I'm pretty sure that setting up
[ ] Eike Actions: Search for or create a familiar of her own
in a regular turn would run into the same hand-wringing about how controlling a master Mathilde is. If this purchase vote were a bit closer I'd maybe include it, but the consensus against Eike getting a familiar as part of her apprenticeship seems about as clear as I'd expected from previous discussion. That's fine though; a purchase turn vote like this is a very low-stakes way of getting poll numbers on a topic.
What was a bit unexpected is the impression a few of the voters expressed that Mathilde has been spoiling Eike, and that this would be more of the same. Because I don't have that impression of their relationship at all. What gifts or indulgences, specifically, has Mathilde gotten Eike?
As far as I can tell, while the thread has talked about things we could give her either now or when she graduates or as an inheritance after the quest ends, the most that Mathilde has actually given her to date is the opportunity to experience fantastic and unusual things by following Mathilde around in her day-to-day. And while tuition from a Lord Magister is a rare and valuable thing to receive, if us teaching her and bringing her with us where we go counts as spoiling her then there was never any possibility she could be otherwise, as there were multiple Lords Magister interested in her as an Apprentice.