It sounds like Romantic Paternalism will lead to uncontrolled colonialism, making any investments into the colonies dilute.
Romantic Paternalism involves high investment colonies, so the basic thing is that it progresses towards three outcomes:
-Small nearby colonies with a land connection will simply be wholly annexed. We'd put in rail connections, we'd import our experts and work crews and we'd export their cultural and political authorities to our cities where they vanish. They'd dissolve entirely.

-Large nearby colonies will probably start eating their undeveloped neighbors after they get developed enough, Whether they'd split off or merge depends on events.

-Distant colonies will nearly inevitably develop to the point where they can seek independence and succeed. Historically the more exploitative imperialism models avoided developing colonies, focusing entirely on resource extraction, but they were forced by circumstances in the World Wars to do so, which led to being unable to keep said colonies later on due to losing the Imperial power gap.

So in practice, we'd grab something like 3-4 colonies at a time(unlike Protected Markets you can't realistically keep huge numbers due to the development commitments, whereas Protected Markets can keep as many as you can project force over), either devouring them entirely to help fund more colonies or releasing them over time into self-governing protectorates/allies as they grow too big.
 
[X][Research1] Nitro Explosives (0/???) [Science][Chemistry][Military][Open]
[X][Research2] Elemental Periodicity [Science][Rare]

Gotta get those fundamentals.
 
The trick with Romantic Paternalism is that at the end, you want a worthwhile ally to come out of it and it offers a valid face-saving excuse why we do release them into independence.

So it isn't direct map painting as the Syffrynites are doing, but in the end we basically build a huge coalition across the world that doesn't hate the DC too much.

Building something like the Soviet Union or EU out of it is unlikely for the next century, but a Commonwealth setup should be doable. With a built in NATO mutual defence clause once we get that far in political development.

If we pull it off, we basically win.
 
The trick with Romantic Paternalism is that at the end, you want a worthwhile ally to come out of it and it offers a valid face-saving excuse why we do release them into independence.

So it isn't direct map painting as the Syffrynites are doing, but in the end we basically build a huge coalition across the world that doesn't hate the DC too much.

Building something like the Soviet Union or EU out of it is unlikely for the next century, but a Commonwealth setup should be doable. With a built in NATO mutual defence clause once we get that far in political development.

If we pull it off, we basically win.

We are already going to win hard.

It's merely a question of: "How hard?"
 
Inevitable? The towns and industries will occupy a very tiny proportion of the landscape.

Unless you mean agricultural land? Even so, the nomads can still do ranching.

A "civilised" group of "peaceful" city builders and farmers expands through an area currently used by nomabic peoples...

I'm not sure that series of words describes anything ever that went well for both sides.
 
A "civilised" group of "peaceful" city builders and farmers expands through an area currently used by nomabic peoples...

I'm not sure that series of words describes anything ever that went well for both sides.
That kind of thing is sort of in the past. We already pacified everyone who was against it, that's why we are getting academy slot out of it.
 
A "civilised" group of "peaceful" city builders and farmers expands through an area currently used by nomabic peoples...

I'm not sure that series of words describes anything ever that went well for both sides.

What makes you think they are not a settled people? The wikipedia page on Cossack suggested to me that they live in towns and settlements just like everyone.

Also, their career tend to be more likely in the military, and all their officers go to our schools, etc.
 
Some Discord Chatter:

On Dual Crown global hegemony:
Citino:
But they (the Wyrmyn) didn't farm right. So we had to save them

KlinkerKing:
Ymaryn policy since the damn stone age

Citino:
It was technically our CB...

HanEmpire:
it's what we're gonna do in the TTL 21st century too
modern farming depletes the soil like nothing else
the Dual Monarchy will act as the world's breadbasket until they learn better
RL has OPEC and oil
PoC has DM and grain

Citino:
Heh, and no danger of people not needing food one day either...

KlinkerKing:
also
We'll sit on most of the oil too lol
Khem probs has a bit as well

Discussion moves onto Trees:
Citino:
Don't the Mapanca sit on a bunch of the world's copper and other minerals as well?

