To be honest I'm actually kind of in agreeance but there are multiple ways to skin a cat. If you want a flaming sword you can make flame grease that lasts a scene with Alchemy, You can Enchant the sword to ignite with the expenditure of Willpower or you can use the Hellfire ritual. There's also the fact that I don't know if we can buy backgrounds with XP or characters can get certain merits without coming pre-loaded with them essentially if I did it right this is just a way to have them in games where you cannot spend XP on backgrounds or merits but you still want to during the course of a game Acquire The Mana background or force of spirit strength of psyche or flow of ki.Messing with Mana is pretty clearly the domain of Mana Manipulation, not Alchemy.
Storing Mana in a potion or similar object is a level 2 ritual of MM.
But then I'm against any permanent buffs without spending the full XP anyway, so whatever.
To be honest if we can buy backgrounds and stuff with XP this could just be a way to enable the spending of XP on those backgrounds or Merits. The Mana background itself mentions taking in potions to do it. There's also the fact a character does not need the path of Mana manipulation to buy any of those merits or the Mana background so in my mind that means there are multiple ways to acquire it whether you were born with Mana or you are a accomplished Alchemist or some kind of Enchantment laid on an object that allows you to take in Mana something.
Last edited: