boys could help protect it for you, ya know, insurance in case of any unforeseen accidents were to befall it.

EDIT: So does this mean that the bay of fundy tidal station is a great big giant soft target painted on the back of the Vickies who cannot, like, shoot down any of our potential cruise missiles seeing as they are retro cultural fetishists?
Don't assume the Victorians are incapable of, or unwilling to, starting to operate better air defense hardware. The military has always been their main area of rationalizations in Retroculture, and it's the area where their anti-academic fetishes hurt them relatively least as long as they can source foreign equipment.

It could also be leftover old US fission reactors or research the Russians were grabbing. Honestly I am surprised the Russians let the Victorians keep them even if under Russian control considering their former nuclear terrorism I would not trust them with nuclear material.
The Russians have Victoria thoroughly penetrated enough from an intelligence standpoint that I think they may just be that confident of being able to nip any Victorian nuclear program in the bud.

QUOTE="PoptartProdigy, post: 12834794, member: 12457"]
Honestly, those two things taken together make me think that the big pieces of power infrastructure were sabotaged. Lind was convinced that the NC had a dire power crisis, and while it's likeliest that he was talking out his ass, it actually makes sense that there'd be plenty of, ah, conscientious objectors with the knowledge and ability to critically fuck over their new overlords during the early years.
[/QUOTE]Yeah. Frankly, the process of turning New England of all places into a totalitarian alt-right-plus-neoreactionary-plus-techno-regressive dystopia cannot have been smooth, to put it mildly.

I wonder how much money and effort Victoria spends on a bunch of useless dams.

Because if it is as little as I fear, then we have a collection of ticking time bombs.
I don't think we should deliberately assume the Victorians are outright incompetent at maintaining basic infrastructure within their own territory. Poor, yes. Incapable of comprehending "you need to do upkeep on a dam," no.

Also, if we're talking about the Fundy tide-power stations... Well, bluntly, the worst case scenario for the Bay of Fundy is "fifty foot wall of water comes washing through," which is basically "Tuesday" in the Bay of Fundy. The consequence of a fuckup is less electricity for the Victorian grid, not giant walls of water.
 
I wonder how much money and effort Victoria spends on a bunch of useless dams.

Because if it is as little as I fear, then we have a collection of ticking time bombs.
It's been ~40 years since the Collapse, which means that most of the currently existing dams and other major infrastructure are ~100 years old when they were intended to last for 50 (Or are repairs/replacements for those ancient structures). Chances are that anything that hasn't been actively maintained over that period has since burst/collapsed. The timer has run down on anything that would be a ticking time bomb.
 
It's been ~40 years since the Collapse, which means that most of the currently existing dams and other major infrastructure are ~100 years old when they were intended to last for 50 (Or are repairs/replacements for those ancient structures). Chances are that anything that hasn't been actively maintained over that period has since burst/collapsed. The timer has run down on anything that would be a ticking time bomb.
Here's hoping the NCR moved fast enough to grab the Hoover Dam.
 
One thing that bears pointing out is that if you know a dam is starting to fall apart, and you don't have a pressing use for it, you can let the water out in a controlled manner and keep it from going 'boom' and causing a huge flood downstream.

For this to be a major problem for Victoria, they'd need to not only be stupid enough not to maintain their dams, but also too stupid to disable their dams in an orderly fashion when they're approaching end-of-life. And, indeed, stupid enough to make that mistake repeatedly.

...

Victoria is an impoverished country in many ways, and the combination of political totalitarianism and royally fucked up military doctrine cripples them still further.

But I think we should credit them with the ability to learn from experience and respond to a dam blowing out once or twice by concentrating maintenance funds on

...

Another thing that occurred to me. Nuclear reactors are good for base load power, as are tidal plants and so on. They're not so great for peak demand. If Victoria actually has more electricity than it needs, which seems likely if the root problem of their 'energy shortage' in the 2030s and '40s was sabotage by opponents of the regime... Well, New York may very well have built up plenty of nuclear reactors to provide base load and minimally keep the lights on no matter what Victoria says, but it's entirely possible that they can get non-base-load electricity more cheaply from Victoria during good times, and just maintain a bunch of natural gas turbines for emergency purposes in case of bad times.

Though the Russians probably reap much of the economic proceeds from Victorian power plants in any case.

...

I think we do need to put some thought, not just into all the ways that Victoria has screwed itself up and sabotaged itself with Retroculturism and so on, but how they manage to function as a nation-state that actually needs to maintain some kind of semblance of an import-export balance. And that has managed to sustain its credibility as a threat to the rest of North America- not just its immediate neighbors, but out into the Midwest and parts of the American South- for a generation after the actively Russian-backed round of wars ended.

Victoria is an insanely flawed nation, reflecting an insanely flawed creative vision. But its role in the narrative doesn't work if it should already have collapsed utterly by some time in the 2060s to the sound of great big Russian shrugs and "fuckits, we don't really need them that badly anyway, they can't do their job anymore."

