- Location
- Spain
- Pronouns
- He/Him
I should once again like to stand up for Garden of Mists
I'm sorry to use your words @Zeful but I find them very convincing... 😅
I want to talk about Liminal Carver, Ling Qi's formation Trait:
As we (the players) move towards managing territory rather than the relationships with individuals, we need to start thinking about what Ling Qi can provide beyond just a stick to hit things with. For example Zhengui can help with harvests and the growth of various plants, as well as start taking command of the local spirit ecosystem. Hanyi's idol work will be helping by providing Ling Qi contacts and managing the local spirit ecosystem (incidently, based on current trends, Hanyi is essentially going to be patron of local priestesses since the whole negotiate with local spirits for protection is essentially what she's doing), but currently Ling Qi doesn't have much, and while there's nothing wrong with being a warrior, Ling Qi isn't really set up that well for teaching (since the change in system removed the benefits from teaching music she got from Songseeker Ceremony) like Gan is.
That's where Liminal Carver comes in, and not to put to fine a point on it, this formation specialty is kind of crazy in terms of civic engineering. Every culture I've ever heard stories from (which, granted, is not many) have ascribed some power to thresholds, and those stories are why I think this trait is as important as things like Winter's Heart or Dreamwalker. The Bible story of Exodus for example had markings on the threshold of every home act as an IFF for a biblical plague; imagine if a Violet Ling Qi could throw out her strongest attacks in her own city and hit none of her citizens. That's probably a little extreme and would probably require very advanced formationcraft that is very expensive, but I feel the point stands. On a less extravagant note, many cultures have charms that are buried under the threshold provide protection for the family that lives inside. Liminal Carver should logically be able to do the same thing, providing more benefits than just a nebulous "protection". And this is all just one part of the trait, there are also a lot of doorways and borders within cities, and estates, and buildings. A hospital benefits from being segmented in a way that this trait could take a ton of advantage of, surgeries need a specific kind of environment to maximize the chance of the patient surviving the operation, recovery rooms want a specific kind of environment to encourage both mental and physical recovery, and even lobbies could benefit.
I could spend another thousand words just explaining how this trait could improve a city, but that would more than belabor the point, Liminal Carver provides Ling Qi a concrete way to improve the world in some small way, be it something impossibly grand like a hospital that can treat any condition or illness, or something as mundane as a park where people can relax and destress. That alone means it needs to, at least, be something the thread invests in regularly, even if not every turn.
I'm sorry to use your words @Zeful but I find them very convincing... 😅
Garden of Mists: You keep no hearth, but you do tend the garden. Kin and clan, parents and siblings, dreams of the future and trials of now. You have come to know the ways of boundaries and stories, told to keep back the night. You protect your own. Alter the WInter Hearth resounding Art, replacing the Fire Keyword with Dream and Music with Formations. Advances Community and Cycles Project by 1. Advances Liminal Carver by 1. (0/5)