KlinkerKing:
Redwood too

HanEmpire:
it's just inaccessible
not if we have anything to say about it
the jungles are worth more

Citino:
IMPERIALISM FOR THE JUNGLES!!!
I do find it funny that AN found our weak point
Imperalism = faster tree research
Faster research was about the only way you could convince SV that empire was worth it

HanEmpire:
tree fascists
that's the best part
far right and far left combining forces to stop Global warming in its tracks

Citino:
The day the Royalists fall, the Tree Fascists shall rise...
CB: Plant Trees
CB: You aren't farming right
CB: Kid, that's not how you log a forest
We said back in the past that we would ride our forests to victory in conquering the world
And our Tree Fascists shall enable us to finally do so!

Killer_Whale:
We will conquer the world to plant trees

HanEmpire:
we can keep them busy on the domestic front until we're ready to move out and kick others down
Sacred Forest it up, Sea to Sea

And then to a vision of the future:
Citino:
Sea to shinning forest embraced sea
TFW we have climate change debates the exact opposite of RL

KlinkerKing:
"it's getting too cold, we need to get rid of some forests"
"fuck off"

Citino:
"We need to stop planting forests! It's changing the environment in ways we can't understand!"
"Burn the heretic with the wood he so clearly desires."

KlinkerKing:
"global average temperature has dropped by 4 degrees in 20 years!"
"fuck off"
500k Tree Spam!

Citino:
"Christ guys, we need to preserve the deserts! We can't forest them all!"
"Just watch us."

HanEmpire:
the Environmentalist movement will therefore be led by the industrialists
CO2 budget
"we need this much CO2 output to prevent an Ice Age"

KlinkerKing:
>tfw Ymaryn accidentally Ice Crown by planting too many trees

Citino:
Truly, we relly want that generic evil empire rating, even if it means destroying the world in unconventional ways...
"Guys, we need to burn more oil to save the world!"
"Coal power plants are good for the enviroment!"

HanEmpire:
"Stop using mass transit! Think of the planet!"
I'd like to live in a world like that
I'd be looked up to for how wasteful I can be

Citino:
"Remember, only YOU can start forest fires."
"Please do so as often as you can."
"Please."
"Those maniacs keep planting them faster than we can burn them..."
Tfw the Sketch take pride in having destroyed all their trees, because it means they haven't been invaded by the DC yet

KlinkerKing:
Paris, Hespranxer, 1981

"God damnit, we're gonna have to do it. They're not compromising at all on this. Initiate Operation Heater!"

Unknown military facility, Redshore, Gulmaryn, 1981

>>Nuclear Launch Detected<< >>Nuclear Launch Detected<< >>Nuclear Launch Detected<<

"Sir, the damn frogs launched a nuke at the Kyberian forests!"

"Blasted traitors!"

Citino:
Those monsters...

HanEmpire:
thriller films in this world must be a blast
heroes rushing to create Tree Plagues to save the world from doom

KlinkerKing:
The Cold War: Literally about the damn Gulmaryn keeping the temperature too cold

Citino:
"Damn it, you tree huggers, millions are literally dying becuase of your forests! Stop planting them."
"NEVEEEEEEEEEEER!"
Elves are evil in that world's fantasy, becuase their forests try to eat every other nation
So humans must work together with the orcs and dwarfs to stop the inevitable advance of Ice and Trees
Industry vs Magic!
Arrogant Elven Empire vs Noble Orc Savage!

HanEmpire:
Not!Tolkein's books will feature the slums of Shire as the ideal countryside
lost to the endless tide of forestation

Citino:
The Smog protects us from The Trees That Stand Beyond...
Global albedo doesn't stand a chance against the Ymaryn.
 
Last edited:
Judging by a few things we've seen in the past, in this era Republicans seem to fill that niche. Including the way they go from "managed problem" to "existential threat" in nothing flat.
Republican sentiments were mostly stuff that had been around but hadn't really been able to do more than make a bit of noise before being smooshed previously. With industrialization driving massive urban population explosions, people using the old suppression methods hadn't quite worked out that the math had changed about how many people they can suppress versus how many people they have to suppress with.

Its a bit more like building your houses out of charcoal blocks and then being surprised when the whole neighborhood burns at the same time
 
Republican sentiments were mostly stuff that had been around but hadn't really been able to do more than make a bit of noise before being smooshed previously. With industrialization driving massive urban population explosions, people using the old suppression methods hadn't quite worked out that the math had changed about how many people they can suppress versus how many people they have to suppress with.

Its a bit more like building your houses out of charcoal blocks and then being surprised when the whole neighborhood burns at the same time

The fact that availability of weapons, military knowlegde, and the ability to travel also exploded didnt help either.
 
Back
Top