They can be an aging, one-eyed, limping tiger- a tiger whose fangs we are in the process of breaking, even. But they can't be a paper tiger. And I think we need to put a bit of thought into what they could be doing to keep themselves afloat and capable of plausibly threatening anyone outside their borders, because at this rate we'll pile them up with so many hamstringings and deficiencies that it ceases to be plausible that they were ever a threat once the Russians stopped actively and continuously holding their hands on a day to day basis. Which isn't what's been happening given that they managed to hold their own through the 2050s and 2060s.
 
One thing that bears pointing out is that if you know a dam is starting to fall apart, and you don't have a pressing use for it, you can let the water out in a controlled manner and keep it from going 'boom' and causing a huge flood downstream.

For this to be a major problem for Victoria, they'd need to not only be stupid enough not to maintain their dams, but also too stupid to disable their dams in an orderly fashion when they're approaching end-of-life. And, indeed, stupid enough to make that mistake repeatedly.

...

Victoria is an impoverished country in many ways, and the combination of political totalitarianism and royally fucked up military doctrine cripples them still further.

But I think we should credit them with the ability to learn from experience and respond to a dam blowing out once or twice by concentrating maintenance funds on

...

Another thing that occurred to me. Nuclear reactors are good for base load power, as are tidal plants and so on. They're not so great for peak demand. If Victoria actually has more electricity than it needs, which seems likely if the root problem of their 'energy shortage' in the 2030s and '40s was sabotage by opponents of the regime... Well, New York may very well have built up plenty of nuclear reactors to provide base load and minimally keep the lights on no matter what Victoria says, but it's entirely possible that they can get non-base-load electricity more cheaply from Victoria during good times, and just maintain a bunch of natural gas turbines for emergency purposes in case of bad times.

Though the Russians probably reap much of the economic proceeds from Victorian power plants in any case.

...

I think we do need to put some thought, not just into all the ways that Victoria has screwed itself up and sabotaged itself with Retroculturism and so on, but how they manage to function as a nation-state that actually needs to maintain some kind of semblance of an import-export balance. And that has managed to sustain its credibility as a threat to the rest of North America- not just its immediate neighbors, but out into the Midwest and parts of the American South- for a generation after the actively Russian-backed round of wars ended.

Victoria is an insanely flawed nation, reflecting an insanely flawed creative vision. But its role in the narrative doesn't work if it should already have collapsed utterly by some time in the 2060s to the sound of great big Russian shrugs and "fuckits, we don't really need them that badly anyway, they can't do their job anymore."

They can be an aging, one-eyed, limping tiger- a tiger whose fangs we are in the process of breaking, even. But they can't be a paper tiger. And I think we need to put a bit of thought into what they could be doing to keep themselves afloat and capable of plausibly threatening anyone outside their borders, because at this rate we'll pile them up with so many hamstringings and deficiencies that it ceases to be plausible that they were ever a threat once the Russians stopped actively and continuously holding their hands on a day to day basis. Which isn't what's been happening given that they managed to hold their own through the 2050s and 2060s.
Resource extraction.
They control a significant chunk of Quebec according to the map, and Quebec has always been resource rich.
From Wikipedia:
The abundance of natural resources gives Quebec an advantageous position on the world market. Quebec stands out particularly in the mining sector, ranking among the top ten areas to do business in mining.[170] It also stands for the exploitation of its forest resources.

Quebec is remarkable for the natural resources of its vast territory. It has about 30 mines, 158 exploration companies and fifteen primary processing industries. Many metallic minerals are exploited, the principals are gold, iron, copper and zinc. Many other substances are extracted including titanium, asbestos, silver, magnesium, nickel and many other metals and industrial minerals.[171] However, only 40% of the mineral potential of Quebec is currently known. In 2003, the value of mineral exploitation reached Quebec 3.7 billion Canadian dollars.[172] Moreover, as a major centre of exploration for diamonds,[173] Quebec has seen, since 2002, an increase in its mineral explorations, particularly in the Northwest as well as in the Otish Mountains and the Torngat Mountains.
There you go.

Add forestry, agricultural goods and some tourism as the Collapse fades. Couple that with rentseeking control of entry and exit to the Great Lakes as both political and economic control lever, and the occasional rental of army divisions to enforce Russian foreign policy a la Cold War Cuba. Add export of light arms; Colt, Stag, Ruger, Mossberg and Remington all had factories in Connecticut.

Probably some cheap Russian-owned manufacturing as well, but I'm not willing to hazard a guess on what that might be.
Probably local pharma industry for their own use and export to the Americas. Those "aid workers" probably get essential medicines from somewhere.

Their selfsufficiency fetish restricts imports to things like advanced electronics and machining where necessary, and hightech military gear.
 
Last edited:
You know, there is something I've been curious:

Where are the mentions of disease in wartime?

Wars are famous for spreading disease because you have a lot of people with open wounds near each other; this should be especially true when it's wet and pouring and generally almost the best possible conditions for disease to flourish.

So. Where is it, and when's the hammer going to fall?
 
Last edited:
Voting is open
Back
Top