Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

^^^
The Reds want to rule, not to destroy reality. They seek power, not annihilation. It just turns out that almost everyone who thinks they can use the Outsiders to their own goals of power and glory almost always find themselves in above their heads.

Those who play with the devil's toys will be brought by degrees to wield his sword.


Adhoc vote count started by uju32 on Sep 11, 2024 at 12:48 PM, finished with 56 posts and 2 votes.

  • [X] Seems like the best you're going to get, show up fifteen, twenty miles from the Old Town and then make your way to one of the entrances
    [X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
    -[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight


====
VOTE
[X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
 
We've been told in this quest by DP that's what the original Yama Kings are. You may disagree, but that's what they are here. Mikaboshi is in part so powerful because he killed an at least part fallen angel and seized its mantle/power, or someone else had previously done that and he seized that power from them in turn:

The history of the Thousand Hells seem to be similar to that of KotE. God put a bunch of angels/ministers of heaven in charge of the Hells for them to rehabilitate mortal souls through punishment and most of them got greedy and fell into corruption, and subsequently other powers joined their number, whether by killing and replacing the fallen angels/ministers or some other means.

In the same way Lucifer fell and became Satan, the Heavenly Ministers in charge of what became the Hells mostly fell and became the Yama Kings. Lucifer under this model, is just one of the many angels who fell at different times, if a particularly powerful one who led other angels to fall with him.

Just as in some forms of angel/chistiology the sires of the Nephilim were angels who fell thanks to their lust but weren't part of Lucifer's treason.

The thing is that Hellfire is a very specific power in the DF where you draw from the Fallen's Hell.

I can buy a functionally similar sponsored magic being provided, but even if you take them as all being the same tier they wouldn't be the same thing and wouldn't be referred to by the same name by someone like McCoy.

In part it's a cultural branding thing. No American is ever going to call a burger a grilled beef sandwich even if that's technically accurate description. Similarly, a burger made with other meat will get called out. A turkey burger will almost always be called that instead of just a burger.

If he meant Lanka's hatefire or something then he almost certainly would have been specific.
 
We don't actually know that. The Red Court may be trying to use the outsiders for their own aims just like the Black Council is.
They publicly and on large scale associate with outsiders. That alone is a reason not to make them part of anything to do with Outer Gates. It should be a reason for them to be exterminated, but isn't somehow.
 
The thing is that Hellfire is a very specific power in the DF where you draw from the Fallen's Hell.

I can buy a functionally similar sponsored magic being provided, but even if you take them as all being the same tier they wouldn't be the same thing and wouldn't be referred to by the same name by someone like McCoy.

In part it's a cultural branding thing. No American is ever going to call a burger a grilled beef sandwich even if that's technically accurate description. Similarly, a burger made with other meat will get called out. A turkey burger will almost always be called that instead of just a burger.

If he meant Lanka's hatefire or something then he almost certainly would have been specific.
I mean in the middle of high intensity situation. I do get what you mean about cultural branding but in the middle of combat Hellfire which is for wizards the same thing as Lanka hate fire but one of those is definitely less well known than the other so you might as well call it Hellfire anyway simply because it's a fire of hell and it does the same thing if it hits you. Which is to say eat away at your magic and try to fucking eat you maliciously so don't get hit by it "Hellfire incoming".
 
They publicly and on large scale associate with outsiders. That alone is a reason not to make them part of anything to do with Outer Gates. It should be a reason for them to be exterminated, but isn't somehow.
They even source them to other factions/individuals like the Walker we fought at the ball. Kind of undermines Winter's efforts at the Gates if a global scale faction blatantly brings them in past the Gates and furthers their agenda. I wouldn't be surprised if Peabody was sourced his current patron from the Reds it's that bad.

Edit: The Las Vegas event was also partially because of a Rampire. It keeps happening!!
 
Last edited:
The thing is that Hellfire is a very specific power in the DF where you draw from the Fallen's Hell.

I can buy a functionally similar sponsored magic being provided, but even if you take them as all being the same tier they wouldn't be the same thing and wouldn't be referred to by the same name by someone like McCoy.

In part it's a cultural branding thing. No American is ever going to call a burger a grilled beef sandwich even if that's technically accurate description. Similarly, a burger made with other meat will get called out. A turkey burger will almost always be called that instead of just a burger.

