Plus, allowing MCAT to deal with the attack on their own terms gives way more legitimacy to them, and a free casus belli of going gloves off with the ministry. The Goverment is gonna go ape shit.
Well, I'm not sure we'd delegitimize MCAT by showing up against their wishes and helping them out.

Samui probably wouldn't want to make a point in public, or with the Diet, that she asked us NOT to intervene in a fight and we went ahead and showed up anyway. That's a lose-lose situation for her, right there. Because:

1) It makes the Diet suspicious of us (mildly inconvenient for Samui) and more likely to order MCAT to take measures against us (very inconvenient for Samui).

2) It forces a test of whether "MCAT says unkind things about the Senshi" will result in the Senshi losing popularity or MCAT losing popularity, and Samui may not be sure she's going to win that contest.

3) It's a situation where the Senshi took personal risks in order to help MCAT against a major threat that was probably literally coming for Samui's head, and so publicly denouncing the Senshi or complaining about them to her bosses would be both profoundly ungrateful and (importantly) a risk of making her seem ungrateful to the Senshi; the words "see if I ever help YOU again" come to mind.

Honestly, if Samui asks the Senshi not to show up, and they don't, the long-term effects on our public reputation could be complicated. It's like if shit goes down in Metropolis and Superman doesn't show up; people will wonder why.
 
Honestly, if Samui asks the Senshi not to show up, and they don't, the long-term effects on our public reputation could be complicated. It's like if shit goes down in Metropolis and Superman doesn't show up; people will wonder why.
Stuff happens all over Japan, even just all over Tokyo, that we don't show up for because *checks notes* there's a lot going on. If something's not at least as big as that ridiculous tree no one's going to think it's weird we missed a specific incident, not unless it's an attack on the Crystal Millennium building or something.
 
Stuff happens all over Japan, even just all over Tokyo, that we don't show up for because *checks notes* there's a lot going on. If something's not at least as big as that ridiculous tree no one's going to think it's weird we missed a specific incident, not unless it's an attack on the Crystal Millennium building or something.
In general, you're right, especially with the "background radiation" that we've got several Pretty Cure groups who are each, in point of fact, fighting more than one monster of the week per week.

The catch is that an attack on MCAT headquarters by an army of wizards is the kind of thing that is as big as the Uminari Tree Incident, in terms of public perception.
 
Much depends on MCAT's performance. Nobody's going to ask questions about our presence if Onogoro gets crushed. Many more questions will be asked if there's no MCAT left to answer them.

In all but the worst case, though, I think we've sufficiently demonstrated that we're perfectly happy to go to bat for MCAT. More likely the questions will be along the line of why forewarning of the attack came from us, rather than from the Public Security Intelligence Agency, whose job that was supposed to be. This could end up giving them a kick in the ass to monitor people who aren't communists.
 
Well, I'm not sure we'd delegitimize MCAT by showing up against their wishes and helping them out.
Thats how government legitimacy works though. If the government tells you not to do a thing and you do it anyway, they have to punish you or demonstrate that your will supersedes theirs, on their own turf.

You have some wriggle room if they never said anything, but its clear cut if they do say something.

This also applies if they order you to do something, but thats why they always frame it as a request - they don't really want to have to enforce orders that they can't make stick.
 
Thats how government legitimacy works though. If the government tells you not to do a thing and you do it anyway, they have to punish you or demonstrate that your will supersedes theirs, on their own turf.
Only if they make public that the order happened, which has all the considerations Simon listed. Maximum face saving would be to simply not mention it outside of a private conversation with Sailor Moon.
 
Another factor is that the attack is slated to happen in the dead of night (11:45 pm). A lack of immediate witnesses could give MCAT some flexibility in how they choose to present the chain of events to the public.
 
Thats how government legitimacy works though. If the government tells you not to do a thing and you do it anyway, they have to punish you or demonstrate that your will supersedes theirs, on their own turf.

You have some wriggle room if they never said anything, but its clear cut if they do say something.

This also applies if they order you to do something, but thats why they always frame it as a request - they don't really want to have to enforce orders that they can't make stick.
Yeah, what Torgamous said. Remember, this is Japan; if "pretend nothing is wrong in order to save face" is an option, there is going to be a strong tendency to take that option where possible, especially when the alternative involves both looking weak and picking a fight with an ally.
 
