Deadly Snark
Tryhard As Fuck
People arguing that refusing this treaty would get Athens to invade us are being overly dramatic.
First of all, regardless of Athens being Athens, it is still something of a democracy, and as we have seen from Obander's journey its common population see us in extremely good light. Calling our grain life saving and such. Now the elites dont give too much of a shit about us its true, but it would be extremely hard for them to convince their Ekklesia to go on a war with one of their main suppliers of grain simply for refusing a treaty of friendship.
Second of all, this is from Alkiabides, and while certainly he was the driver behind the sicilian expedition in OTL, that does not mean that with it gone he will simply push for an Epulian Expedition. He might very well still do it in the future of course and I am sure that if we refuse he will keep that fact as a tool in his political arsenal. But judging by what little we have seen of Athenian politics on the surface level, I wager that for now Alkiabides intent to use our answer as an excuse to break the Truce.
If we agree to the Treaty, emboldened by our grain, he and Eramus will push for attacking Sparta. Since Athens will be backe by the Life saving grains of its long friend Eretria, it has nothing to fear from an Spartan Blockade/Siege anymore. If we turn it down, he'd likely push for continuation of hosility with Sparta based on how clearly we were afraid because Athens didnt show enough Arete and that in order to prove to the neutral cities that Athens will win they simply need to sack every Spartan ally into the ground or something like that.
In any case with our proxenoi and our historical relationship, there will be opportunities to repair the relationship with Athens.
And yes those arguing that choose neutrality is a Choice are right. No one is denying that. People are very aware that by not choosing either Sparta or Athens, we are choosing a third way, and while I have been skeptical of the talks of Eretria uniting Italia in the past. Eretria is one of the polis better positioned to weather the aftershocks of the war, who could potentially gather to it strong allies opposed to the meddling of Athens.
First of all, regardless of Athens being Athens, it is still something of a democracy, and as we have seen from Obander's journey its common population see us in extremely good light. Calling our grain life saving and such. Now the elites dont give too much of a shit about us its true, but it would be extremely hard for them to convince their Ekklesia to go on a war with one of their main suppliers of grain simply for refusing a treaty of friendship.
Second of all, this is from Alkiabides, and while certainly he was the driver behind the sicilian expedition in OTL, that does not mean that with it gone he will simply push for an Epulian Expedition. He might very well still do it in the future of course and I am sure that if we refuse he will keep that fact as a tool in his political arsenal. But judging by what little we have seen of Athenian politics on the surface level, I wager that for now Alkiabides intent to use our answer as an excuse to break the Truce.
If we agree to the Treaty, emboldened by our grain, he and Eramus will push for attacking Sparta. Since Athens will be backe by the Life saving grains of its long friend Eretria, it has nothing to fear from an Spartan Blockade/Siege anymore. If we turn it down, he'd likely push for continuation of hosility with Sparta based on how clearly we were afraid because Athens didnt show enough Arete and that in order to prove to the neutral cities that Athens will win they simply need to sack every Spartan ally into the ground or something like that.
In any case with our proxenoi and our historical relationship, there will be opportunities to repair the relationship with Athens.
And yes those arguing that choose neutrality is a Choice are right. No one is denying that. People are very aware that by not choosing either Sparta or Athens, we are choosing a third way, and while I have been skeptical of the talks of Eretria uniting Italia in the past. Eretria is one of the polis better positioned to weather the aftershocks of the war, who could potentially gather to it strong allies opposed to the meddling of Athens.