If he meant Lanka's hatefire or something then he almost certainly would have been specific.
This.
When he first met and talked with Molly, he described her not as a hell-princess, but specifically as something out of Lanka:
"Dad I literally felt absolutely nothing," you insist squeezing his hand to make the point that you are alright, other than being an icicle and all.
"OK so we have established that Outsiders cannot mess with my head and they burn when I set them on fire..."

"Usually when something looks too good to be true that's because it is," McCoy cuts you off before taking a sip of his coffee as if daring you to argue. "Lucky for you that you look like some mad conjuror's set loose one of Ravana's Maharajas until we had a sit down. Good talk."

Usum actually starts giggling. "I like this one."
This was after seeing Molly's hell aura and demon sword with all the fire on it.

When he says Hellfire here, he isnt likely to be talking about something out of the Thousand Hells.
Or from beyond the Outer Gates.
Dude has the experience to be precise about what he's referring to.

And precision is probably necessary here, since he's about to lead other wizards into combat.
The vulnerabilities, and applicable banes, of the hostiles they will meet are different depending on their affiliation.
Holy water might work on people aligned with Hell; wont work on Outsiders AFAIK.

They even source them to other factions/individuals like the Walker we fought at the ball. Kind of undermines Winter's efforts at the Gates if a global scale faction blatantly brings them in past the Gates and furthers their agenda. I wouldn't be surprised if Peabody was sourced his current patron from the Reds it's that bad.
We know nothing about the source of the Raith Ball Walker.
The White Court has its own independent history of meddlers playing footsie with Outsiders; the White King has an antimagic Investment from Outsiders, and was using an Outsider-summoning ritual to kill people in Blood Rites.


There is no grand conspiracy of evil, and Evil will backstab Evil as soon as they find it profitable to do so.
Do remember that the White Court under Lord Raith masterminded the fall of the Black Court of vampires.
And in this quest, the Red Court specifically fucked over Iku-Turso and the Pathfinders.

They act in their own perceived interest.
 
Last edited:
[X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
-[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight
 
We know nothing about the source of the Raith Ball Walker.
The White Court has its own independent history of meddlers playing footsie with Outsiders; the White King has an antimagic Investment from Outsiders, and was using an Outsider-summoning ritual to kill people in Blood Rites.
I thought it was established otherwise but I don't care enough to go back and check. At any rate yes some of the Whites do, undermining what Winter does even more but the Reds are way worse and much more blatant with it. Shouldn't even have trusted a Red to hold the Gate in Vegas.
 
[X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
-[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight
 
They even source them to other factions/individuals like the Walker we fought at the ball. Kind of undermines Winter's efforts at the Gates if a global scale faction blatantly brings them in past the Gates and furthers their agenda. I wouldn't be surprised if Peabody was sourced his current patron from the Reds it's that bad.

Edit: The Las Vegas event was also partially because of a Rampire. It keeps happening!!
Part of this might be that winters being cheap and letting the council deal with it first. Also you know its probably not the first time shit like this has been pulled by an earth faction.
 
[X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
-[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight
 
Part of this might be that winters being cheap and letting the council deal with it first. Also you know its probably not the first time shit like this has been pulled by an earth faction.

Or they don't think the Red Court's dealings with Outsiders are a real threat, and it's worth whatever risk it does present if the result is to weaken or destroy the White Council.

Winter could well also be indirectly trying to use Outsiders as a weapon, by turning a blind eye to the Red Court using them against a mutual enemy/competitor, given the way that the White Council is the only major supernatural power that stands up for humanity.

This is probably foolish and short sighted, but is probably quite possible.
 
Or they don't think the Red Court's dealings with Outsiders are a real threat, and it's worth whatever risk it does present if the result is to weaken or destroy the White Council.

Winter could well also be indirectly trying to use Outsiders as a weapon, by turning a blind eye to the Red Court using them against a mutual enemy/competitor, given the way that the White Council is the only major supernatural power that stands up for humanity.

This is probably foolish and short sighted, but is probably quite possible.
ehhh I'm fairly sure mab does not want to weaken white council. Also not to be rude but the white council is not a threat to the winter court they'd need to like double or triple their numbers to reasonably fully threaten the court.
 