/Reminds the thread that Samui has our number. If they ask us to stay away at first, but it turns out the Onogoro attack has them in over their heads, they have the means to contact us (and several Pretty Cure as well) to come in like a cavalry charge.

Edit: Also, Lunaryon has been known to include the general flow of the discussion when expositing the various thought processes of the characters, and what we say to other characters from those thoughts. While "they might not be confident in taking on the trap" would be a valid conclusion off the side, much of the discussion about our desire to avoid the trap hasn't been on whether we can take it, but rather on our preference to deny an enemy information. When Usagi talks to Samui and makes our offer to assist MCAT, it is likely that this preference for information denial is going to be a greater factor in our reasoning for our preference to take on a support role.
 
Last edited:
/Reminds the thread that Samui has our number. If they ask us to stay away at first, but it turns out the Onogoro attack has them in over their heads, they have the means to contact us (and several Pretty Cure as well) to come in like a cavalry charge.
I doubt we'd get Pretty Cures at this time of the night, but you're right that MCAT is capable of trying to contact the Senshi if a decision to send them away proves regrettable.

Edit: Also, Lunaryon has been known to include the general flow of the discussion when expositing the various thought processes of the characters, and what we say to other characters from those thoughts. While "they might not be confident in taking on the trap" would be a valid conclusion off the side, much of the discussion about our desire to avoid the trap hasn't been on whether we can take it, but rather on our preference to deny an enemy information. When Usagi talks to Samui and makes our offer to assist MCAT, it is likely that this preference for information denial is going to be a greater factor in our reasoning for our preference to take on a support role.
On the other hand, this vote was explicitly about attitude, not just tactics or actions. This may be a bit frustrating to people who want Usagi to be an 'empty vessel' for the players' will, but insofar as she still has a personality of her own, her reactions will tend to be "channelized" by her own mentality.

Over and over in this vote, we have seen people start from a technical interpretation of a word or from a justification-neutral description of an action taken, and work backwards to the mindset that they picture giving rise to that action, or that is technically in line with that interpretation of a word.

But the vote itself says it's about the opposite- attitude, not tactics or actions, again.

Usagi isn't a character dominated by her Intrigue score. Indirect thinking like "I don't want to let the enemy know whether their thing would have worked" is less likely to be at the forefront of her mind in general, as compared to "I don't want all my friends getting hit by the thing."

There have been exceptions to that rule in the past, I'm sure, especially in the context of secret identity protection and when Usagi has ample time to consult with advisors. But I don't think we should get used to expecting exceptions to the rule, especially when those exceptions are anticipated in order to enable us to have our cake and eat it too.
 
IMO the in character attitude for the vote lineup is probably:
-There is no reason to keep this secret from an ally. We don't need to worry about MCAT trying to take the method to use against us so we'd only hide it from them if we think we need to act against their instructions.

-We respect the choices of our allies in their own matters. Hopefully they will also respect our choices when the tables turn.

-No reason to take unnecessary risks. It might work, it might not work, but we shouldn't be so cocky as to invite being hit if we don't have to. MAYBE if we can use it to strike a decisive blow or avert disaster, but it doesn't quite seem like that here.
 
-We respect the choices of our allies in their own matters. Hopefully they will also respect our choices when the tables turn.
Do you mean at some future time, not during the present event?

-No reason to take unnecessary risks. It might work, it might not work, but we shouldn't be so cocky as to invite being hit if we don't have to. MAYBE if we can use it to strike a decisive blow or avert disaster, but it doesn't quite seem like that here.
Well, just by showing up and engaging them there's probably some risk; the question is whether to prioritize that at the expense of actually standing and fighting.
 
Well, just by showing up and engaging them there's probably some risk; the question is whether to prioritize that at the expense of actually standing and fighting.
Moon: My work here is done.
IMO Goon:...But you didn't do anything?
Moon:*vanishes in a capeflip*
Samui:...where'd she get that cape anyway? She didn't have it when the Senshi got here.
 
Speaking of goons, it'll be interesting to finally see what Onogoro has to bring to a full-fledged assault. We've seen a few glimpses through the Night Market raid and the... *ahem* "diplomatically challenged" Guardian in the Master of the Mountain sidestory, but this will be the first time we see Onogoro put their best foot forward (Prowess-wise, at least).
 
Speaking of goons, it'll be interesting to finally see what Onogoro has to bring to a full-fledged assault. We've seen a few glimpses through the Night Market raid and the... *ahem* "diplomatically challenged" Guardian in the Master of the Mountain sidestory, but this will be the first time we see Onogoro put their best foot forward (Prowess-wise, at least).
Also the Akaishi Mountain castle garrison, who would presumably have been loaded for bear, as it were. But we never saw them using that firepower.
 
Also, don't forget to read the side content! Sidestories are generally at least mostly canon, apocrypha aren't canon but are fun anyway!
 
Brazil Omake: Transitions New
Brazil Omake: Transitions

Monday, June 22nd

Zoolingualism. The ability to communicate with all members of the animal kingdom. Some mages could cast spells to achieve this effect; others had it as an inherent ability. A few had even made it the cornerstone of their whole magical careers. One of the most famous examples was Antonio Madrigal, who was known for being surrounded by a crowd of animals. Jaguars, capybaras, toucans, coatis, and more other species than anyone could keep track of. He could bring them all together in one harmonious cuddle pile, or unleash them as a terrible wave of nature against those who would threaten his family.

…Lorena was starting to suspect that either Antonio had some empath powers as well, or that all the stories tended to skip over the learning curve.

"Alright, one more time," Lorena said, a bit exasperated. "If any of you see a two-legger with black hair, black eye-covers, and a black cat, heading to this apartment, within three street corners of here, then you come to this balcony and tell me. Understood?"

All the eyes of the flock of pigeons were on Lorena. Granted, the direction their beaks were facing shifted every four seconds or so, so it was a little difficult to determine if they were truly paying attention.

"And then we get food?" one of the pigeons asked.

"Yes, you get food when you report seeing him, and once in the morning every three days," Lorena said. "We'll keep this arrangement for one month, er, one moon, then see if we want to keep working together."

"…Food now?" another pigeon asked.

Lorena sighed. "Yes, that includes food now. Deal?"

The flock replied with an intermittent chorus of "Deal." Lorena grabbed a handful of birdseed from her bag, scattered it across the balcony, then stepped back as the pigeons ravenously descended on it. "And no pooping on the balcony!" she said as she closed the sliding glass door behind her. She was glad that she lived in a "magic-friendly" neighborhood. Negotiations with pigeons might raise a few eyebrows elsewhere.

Lorena sighed as she sat down at her desk and started on her homework. After the ritual at Mama Sandra's farm, Lorena had been excited to discover that she could understand and be understood by the farm animals. That little perk of creating a ritual through the Den of Beasts was unexpected, but not unwelcome. However, after some experimentation showed that the ability could be "selectively muted". Mama Sandra had taken Lorena aside and explained that any hopes of suddenly becoming a "Disney princess" would not be so simple. Animals had different perspectives, priorities, and values from humans, and generally lacked the capacity or desire to try to see things from a human's point of view, so any communications would have to be brought down to the animal's level. There were also other factors to consider, like whether she wanted to hear the thoughts of insects or pests, the intent behind most bird calls being ruined forever, and reexamining her relationship with the food chain. In short, this ability could prove a blessing, but fully incorporating it into her lifestyle would take careful consideration regarding her investment and intentionality.

"If you wish to practice with deal-making, don't start with dogs," Mama Sandra had said. "They will spoil your expectations. Eager to please, happy to work, and quick to forget grudges. Cats, on the other hand, are too hard. Entitled little beasts, who must be praised like kings or tricked into thinking that a task was their own idea, and even then may simply forget about any deals if sufficiently distracted. Pigeons are good for beginners. No innate affection or dislike in either direction, making a blank slate to start negotiations from. They're good with directions and time, they can count up to nine, and they respect consistency. Start with something simple; mistakes will happen and you can both learn what to expect from each other. Don't deal with parrots or caracaras until you're ready to get serious. They're smarter, but they're more exacting in their terms and can carry grudges for a LONG time."

