But assuming the ORDI is just for group defense in a less developed part of space, it still looks like the start of something greater.
I would caution that sheer numbers and centuries of cultural heritage means us leading the nations of our pact is quite unlikely. However taking the position of invaluable trade partner, leader in R&D, and financial hub is well within our means. In that way our neighbors act as a screen between us and the IS while paying us for the privilege.
 
I would caution that sheer numbers and centuries of cultural heritage means us leading the nations of our pact is quite unlikely. However taking the position of invaluable trade partner, leader in R&D, and financial hub is well within our means. In that way our neighbors act as a screen between us and the IS while paying us for the privilege.
Playing devil's advocate here, but why shouldn't the Helghast head such a hypothetical empire? Because they lack the history these other Empire's do, especially with each other, they won't chaff from having to work under the auspices of their former rivals. They've also been the one's to build these diplomatic and cultural ties, bring incredible knowledge with them, developing new technologies while rediscovering the old(for this universe), have an incredible industrial base, are building their own FTL comm systems and FTL ships, and militarily are not pushover's in the slightest(really looking forward to developing Petrusite weapons and technologies). The thing working against them the most, at the moment, is somewhat lacking population numbers. Even then there's something like what, a billion and a half of them?

I don't think the other empires would like being under Helghast rule, not at first, but to me it comes across as by far the least bad opinion, maybe even reaching into good.
Solid analysis and I'm glad you did it, as it shows a pretty good idea as to what the more savvy of the inner sphere and *com may be thinking.
Thank you, but while that was part of what I intended, I was also asking how close I was to the thread's own goals.
In time.
 
Last edited:
Thank you, but while that was part of what I intended, I was also asking how close I was to the thread's own goals.
You are actually fairly close to the mark (if not spot on the mark). We are sort of building a hegemonic empire and expanding our sphere of influence across the periphery and even into the Inner Sphere (starting with the Federated Suns). We are also steadily expanding our own boarders by colonization and other means, thus building our own empire. As for if any of this is a stated and agreed goal/s we are working toward, the only one we actually agree upon is the steady expansion of our boarders. The rest is somewhat uncertain as we have not agreed or decided upon an exact imperial goal.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the other empires would like being under Helghast rule, not at first, but to me it comes across as by far the least bad opinion, maybe even reaching into good.
Long long incredibly long history of other powers attempting to assert their authority into these systems shows that they will far more than not like any kind of political coup. The Star League tried to claim dominion of the Rim Nations with every material advantage possible and broke apart before succeeding. We cannot unilaterally decide to rule these people without convincing them it would be the better option which will take a diplomatic miracle.
 
I think we are gonna end up more like a looser but more streamlined European Union with a hefty dash of NATO. if we end up as a leader its because we're operating as a soft power hegmon where we don't demand things but rather we can simply ask nicely about things and the others will go along simply because its minor compared to what we have done for them and it doesn't hurt them.
 
I think we are gonna end up more like a looser but more streamlined European Union with a hefty dash of NATO. if we end up as a leader its because we're operating as a soft power hegmon where we don't demand things but rather we can simply ask nicely about things and the others will go along simply because its minor compared to what we have done for them and it doesn't hurt them.
That's what @Nottheunmaker have been saying? At least that's the impression I got.
 
Last edited:
Playing devil's advocate here, but why shouldn't the Helghast head such a hypothetical empire? Because they lack the history these other Empire's do, especially with each other, they won't chaff from having to work under the auspices of their former rivals. They've also been the one's to build these diplomatic and cultural ties, bring incredible knowledge with them, developing new technologies while rediscovering the old(for this universe), have an incredible industrial base, are building their own FTL comm systems and FTL ships, and militarily are not pushover's in the slightest(really looking forward to developing Petrusite weapons and technologies). The thing working against them the most, at the moment, is somewhat lacking population numbers. Even then there's something like what, a billion and a half of them?
So we're the equivalent of the Terran Hegemony? Actually, extending this comparison further, ORDI could be seen as something similar to the Star League. The main difference is that we actually share our tech and aren't being a bag of dicks. It also helps that we don't have a Drac equivalent that's constantly stirring shit up.
 