Part of this might be that winters being cheap and letting the council deal with it first. Also you know its probably not the first time shit like this has been pulled by an earth faction.
If it's been done by other global scale factions, so blatantly, consistently and to such a degree we haven't heard of them. They don't seem to face much in the way of reprisal from the Fae Courts on a non personal vendetta sort of way. I'm guessing their charge with the Gates only extends to that.
Or they don't think the Red Court's dealings with Outsiders are a real threat
That wouldn't make sense. Maeve and Lea got N'fested because of the Reds.
 
If it's been done by other global scale factions, so blatantly, consistently and to such a degree we haven't heard of them. They don't seem to face much in the way of reprisal from the Fae Courts on a non personal vendetta sort of way. I'm guessing their charge with the Gates only extends to that.

That wouldn't make sense. Maeve and Lea got N'fested because of the Reds.
because full blown war is costly and its estimated winters standing forces are like 40k? Losing thousands of soldiers when the white council is already at war with them isn't the best bet when they can just wait first.

Also you know mab clearly somewhat masterminded the events in canon to end up in their extinction. Not completely of course but it was definitely a factor in their complete destruction.
 
Last edited:
because full blown war is costly and its estimated winters standing forces are like 40k? Losing thousands of soldiers when the white council is already at war with them isn't the best bet when they can just wait first.

Also you know mab clearly somewhat masterminded the events in canon to end up in their extinction. Not completely of course but it was definitely a factor in their complete destruction.
Where did you get 40k? Not saying your wrong but I don't recall hard numbers. I don't see why it'd necessitate "full blown war". If the entirety of the Reds fought Mab they'd only have a chance of winning. Cutting the heads off the snake and making it known why was/is an option and I doubt they only started messing with Outsiders after declaring war.

I don't see Mab taking advantage of a situation as being proactive about it. They really must only be obligated to hold the Gates not so much fighting Outsiders in general if they need an excuse.
 
Part of this might be that winters being cheap and letting the council deal with it first. Also you know its probably not the first time shit like this has been pulled by an earth faction.
Winter has quite a few limitations on how they can act on earth. Including the fact whenever they try and act on earth the summon court sends someone to keep an eye on them as well as interfere with them for what Winter thinks of as dumb reasons.
 
I thought it was established otherwise but I don't care enough to go back and check. At any rate yes some of the Whites do, undermining what Winter does even more but the Reds are way worse and much more blatant with it. Shouldn't even have trusted a Red to hold the Gate in Vegas.
Supernaturals could just as easily point out that every Outsider summoning from beyond th Gates requires a mortal magic user.
And so mortals cant be trusted
:V

A Red is not the Red Court as a whole, and as both Changes demonstrated in canon, and th Vegas affair demonstrated here, Reds are not a monolith
I wouldnt trust a Red without guarantees, but the Sin-Eater had the Dragon in service for close to a century of peace.

If it's been done by other global scale factions, so blatantly, consistently and to such a degree we haven't heard of them. They don't seem to face much in the way of reprisal from the Fae Courts on a non personal vendetta sort of way. I'm guessing their charge with the Gates only extends to that.
1)We've only been around for less than a year. If other people are trying shit, we might not know
Its canon in WoD that at least one Yama King has dealings with their equivalent of the Outside, for example.


2)Summer almost decapitated the Red Court last year during Proven Guilty.

If a diversion hadnt pulled off enough of the White Council to allow the Red King and and his army to retreat, they would have been caught on the battlefield as the sun rose with no prep, which would have massacred their mooks and allowed the wizards and Fae to focus down the elders.

That one ambush almost ended the Vampire War.

Then there was Mab providing Harry sufficient backing to attack the Reds in their own place of power in Changes.
The Fae are immortal, and take a long view of grudges.
That doesnt mean they dont settle them.
 
Last edited:
Vote closed
Adhoc vote count started by DragonParadox on Sep 11, 2024 at 2:48 PM, finished with 77 posts and 8 votes.

  • [X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
    -[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight
    [X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
    [X] Seems like the best you're going to get, show up fifteen, twenty miles from the Old Town and then make your way to one of the entrances


Damn this is late, sorry about this guys, I was very busy today
 
Adhoc vote count started by Anaja on Sep 11, 2024 at 2:48 PM, finished with 78 posts and 8 votes.

  • [X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
    -[X] Take all possible precautions, such as prepping PFoR and BSM to support BMI against Sight
    [X] You will take your chances with a closer emergence, time could mean lives
    [X] Seems like the best you're going to get, show up fifteen, twenty miles from the Old Town and then make your way to one of the entrances
 
Back
Top