Luckily, given how much work it was taking to get used to, the zoolingualism was merely an unexpected side benefit. Coco was the real prize, and Lorena was more than happy with her. The familiar was about as curious and energetic as a seven-year-old. She had a LOT to learn, having only been born a week ago, but she absorbed information like a sponge. And, thankfully, Coco was able to maintain her discipline on outings with Lorena, while transformed as a white sunhat. Lorena had tried checking out books on childcare, rabbit care, and familiars from the Universidade library, and had spent a considerable amount of time trying to cross-reference them into some cohesive understanding of how to make sure that Coco would develop properly.

The book on familiars provided some degree of comfort, explaining that the key element that familiars needed at this early stage of development was simply continued engagement with their master. Familiars were tied to their master's very souls, and over time they would naturally develop a sense of synchronicity with their master's mentality and health. As long as the familiar shared time and attention with their master, and wasn't actively abused or neglected, then everything would eventually settle into equilibrium.

…Of course, there were a few things that the familiar-raising book didn't have right about Coco. Lorena had considered that maybe it was an outdated copy, and that familiar-crafting may have been refined a bit more since it was originally published. Maybe it was intended to present a generalist approach, to accommodate the full range of familiars that could be crafted, formed, and summoned by different rituals. Otherwise, the only remaining conclusion was that Coco's capacities as a familiar were… a bit of an outlier.

The book said that a familiar would have a small mana pool of its own that it could use to cast spells, and that the master mage could draw upon this in case of emergencies. The book warned that this should be done with great care, especially in the early period, because it could easily exhaust the familiar. Coco had her own pool, sure enough… but it refilled itself very quickly indeed. Lorena found herself drawing a trickle from her almost by accident at times, and this seemed to have no ill effect on Coco at all.

The book said that a new, professionally-crafted familiar could maintain their connection to their master at a range of up to four kilometers. After leaving Coco with Ruan and Café for a play-date, Lorena discovered that her link to Coco held itself together well past seven kilometers- probably eight. Either the book had left a few things out, or her craftsmanship was rather more than merely professional.

The book went into great detail about the hallmark capability of a familiar: spell transference. In addition to telepathy at a distance, a mage could eventually learn to see through the familiar's eyes, listen through its ears, and even send spells through their connection to their familiar as if they were casting from their own hands. The book cautioned the reader that mages who had just gotten familiars may have to put themselves into a meditative trance to use those capabilities until they'd gotten considerable practice, and mentioned the lower "fidelity" of sensory data and potency of spells carried by the link to the familiar at the limits of their range.

Lorena and Coco had, so far, run into very few of these problems. The little performance they'd prepared for her family (with Coco wearing the *cutest* little witch hat) had seen Lorena cast spells "through" Coco with ease and fluidity. Even during the range experiment, her telepathy only started developing "static" in the last 30 meters or so. 'Static' wasn't quite the word, and the experience had been... odd... but compared to what the book warned Lorena to expect, the quality and fidelity of the connection was outstanding.

Even if Coco somehow wasn't a record-setter, her abilities were more than enough to recommend the idea of using the Companions of Legend ritual to give similarly gifted familiars to all her family… if it weren't for the "gatekeeper." Ruan had originally recommended the ritual in the belief that the Den of Beasts was empty, and would passively permit the ritual's completion. It muddied the waters a bit to know that there was some Japanese god involved who, if nothing else, clearly had opinions about who deserved to be granted a familiar. So next term, Lorena would take a class in Japanese at the Universidade, and then work with Ruan to reach out to the Den of Beasts again to learn the god's expectations for future petitioners. Until then, spreading the ritual around would have to wait. It would be bad if she tried sharing the ritual with her family, only for them all to be rejected- or, conceivably, worse- because the god didn't "find them worthy."

Lorena suddenly heard Coco's voice in her mind. "Lorena, come here! My new picture is done!"

She smiled. Coco had taken a shine to her drawings, and had eagerly tackled making drawings of her own with the crayon set Lorena had bought for her. "Alright, let's take a peek!"

Following the thread of her exchanged thoughts, Lorena reached out to Coco to see… two little paws covering her eyes?

"No, no peeking through my eyes! I want to see your face when you see it!"

"…Very well, I'm on my way."
Lorena stood up and headed to the living room, where she had set up Coco's enclosure.

"I'm here, now show me what you got."