So, as an outsider looking in, I'll give my take on what the Helghan Republic are doing. This my way of saying hi, by the way.

First, a clarification. I say outsider looking in because I haven't read the majority of the thread discussion. I'm sorry, but this thread is almost four hundred and three quarters long, and most of it seems to be hashing the fine details of plans. It's not worth sorting through to find large minded goals or ideas that have been tossed around. I should also note I know very little about Killzone or Battletech, beyond #HelghastDidNothingWrong and #MechsAreAwesome. So I'm missing some context.

Also, I must say having a crossover between something like Killzone and Battletech is inspired and daring in the best possible way, and I admire the meer idea greatly. The execution? Even more so. Sure, plonking Helgan in a little what I assume to be a backwater corner of the Battletech galaxy isn't much of a brain melter, but watching the butterfly effects of it happening and the player's efforts to affect the area is both very well handled and fascinating to watch. Really makes me want to take a stab at a Valkyria Chronicles/Resistance: Fall of Man cross I've kicked around. But I digress.

So, the first thing that comes to mind is they way the Helghast are courting the large nearby powers. Supporting the war efforts of the Taurian Concordat, having helped restore the legitimate government of the Aurigan Coalition, keeping the Magistracy of Canopus from losing their science and academics. Then there was the anti-pirate protection agreement, building their own FTL comm system between, at least, the capitals of these powers systems, and finally, trading technical knowledge for technical knowledge and following up on it with research agreements. Not to mention the continued efforts in tourism and cultural exchanges.

From my point of view, the Helghast are trying to unite these empires, possibly with just formal agreements that strongly encourage them to act as one. But, if I were more cynical, then I would think the Helghast are trying to build an Empire in the Periphery, one with the technology, industrial base and population to rival an inner sphere power, with themselves leading it. And why not? They've got the much more developed education system, they're not only reverse engineering advanced technologies but developing new ones, have access to a unique resource that will give them powerful advantages, and the Helghast themselves, as I've read, are simply superior to humans. They're bigger, stronger, adapted to harsh environments, and more intelligent. Sure they mostly lack hair, are pale and cover themselves heavily, but they've got an undeniable advantage on humans.

But assuming the ORDI is just for group defense in a less developed part of space, it still looks like the start of something greater.

Welcome newcomer! Always nice to see a friendly face.

As for your evaluation of events, yes we are basically trying to tie the 3 local nations together, though their cultures and histories makes that very difficult to push past the current defense pact state. the best we are probably going to get is something like a NATO/NAFTA set up rather than the EU. Each of the member Nations outside of the Republic have strong reasons to dislike and distrust each other, which is why it took bribing them with FTL comms to get ORDI off the ground to begin with so a unified foreign policy and/or economy isn't happening any time soon if at all.

Also the difference between the Helghast and Humans is basically zero, its mostly just propaganda going one way or another between Helgens and Vektans.
 
I think we are gonna end up more like a looser but more streamlined European Union with a hefty dash of NATO. if we end up as a leader its because we're operating as a soft power hegmon where we don't demand things but rather we can simply ask nicely about things and the others will go along simply because its minor compared to what we have done for them and it doesn't hurt them.

The problem is the EU style system requires sacrificing sovereignty which none of the member states would ever agree to. extended trade agreements, research, and a robust defense pacts are probably how things will turn out. And trying to press beyond that risks destroying everything we are building, its not worth it just to say we can paint the map with our name a bit bigger. Thats the trap the Great Houses fell into, and look where it got them.
 
now i'm imaginign a comstar schism where the idealists defect to the ORDI as being the closest they are gonna get to a second star leauge.
Sounds like a toxic element? We don't (seem to) want the tech monopoly as badly and they'd be liable to press on our allies more than feasible.

It'd be worth embracing to weaken C*, once we get independent confirmation in-game on what they've been up to--but carefully, and on a very short leash.
 
