Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
How does a Hedgewise acquire so many books?
The hut is in northwestern Wissenland, which can't be far from Nuln, a city full of institutions of learning. Wissenland Hedgefolk are also associated with Verena, so it makes sense they would value books, although...
What is a statue of Haletha doing in Wissenland?
Yeah. There's a section in Shades of Empire that talks about the diverse religions of the different Hedgefolk branches, but later in a section about the common communities surronding them it says "the Hedgefolk are not Witches, they are blessed folk in the service of one of the Gods—typically Ranald or Halétha, or so most small communities believe". Either the book is simply being inconsistent, or they are saying whichever Gods the Hedgefolk actually worship, they often let outsiders believe they worship Ranald or Halétha for some reason.

If you don't assume that the book is just being a little incosistent here then you can say this hint that Halétha is universally important to the Hedgefolk, and as another piece of evidence you can point to the fact that Hedge magic has a spell named after Her but not after any other God. I personally think this is just an inconsistenty, though.
More books, and apparently the Hedgewise use Morrslieb water.
As Mopman pointed out, Fellstave uses blood drawn during Morrslieb. Of note is that the section on that hut very clearly implies that the local Hedgewise casts Fellstave on the area, as it says that the local Beastmen and Greenskins seem to avoid the hut and the nearby village.

Hedge magic generally seems to use metaphorical resonances, so you can imagine 'Morrslieb water' could be used in Hedge magic against Chaos or corruption in a 'like cures like' sort of way.
 
Last edited:
@Boney, does Szarka have anything to do with the Ostland Hedgewise? "Witch goddess of the dead" reminds me of Morai-Heg, who may or may not be Lileath's grandmother and is certainly in a trinity with her.
 
@Boney, does Szarka have anything to do with the Ostland Hedgewise? "Witch goddess of the dead" reminds me of Morai-Heg, who may or may not be Lileath's grandmother and is certainly in a trinity with her.
Funny you should ask, I recently came across Szarka as well. I thought a bit about her when I was trying to figure out who might have been the patron God of the Udoses, and I do think She could be related to Halétha.

The name Szarka is mentioned nowhere else in canon as far as a I know, it is apparently a real world of Slavic origins, meaning 'magpie'. Two possibilities come to mind: the first, since this is a Slavic word, is that Szarka is related to Kislev (which of course borders Ostland from the north). A potential 'Witch Goddess' is The Widow, who grants Her witchy powers to the Ice Witches and possibly also the Hag Witches. But another potential 'Witch Goddess' is Halétha. The Udoses inhabited part of the Forest of Shadows and/or the area near it, so Halétha is a natural candidate for their patron Goddess, and as patron Goddess of the Hedgewise (who are widely considered Witches, and who in the canonical rpg mechanics use a 'Witch Lore', whatever that means) She could certainly be called a 'Witch Goddess'. Szarka might be a Kislevite name for Her, and note that the name means magpie, which is one of the sacred animals of Ranald. Finally, as the daughter of Shallya She is a granddaughter of the God of the Dead, which might explain how She could 'reside over the dead of Ostland'.
 
I like the "generate a big fog bank that completely disorientates and confuses foes inside of it, who cannot readily tell friend from foe or where they are" idea, since it's an encapsulation of the Fog of War into spell form.
It os one of my favorite ideas as well, especially because it would lead to hilarious situations like causing two enemy formations to slaughter each other.
 
Transitioning someone from life to death is easier than transitioning someone from flesh to mist, and Ulgu already has Penumbral Pendulum.

The problem here is in the abuse of the word 'transition' when this spell idea is solidly in the realm of transmutation. You could make an anti-hero Ulgu spell, but it would ideally be based on themes and ideas more in line with Ulgu. Specifically the nastier, more lethal side of Ulgu, so probably something to do with shadows and morale instead of fog.

One idea is to form a guillotine out of the target's own fear and grief (based on Okkam's Mindrazor and Dance of Despair), so roll Leadership save or die. (Though the problem with this idea is that the guillotine hasn't been invented yet. Maybe something about the Sword of Damocles can be substituted in?)

EDIT: Also I want to say that I like how Okkam's Mindrazor is a play on "fear is the mind-killer".
Thing is, those ideals and themes aren't within Mathilde's wheelhouse. We stretched her Warrior of Fog spell creation trait pretty far to make Rite of Way work. Manifesting a target's fear and grief just doesn't fit at all. (Not that my spell idea's much better, really.)
You could come up with a complex metaphysical reason about why you'd be able to transmute people into a suspension of water droplets.

Or you could embrace that Rita Repulsa energy, cackle maniacally, and say "You will be Mist".
Lethal punishment.
 
Can't be done anymore, we have 0 dwarf favour to use.
Any request to study the fancy hat requries us to explain why doing so is for the benefit of Karaz Ankor.
12 gallons of AV could be converted into up to 36 Dwarf Favour, and I'm note entirely certain there's a better possible use for it now than to be converted into Dwarf Favour anyways. I know the liminal realm possibility is there, but we don't really have a use for it that justifies such a massive expense for a smaller space, and I don't see much appetite for experimenting with AV more now that the book is done. Is there anything else people want to tackle with it? Part of me wonders, after giving the AV away for Favour, if it might not be better to just give the box itself to Thorek for some big boon.
 
"So we can write a paper about how Dwarf work is better."
Not a good reason.
Everyone (that matters) knows dawi work is better, no need to go digging old relics and opening old wounds.

edit-
12 gallons of AV could be converted into up to 36 Dwarf Favour, and I'm note entirely certain there's a better possible use for it now than to be converted into Dwarf Favour anyways. I know the liminal realm possibility is there, but we don't really have a use for it that justifies such a massive expense for a smaller space, and I don't see much appetite for experimenting with AV more now that the book is done. Is there anything else people want to tackle with it? Part of me wonders, after giving the AV away for Favour, if it might not be better to just give the box itself to Thorek for some big boon.
When i say we have 0 dwarf favour, i do mean we have 0 dwarf favour, the favour system for dwarves was broken.
We can trade AV for, something, not actually sure what, but the system has changed from when we could just throw some DF to examine the pheonix crown.
 
Last edited:
12 gallons of AV could be converted into up to 36 Dwarf Favour, and I'm note entirely certain there's a better possible use for it now than to be converted into Dwarf Favour anyways. I know the liminal realm possibility is there, but we don't really have a use for it that justifies such a massive expense for a smaller space, and I don't see much appetite for experimenting with AV more now that the book is done. Is there anything else people want to tackle with it? Part of me wonders, after giving the AV away for Favour, if it might not be better to just give the box itself to Thorek for some big boon.
AV can be turned into Runesmith favor, but the crown isn't in the possession of the Runesmiths, it's in the vaults of the king.
 
I'm not actually invested in the elf hat specifically, was just musing on AV and DF generally, which from how its written can still be spent the way it could be before Dum specifically in the context of AV unless there's some WoG outlining a distinction. But anyways, we already have three free options to take for enchantment insight and the hat is probably so far beyond us that there's no point even looking at the thing until we first build up a better baseline of knowledge

But what would thorgrim get out of that...
Like loyalty, annoying Elgi appears to be its own reward
 
Last edited:
Is there anything else people want to tackle with it? Part of me wonders, after giving the AV away for Favour, if it might not be better to just give the box itself to Thorek for some big boon.
There is no research, but The Box is valuable both for Colleges (as the currently only extant extraction method for AV which is necessary for Orbs of Sorcery) and Runesmiths, so i would prefer it stays with us for now.
 
There is no research, but The Box is valuable both for Colleges (as the currently only extant extraction method for AV which is necessary for Orbs of Sorcery) and Runesmiths, so i would prefer it stays with us for now.
I guess I'm just not personally a fan of the 'moneyfication' of things like that. It made sense to keep this awesome exotic box around as a research thing when we were constantly learning new things from it, but now that its time has passed it feels like it will just be treated as a quest mechanical resource to keep track of the way our gold is which I don't love. Isn't it better to have it go out on a high note? Just a personal gripe I guess and I know my own perspective on slimming down quest mechanics whenever possible goes against the number go up incentive a lot of people have for quests in general
 
I guess I'm just not personally a fan of the 'moneyfication' of things like that. It made sense to keep this awesome exotic box around as a research thing when we were constantly learning new things from it, but now that its time has passed it feels like it will just be treated as a quest mechanical resource to keep track of the way our gold is which I don't love. Isn't it better to have it go out on a high note? Just a personal gripe I guess and I know my own perspective on slimming down quest mechanics whenever possible goes against the number go up incentive a lot of people have for quests in general
Give it away? Surely you jest. The Mirrorcatch box is a symbol of Mathilde triumph over the chaotic forces of magic, of Mathilde turning danger and malice into knowledge and power. The perptually suffering snake inside it was the result of Mathilde's first miscast, and it was defeated through the help of both Mathilde's mentor and Mathilde's God, with skill and guile and a whole lot of dumb luck. That same snake is now embedded into Mathilde's coat of arms. It is of immense sentimental value, and it shall be a treasured heirloom of House Weber for all time.
 
Last edited:
Honestly I like that we can only look at the crown with proper justification, because it makes it clear that we don't actually have any reason to do so.

If we did, we could, but we don't, so we can't.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top