Personally, I'm going to take this as me being right and Kyoko not actually being Kyoko. I expect to be proven wrong, but until then I'll enjoy my guess work.
*Only now gets an insightful rating by the quest master*
oh u so cheeky
Since there has clearly been some failure to properly communicate this on my part, I'll state it clearly here.
Combat with Nothing There is not an instant loss. It is currently significantly weakened in order to maintain its current level of humanity, and will not give that up unless it has absolutely no choice. Nothing There and X are equals physically right now, with the differing factors being X's EGO Gear and support from others against NT's stolen Magic.
Fighting is a viable option as long as you're smart about it.
No, some people decide it was hopeless before this situation even occurred. No failure on your part, just some people talking themselves into a corner.
...Theoretically, I suppose we could, yes. But should we?? Should we really? It doesn't feel right to me. Sure, we gain another sapling and all the soul gems, but in exchange we lose the possibility of seeing an Abnormality become 'complete' in a sense. Seeing an Abno's ambitions fulfilled with no chance of backsliding... It's unprecedented. Abnormalities as a whole are built on a foundation of tragedy. Walpurgis is an entity that thrives on it. No, even if we could Suppress NT, we shouldn't, because we'd be shooting ourselves in the foot. Feeding into the cycle of grief and tragedy Facility X-394 was built on.
Nothing There has grown more intelligent with each shell she took. At this point, she's reached a level where she could absolutely be a person if she had all the context. All we have to do is help her realize that and show her that the soul gems are a crutch. Teach her social norms, some biology, effectively raise a child for a bit and we'll be a step closer to Victory Forever. She won't need to take other peoples' shells because she can just make her own.
She'll have everything she ever wanted and more, and we'll have on our side the full, unrestricted might of the greatest Red-Damage Abnormality in existence, without needing to sacrifice any more lives. Hell, we might still be able to extract EGO from her like that.
It's currently costing 37 kids their bodies, their autonomy, while being in extreme pain. As someone who has had to live with extreme pain, Nothing There can get bent.
There's no guarantee getting more Gems would work anyway. It's already 37 deep. What, is 40 the magic number? 50? A hundred. Just because Nothing There thinks it's getting closer doesn't mean it is. It's very easy to bullshit yourself.
-[x] By the way, how did they make the illusion and what is Kyubey following right now?
We already know how, it's using a Magical Girl power, probably Kyoko's, to send an illusion over there.
I'm not voting for any plan that does get all 37 Soul Gems in agonizing pain out of Nothing There. Full stop. No excuses, no bullshit. I'm not opposed to resolving this peacefully, but I'm not taking chances.
[X] Try to Convince Nothing There this isn't the way. There's other options. You made a Cage out of your own EGO, surely it-, or she, of she prefers, can at least let you try to do the same for her. A Shell made of herself. She saw how Lobotomy worked, after all. Those Soul Gems can't take the strain of what she's doing to them, and we know it's hurting the girls inside. X doesn't want that. Anything worth calling human doesn't want that.
-[X] If it continues to refuses, or gets violent, pretend to back down. Ask to at least check on the gems it's had longest with Lobotomy. After it either lets them get checked, or refuses, say that your willing to take the deal until you can figure out something better. The moment you feel that's guard is down, telepathy Homura, and tell her to time stop and get here to bring you into timestop. Then hit Nothing There with Lobotomy, either to put it to sleep so you can safely extract the Soul Gems, or cut it off from the Soul Gems magic and stop the pain.