"Yay! Here we… oops, lost the page." Coco reached over to a notepad almost as big as she was and started flipping through it. Lorena glimpsed the earlier crayon "masterpieces" that Coco had worked on: the Oliveira family, Coco and Café together, the view from the apartment window, a white castle (Coco called it a 'Moon Palace' and Lorena still didn't know where she'd gotten the idea for that one), and finally…

"Ta-da!" Coco flipped the notebook to display a picture of four girls in frilly dresses. Lorena quickly recognized the colors and styles of the red, yellow, and blue Curas Bonitas, but they seemed to be joined by a fourth Cura who wore a white dress and… had a hat with bunny ears sticking out the top.

"Very nice, Coco! It looks like the Curas Bonitas and… is that supposed to be you and me?"

Coco nodded. "Mmm-hmm! I thought it would be cool to have a team-up with the Curas Bonitas and Lorena, the Witch Bunny and her adorable assistant, Coco! What do you think?"

Lorena gave some thought about how to respond to that. "Well, it's a wonderful drawing, and I'm glad to see you excited about magic. But… you know that I'm not strong enough to fight those Phantom Empire cryptids, right? I don't have the spells or training to do that."

Coco sighed. "I know. But the pretty girls need help, right? When are the Peacekeepers going to team up with them?"

"There's been some difficulties with that," Lorena admitted. "The Peacekeepers have been helping the police behind the scenes, but the Curas haven't exactly been leaving ways to contact them, and the Peacekeepers are… hesitant to try and catch them in broad daylight. Remember when we talked about the Masquerade?"

Coco nodded. "I remember, but… Lorena, you said that knowledge of magic and cryptids can end up scaring regular people, and regular people can end up doing dumb and hurtful things when they get scared, so it's best for everyone for magic and cryptids to stay hidden."

"Yes, that's mostly right."

"But the Phantom Empire isn't hiding."

Lorena paused. "…Yes, that's true."

"And the Dark Liberators you talked about aren't hiding. And the towers of brass and silver are, uh, whatever the exact opposite of hiding is. So all the bad mages and cryptids are out there making people scared, but the good mages and cryptids care more about hiding than stopping them?" Coco tilted her head. "…Lorena, this whole Masquerade thing sounds kind of dumb."

"Coco, it's not… It's a lot more complicated than that," Lorena tried to explain. "The mages and cryptids have been maintaining the Masquerade for hundreds of years, even when weren't on good terms with each other. I know that it's frustrating, but you have to trust that the Peacekeepers know what they're doing."

Coco turned her head away, frustrated. "Hmph. Still think it's dumb."

Lorena sympathized with Coco's frustration. The limitations of the Masquerade in the face of the recent invaders were making things... difficult. Coco wasn't the only one starting to feel that way. And Coco didn't even have a frame of reference of what is was supposed to be like. All she had ever known were these berserk super-cryptids and magical girls running around.

…Perhaps it would be good to show Coco what some "secret helping" would look like.

"Well, I do my part to help the neighborhood from time to time. Would you like to join me on my next patrol?" Lorena asked with a sly grin.

"…Am I going to be stuck as a quiet hat the whole time?" Coco asked suspiciously.

"Nope, you can be a loud and proud bunny the whole time. In fact, my special patrols allow me to use magic as freely as I want!"

Coco's expression shifted to excitement. "Really? Why didn't you tell me sooner? Let's go!"

"Easy there, Coco. You just need to make sure that you go to sleep early tonight. Can you do that for me?"

"Early bedtime, got it! Will we be waking up super early?"

"…Something like that."
 
"If you wish to practice with deal-making, don't start with dogs," Mama Sandra had said. "They will spoil your expectations. Eager to please, happy to work, and quick to forget grudges. Cats, on the other hand, are too hard. Entitled little beasts, who must be praised like kings or tricked into thinking that a task was their own idea, and even then may simply forget about any deals if sufficiently distracted.
Now where was that quote....
Dogs are like🐶: This person feeds me, waters me, pets me. They must be God.
Cats are like🐱: This person feeds me, waters me, pets me. I must be God.
Not sure where the bunny is going to fall onto the spectrum.
 
That sure is one suspicious magic bunny!

I... suppose there's nothing preventing an ensouled familiar from being a reincarnation from before the Fall though?
 
Back
Top