Playing devil's advocate here, but why shouldn't the Helghast head such a hypothetical empire? Because they lack the history these other Empire's do, especially with each other, they won't chaff from having to work under the auspices of their former rivals. They've also been the one's to build these diplomatic and cultural ties, bring incredible knowledge with them, developing new technologies while rediscovering the old(for this universe), have an incredible industrial base, are building their own FTL comm systems and FTL ships, and militarily are not pushover's in the slightest(really looking forward to developing Petrusite weapons and technologies). The thing working against them the most, at the moment, is somewhat lacking population numbers. Even then there's something like what, a billion and a half of them?
Mostly because we have no interest in making an Empire out of them. We want allies not subjects and a barrier. We have our own area of interest we want them to help protect that and get things going so we can resist any other power trying to start shit with us or our friends. Also for the Helghast thing while they are superior to baseline humans it isn't nearly as much as it was played up to be. And the hair loss and paleness were not from the changes but from not having good health care or nutrition. Same with the mask they don't need them they just keep them because they are cultural. They are still pale but no more than a normal person that doesn't get a lot of sun and they have hair unless they are balding or shaving.
 
Also the difference between the Helghast and Humans is basically zero, its mostly just propaganda going one way or another between Helgens and Vektans.
laughs in Helghast natural immunity to radiation.

Other then that little canon detail yes there is almost no difference. It's pretty much just skin color and body shape. And as said before only major difference is that native helgans are immune to radiation while vektans need genetherapy or lots of anti-rad treatment s or meds. Which could prove usefull if we need to recover stuff from truely dead worlds bombed into Oblivion by nukes.
 
laughs in Helghast natural immunity to radiation.

Other then that little canon detail yes there is almost no difference. It's pretty much just skin color and body shape. And as said before only major difference is that native helgans are immune to radiation while vektans need genetherapy or lots of anti-rad treatment s or meds. Which could prove usefull if we need to recover stuff from truely dead worlds bombed into Oblivion by nukes.
The Helghast are stronger than normal Humans as well but not majorly and that is because they adapted to live on high gravity worlds. Body shape is the same and paleness is because they live on a planet that got less sun. But if they got sun they would be more normal.
 
Sounds like a toxic element? We don't (seem to) want the tech monopoly as badly and they'd be liable to press on our allies more than feasible.

It'd be worth embracing to weaken C*, once we get independent confirmation in-game on what they've been up to--but carefully, and on a very short leash.
Comstar has three "factions", the idealists, the Blakists and the Toryamaist. The Idealists are the rank and file who fully believe in comstar's public persona and all want to make things better; because of this they are completely locked out of leadership roles outside of the explorer corps.

The other two factions both buy into the comstar is destined to rule stupidity with arguments over methods. The Blakesits want to use a soft touch approch and "guide" inner sphere while the other faction are the ones who founded the Word of Blake.
 
They've got the much more developed education system, they're not only reverse engineering advanced technologies but developing new ones, have access to a unique resource that will give them powerful advantages, and the Helghast themselves, as I've read, are simply superior to humans. They're bigger, stronger, adapted to harsh environments, and more intelligent. Sure they mostly lack hair, are pale and cover themselves heavily, but they've got an undeniable advantage on humans.
I would have to dig deeper to find a proper cite, but IIRC this last bit has been heavily downplayed/retconned as having been mostly propaganda pushed by the fascists (Visari and co) while they were in control as part of their justifications for the rest of the stuff they did.

The main difference is that we actually share our tech and aren't being a bag of dicks.
We definitely aren't being a bag of dicks, but we haven't actually done all that much tech sharing - there's been a few joint research projects and we've been happy to share the products of our techbase, but none of the major tech advances (all of the petrusite derived stuff, our FTL method, our FTL comms) have been shared as of yet.
 
Long long incredibly long history of other powers attempting to assert their authority into these systems shows that they will far more than not like any kind of political coup. The Star League tried to claim dominion of the Rim Nations with every material advantage possible and broke apart before succeeding. We cannot unilaterally decide to rule these people without convincing them it would be the better option which will take a diplomatic miracle.
I could defintaly be wrong, but that makes it sound like CommStar tried something like an invasion, which so far isn't something the Helghast are going to try.
I think we are gonna end up more like a looser but more streamlined European Union with a hefty dash of NATO. if we end up as a leader its because we're operating as a soft power hegmon where we don't demand things but rather we can simply ask nicely about things and the others will go along simply because its minor compared to what we have done for them and it doesn't hurt them.
That's what @Nottheunmaker have been saying? At least that's the impression I got.
they were a bit more round about with it.
More like leaving room for interpretation. So far if the Helghast have wanted something from their neighbors, they've been able to bribe or call in favors from past bribes to get it done. They haven't used force much yet, but I'm not ruling out the possibility of it in the future.
The problem is the EU style system requires sacrificing sovereignty which none of the member states would ever agree to. extended trade agreements, research, and a robust defense pacts are probably how things will turn out. And trying to press beyond that risks destroying everything we are building, its not worth it just to say we can paint the map with our name a bit bigger. Thats the trap the Great Houses fell into, and look where it got them.
Never say never. The Republic has been very good at enabling the various large powers to accomplish their own goals, solving disputes between them while also helping to develop their technology, industry and culture. The ORDI is a never before seen development between these powers, and given how such agreements are likely seen by outside powers, and how important appearances are to nations like this, that they agreed at all indicates they're more open to the idea then they've ever been before.
Mostly because we have no interest in making an Empire out of them. We want allies not subjects and a barrier. We have our own area of interest we want them to help protect that and get things going so we can resist any other power trying to start shit with us or our friends.
I can see that, but only after you explained it like that. But given how it seems most nations behave I think it's more likely to be seen as a kind of empire building. More maybe just converting those powers from within.

During the Succession War, the Taurian Concordat fought with a great deal of ammunition supplied by the Helghast. While can't say how well they would've done without it, I think they took something like ten worlds with that ammo. Not to mention the anti-grav tech they've developed, though limited, is known to be somethingonly the Helghast had. The Aurigan Coalition current leader was supported partly by Magistracy, but very publicly by the Helghast, and again during the war Helghan troops personally defend Coalition planets. And the Magistracy of Canopus greatly owes the Helghast for not only halting the backslide of their biomedical industry, which was one of their greater claims to fame, but is even now working with them to generate new developments.

Plus day-to-day, the Helghast export lots of personal electronics only they seem to know to produce to all of these powers in addition to other technological goods, and a great deal of military goods as well. And now their focusing hard on culture trade, and while Helghan is likely to become the main cultural melting pot of the Periphery, that melding culture is getting re-exported back out with heavy overtones of the Helghan Republic's already strong culture. Not to mention all these Helghan lead research initiatives and Helghan businesses setting up branches in ORDI nations.

While this doesn't seem to be the intent, if people are using Helghast computers to watch Helghast movies, working at Helghast companies, and those people are defended by Helghast guns and sometimes even Helghast soldiers, then from the outside those people of Taurian, Aurigan and Canopus nationalities look like the Helghast.
Also for the Helghast thing while they are superior to baseline humans it isn't nearly as much as it was played up to be. And the hair loss and paleness were not from the changes but from not having good health care or nutrition. Same with the mask they don't need them they just keep them because they are cultural. They are still pale but no more than a normal person that doesn't get a lot of sun and they have hair unless they are balding or shaving.
I would have to dig deeper to find a proper cite, but IIRC this last bit has been heavily downplayed/retconned as having been mostly propaganda pushed by the fascists (Visari and co) while they were in control as part of their justifications for the rest of the stuff they did.
Just to be clear, is this something from Killzone canon, or is it just for this quest?
So we're the equivalent of the Terran Hegemony? Actually, extending this comparison further, ORDI could be seen as something similar to the Star League. The main difference is that we actually share our tech and aren't being a bag of dicks. It also helps that we don't have a Drac equivalent that's constantly stirring shit up.
We definitely aren't being a bag of dicks, but we haven't actually done all that much tech sharing - there's been a few joint research projects and we've been happy to share the products of our techbase, but none of the major tech advances (all of the petrusite derived stuff, our FTL method, our FTL comms) have been shared as of yet.
The Helghast treat their tech as a trade tool far as I've seen. If someone has a tech they want, they'll trade their own tech for it.



Okay, that's responses. I've still got a few questions about Helghast activities on the independent worlds near them, or at least observations.

Caliban seems straightforward in one way, but a mystery in another. I assume with all the infiltration of the Prospero Pact the idea is to take it down from the inside. But what about the Kahn? I've seen no moves against her, nor attempts to entice. I doubt the Helghast are quite so generous as to settle for controlling half a planet, ironic though it would be given the irrelevant events of Shadow Fall, so I'm wondering what the plan is for it.

New Oslo I know has lots of Star League tech buried under the ice, but the last action I saw voted for was selling guns to the sides that don't have guns. I'm guessing this is to sew instability on the planet like was originally done for Portland that the Republic can use as a front to go in and take over, especially with the very low local technology levels. Then rebuild the orbital mirrors to make the place much more habitable and defrost the SL tech.

Tiverton is easy. It's unstable, is near those Pirate worlds and can't put up a unified front. Better to make them part of the Republic now then have them make trouble later, or join up with the pirate empire.

Rockwellawan is what I'm most confused by. I get they're in a dangerous position and we want to help them out, but I'm not clear on long-term goals for the planet or if there even are any.

Anyway, just want to know if I'm missing the mark and by how much if so.
 
I could defintaly be wrong, but that makes it sound like CommStar tried something like an invasion, which so far isn't something the Helghast are going to try.
The Rim was getting a boot to the teeth from the major Inner Sphere powers long before Comstar was a glint in Blake's eye. The cultural scars of their quite brutal conquest and occupation will shape any attempts for us to effect their politics, is basically what I am saying. Especially the Concordant where one of their national ideals can be summed up by this picture except the grenade is an oversized nuclear stockpile.
 
Okay, that's responses. I've still got a few questions about Helghast activities on the independent worlds near them, or at least observations.

Caliban seems straightforward in one way, but a mystery in another. I assume with all the infiltration of the Prospero Pact the idea is to take it down from the inside. But what about the Kahn? I've seen no moves against her, nor attempts to entice. I doubt the Helghast are quite so generous as to settle for controlling half a planet, ironic though it would be given the irrelevant events of Shadow Fall, so I'm wondering what the plan is for it.

New Oslo I know has lots of Star League tech buried under the ice, but the last action I saw voted for was selling guns to the sides that don't have guns. I'm guessing this is to sew instability on the planet like was originally done for Portland that the Republic can use as a front to go in and take over, especially with the very low local technology levels. Then rebuild the orbital mirrors to make the place much more habitable and defrost the SL tech.

Tiverton is easy. It's unstable, is near those Pirate worlds and can't put up a unified front. Better to make them part of the Republic now then have them make trouble later, or join up with the pirate empire.

Rockwellawan is what I'm most confused by. I get they're in a dangerous position and we want to help them out, but I'm not clear on long-term goals for the planet or if there even are any.

Anyway, just want to know if I'm missing the mark and by how much if so.

Caliban : The pact is a greater long term threat to our occupation than the Khan, given that the majority of the Khans power comes from the fact that she is the only one on the planet with a Battlemech. Additionally the Khanatte's future in question once the Khan dies given probable lack of heirs, really all we have to do with the Khannate is wait until it either comes to the table or collapses. Conversely the Pact is an established power on the planet and is much harder to defeat without just stomping it with military force , which people refuse to do, hence the sabatoge.

New Oslo: Pretty much the same thing as Caliban but in reverse in that we don't want things to implode. The would be king has no ability to hold their power/position long term, and all us supporting him would do is make things bad in the long run. I am hoping that selling guns to the other side would cause both parties to stop fighting, due to being equals, and maybe settle on the original borders. I am expect either a cold war situation to form or the Coalition to crush the king. Either way this conflict pales in comparison with the long term issue of dealing with New Oslo's religion/governance, because that is the big issue to try and deal with without ruining relations, if the ultimate goal is to integrate them peacefully because thats very tricky.

Rockwellawan: basically Portland 2.0, where we want them to join the Republic of their own accord, based on current relations this will happen sooner rather than later given we are already defending them. Tie in an FTL line and wait for the pirates to do something stupid, like attack detroit, and they will probably see joining the republic as the safest bet.
 
Back
Top